Military Quacks
Nesmith, Russelle Carollo, Jeff
Military Quacks It’s time to repair tbe miZitary medical system BY RUSSELLC AROLL AND JEFF NESMITH LEIGH CLARK, 16 , WAS TO UNDERGO A 45-minute laparoscopic procedure to provide physicians...
...Only one member of the House voted against the bill...
...But Emily will never be fine...
...Responded Hobson: “I probably will be doing something about this.’’ Later, Hobson quietly dropped his plans to introduce a bill changing the Military Claims Act...
...Some patients don’t meet their surgeons until they are in operating rooms or until an operation is over...
...Understandably, since military physicians are frequently transferred from one installation to another, it would be unworkable to require them to obtain a new license every time they landed in a new state...
...Another military doctor had failed 14 times...
...Oct...
...Of course, even highly qualified doctors sometimes have trouble providing the best care for military patients, in part because of a lack of systems to track patient records...
...Today, a six-year-old, she cannot see, hear, talk, or walk...
...Martin said...
...In January 1995, Wells received a CAT scan at an Army hospital...
...At the time, McKinley had a medical record that included high blood pressure, diabetes, angina, high cholesterol, an abnormal heart beat, a history of heavy smoking, and a severely occluded aorta...
...State boards can discipline physicians, and data compiled by the Public Citizen Health Research Group contain over 16,000 cases of doctors who have been disciplined for everything from repeated cases of malpractice to murder...
...Gary Christopherson, who a few months ago succeeded Dr...
...Martin said he was instituting a system in which civilian doctors would review the conduct of military physicians in cases of alleged malpractice...
...For civilian doctors, state licenses involve more than simply passing a test and opening an ofice...
...See the Monthly’s April 1998 issue for details on FEHBF...
...I think they ought to have the same remedies as people over here...
...But repeated claims can signal problems...
...Military Quacks It’s time to repair tbe miZitary medical system BY RUSSELLC AROLL AND JEFF NESMITH LEIGH CLARK, 16 , WAS TO UNDERGO A 45-minute laparoscopic procedure to provide physicians with pictures of the inside of her abdomen, where she had complained of sharp pains...
...Monsanto, a committee concluded that his care had not met prevailing medical standards...
...The second most common is the related care of healthy newborns...
...Under-Covered After the Dayton Daily News published a sevenpart series on problems in military medicine last October, officials of the Defense Department Office of Health Affairs appeared before congressional committees and veterans’ groups and acknowledged that problems had developed in the 115 hospitals and medical centers and 471 clinics that make up the Military Health Services System...
...In addition, a law called the Military Claims Act provides that when civilian dependents of active duty personnel are the victims of malpractice while living overseas, they have no access to the courts...
...That case, in which the government paid slightly less than $2 million to settle the claim, was reported to the data bank...
...The treatment: decrease the coffee,” the doctor wrote...
...The doctors did not have to obtain medical malpractice insurance or to maintain a practice record that enabled them to keep it...
...Campbell underwent a brain catheter procedure at Walter Reed Army Medical Center to determine if a malformation that seemed to be causing him sleep disorders and other problems could be corrected...
...prescribes more Mylanta...
...Recent votes in Congress may have opened a valve through which the military system could bleed to death in a few years...
...The controversial ruling has been interpreted to apply to any medical care provided to an active duty troop by a military hospital or clinic...
...When Congress created it, members acknowledged that having to pay a malpractice judgment or settlement does not necessarily mean a doctor is incompetent...
...One doctor flunked various state exams 30 times between 1973 and 1992 before obtaining a special license that enabled him to become an Air Force doctor...
...A civilian doctor would have automatically been reported...
...In testimony before the House Appropriations Subcommittee on National Security in February, Dr...
...In fact, Army medical care providers were accused of malpractice in more than 900 incidents in 1994 and 1995, and the government paid $66 million to settle malpractice claims, according to computerized records...
...Clark was on the verge of bleeding to death when a second surgeon, summoned from his home, saved her life...
...His doctor thought the pains may have come from muscle soreness, even though McKinley could not recall any recent exertion...
...Leigh Clark, Emily Houck, and Donald McKinley were not unlike victims of medical accidents and misjudgments that occur every day in hospitals, doctors offices, and clinics throughout America, except in one respect: In all three cases, the doctors involved worked for the US...
...Among other things, the licensing process for military doctors is less stringent than for civilian doctors...
...What problem...
