Marsh Mellow Fluff
Weisberg, Jacob
Marsh Mellow Fluff Everything you never wanted to know about rock and roll. by Jacob Weisberg The moment you begin to analyze rock, you lay yourself open to the charge of taking...
...The lyrics don't offer an obvious message, but they do get across a feeling that something is wrong with the world...
...That's a distortion...
...some band called Nolan Strong and the Diablos, Marsh hears "the wimp-perfection of mid-eighties Michael Jackson" and feels "spooked and confirmed...
...Simplistic and self-righteous though rebel rockers sometimes seem, they are a vessel for the healthy negative instinct of adolescents and college kids...
...Marsh, the guilty white boy par excellence, admires the black, the soulful, and the emotional, while despising everything that is white, "progressive," "album-oriented," and to some extent, anything that is thoughtful in pop music...
...Nothing is less appropriate to the unselfconsciousness of America's great cultural innovation than the high dudgeon it inspires in certain of its academic hangers-on...
...It captures a mood of discontent...
...Pop culture always seems to inspire list-making (So what are your 10 greatest movies of 1989, Gene...
...In books on Bruce Springsteen and The Who, as well in his writings in Rolling Stone and elsewhere, Dave Marsh has been as guilty as anyone of this failure to let it be...
...Elvis Costello's "What's So Funny 'Bout Peace Love & Understanding," Springsteen's "Darkness on the Edge of Town," and Sly Stone's "Stand" are all songs of this type: powerfully felt protests about the way things are, in politics, in love, in everyday life...
...A fan of fifties R&B and sixties Motown, he gives 17 entries to Marvin Gaye, 13 to Chuck Berry, 12 each to James Brown and Aretha Franklin, 11 to Otis Redding, and 10 to Little Richard and the Temptations...
...Dave Marsh...
...For me, Neil Young's "Rust Never Sleeps" and the Clash's "London Calling," which I listened to every day after high school for most of my freshman year, sum it up...
...Part of what's funny about Marsh's book is the surgical precision of the rankings that accompany this quackery...
...might have it...
...Lighten up, you want to say...
...There is endless discussion of fifties combos no one cares about, like the Elegants, the Jewels, the Diamonds, the Platters, the Coasters (the Drinks, the Ice Cubes, etc...
...Anybody who has grown up since the Beatles era knows what this side of rock means...
...The Trammps's "Disco Inferno," we learn from his book, is the 83rd greatest single of all time, while Tracy Chapman's "Fast Car" is the 772nd, and Dave Edmunds's "Almost Saturday Night" and the Eurythmics' "Thorn in My Side" aren't among the thousand best at all (that hurts...
...Marsh himself remains pop's master obscurantist...
...Though a racial divide persists in music, as it does in most aspects of American life, white and black have influenced each other to a point that it's impossible to say whether Prince and Madonna are black or white cultural phenomena...
...Rock-as-rebellion," Marsh writes in the introduction, "is a story compiled almost exclusively by white men...
...Rock objects to the status quo without worrying about what should replace it...
...One sees this phenomenon not just in the U.S., but in the Soviet Union, East Germany, and Czechoslovakia, where hardcore and heavy metal have become vehicles for mass dissidence...
...Where television fosters dull complacency, the guitar heroes of the young are the emblems of a mutiny that is partly personal, partly political...
...Elvis Presley's Sun recordings were not poor imitations of R & B hits, but a multi-racial hybrid...
...It's no accident...
...Marsh is intent on making comparisons not just within genres but among them...
...The Heart of Rock and Soul: The 1,001 Greatest Singles Ever Made, is a massive compendium of such piffle—in excelsis, as the author himself Pop culture always seems to inspire listmaking (So what are your 10 greatest movies of 1989, Gene...
...Nor does music made by white people intrinsically lack feeling or sexual energy, as the Rolling Stones and Bruce Springsteen demonstrate...
...That doesn't mean rock has to have an explicitly political content...
...The mawkish globaloney of "We Are the World" (#717) is his idea of how pop should be involved with politics...
...By contrast, the Velvet Underground, Neil Young, James Taylor, David Bowie, the Talking Heads, the Psychedelic Furs, T-Bone Burnett, R.E.M., and Tom Waits all get zero entries (to mention only a few...
...When it does, it often degenerates into slogan-mongering or propaganda, as in John Cougar Mellencamp's posturing about the farm crisis or Peter Gabriel's human rights crusading...
