Ethnic Cleansing, Russian Style

...As a culture, as a nation with a language and a history, they were meant to vanish, having been removed from the land which had been theirs...

...Then you say, “they are not like us, and they cannot live among us...

...Aren’t they right to attack them for setting off bombs in Moscow apartment blocks...

...I’ve lately heard, several times, an argument which goes like this: Terrorism is bad...

...All of the Chechens—all of them, men, women, and children—were given a few hours to pack what pots and pans and warm coats they could carry, crammed into cattle trucks and goods trains, and unceremoniously dumped in the wastes of northern Kazakhstan, where half of them died of starvation...

...Given the history of this part of the world, it is not the Chechens who need to be defended from racist insults, but the Russians who need to explain the hubris that allows them to speak of the Chechens in anything but embarrassed and apologetic tones...

...The use of biological designations (“poisonous weeds” or “parasites”) and political insults (“enemies of the people”) dates back to Lenin himself, who in one infamous essay proposed to “purge the Russian land of all kinds of harmful insects...

...Aren’t the Russians therefore right to be fighting this lawless Islamic republic...

...they cannot live among us...

...But in Western public reactions and statements, we might at least express some outrage, manifest some awareness of what was done to the Chechens in the past...

...Now, thanks to the power of the media to transmit ideas across borders, another ethnic stereotype has entered the English language...

...What we are witnessing, with the encirclement of Grozny and the killing of civilians is the first concrete consequence of the Russian refusal to come fully to terms with the Soviet past...

...Although similar to other orders of the time, which demanded the arrests of kulaks or Trotskyites, this one surprised even some of Yezhov’s colleagues, who understood it as an order to arrest anyone with Polish blood, a Polish passport, or any Polish connections at all...

...existence disturbed him...

...During the war years, the number of enemy ethnicities rose...

...As the Red Army marched west, orders were variously given for the murder and deportation of Lithuanians and Latvians, Ukrainians and Estonians, Moldovans, Armenians, Greeks, Bulgars, Hungarians, and other peoples who happened to live in the newly occupied Soviet territories (or even in the old territories) and seemed less than accommodating to the Soviet regime...

...But the assault on the Chechens is a moral horror...

...Translated from the Russian, the hitherto unfamiliar “Chechen terrorist” is slowly becoming part of our political lexicon...

...Which is why the Russians, if they knew their history, if they really remembered what they had done to the Chechens in the past, would be no more able today to deride the Chechens as a “bandit nation” or to speak of “total elimination” of this “bandit nation” than Germans could speak comfortably about the total elimination of the Jews...

...Over the next few years, 180,000 Poles or alleged “Polish sympathizers” resident in the Soviet Union were duly imprisoned or shot, among them (rather satisfyingly) Nikolai Yezhov...

...So powerful, in fact, is this rhetoric, that it has filtered its way into popular understanding of the Chechen war—or rather wars—in the West...

...In Moscow, this language is repeated constantly—except that away from the television cameras, Chechens are referred to as “blacks...

...Not satisfied with the slow method of arresting “spies” or “diversionaries” and shipping them off to camps, he found a faster method to eliminate completely a few, not especially popular, tiny nations whose A journalist based in Warsaw and London, Anne Applebaum is writing a history of Soviet concentration camps...

...What we are now witnessing in contemporary Russia is no ordinary outbreak of racism, no simple case of abuse of military enemies...

...Eventually they let me in, however: They would make an exception in my case because, they said, I didn’t look like a “black...

...International terrorism is worse...

...How often have you heard that “history which is not remembered is liable to be repeated...

...No one, however, has expressed moral horror...

...As early as 1937, Nikolai Yezhov, chief of the Soviet secret police, signed an order: “On the fascistrebellion, espionage, defeatism, diversion and terrorist activity of Polish spies in the USSR...

...Our own reaction, although not as dramatic, is hardly better...

...If it was not quite genocide, then it was ethnicide: Stalin intended that the Chechen people should, sooner or later, cease to exist...

...The West’s response to the first Chechen war was shocking: We turned away and called it an internal Russian matter...

...Before one group of people can feel itself justified in destroying another, it is first necessary to remove its humanity...

...Then, as the war turned in Stalin’s favor, he ordered even more brutal attacks on those “enemy nations” who remained within the Soviet borders...

...It is repulsive,” writes Yevgenia Albats, one of Moscow’s braver journalists, “that even politicians with democratic leanings are keeping silent for fear of slipping in the ratings...

...Our response this time is still insufficient...

...therefore, they cannot live...

...First you say, “they are not like us...

...He went on to claim that the Chechen president had “directly linked up with terrorist formations,” that two of the leading Chechen military commanders were “terrorists,” and that the entire Chechen government worked closely with “terrorist and bandit formations...

...Among most Russians, there is no popular understanding— and no willingness to understand...

...In response, I could point out that nobody except the Russian government has linked the Chechens to international terrorism...

...So powerful is this rhetoric, that Russian politicians are afraid to oppose it...

...Before attempting to destroy the Chechens, Stalin first labeled them “war criminals...

...Over the past century, Russia’s leaders have proved expert at thus dehumanizing their enemies...

...Under this rubric, the entire nation was accused of Nazi collaboration, and the entire nation suffered...

...The truth, alas, is that we don’t even live by our own clich?s...

...Again, if we really felt—if we really, viscerally felt—that what Stalin did to the Chechens was evil, it is not only Boris Yeltsin who would be unable to bombard Chechen civilians now, but we who would be unable to sit back with equanimity and watch...

...Here is how Boris Yeltsin used it, just before stomping off from the European security summit in Istanbul last month: “We want peace and a political solution to the situation in Chechnya . . . to achieve this, there has to be complete elimination of the gangs, eradication of the terrorists...

...For the past decade, those Russian historians and journalists who have labored to uncover and describe the crimes of the past have found themselves working in relative obscurity and silence...

...Those who survived returned home only in the late 1950s, after Stalin’s death...

...Of course, we cannot force the Russians to study their history, any more than we can force the Russians to withdraw from Grozny...

...There have been calls for a “peaceful solution” and some mumbling about humanitarian issues, alongside some carefully worded support for the Russian “fight against terrorism...

...We are not going to bomb Moscow as we bombed Belgrade, even if that were the right thing to do...

...For the Russians have reduced the Chechens to the status of “bandit state” before, and for similar reasons...

...On a recent trip there, I was stopped walking into a government building because I didn’t have the Moscow residency permit that the security guards, then in a frenzied search for illegally resident “Chechen terrorists,” required...

...Stalin refined the technique and pioneered its use against particular ethnic groups, as well as class enemies and political opponents...

...I could add that nobody has proven their connection to the still mysterious Moscow bombings...

...The Russian leadership’s insistence on using the adjective “terrorist” before every mention of the word “Chechen” is not merely a piece of successful wartime propaganda, although it is also that: 65 percent of Russians support the use of force against Chechnya...

...From there, it is a very short step to say, “they are not like us...

...Here is how one of Russia’s generals used it: The war in Chechnya will not be halted, he said recently, until after “the full destruction of terrorists...

...But why should I or anyone need to make either argument...

...These included the Crimean Tatars, the Volga Germans, the Balkars, Karachai, Kalymyks, Ingush, and, more to the point, the Chechens...