The Bush Doctrine Comes to Cuba
The Bush Doctrine Comes to Cuba Fidel Castro, always full of bluster, says Cuba will never change its socialist ways. He says he might cut off ties with America altogether by shutting down the U.S....
...They've been slapped with fraudulent back taxes and had their development plans stolen...
...Fred Barnes, for the Editors...
...And it’s true—unless the bizarre alliance of political left and right and corporate America prevails in its campaign to open full relations with Cuba...
...He allowed Cubans to open restaurants and hotels in their homes...
...They're clamoring to lift the trade embargo, the travel ban, and the requirement that Cuba use only cash, not credit, in buying U.S...
...In 1965, he announced Cuban Americans could come pick up relatives at a Cuban beach...
...It's a bad argument...
...And Cuba is so desperate for food that it stiffed its creditors earlier this year and plunked down $73 million in cash to purchase food in the United States...
...In a country where unemployment and underemployment taken together exceed 50 percent, the average GDP per capita is a mere $1,500, less than every other western hemisphere nation except Haiti," notes Jerry Haar of the University of Miami...
...Pressure, not concessions, worked...
...This time, mass migration won’t suffice...
...Interests Section is grossly violating Cuba's sovereignty by handing out free radios so listeners can tune into Radio Marti (or any other station...
...And the sugar crop, once Cuba's chief export, is approaching its lowest levels of production in more than a century...
...He legalized holding dollars...
...Just last week, Cuba celebrated America’s Independence Day...
...It was a worthy precursor to his Palestinian policy, offering “a meaningful American response” in exchange for Cuban steps toward democracy, free markets, and private property...
...And rather than accept Bush’s insistence on democratic and free-market reforms, Castro recently organized a petition drive in favor of socialism...
...His only allies are pariah states like Iraq and Libya or Communist states such as China and North Korea...
...Tyrants—Stalin, Hitler, Saddam, Arafat—regard concessions by their foes as acts of weakness to be exploited...
...Despite Castro's grousing, the Russians dismantled their massive Cold War listening post in Cuba after having terminated their annual multi-billion dollar subsidy a decade ago...
...It called for free elections and capitalist reforms...
...Interests Section in Havana...
...He's threatening to flood America with a new wave of refugees...
...These reforms weren't sweeping, but the point is Castro didn't willingly adopt them...
...Still, he would decide the terms of trade and what businesses would get to enter the meager Cuban market...
...The argument is that an opening to Cuba will lead to liberalization and maybe even democracy...
...The experience of foreign investors, supposedly protected by Cuba's touted Foreign Investment Law No...
...After Russian aid was withdrawn in the 1990s, Castro created a crisis by casting off hundreds of rafts with refugees eager to reach Florida 90 miles away...
...Venezuela, whose president is onetime Castro acolyte Hugo Chavez, has halted shipments of subsidized oil, forcing Cuba to institute blackouts...
...With the pressure on, now is not the time to bail out Castro and his failed regime...
...Not only would the bans on travel and trade be lifted, but the United States would provide humanitarian aid and scholarships for Cuban students...
...By unleashing American tourists, if only the curious ones, and allowing Cuba to buy food on credit, they’d give Castro a reprieve...
...Cuba is now in deeper trouble, both economically and politically, than at any time in the 43 years of Castro's rule...
...But that isn’t the case...
...He was forced to, if only to relieve the pressure on his government...
...At the moment, Castro isn’t ready to yield...
...And the Cuban people wouldn’t be rewarded...
...Castro is under far greater pressure now than in the 1990s...
...But pressure, external and internal, is another matter...
...Confronted by a deep economic downturn in the 1990s, Castro instituted free-market reforms...
...Now he expects us to believe it was signed voluntarily by 99.2 percent of Cuban adults...
...None is offering help...
...Last winter, he issued no complaint when prisoners of war from Afghanistan were locked up at Guantanamo Bay...
...We know this from the way dictators act generically, and Castro specifically...
...Dictators cannot ignore pressure...
...Not only is Castro slipping mentally and physically, but he's lost most of his friends around the world...
...In 1980, he dispatched the Mariel boatlift...
...The current economic slump has caused Cuba to default on debts to private banks and firms in France, Spain, Japan, Canada, Chile, and Venezuela...
...The countries with whom he’s had economic relations aren’t stepping forward either because they’ve been burned once too often by Cuba...
...Yet that's precisely what a growing group of lobbyists and business leaders want...
...Last year, Cuba devalued its peso 18 percent...
...Castro maintains that free radios constitute a serious diplomatic breach...
...He insists the U.S...
...When Castro has faced domestic ecoNow is not the time to bail out Castro and his failed regime...
...That was twice the amount of food Castro had initially planned on buying...
...77, has been excruciating...
...The national assembly took up the matter and, after three days and 168 speeches, “irrevocably” declared socialism the way of life in Cuba...
...Castro may decide he has to strike a bargain with Bush...
...We’ve got him by the nuts,” a Bush administration official says inelegantly...
...The government takes 95 percent of salaries paid to Cuban workers...
...Yet that's precisely what a growing group of business leaders, agricultural lobbyists, and members of Congress want the United States to do...
...And that could be, at long last, the beginning of the end of his brutal, dictatorial regime...
...Since President Bush announced his new Cuban policy of carrot and stick last May, Castro has been frantic, irrational, counterproductive...
...But forced migration hasn't been Castro's only tack...
...The truth is Castro has nowhere to turn but the United States...
...They must respond, and can thus end up being the ones who make concessions...
...Socialism would stay...
...But there is something new...
...nomic pressure and America's steady refusal to open full economic relations—as in 1965, 1980, and the early 1990s—he's blinked...
...Castro’s hardline reaction might make sense if it were the only signal he was sending...
...We've heard all this before...
...The pressure has rattled Castro...
...medicine and food...
...Since September 11, the flow of European tourists has slowed so drastically that 12,000 hotel rooms have been closed up...
...But as poverty and squalor increase over the summer, so will unrest...
...It's Castro boilerplate...
...Nothing has worked...
...This, by the way, nullified the authentic Varela petition, gathered by democratic dissidents and endorsed by former President Jimmy Carter when he visited Cuba in May...
...He encouraged foreign firms to invest in joint ventures with Cubans...
...Contrary to media reports, Bush’s Cuban initiative did more than tighten the screws...
Vol. 7 • July 2002 • No. 42