...Whenever some trendy bore asserts that a new rap song is a "definitive and infectious cry of pain from the viscera of Reagan's promised land," he is mouthing the frothy rock-cant developed by the likes of Dave Marsh...
...The music Marsh likes best embodies the opposite principle: it is more inward-looking, preoccupied with private problems, or just about having a great time...
...The ultimate source of Marsh's dichotomy is the myth that blacks are more authentic and sexually potent than whites, a stereotype the neglected Lou Reed caricatured in his song "I Want to Be Black...
...Led Zepplin's "Whole Lotta Love," "becomes an essence of grunge, a ragged, nasty projection of male hormonal anguish, that's as dangerous if it's feigned as it is if it's real...
...Rarely do these "pseudy" adjectiva phrases convey much more than a sense of "I like this a lot...
...Go to a concert by the Smiths today and you'll see teenagers who think their parents are hypocrites, feel strongly about gay rights, and like to dance...
...When you listened to the Clash's "Lost in the Supermarket," or Young's "Hey hey, my my," you got indignant...
...These albums were about politics without supplying much of a program...
...In fact, the best rock music is not a rhythmic expression exclusive to blacks, or a desiccated white radicalism, but a marriage of the rebellious instinct, sometimes articulate, with true feeling...
...How can one evaluate Muddy Waters's "Mannish Boy" against the Beatles' "Ticket to Ride" and Joy Division's "Love Will Tear Us Apart —? They're all great songs on their own terms, too different to yield a meaningful comparison...
...But the basic impulse of rock is anti-authoritarian: it may begin as just a moan about parental authority, but it leads to a questioning of institutional and governmental power...
...by Jacob Weisberg The moment you begin to analyze rock, you lay yourself open to the charge of taking something that's supposed to be fun way too seriously...
...And the assumption that "black music" is expressive rather than intelligent is a canard dispelled by the recordings of such singers as Gil Scot-Heron, Tracy Chapman, and Joan Armatrading...
...It's a commonplace to say that the roots of rock and roll are in black blues and gospel...
...they were concerned with principles and "selling out," not with supporting the ACLU...
...If the Smiths and their fans had a sense of humor about themselves, they'd have it made...
...New American Library, $14.95...
...That's perfectly true, but Marsh is hung up on the idea that rock is something the white man tried to plagiarize from the brothers and never got right...
...If that's true, The Heart of Rock & Soul is the affirmative action plan...
...Revolt is much more important to pop than partying...
...Dylan's "Subterranean Homesick Blues," is a great song because it's partly a socially-conscious protest rant and partly a dadaist comedy that doesn't mean anything...
...His new book* offers some gems of inscrutable prose: Marvin Gaye's version of "I Heard It Through the Grapevine" "distills 400 years of paranoia and talking drum gossip into 3 minutes and 15 seconds of anguished soul-searching...
...Beat politics More than books, movies, or television, music has a role in forming a political consciousness in young people...
...sponsibility for the vapid, pretentious tone that has infected rock reviewers at alternative papers and music magazines around the country...
...Bob Dylan, Paul Simon, Elvis Costello and all of punk are included but undervalued...
...It's only rock and roll...
...When he listens to "The Wind," a 1954 single by * The Heart of Rock & Soul: The 1.001 Greatest Singles Ever Made...
...but Marsh has managed to produce a self-parody of the whole nerdy genre...
...Whether it's Allan Bloom linking Mick Jagger's Dionysian revel to the decline of Western civilization in The Closing of the American Mind, or Greil Marcus applying Theodor Adorno to the Sex Pistols in Lipstick Traces, critics who dissect pop tunes too fervently always seem to miss not only the point but the pleasures...
...A critic's critic, he bears a special reJacob Weisberg is associate editor of The New Republic...
...but Marsh has managed to produce a self-parody of the whole nerdy genre...
...He is especially hostile to claims that protest is basic to the form...
...The whole endeavor is so pointless as to defy comprehension...
...Of course there's nothing wrong with adolescents going surfing and feeling groovy, but rock does embody some nobler impulses as well...
...And Marsh's list-making notwithstanding, its golden days are not ancient history yet...
...In this respect Marsh, the African-American wannabe, is not just patronizing but racist himself...
Vol. 21 • December 1989 • No. 11
