FUTURE PERFECT
MURRAY, BRIAN
FUTURE PERFECT H.G. WELLS AND THE HISTORY OF THINGS TO COME • BY BRIAN MURRAY H.G. Wells is famous today mostly—perhaps only—for the science-fiction novels he published in the 1890s, the first...
...But as the bilious Mencken recognized, Wells and Dickens were, in fact, vastly different...
...Presumably," as Anthony Burgess once observed, "both blacks and Jews have opted out" of Wells's "great biological experiment...
...to 1915 to produce several ambitious novels about class and society, including Kipps, Tono-Bungay, and The New Machiavelli...
...But after these early successes— insisting that he didn't want to be remembered as a mere purveyor of "sensational" stories—Wells began to distance himself from the "scientific romances" that had made his name...
...Wells's New Republicans wouldn't be troubled by the demands of the old religions and traditional morality...
...Gummidge would be urged to end her troubles with an overdose of opiates, and chronic debtors like old John Dorrit would join Sairey Gamp and Mr...
...And for the rest—"those swarms of black, and brown, and dirty white, and yellow people, who do not come into the new needs of efficiency...
...Bumble to Edward Murdstone to Thomas Gradgrind reveal, Dickens deplored those who relish dictating terms to their weaker or less fortunate fellows...
...Huxley, known popularly as "Darwin's Bulldog," stressed that evolution didn't necessarily equal progress...
...at the time, many still assumed that motorized vehicles were simply a comical craze...
...It shows his debt not only to Huxley, but to The Martyrdom of Man, an 1872 paean to progress through "Science" composed by Winwood Reade, whose better-known uncle, Charles Reade, had previously found fame with such novels as the 1856 It Is Never Too Late to Mend...
...Central heating, he predicted, would become universal, and "neat little" electric stoves would abolish the laborious mess that comes with cooking, making it "a pleasant amusement for intelligent invalid ladies...
...The hopelessly melancholic Mrs...
...Dickens wasn't much of a churchgoer...
...Dickens never believed that social problems would end as government became more powerful...
...he will then be a creator...
...But as Wells pointed out in Anticipations, science first had a few less extravagant tasks to perform, like getting rid of household dirt...
...The earth, "which is now a purgatory, will be made a paradise...
...These New Republicans would deny then the "self-contradictory absurdities of an obstinately anthropomorphic theology...
...For example, Wells's 1916 novel, Mr...
...Then came the string of early, popular novels, including The Island of Dr...
...For Reade and Wells, science represented freedom, clarity, truth...
...Panoramic, humorous, satiric, rather loosely structured, they feature vivid characters making their way amidst assorted social climbers and rogues...
...Chesterton's Eugenics and Other Evils, published in 1922...
...We are all of us naked under our clothes," he cheerfully reported, "and we are all of us tailed under our skins...
...Now largely forgotten, Anticipations was intended as a serious prediction about the shape of human life and culture in the year 2000...
...Well," Wells wrote, "the world is a world, and not a charitable institution, and I take it they will have to go...
...In this "New Republic," there would be no room for the "flushed, undignified" politician who, with "collar crumpled, hair disordered, and arms in wild activity," talks "copiously" on "tubs, barrels, scaffoldings" as he grubs for votes from untutored rubes...
...He "has caught the trick," as one reviewer claimed at the time, of mixing "imagination with the technical precision of a newspaper reporter...
...It was the Future Shock of its day, widely disputed and hotly defended throughout England and America...
...In novels, Utopias, essays, films, pamphlets, the antithesis crops up, always more or less the same...
...History as he sees it is a series of victories won by the scientific man over the romantic man...
...And his later works are neither full of racist rants nor obsessed with human breeding...
...Mankind will migrate into space, and will cross the airless Saharas...
...To live on classics, however splendid," Wells wrote, "is senility...
...Only after the success ofAnticipations were Wells's books widely discussed by Britain's leading "progressive" intellectuals, among them Bertrand Russell, Beatrice Webb, and the ubiquitous George Bernard Shaw...
...Moreau in 1896, The Invisible Man in 1897, and When the Sleeper Wakes in 1898...
...Wells himself called Anticipations "the keystone to the main arch of my work...
...Furthermore, it's difficult not to think of the ideas that Wells helped make acceptable when, in Mein Kampf, one finds Hitler asserting that stopping the "procreation" of "the physically degenerate and mentally sick" will purge "the germs of our present physical and hence spiritual decay...
...Lawrence and W.B...
