To Know Her Is To Respect Her
BARNES, FRED
To Know Her Is To Respect Her The great Palin divide. BY FRED BARNES Lorne Michaels is the longtime executive producer of Saturday Night Live. Sarah Palin appeared on SNL in mid-October,...
...Ronald Reagan did...
...Barack Obama has been attacked for his limited experience in foreign policy...
...Indeed, if she knew more, she might have skewered Biden for the whoppers he told—about the Middle East, Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan—in their debate on October 2. The press, while critical of Palin, didn’t notice the inaccuracies either, or at least failed to draw attention to them...
...With Palin, it’s the opposite...
...Bill Clinton did...
...I watched the way she connected with people, and … you can see that she’s a very powerful, very disciplined, incredibly gracious woman...
...On foreign and national security affairs, Palin has a knowledge gap...
...A good example is Ken Adelman, who headed the arms control agency in the Reagan administration...
...Yet this person, too, regards Palin as a rare talent with the skill and self-confi - dence to be a national political leader...
...So did George W. Bush...
...And with gasoline prices falling, that issue has become less important than expected in the campaign...
...But that wasn’t all he said...
...Another Republican who has followed her career closely believes Palin has a ruthless streak...
...What appears to be her fi nal judgment is that Palin’s nomination for vice president is “no good, not for conservatism and not for the country...
...Palin, a governor for less than two years, has no record in national affairs, with the exception of one issue— energy...
...What has she done...
...And Palin’s Alaska acquaintances were certain, from the moment she became John McCain’s vice presidential running mate, that her acceptance speech would be a smashing success and she’d have little trouble in her debate with Joe Biden...
...Normally in politics, campaign operatives are called on to make excuses for a dull and uninspiring candidate...
...The positive assessment of Palin by those who know her or have worked with her has come close to being drowned out by her critics, from the right and the left...
...The basis for Parker’s conclusion was a comment by her husband about Palin, seconded by a friend (“I’m sexually attracted to her”), and a magazine article...
...Lack of experience is a recurring issue not only for vice presidential candidates, but for presidential nominees as well...
...Yet Ruedrich says Palin is smart, very capable, and a political star...
...She ousted an incumbent governor of her own party, successfully fought corruption in the party, and tore up a deal with oil companies, forcing them to accept a less lucrative agreement on a new natural gas pipeline...
...I asked him to name his favorite president of the past 60 or 70 years, and he chose Harry Truman...
...Fred Barnes is executive editor of THE WEEKLY STANDARD...
...And then there’s the view of Matthew Dowd, a top strategist for President Bush’s reelection campaign in 2004...
...Sarah Palin appeared on SNL in mid-October, after which Michaels noted, “Her politics aren’t my politics...
...Had Obama picked Virginia governor Tim Kaine as his veep, Kaine would have been hit with those questions...
...Palin’s record is another critical test of her personal skill as a leader...
...David Brooks, the New York Times columnist, has rendered an even harsher verdict, calling Palin “a fatal cancer to the Republican party...
...People connect to her...
...The answer is a no-brainer...
...She helped drive him off the state’s Oil and Gas Conservation Commission, criticized him publicly, and later tried to get him ousted as party chairman...
...And, yes, it’s a mark against John McCain...
...He isn’t...
...The difference of opinion here, between those who know Palin and those who don’t, is unusual...
...Invariably, they explain that in private, especially face-to-face with a small group of voters, the candidate is dazzlingly likable and enormously persuasive...
...Kathleen Parker, a conservative columnist, wrote last week that McCain was seduced by Palin’s attractiveness into picking her as his running mate...
...This was her first time out and she’s had a huge impact...
...Randy Ruedrich, the Republican chairman in Alaska, is someone you might suspect would be a friend and ally of Palin...
...Or those who haven’t...
...Adelman recently endorsed Obama and said he “would not have hired [Palin] for even a mid-level post in the arms control agency...
...So the qualms about Palin’s experience are merely par for the course...
...A lot more than Kaine or Pawlenty or most governors...
...Palin doesn’t recall ever having met Parker, much less been interviewed by her...
...He’s been quoted as saying that McCain actually knows now that Palin is unqualifi ed to be vice president...
...By choosing her, McCain “put the country at risk...
...No one questions her ability to excite a crowd...
...My advice is ignore the critics who know far less about Palin than she does about foreign policy...
...Governors who run for national offi ce automatically face questions about their inexperience in foreign affairs...
...BY FRED BARNES Lorne Michaels is the longtime executive producer of Saturday Night Live...
...Palin and Noonan have never conversed either...
...But that didn’t matter...
...Turned out they were right...
...And though Biden, his running mate, has spent 36 years in the Senate, he seems to have learned very little from this experience...
...Truman never went to college but became a pretty good president nonetheless when he succeeded FDR after only a few weeks as vice president...
...And Ken, I’m sorry to tell you, but I think there are an awful lot of jobs in Washington that Palin would get before you...
...Is it those who’ve worked with her, or know her, or have at least met and talked with her...
...In judging Palin, it comes down to who is more credible...
...So far as Palin knows, she’s never met Brooks or been interviewed by him...
...Okay, I may be biased on the subject of Palin, having been impressed after spending nearly two hours with her on one occasion and an hour on another...
...The criticism of Palin is personal...
...Simply by stepping on stage at rallies, Palin rouses audiences, and her speeches are frequently interrupted by chants of “Sarah, Sarah, Sarah...
...This is pure snobbery...
...The issue of experience is more serious...
...Well, I know both Palin and Adelman...
...A media person I know dismisses her as “a journalism graduate of the University of Idaho...
...Palin is in a familiar situation...
...It’s the private Palin, the person— who she is, what she knows, her lack of experience—that has provoked both the strongest criticism and most legitimate doubts about her readiness to be fi rst in the line of succession if the president dies or is incapacitated...
...I think Palin will continue to be underestimated,” Michaels told EW.com...
...Ruedrich is part of the “body count” of male politicians Palin left behind as she rose to become governor of Alaska...
...Ruedrich isn’t alone among Alaska politicians who take a cold-blooded view of Palin...
...Peggy Noonan, the former White House speechwriter for President Reagan who now writes for the Wall Street Journal, has run hot and cold on Palin, mostly cold...
...If McCain had chosen Minnesota governor Tim Pawlenty (as he came close to doing), Pawlenty would have faced the same doubts...
Vol. 14 • November 2008 • No. 8