...He was whimpering and moaning in pain and saying to me that he was seeing lightning bolts and streaks,” she recalls...
...26,1992: Doctor says Wells has a sinus problem and prescribes Drixoral, an over-thecounter drug...
...But he notes: “There are two kinds of doctors in the military...
...The doctor prescribed an anti-inflammatory drug...
...Two antibiotics March 8,1994: A physical exam...
...4,1992: Doctor notes Wells “has many stressors,” including his job as a recruiter, his wife’s problems with depression, and their three children...
...A few days later Emily’s temperature rose and she began to lose weight, so her mother took her back...
...Such a change, in which retirees would have the option of buying FEHBP coverage with the Defense Department paying 72 percent of the premiums has been vigorously opposed by the department...
...New openness rules notwithstanding, the full degree of medical malpractice in the military will never be known because a large portion of the system’s patients cannot bring court actions in which incidents are made public...
...That was too bad for Sgt...
...They were virtually immune from malpractice suits, because in such claims, the government is the defendant...
...The retirees could use the FEHBP coverage to supplement their Medicare benefits...
...Edner C. Monsanto provided satisfied the “standard of care...
...The government paid $4.2 million to settle the malpractice claim brought by Emily’s mother...
...We are going to open up the system,” he vowed...
...Among other things, the military is moving to end the practice of allowing its physicians to operate with the special licenses from Oklahoma...
...A pediatrician who examined the infant acknowledged later that he suspected a herpes infection...
...says Marla...
...April 18, 1994 Doctor notes that stomach pain came after meals with spices and coffee...
...It also finds itself caught between everchanging and often contradictory priorities...
...Military officials also acknowledge that the services routinely fail to report doctors to the National Practitioners Data Bank when malpractice claims are paid...
...Most Americans have never heard of the National Practitioners Data Bank...
...In the case of Emily Houck, a committee of Navy physicians met behind closed doors and reviewed whether the treatment Dr...
...Paying FEHBP premiums for this group alone would be a major additional expenditure-$1 billion a year according to estimates by the Congressional Budget Office...
...The committee concluded that Dr...
...Officially, the primary purposes of the military medical system are to provide medical care for active duty troops and prepare military doctors to provide battlefield medical care...
...But so broad was this licensing rule that it encompassed even doctors holding “special licenses’’ from the State of Oklahoma...
...Wells, who continually complained of stomach pains...
...Although a bill to overturn the Feres Doctrine has passed the House of Representatives three times, it has never passed the Senate...
...A few weeks later, McKinley’s wife found him lying face down in the backyard...
...He had died of a heart attack...
...Bryce and I looked at each other and said, ‘The problem...
...In previous jobs he had delivered pizza, worked in a furniture store, and made sales pitches as a telemarketer...
...Compounding the problem, the military is facing systemic stresses that may make reform even more difficult...
...That meant the patients were treated in an environment not governed by some of the most significant safeguards that help protect civilians from bad medicine...
...His medical records, obtained by his widow, show in part: Feb...
...28, 1993: ‘Acute sinusitis...
...They’re either fabulous, wonderful doctors, or they’re spectacularly incompetent...
...Monsanto’s decisions had been proper and, notwithstanding a $4.2 million settlement, he was not reported to the registry...
...A similar, less extensive bill has passed the Senate...
...William 0. Bank, an internationally known neuro-radiologist, would attempt to correct the vein malformation...
...The doctor prescribed 2 tablespoons of Mylanta after meals, along with Tagamet...
...Holders of special licenses are not authorized to practice medicine on civilians in the state, but can practice in prisons, on Indian reservations, and in the military, as well as work in laboratories that handle human organs for transplant purposes...
...Among other things, officials subsequently disclosed to a congressional subcommittee that the Army had a backlog of more than 800 cases in which the secret review committees had never met...
...The pediatrician who would later admit he failed to treat Emily Houck with a toothpaste-sized tube of ointment that might have prevented the brain damage that today confines her to specially-built, $S,OOO wheelchair, was licensed by the State of New York, although he was practicing in Georgia...
...When asked why, he said Justice Department lawyers had talked him out of it...
...These licenses do not require physicians to pass the medical exams Oklahoma and other states require for most licenses...
...None of the doctors was licensed in the state where he practiced, and in the Clark surgery, which took place at Fitzsimmons Army Hospital in Denver, the surgeon had been specifically rejected for a medical license by the Colorado Board of Medical Examiners...