...As John Carey documents in his superb 1993 The Intellectuals and the Masses, many of this century's most admired literary figures—including D.H...
...Would, say, Wilkins Micawber or Betsey Trotwood meet the state's "new needs of efficiency...
...The earth will become a Holy Land which will be visited by pilgrims from all the quarters of the universe...
...in whose ranks he appeared to include Asians, Africans, and "that alleged termite in the civilized woodwork, the Jew...
...Between 1900 and 1930, breezy talk of eugenics was in the air...
...As characters from Mr...
...Bernard Shaw, for instance, bluntly suggested that "if we desire a certain type of civilization and culture, we must exterminate the sort of people who do not fit into it...
...Wells wrote...
...Determined to stick with his education, he won a scholarship to train as a teacher at the Normal School of Science in South Kensington...
...Of course Friedrich Nietzsche— the era's most influential philosopher— railed frequently and famously against the "rabble," as Carey notes...
...Wells didn't condone the Nazi genocide that killed millions in the next decade...
...The book's appeal came partly from its novelty...
...In 1927 Wells attacked Italian Fascism for its "blood-lust" and "puerile malignity...
...And it's impossible to imagine Dickens approving of Wells's belief in selective breeding...
...There was an entire genre of such "future histories," sparked by the turn of the century, but unlike most of them—including Edward Bellamy's still-read Looking Backward—Anticipations didn't present itself as a novel...
...Wells, reared in near poverty, was long obsessed with civic and domestic tidiness...
...In his 1910 review of Wells's The History of Mr...
...Dickens "regarded his characters as a young mother regards her baby...
...Huxley looked forward to a worldwide "Kingdom of Man" where "the struggle for existence" is ended and enlightenment reigns...
...Wells insisted that he could not understand "the exceptional attitude people take up against the Jews...
...But Anticipations is more about politics than technology...
...He wanted to be thought of as a serious literary artist, which drove him from 1900 Brian Murray teaches in the writing and media department at Loyola College in Baltimore...
...Hitler formed his monstrous, half-baked ideology from diverse sources, including Darwin, Machiavelli, Wagner, and Wagner's son-in-law, Houston Stewart Chamberlain, whose anti-Semitic tracts contributed infinitely more to Nazism than anything H.G...
...So, to an extent, Wells wasn't exceptional...
...Science would end disease, eliminate poverty, and—eventually—propel us to bright new habitats among the stars...
...They would also recognize that "those who sincerely think and write"—including, presumably, Wells himself—are "the salt of the social body...
...On the one side science, order, progress, internationalism, aeroplanes, steel, concrete, hygiene: on the other side war, nationalism, religion, monarchy, peasants, Greek professors, poets, horses...
...Mencken noted that Wells had "staked out for himself the English lower middle class that Dickens knew so intimately and loved with such shameless sentimentality"— that "tea swilling garde du corps of all the more disgusting virtues, traditions, superstitions and epidemic diseases of the Anglican people...
...And how," Wells wrote, "will the New Republic treat the inferior races...
...But Wells, in fact, had ventured down this road before...
...The nineteenth century had, after all, produced major progress in manufacturing, transportation, housing, and hygiene...
...Although "prayer is useless," science, Reade argued, is not...
...But his schooling was uneven, his options few...
...Early in his career Wells was often hailed as Charles Dickens's true heir...
...These, he predicted in Anticipations, would find their place "in some convenient corner" of every household, "beside the barometer, to hear or ignore...
...But unlike Wells he never abandoned his Christian faith, and never ceased promoting in his fiction such simpler and vastly more difficult virtues as humility, generosity, forbearance...
...Malthus, Wells wrote, recognized that "the main mass of the business of human life involves reproduction," and that no "Golden Age" will ever be possible without controlling population...
...they will become themselves architects of systems, manufacturers of worlds...
...Chesterton mocked "the idea that to breed a man like a cart-horse was the true way to attain that higher civilization, of intellectual magnanimity and sympathetic insight, which may be found in cart-horses...
...Britling Sees It Through, became an international success with its elegiac portrait of Britain's homefront during a time of war...
...Dick among the ranks of the disappeared...
...The world it predicted and celebrated in 1901 was clean, technological, bureaucratic, scientific— and a whole lot like Hitler's Germany...
...Uncompromising forward thinkers, Wells's "New Republicans" would dump traditional curricula in favor of "contemporary literature," the "breath of civilized life...
...The "base" would apparently include alcoholics and chronic depressives, as well as the "undersized, diseased little man" who is "incapable of earning a decent living for himself," and is probably married to "some under-fed, ignorant, ill-shaped, plain, and diseased little woman" and "guilty of the lives of ten or twelve ugly, ailing children...
