Horse Opera

...John Wayne, for instance, usually played strong men with tainted pasts who still knew the right thing to do...

...It is what Scott is seeking, and what he hopes to offer to the warped half-heroes whom he meets on his endless pilgrimage...

...He had a thin-lipped mouth and a hawk-like profile, and wasn't afraid to act his age on screen...

...Would they be lisping about aspect ratios or dye-transfer processes...

...Unlike such better-remembered films as Shane, Rio Bravo, and The Searchers, it is known only to a small but stalwart band of critics and buffs who regard it as a minor masterpiece...

...My outlook is purely mercenary," he told an interviewer...

...The main difference is that in the old days, such films were mass-produced on the assembly lines of the major studios...

...I doubt that Randolph Scott ever got around to reading The Brothers Karamazov, but he and Boetticher knew by instinct that in a world without laws or lawmen, every man must choose between the moral integrity of the old-fashioned cowboy and the moral cannibalism of his self-willed enemies...

...Nor are they likely ever to become cable-TV fodder, for they are at the same time too spare and concentrated to please the contemporary shoot-'em-up audience and too morally aware for the comfort of postmodernists...

...If the show in question was a western or a mystery, that was good...

...A few weeks later, I went to the opening of a Budd Boet-ticher festival presented by the Film Society of Lincoln Center, and was equally astonished to find myself seated behind an intense-looking man who'd brought along a pair of small children...

...Though never obvious about it, he was among the most visually imaginative of western directors...

...Wayne was already committed to filming The Searchers, so when Boetticher asked him who he wanted to play the lead, he casually replied, "Let's use Randolph Scott...

...But nobody went out of his way to see a Wayne western directed by Howard Hawks, much less a Mitchum mystery directed by Jacques Tourneur...

...Colin Powell had said something flaccid about Yasser Arafat that morning, and the women were grumbling about how weak-willed he was...

...And though Boetticher shies away from overt religious symbol-ism—the cross-like hanging tree in Ride Lonesome is a rare exception—it is hard to fathom Scott's old-fashioned integrity without supposing that he believes in something beyond his own iron will...

...Don't you...

...This is what makes Red River and The Searchers Wayne's most morally interesting movies...

...Wondering how a fellow who bore all the stigmata of film geekery could have Terry Teachout, the music critic of Commentary and the film critic of Crisis, is the author of The Skeptic: A Life of H.L...

...Ride Lonesome, originally released in 1959, is a B western directed by Boet-ticher and starring Randolph Scott...

...Yet he continually found himself forced to make moral choices that were always clear but rarely easy...

...You took what you got, and if what you got happened to be Red River or Out of the Past, then you got lucky...

...The art, of course, was optional, and most such movies were as forgettable as a Law and Order rerun, but some of them were as good and as serious as a movie can be...

...That's why I'm here today," the first one proclaimed without a trace of irony...

...Had the breaks fallen differently, he might well have evolved into an all-American version of Cary Grant (with whom he shared a bachelor pad in the 1930s...

...On two occasions, in Coroner Creek (1948) and Hangman's Knot (1952), Scott wriggled out of his good-guy straitjacket to deliver cold-eyed, un-settlingly harsh performances that showed what he could do when given the chance, but otherwise he stuck to predictable B-plus oaters whose profits he shrewdly invested in the oil business...

...This was and is an unusual approach to the western, whose moral ambiguities generally prove on closer inspection to be superficial...

...André Bazin called Seven Men from Now "the most intelligent western I know, while being at the same time the least intellectual, the most subtle and least aestheticizing, the simplest and finest example of the form...

...Why else would he insist on preserving his honor at the cost of his happiness...

...I'm gonna have me a place someday," he says...

...The viewers I have in mind are the pure-hearted obsessives, overwhelmingly male and uniformly unattractive, who flock to revival houses on sunny spring afternoons to take in the latest week-long tribute to Alexandr Dovzhenko, Ida Lupino, or Edgar G. Ulmer—it scarcely matters, since the same folks show up every time, no matter what's showing...

...I stood behind two of them in the popcorn line at Lincoln Center's Walter Reade Theater, a pair of silver-haired dowagers whom you'd never have taken for western fans...

...No sooner had I started listening than I overheard a snatch of conversation so appropriate to the occasion that I scribbled it down in my notebook: Child #1 (firmly): "Two wrongs don't make a right...

...I once had the opportunity to ask him if his feel for composition had been shaped by the paintings of such western artists as Albert Bierstadt and Frederic Remington, to which he replied that while he liked their work, Renoir and Toulouse-Lautrec had meant even more to him...