...Donald McKinley, 67, complained repeatedly to his doctor of chest and shoulder pains, sometimes so severe they kept him awake at night...
...Bank told the Campbells that because of “the problem at Walter Reed,” he would be forced to try to insert a catheter into Bryce’s brain by way of the left carotid artery, rather than the right-the side where the malformation was located...
...An Air Force sergeant whose hand was mistakenly amputated when he went to a clinic after being bitten by a dog, an Army sprinter who was training for an Olympics tryout when a series of operating room foul-ups left him crippled, a Marine Corps corporal who complained of stomach pains for over a year before Navy surgeons realized they had left a sponge and a felt-tip marker in her abdomen, an Army SPC who died of an overdose of lidocaine following treatment for a bee sting, an Air Force sergeant who lost her ovaries and a fallopian tube because of an operating room error-the list of Feres-barred cases that have come to light, but will never come to court, seems almost endless...
...And despite a scathing dissent by Justice Antonin Scalia, the Supreme Court has refused to review the decision...
...April 24,1994 Diagnosis: heartburn...
...Arthur A. Wells, who saw 10 doctors in nearly three years at McChord Air Force Base, just outside Tacoma, Wash...
...He loved the .Air Force,” says his wife...
...It fell to Dr...
...As he prepared for the procedure, Dr...
...Only five of the 10 doctors reported board certification to the American Medical Association-four in family practice and one in orthopedics...
...There’s going to be a lot of sunlight shined on it...
...I really have a problem with that,” Hobson said...
...In an earlier case involving Dr...
...These are real problems and these are real people,” Dr...
...yet another had taken licensing exams 18 times, in Louisiana, Arizona, Alabama, Tennessee, and Oklahoma, before obtaining the Oklahoma special...
...This could motivate still more civilian beneficiaries to press for the FEHBP option, necessitating further cutbacks, and so on, he warned...
...Martin as acting head of health affairs, recently told a House subcommittee that such a development could lead to a slippery slope that could destroy the military medical system...
...Doctors are frequently required to see patients they’ve never seen before and who have been passed from doctor to doctor...
...Wells died in June 1995, of cancer...
...Yet the most common medical procedure performed at any military hospital is delivering babies...
...But unless direct steps are taken to correct some of the flaws in the military medical system, we’ll continue to see far too many cases like that of Navy Lt...
...But under Defense Department rules, the incident would not be reported to the National Practitioners Data Bank, a nationwide registry created by Congress in the 1980s to track malpractice in the United States...
...None was a board certified cancer specialist...
...In order to come up with the $I billion and comply with the deficit neutrality mandate, Christopherson explained, the department would have to close more hospitals and cut more services...
...And a physician stationed at a military reservation in one state while holding a license from another state is of little interest to the medical board in the state where he practices...
...But something went wrong and a surgeon’s mistake caused her right femoral artery to be severed...
...RUSSELLC AROLLisO a reporterfor the Dayton (Ohio) Daily News and JEFF NESMITisH a reporter in the Washington bureau of Cox Newspapers...
...At the hearings last fall, Rep...
...A perhaps extreme example of how this lack of continuity of care can undercut treatment is the case of Tech...
...After several hours in surgery, Lt...
...Do you think the code should be amended...
...Currently, the DoD drops retirees from its population of beneficiaries as soon as they turn 65, leaving them to Medicare...
...When the data bank was created, however, Defense Department lobbyists got military hospitals excluded...
...military...
...June 10,1992: Doctor notes Wells had picked up an infection from his son, prescribes more fluids and said to avoid dairy products...
...But the military licensing policy has broader implications...
...Because of hundreds of cases like these, even the people in charge of the military health care system now say their system must be reformed if it is to provide the top-notch medical care every recruit is promised for himself and his family...
...For example, after the Daily News disclosed that hundreds of paid malpractice claims had not resulted in reports to the data bank-and that 75 military hospitals and clinics that had been targets of more than 1,000 malpractice suits had never reported a doctor-the Office of Health Affairs conducted its own investigation...
...and a decongestant...
...A lot of things that used to be kept secret are no longer going to be secret...
...Campbell was wheeled back to his room and his wife, Marla, a nurse, was told simply that the procedure had not been successful...
...The doctor who treated McKinley was practicing in Texas with an Alabama medical license, and although he has never been sued in either state, the government has quietly paid claims in three different cases in which he failed to correctly diagnose illnesses and the patients subsequently died...
