Why American Roads All Go to Pot
Dance, Betsy
Why American Roads All Go to Pot When it comes to building highways, Europe is kicking our asphalt by Betsy Dance riving down New York City’s hubcapDs trewn FDR Drive is a little like...
...The consensus among these private corporations is clear: Trying to transfer their technology to the public sector takes far too much time, money, and energy, thanks to the absurd way the system is rigged...
...The federal government provides money only for new construction...
...According to the Office of Technology Assessment, delays and road repair expenditures often double the total expense of a road...
...Washington, D.C.’s roads are in such a sorry state that, despite a repair budget that’s quadrupled in the past decade, the city still boasts an astonishing $1.6 million backlog in street repair projects...
...All that is required now is political will...
...And third, contractors in virtually all European countries must guarantee their work for up to five years after completion...
...Needless to say, that low bidder’s costs aren’t going to be so low if he incorporates state-of-the-art materials or construction processes into his bid...
...Don’t take our word for it...
...Smart federal policy would start by passing the Beilenson amendment and then encouraging states to loosen up their specs...
...Novophalt, which Europeans began using enthusiastically in 1976, costs between 4 and 8 percent more than traditional asphalt, but it lengthens the pavement’s life between 50-100 percent...
...Thanks to stunning inaction among highway officials, it wasn’t even sold in this country until 10 years after the Europeans started rolling it across the Continent...
...Despite a higher percentage of trucks (with heavier payloads than permitted in the U.S...
...Real reform requires doing what the British do: Ditching low-bid requirements for long-term costbenefit analysis...
...Only bungee-jumping is more controlled...
...Anyone who doesn’t commute daily via the FDR Drive might make the disposable-road argument: Build it cheap, and if it breaks, fix it again...
...Anthony C. Beilenson reproposed a guarantee and warranty amendment, ARTBA whipped a letter off to Congress...
...But the provision was excised in committee, thanks in large part to the vociferous objection of the Association of General Contractors (AGC) and the American Road and Transportation Builders Association (ARTB A...
...Traffic congestion, caused and aggravated by endless road repairs, costs this country $30 billion each year...
...We don’t pay now...
...But that’s just a start...
...What’s worse is that we don’t have to...
...And the cost of bad highways doesn’t stop there...
...This concept is totally unrealistic,” the letter read, arguing that if contractors guaranteed their work, they would suddenly become liable “for problems caused by faulty design or material specifications and other factors...
...Last year, visitors to Europe from the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) reported, “The extreme forms of distress that are evident in many parts of the United States-rutting, raveling, cracking, and potholes-were, simply, rarely seen...
...We have the technology-or at least we can import it...
...Now that we have it, we barely use it...
...Our roads are allowed to get rocky by a remarkable web of disincentives for American road builders-in fact, federal policy virtually drives roads to ruin...
...And given today’s rigid (that is, with regard to materials, not performance) state specifications, that’s a legitimate concern...
...Holier than thou In the U.S., everything from federal specs to contractors’ legal obligations conspire to ensure not just that today’s roads are unnecessarily rocky, but that tomorrow’s roads will look exactly like today’s...
...Unfortunately, that’s not what American road builders want...
...You get quality specs from the state and you build to those specs...
...In France and Italy, the government’s contract specifications explicitly encourage contractors to make use of new, more durable materials -and the contract-award scheme freely permits an initial increase in costs for long-term gain...
...They can’t always brace before the car plunges into the abyss, but they usually know what hit them...
...Highway robbery One rare step toward better roads almost made it to the floor of the House this fall as part of the 1991 Surface Transportation Act: a provision that would allow states, for the first time, to require builders to guarantee their roads...
...Take Novophalt again...
...I’m not sure it would be worth the effort,” concurs T. Peter Ruane, president and CEO of ARTBA, adding, amazingly, “The current system, as far as we know, indicates that there are no problems...
...In Great Britain, for instance, a 40-year-life-cycle cost analysis is required for all pavement designs...
...And it’s not just Novophalt we’re neglecting...
...Betsy Dance is a Washington writer: Research assistance was provided by Coates Lear and Elizabeth Pitofsky...
...If you’re going to hold them accountable, then you’re going to have to give them a role to play...
...Meanwhile, Mack mixes his cement with run-ofthemill, crack-prone, porous aggregate...
...Over the past decade, as federal highway expenditures actually decreased, no one seemed to be calculating the hidden costs of poorly built roads or overlooked repairs...
...In other words, the system’s rigged so that if Mack’s road starts looking like the surface of the moon, Mack won’t care...
...The way the federal law reads now, states are forbidden to have Mack guarantee his work...
...And they make wide use of new technologies like Novophalt, a polymer-modified asphalt binder that gives cement more flexibility and thus increases the pavement’s service life...
...Also behind it were dozens of state officials and national advocacy groups...
...They mix their asphalt with additives-rubber, carbon, polyethyleneto a far greater extent than Americans do...
...Roads scholars This multifold, billion-dollar damage is brought to us thanks in large part to a very simple scientific fact, a fact most seven-year-olds readily comprehend: When water freezes, it expands...
...Last month, when California Rep...
...No one but the French would adorn the industrialstrength Autoroute from Nancy to Nice with miles and miles of flowers...
...Right now, [contractors] have no freedom to be innovative,” acknowledges Doug Bernard, director of FHWA’s office of technology applications...