...In the end, Dickens from the start knew one vital truth Wells never quite grasped: that hubris and grand plans for the "perfectibility" of the human race are as plentiful as tea leaves, and that simple decency regularly practiced remains, alas, the rarest thing in the world...
...Even war was widely viewed as a bane of the past...
...Most of the human types," Wells mused, "that by civilized standards are undesirable, are quite willing to die out if the world will only encourage them a little...
...In The World Set Free, published in 1914, Wells convincingly describes atomic warfare—some twenty years before the Joliot-Curies artificially produced radioactive substances...
...The great majority of men have no right to existence," Nietzsche proclaimed, "but are a misfortune to higher men...
...Man then will be perfect...
...Throughout his career, Wells was widely hailed for the remarkable accuracy of his various prophecies...
...Wells's New Republicans would sterilize and, he implied, simply eliminate those who, ignoring ready contraception, chose instead to reproduce...
...But he never missed the lectures of South Kensington's star instructor, Thomas Huxley, who was known internationally both for his biological research and his elegant, accessible essays on various scientific issues and social themes...
...But, like the Nazis, Wells exalted eugenics and "the strong arm of the state" (as he puts it in Anticipations...
...The nineteenth century was, on the whole, remarkably peaceful— "an anomaly," writes one historian, "in an otherwise continuous pattern of warfare" over the previous five centuries...
...Wells's new leaders would however revere one "classic" work— Thomas Malthus's 1798 Essay on the Principle of Population...
...And despite his demands for global community, Wells seemed to forget that the world is not exclusively European and white...
...Christianity is dead, he declared, Darwin having delivered the decisive blow...
...Win-wood Reade's own career as a novelist flopped, but The Martyrdom of Man remained steadily in print through dozens of editions, becoming one of the bestselling books of the Victorian Age...
...Their God, like Reade's, is unfathomable and glimpsed only, dimly, through unfettered scientific inquiry...
...They would permit only "the procreation of what is fine and efficient and beautiful in humanity—beautiful and strong bodies, clear and powerful minds, and a growing body of knowledge...
...If one looks through nearly any book" written by Wells "in the last forty years," Orwell observes, one finds: the same idea constantly recurring: the supposed antithesis between the man of science who is working towards a planned World State and the reactionary who is trying to restore a disorderly past...
...In 1901, he published his Anticipations of the Reaction of Mechanical and Scientific Progress Upon Human Life and Thought...
...Yeats—voiced the belief that to make the future safe for artists and intellectuals, society must be cleansed of the hopelessly vulgar, the chronically coarse...
...Polly, H.L...
...In "Hitler, Wells, and the World State," published in 1941, George Orwell traced the fascistic thread that runs through much of Wells's work...
...But Wells's strapping supermen would be plainly up to the task...
...Britling concludes with a call for world peace that features some of Wells's most powerful rhetoric, including one lyrical line—"At a thousand points the light is shining through"—that seems to have found its way, albeit altered, into George Bush's 1988 acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention...
...In fact, if they were somehow transported to Wells's New Republic, many of Dickens's most memorable characters would find themselves fearing for their lives...
...And he wanted to be thought of as a pundit and seer, which drove him in 1905 to write A Modern Utopia—the book that his modern readers assume represents his first foray into what would become a life-long obsession: the establishment of a super-efficient "World State...
...Dickens loathed the sort of self-aggrandizement that one finds in so much of Wells's work...
...He didn't cheer the passing of a Eugenics Sterilization Law in Berlin in 1933...
...Wells's first published fiction included Poe-like tales and humorous sketches that owed a bit to Charles Dickens's Sketches By Boz...
...Of course keeping close watch on the reproductive habits of large populations was going to be no easy matter...
...Finally, men will master the forces of nature...
...Although the books owed something to Jules Verne and Edgar Allan Poe, Wells devised a style strictly his own to create such works as The Time Machine and The War of the Worlds...
...Elsewhere he famously forecast the development of the army tank, and the rise of radio-like devices destined to compete with newspapers in the delivery of timely news...
...Reade insisted that intelligent people must simply accept the fact that "the Supreme Power" is neither approachable nor attentive, but rather an obscure "Force" knowable—if at all— through close study of scientific law...
...Ironically, "much of what Wells has imagined and worked for is physically there in Nazi Germany...
...And yet, on some occasions, he made the right calls...
