A Winnable War

...Officially known as Linebacker II, this massive, around-the-clock air campaign far exceeded in intensity anything that had gone before...

...The goal was to prevent a crisis from spinning out of control, leading to uncontrolled escalation, possibly to nuclear war...

...An action by one side elicits a response from the other that may be unexpected...

...Moyar contends that this is false...

...but when evidence of Lodge's duplicity became clear, Kennedy did not replace him for fear that Lodge would turn his ouster into a campaign issue...

...Triumph Forsaken is meticulously documented and bold in its interpretation of the record...

...Triumph Forsaken is one of the most important books ever written on the Vietnam war...

...ambassador to South Vietnam, Henry Cabot Lodge, against Diem...

...Everything that could be done in an attempt to crush the revolution was carried out by Diem...

...But contemporary Chinese documents make it clear that no such response was contemplated...

...That claim is belied by the fact that Johnson saw intervention only as a last resort to avoid the defeat of South Vietnam and what he thought would be the subsequent toppling of the Southeast Asian dominoes...

...Lodge's continued meddling made Diem more intractable, which reinforced Lodge's predisposition to replace him...

...Both Krulak and Mendenhall briefed Kennedy on September 10...

...The Hanoi Politburo recognized the opportunity that the coup had provided the Communists: "Diem was one of the strongest individuals resisting the people and Communists...

...policy and strategy for Vietnam proved especially counterproductive, if for no other reason than the "value of the object" for the North Vietnamese was greater than that of the Soviets in Cuba...

...But the militant Buddhist leaders were far from the political innocents described by Halberstam and Sheehan, and the most important of them, Thich Tri Quang, was a brother of the North Vietnamese official in charge of subversion in the south...

...ground troops that began in 1965...

...Moyar argues that President Lyndon Johnson rejected several aggressive strategic options available to him, options that would have permitted South Vietnam to continue the war, either without the employment of U.S...

...that the "domino theory"—the belief that the fall of South Vietnam to the Communists would lead to the collapse of other non-Communist regimes in Southeast Asia—was false...

...Moyar shows that our actions in Vietnam were based on bad intelligence in the service of a flawed theory of war...

...As journalists such as Stanley Karnow later admitted, Pham was very good at his job...

...The rejection of these options meant that Johnson was left with the choice of abandoning South Vietnam, a step fraught with grave international consequences, or fighting a defensive war within South Vietnam at a serious strategic disadvantage...

...Many policymakers had come to believe that strategy in the traditional sense was no longer possible in the nuclear age...

...In fact, Diem's efforts to mollify the Americans by offering concessions to the Buddhists only invited more demands, undercut Diem's authority, and emboldened his enemies, who interpreted his attempts at compromise as weakness...

...Moyar's history takes issue with all of these contentions...

...Victory or defeat depends on decisions actually made and strategies actually implemented...

...If there is a villain in Moyar's account, it is Lodge...

...strategic decisions in Vietnam without reference to nuclear deterrence...

...According to the orthodox view, Vietnam was indeed a "quagmire," a war the United States was destined to lose...

...But then, these same reporters were themselves influenced by others with axes to grind...

...In fact, Diem was an effective leader who put down the organized crime empires that had thrived before his rise to power...

...Moyar contends that Johnson had viable military options that could have enabled South Vietnam to survive while avoiding the massive commitment of U.S...

...The second observer was Joseph Mendenhall of the State Department, who had been recommended to the president by Averell Harriman and Roger Hilsman...

...advisers to the South Vietnamese army, Krulak concluded that the war was going well...

...Nothing illustrates the orthodox/revisionist divide more than their respective treatments of Ngo Dinh Diem...

...Influenced by American journalists, he saw Diem as an intransigent opponent of reform...

...ground forces or by a limited deployment of U.S...

...Mendenhall, like Har-riman and Hilsman a longtime advocate of replacing Diem, visited three Mackubin Thomas Owens is professor of national security at the Naval War College...

...They were especially effective in portraying Buddhists as victims of Diem's repression of non-Catholics...

...No review can do full justice to this critically important book...