...Edward D. Martin, then the acting assistant secretary of defense for health affairs, appeared before a coalition of military advocacy groups, including the Veterans of Foreign Wars, the Military Family Association, and others, and vowed to correct problems the paper had described...
...access to the data it contains is strictly limited to hospitals, state medical boards, HMOs, and government agencies that may need to investigate the background of a job applicant...
...As a result, military doctors may practice anywhere so long as they hold a valid license from any state...
...March 22,1993: Lungs and chest checked...
...He insisted that problems in military medicine were not dissimilar to the private system but went on to say that this did not relieve the services of correcting the problems...
...They may file a claim with the branch of the service responsible for the alleged malpractice, but if the claim is denied or the claimant is not satisfied with an award, there is no right to appeal to federal courts...
...Bank to inform them that during the procedure at Walter Reed, the left carotid artery, one of the two main avenues of blood to the brain, had been torn and had healed in a way that left it 95 percent occluded...
...The data bank is searched 8,000 times a day, and one in nine searches matches a name with a stored report...
...Overlay on that overlay a growing move among military retirees to get out of the medical care system, and the prospects for reform become even dimmer...
...Strapped for cash by congressional “deficit neutrality” dictates and slammed by downsizing and hospital closings, the military medical system faces a growing population of increasingly unhappy civilian beneficiaries...
...March 17,1993: Doctor gives Wells a physical...
...Patients are by statute entitled to free medical care, so they are treated like welfare patients...
...Yet, it reported only one practitioner to the National Practitioners Data Bank...
...A herpes infection caused her temperature to rise even more, damaging her brain...
...Emily Houck was only a few days old when her mother became concerned about small blisters that had appeared on her head and took her to a clinic...
...Later, Marla was told her husband would be transferred to George Washington University Medical Center where Dr...
...Martin, flanked by the surgeons general of the Army, Navy and Air Force, replied: “On the family issue, not being lawyers, we believe our dependents ought to be treated the same way when they are living overseas as when they live here...
...David Hobson (R-Ohio), argued that the Military Claims Act unfairly denied a particular class of American citizens the right to appeal to the courts...
...The scan found four tumors in his abdomen, some the size of a grapefruit...
...In 1996, Lt...
...She’ll be fine, the mother recalls the doctor telling her...
...They are barred by a 1946 Supreme Court ruling known as the Feres Doctrine from suing the government for any harm that befalls them as a result of actions that are deemed “incident to service...
...Physicians already holding such licenses are being assigned to jobs in which they do not treat patients...
...Then you overlay on that a military system that protects its own...
...Bank, a former Navy flight surgeon, declined to comment on the case, saying he did not know what was involved in the Walter Reed procedure...
...doctor Oct...
...However, a military doctor who is licensed in Texas and practicing in Alabama is beyond the reach of the Texas state medical board, which does not have the budget to send investigators to another state...
...All told, in our reporting for the Dayton (Ohio) Daily News, we found that at least 77 Army, Navy, and Air Force physicians (out of the more than 15,000 total) held the special licenses...
...License to Kill Though one would assume that the military would ensure that the men and women who serve in this country’s armed forces receive the best medical care available, in many ways the system seems to work toward the opposite effect...
...Instead, the secretary of defense and the secretary of health and human services have signed a “memorandum of understanding” under which each branch of the services decides if a doctor whose action resulted in a malpractice payment by the government should be reported...
...Unhappy with the Civilian Health and Medical Plan for the Uniform Services and its successor, TRICARE, military organizations have been lobbying for permission to opt out of the system and into the Federal Employee Health Benefits Plan, or FEHBP, the medical insurance plan for civil service employees and retirees...
...The largest group consists of active duty members of the Army, Navy, Air Force, or Coast Guard...
...But just how successful the overall reform effort will be remains to be seen...
...By then, the tumors had spread beyond hope...
...It [shortcomings in military medicine] is an institutional problem that I don’t think they can correct,” says Walter Boyaki, an El Paso lawyer and one of a growing group of lawyers who specialize in medical malpractice suits against the military...
...Notwithstanding such warnings, the House, in one of its last actions before recessing for the Memorial Day weekend, voted to extend the FEHBP option to a demonstration group of up to 70,000 Medicareeligible retirees...
...Loss of blood caused her right leg to wither...
...Bryce Campbell...
Vol. 30 • September 1998 • No. 9