...Chevron Corporation, a major asphalt supplier, cut its research staff too...
...In chilly Sweden or Alpine Germany, where winter is a way of life, you’d think such rough riding would be inevitable...
...When they screw it up, they fix it up-a concept positively foreign to the builders of American roads...
...And those same people who can’t get to work on time are stuck in cars belching noxious gases that are poisoning our air...
...And, more importantly, they’ve managed to get the private sector to carry the weight...
...We pay big later...
...Funny thing, though-millions of local, state, and federal dollars were poured into the FDR in the eighties...
...The FDR’s drivers don’t always have the benefit of knowing when they’re going to plummet...
...Those three changes would give road builders and pavement corporations real incentives to investigate new methods and techniques instead of just slapping down the cheapest stuff they’ve got...
...Problem is, thanks again to the federal funding process, that doesn’t happen...
...Owens-Corning Fiberglass Corporation withdrew from highway and transportation research altogether...
...That’s $30,000,000,000...
...Despite the appalling condition of New York’s roads, the state dedicates only a tenth of its transportation budget to repair them...
...His materials cost a little more, but his roads endure decades of stress and salt and ice...
...After that, the states and various localities therein are responsible for road maintenance...
...But hardly an unsolvable one-another lesson that can be learned abroad...
...The reason for the continental difference is no mystery...
...But here’s the catch: The best bidder never wins, just the cheapest...
...A state can’t consider the cost-effectiveness of new pavement technologies or equipment even if it wants to...
...When water seeps into the cement on a road’s surface and freezes, the cement cracks...
...And in the current political hierarchy, the millions of frustrated American drivers can’t hold a candle to the powerful road-builders’ lobby...
...It’s been closed for major improvements twice in the past five years...
...Nick Yaksich, director of AGC’s highway division, bluntly explains his opposition: He doesn’t want to design roads, he just wants to lay them...
...The structural disincentives are so real that even officials at the FHWA are beginning to get the picture...
...Smooth, black Ameri-Autobahns are possible and affordable, once we straighten out the twisted federal incentive system...
...We have the European model to learn from...
...That’s that...
...But if the road falls apart-hell, if it kills a dozen drivers while caving in-there’s nothing the ‘government can do...
...In the U.S., private contractors bid to build roads based on state-mandated design and materials specifications...
...To get federal money to build new roads, it must by law choose the lowest bidder...
...We want to foster an environment for innovation...
...despite millions of travelers annually, there are virtually no crevices in the Autoroute -or, in fact, in most of France’s major roads...
...Let’s say Sid mixes his cement with durable, non-porous polymers-the best in tarmac technology...
...Why American Roads All Go to Pot When it comes to building highways, Europe is kicking our asphalt by Betsy Dance riving down New York City’s hubcapDs trewn FDR Drive is a little like bungee- jumping, that masochistic sport that requires you to tie yourself to a huge rubber band, jump off a high bridge, and pray furiously until you ricochet back up...
...We want them to be involved in the design and the construction, and in the selection of materials...
...But, mysteriously-or rather, not mysteriouslyNorthern European roads are usually as smooth as silk...
...Yet a driver can afford to sit back and enjoy the foliage, because he never has to worry about hitting a pothole...
...According to the Strategic Highway Research Program, one of the few federally supported pavement research institutes, simply encouraging widespread use of chemical binders in asphalt-what the Europeans have been doing for years-could save $270 billion a year...
...Or actually, what they hit: a pothole...
...Here’s how it works . . . or doesn’t...
...The research budget at the Portland Cement Association hit a 20-year low, as did the Asphalt Institute’s R&D expenditures...
...First, European nations invest directly in road surface research to a much greater extent than we do...
...Unfortunately, flooring it out of state won’t help...
...Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company laid off more than 100 researchers...
...And why should he shoot for finessed workmanship or product longevity if he doesn’t have to guarantee his work...
...When roads need to be built or substantially repaired, states contract the jobs out to industry bidders...
...When no one fixes it, that’s a pothole or a rut-or, if you’re driving over it, an annoyance...
...Does this daring approach work...
...But like the rest of New York’s roads, the FDR Drive somehow just keeps falling apart...
...In fact, in the next decade, state officials say, more roads will be closed for restoration than will be open...
...Would it pay off...
...But we have a plan for building that too: a mandatory field trip down the FDR Drive for every single member of Congress...
...In return for guaranteed work, virtually all the European governments have long made their design requirements flexible, freeing the contractor to use the best materials and the best design...
...And upkeep is not a political priority-it’s not as dramatic as a brand new road, no one pulls out the ticker tape, so no one wants to sink money into it...
...That’s why you should...
...The idea quickly won the support of the FHWA and the Department of Transportation...
...In fact, as Europe forged ahead on road technology, America in the eighties actually slipped backward...
...Therein lies the problem: State departments of transportation aren’t known for bold, innovative methods, for perfectly logical reasons...
...Despite an annual outlay of nearly $80 billion, the federal government now classifies one third of America’s roads as deteriorated...
...Mack’s cement is cheaper, at least before maintenance costs kick in, so he is awarded the multimillion dollar road contract...
...The reason is that France, like the rest of Europe, has over the past few decades made a concerted effort to build roads with an eye to the long haul-to spend early to avoid spending more later...
Vol. 23 • November 1991 • No. 11