...Ride Lonesome and Comanche Station, both written by Kennedy, are for all intents and purposes the same movie as Seven Men from Now—the basic plot mechanism is recycled from film to film, along with a few choice snippets of dialogue—while Decision at Sundown and The Tall T, the former doctored by Kennedy and the latter adapted by him from a novel by Elmore Leonard, arise from different situations but develop in similar ways...

...All that mattered was that he stayed more or less within the accepted conventions of the genre— and, as it turned out, the conventions of the western and the mystery happened to be wonderfully well suited to the artful telling of serious stories that were both entertaining and cheap to produce...

...Ironically, it was Wayne who turned Scott's career around...

...I like what André Bazin said about Seven Men from Now, but I like what the first old lady said about Randolph Scott even more: He always knew what to do, and whether he liked it or not, he did it...

...As it happens, Scott also had a knack for light comedy—he even appeared in two Fred Astaire-Ginger Rogers movies, Roberta and Follow the Fleet—and for no obvious reason he became typecast as the white-hatted good guy who rode a horse...

...Fortunately, all six films can be seen with reasonable regularity in art houses and on museum film series, where movie lovers continue to stumble onto them in much the same way that the novels of Dawn Powell keep on being rediscovered four decades after their author's demise...

...Americans of all ages went to the movies once a week, and they expected to see something different every time they went...

...But when Boetticher died last December, only one of them, Comanche Station, was available on videocassette, and so far as I know there are no plans to release any of the others...

...Not long ago, I was flabbergasted to see a gaggle of so-I'm-like-duh teenagers at a screening of Jean Renoir's The Rules of the Game, though I soon realized that they were film-studies students doing their homework...

...To be sure, I am among their number, but at least I have an excuse: I write about movies...

...Sometimes you don't have a choice," the outlaw answers...

...Precisely because they were commodities, their makers tended to be ignored by the front office: So long as a director's last picture turned a profit, however small, he got to make another one...

...A man should have somethin' of his own, somethin' to belong to, to be proud of...

...If he'd been younger and prettier, he would have been too good to be true, but Scott was no dresser's dummy...

...The Tall T (1957), Decision at Sundown (1957), Buchanan Rides Alone (1958), Ride Lonesome (1959), and Comanche Station (1960), all co-produced by Scott and his partner Harry Joe Brown, run about seventy-five minutes each, the length of a typical B movie, and were shot quickly on location in the barren, rock-strewn hills of Lone Pine, California...

...After 1947, though, Scott started making westerns exclusively, and for several years they ranked among the highest-grossing movies in America...

...Eventually, Scott's indifference caught up with him...

...Without preaching or hectoring, Boet-ticher and Scott succeed in reminding us that there is a difference between hard choices and meaningless ones, between the uneasy honesty of moral ambiguity and the slick-walled abyss of moral relativism...

...Except for the occasional Gone With the Wind, the modern Spielberg-style "event" movies that now dominate Hollywood filmmaking didn't exist...

...Significantly, he sees the potential for redemption in the men he kills, slaying them reluctantly and only after giving them a fair chance to change their ways...

...It is Roberts, not Scott, who gets the line that could stand as the motto of all six films, "There are some things a man just can't ride around...

...The casts were kept small and star-free in order to hold down costs, and Scott and Brown cut other corners whenever they could: Ride Lonesome and Comanche Station, for example, contain no interior scenes whatsoever...

...The heroes are villains, the villains heroes, and everyone in sight is corrupt beyond hope of redemption...

...The children didn't know it, but the conundrum about which they were arguing was the subject of the movie their father had brought them to see...

...Scott was secure enough to let his colleagues do the talking, knowing that his gritty, hard-faced on-screen presence would speak for itself...

...I can't think of a better reason to go to the movies on a pretty spring day...

...Scott asks...

...if it starred John Wayne or Robert Mitchum, that was better...

...Similarly, Burt Kennedy makes a virtue out of necessity by letting Scott and his engaging enemies spend most of their time talking instead of fighting, giving the best lines to the not-entirely-bad guys: Lee Marvin in Seven Men from Now, Richard Boone in The Tall T, Pernell Roberts in Ride Lonesome, Claude Akins in Comanche Station...

...More often than not, Scott plays the part of a solitary, vengeful drifter who is searching for a man who has wronged him, usually by murdering his wife...

...Midway through The Tall T, Richard Boone tries to explain to Scott why he became an outlaw...

...Child #2 (smugly): "Oh, yes, they do...

...Redemption, on the other hand, is the whole point of the Boetticher-Scott films...

...The two men had worked together twice in the 1940s, but didn't quite get along...

...Boetticher and Scott went on to make five more films together (plus Westbound, a forgotten potboiler that Boetticher directed simply to keep the collaboration going...