...Wells is famous today mostly—perhaps only—for the science-fiction novels he published in the 1890s, the first decade of his long and prolific career...
...This wasn't scientific fiction, or tea-leaf augury, but scientific prediction, written in a prose so assured it seemed to carry instant conviction...
...Humanity, Reade predicted, would shed the main sources of its long "mar-tyrdom"—religious superstition and intellectual fear...
...for Darwin, they would realize, "destroyed the dogma of the Fall upon which the whole intellectual fabric of Christianity rests...
...he repeatedly insisted that only more goodness more widely displayed could advance human life in a permanently flawed—or "fallen"—world...
...But, he added optimistically, at least some of these losers would depart voluntarily, through suicide, "a high and courageous act rather than a crime...
...His mother, a lady's maid, forced him at fifteen to start work as a draper—a future he loathed...
...and that while human beings couldn't hope to escape distant cosmic calamity—a "universal winter" induced by a cooling sun—they could in the interim improve their earthly lot...
...Indeed, Huxley's central ideas inform virtually everything that Wells ever wrote...
...the laboratory is an Anglo-Saxon preserve...
...Thus Wells's "men of the New Republic" wouldn't allow careless breeding of "base and servile types," or "fear-driven and cowardly souls," or the "mean and ugly...
...Rather, he would have endorsed G.K...
...Modern Germany," Orwell adds, "is far more scientific than England, and far more barbarous...
...In Anticipations, he acclaimed the array of new "solvents" that, in future years, would wonderfully simplify the "tedious cleansing and wiping of table ware," as well as the "painful rub, rub, rub" required for washing windows...
...As a child Wells was intellectually curious and read voraciously...
...Man then is but an animal, however clever, forced with his fellow brutes to scrap and struggle for power, shelter, and food...
...Wells, as he later did in his more famous A Modern Utopia, claimed a highly centralized "World State" would take shape as the flaws of democracy were more widely perceived...
...Wells had to face the fact that his vaunted "science" was, as Orwell points out, "fighting on the side of superstition...
...Wells was (as the British writer Brian Aldiss more recently put it) "the Shakespeare of science fiction...
...His father ran a struggling shop in Bromley, a far London suburb...
...Wells wasn't a notable student, tending to neglect his classes in favor of roaming London's engrossing streets...
...he will then be therefore what the vulgar worship as a god...
...As novelists, then, Dickens and Wells were, as Mencken recognized, "as far apart as the poles...
...His 1901 Anticipations caught well the hopeful mood that prevailed throughout much of the industrialized world between the 1890s and the First World War...
...So far as they fail to develop sane, vigorous, and distinctive personalities for the great world of the Future, it is their portion to die out and disappear...
...The order, the planning, the State encouragement of science, the steel, the concrete, the aeroplanes, are all there, but all in the service of ideas appropriate to the Stone Age...
...Sales of Wells's books steadily increased—bringing him the sort of wealth and influence that, among his contemporaries, only Rudyard Kipling and perhaps Arnold Bennett enjoyed...
...And he foresaw the easy availability of aviation, claiming, more guardedly, that "probably before 1950, a successful aeroplane will have soared and come home safe and sound...
...Wells also insisted, in Anticipations, on the total triumph of automobiles and trucks...
...Rather, the New Republic's appointed rulers would autonomously supervise all forms of cultural, economic, and social activity, including education, which Wells—the failed schoolmaster—found in dire need of mass reform...
...Writing in 1916, one critic called Wells "a world figure" and noted that "his books were in the window of every important bookshop in Germany," where "he was studied rather than read...
...Given his spotty record at Kensington, Wells couldn't land a good teaching job and so tried his hand at journalism...
...Wells himself, incidentally, was plumpish and short, and had been sickly as a youth...
...Wells looks at his as a porkpacker looks at a hog...
...Still, Wells has much to answer for, particularly in his stereotyping of the Jews...
...that "retrogressive is as practical as progressive metamorphosis...
...Wells's social novels Kipps and Tono-Bungay display certain clear Dick-ensian traits...
...Indeed, Wells wrote with such cleverness and zest that, in later years, he could fairly point to himself as a prime example of what happens to a talented man who finds his focus and masters his will...
...For starters, they would "rout out and illuminate urban rookeries and all places where the base can drift to multiply...
...And yet he gratuitously listed some of those prejudices before noting hopefully that, through social pressure, intermarriage, and "a common language and a common rule," Jews would "cease to be a physically distinct element in human affairs in a century or so...
Vol. 4 • May 1999 • No. 33