...I thought about it, I thought about it a lot...

...In 1955, Wayne read a script called "Seven Men from Now" by a novice writer named Burt Kennedy, bought it for his production company, Batjac, and hired Budd Boetticher, an unknown journeyman director, to put it on the screen...

...Rarely are such proceedings invaded by those with lives, but innocent strangers have been known on occasion to wander into an art house just for fun...

...The dashing young leading man of the 1930s now looked as though he'd been carved from a stump, and every word he spoke reeked of disillusion...

...Though comparatively few critics are more than vaguely familiar with the Boetticher-Scott films, they have always had their fervent admirers, both here and abroad...

...Conversely, the "adult" westerns that followed in the wake of Sam Peckinpah's The Wild Bunch, the most influential western of the postwar era, tend to be nihilistic...

...And you think you'll get it this way...

...That's why so many of the best films made in Hollywood in the 1940s and 1950s were westerns and mysteries...

...In the course of his travels, he meets an unhappily married woman, to whom he is powerfully and illicitly attracted, and a villain who is charming and courageous—a hero gone bad, in other words...

...Randolph Scott didn't set out to make serious movies...

...Far from it...

...Scott replies...

...Though he was at least as popular as John Wayne, Wayne consistently picked better directors and scripts, and by the mid-1950s, Scott was slipping into bottom-of-the-bill obscurity just as his younger competitor was becoming the most beloved American actor of his time...

...they respond in unison, then doff their hats reverent-ly—an accurate indication of how closely identified Scott was with the western genre...

...Then as now, nearly all it produced fit neatly into the pigeonholes of a limited number of highly stylized genres: gangster movies, costume dramas, romantic comedies, westerns...

...That's what Randolph Scott and Budd Boetticher knew: Everybody has a choice...

...And that is why it is good to watch their movies at a time when America is struggling to deliver itself from the evil in which its citizens have long been taught to disbelieve...

...Hence the studio system, which ground out product fast enough to meet the omnivorous demand...

...As a rule, fanatics are not to be trusted on any subject whatsoever, least of all one that falls within the compass of their obsessions—but every once in a while, they're right...

...He's through...

...This message rings truer still as we look back at a century that might have been designed for the sole purpose of dramatizing the truth of Dostoevsky's terrible warning, "If there is no God, then anything is permitted, even cannibalism...

...The other one nodded her head in emphatic agreement...

...At least Randolph Scott always knew what to do...

...forgotten himself long enough to father two cute kids, I tuned in on their preshow chatter...

...Mencken, forthcoming in November from HarperCollins...

...What's more, some of Randolph Scott's original fans are still alive...

...In certain ways, Hollywood today is just as it was a half-century ago: a company town, a plantation devoted to the manufacture of cultural commodities to please the largest possible number of people...

...Most filmgoers under the age of sixty are puzzled by the scene in Mel Brooks's Blazing Saddles in which Cleavon Little attempts to persuade the craven townspeople of Rock Ridge to stand up to the evil Hedley Lamarr by telling them, "You'd do it for Randolph Scott...

...The clean, spare look of the Boet-ticher-Scott films is mirrored in their no-nonsense scripts...

...Sometimes the woman's weak husband is killed, too, thus freeing her to fall in love with Scott, but in Ride Lonesome and Comanche Station, the best and most characteristic films of the series, he discharges his stern duty and rides off into the sunset without looking back, alone again and likely to remain so...

...He always played the same character, a lanky, dryly amusing cowboy with a Virginian accent who spoke only when spoken to and shot only when shot at, and you could take it for granted that he'd do the right thing in any given situation...

...A dignified, upper-middle-class gentleman from North Carolina, he went to Hollywood on a whim in 1928, caught the eye of an industry talent scout, and within a couple of years was churning out Zane Grey westerns by the score...

...In both cases, he knows what he has to do—kill Montgomery Clift and Natalie Wood—but it's the wrong thing...

...You went to the movies not to see Spider-Man or Lord of the Rings, but simply to see a show...

...What Scott should do at any given moment is never in doubt, but we also understand that doing it will not make him "happy" in any conventional sense of the word: He must do the right thing for its own sake, not in the hope of any immediate reward...

...What sounds repetitive on paper proves miraculously varied in practice, as Boetticher comes up with ever-fresh ways to frame his players among the sun-scorched rocks of Lone Pine, finding painfully austere beauty in that least seductive of landscapes...

...The villain is looking for the same man as Scott, but their interests are in conflict, forcing them into a climactic showdown...

...No doubt stranger scenes have taken place in Manhattan since September 11, but that one was strange enough for me...

...Nobody in Hollywood, not even John Wayne, looked more believable in a Stetson...