...And indeed, the coup provided the incentive for the Communists to push for a quick victory against the weak South Vietnamese government before the United States intervened...

...Moyar has exhaustively consulted the relevant archives and uses them to demonstrate the very real limitations of the orthodox view...

...Indeed, most observers at the time criticized Johnson for not responding forcefully enough to the Tonkin Gulf incident, and major U.S...

...In the orthodox view, Diem was a tyrant losing control of his country, a Catholic running roughshod over a predominantly Buddhist populace...

...He did not, as many have argued, use the August 1964 Gulf of Tonkin incident as an excuse to escalate U.S...

...The first, Major General Victor Krulak, USMC, the special assistant for counterinsurgency for the Joint Chiefs of Staff, visited some ten locations in all four Corps areas of Vietnam...

...So diametrically opposed were their conclusions that the president quipped, "The two of you did visit the same country, didn't you...

...Orthodox historians often act as if Hanoi pursued a course of action with little regard for what the United States did...

...This is an example of what has been called "national narcissism," the idea that history is just about us...

...Most often associated with the Harvard political scientist Thomas Schelling, limited war theory emphasized using military force in a controlled way to "signal" one's opponent...

...This is a far cry from the orthodox view, but Moyar has some pretty good witnesses: the Communists themselves...

...In that sense, Kennedy was hoist on his own petard: He had sought to neutralize Lodge, a likely 1964 Republican presidential candidate, by sending him to Saigon...

...Rather than focusing on the choice of the proper means to achieve national goals, as strategy demands, policymakers saw Vietnam and similar cases as "crises" in need of control...

...While conditions had changed vastly in seven years," Pike continued, "the dismaying conclusion to suggest itself from the 1972 Christmas bombing was that had this kind of air assault been launched in February 1965, the Vietnam war as we know it might have been over within a matter of months, even weeks...

...But Moyar demonstrates that the North Vietnamese strategy was greatly affected by U.S...

...Limited war theory was the very negation of strategy, but McNamara and others wrongly saw the Cuban Missile Crisis as its validation...

...Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara was a proponent of Schelling's theory, but the uniformed military and former President Eisenhower were skeptical...

...Hanoi was stunned...

...Indeed, we cannot understand U.S...

...Moyar does acknowledge the role of the academic theory of limited war, which was developed precisely to prevent a crisis from escalating...

...ground intervention did not begin until nearly a year later...

...Based on extensive interviews with U.S...

...Even orthodox historians will be forced to acknowledge the magnitude of Moyar's scholarly achievement...

...imperialists...

...Nor was he a democrat: His legitimacy, in the eyes of the people, arose from his ability to wield power effectively and provide security for the people who were the target of the Communist insurgency...

...Of course, important decisions were also made in Hanoi, Beijing, Moscow, and many other places...

...After reading Mark Moyar's remarkable new book, Triumph Forsaken, readers accustomed to the "orthodox" view of the Vietnam war—entrenched in the academy and the press for decades— will no doubt have the same sort of "Kennedy moment...

...They feared the North was to be visited by intolerable destruction which it simply could not endure...

...First, he was a victim of press bias: No one did more to undermine Diem's reputation in the United States than David Halberstam and Neil Sheehan...

...As a result, North Vietnamese leaders concluded that the United States lacked the will to bear the cost of the war...

...He not only places Vietnam in its proper geopolitical context, but demonstrates the Clausewitzian principle that war is a struggle between two active wills...

...The first of two projected volumes, it focuses on the period from the defeat of the French by the Viet Minh in 1954 to the eve of Lyndon Johnson's commitment of major ground forces in 1965...

...that among the most corrupt was the regime of Diem, who Triumph Forsaken The Vietnam War, 1954-1965 by Mark Moyar Cambridge, 542 pp., $32 was good at repressing Buddhists (Diem was Catholic) but was losing to the Viet Cong Communists...

...Diem was one of the most competent lackeys of the U.S...

...Moyar's thesis is that the American defeat was not inevitable: The United States had ample opportunities to ensure the survival of South Vietnam, but it failed to develop the proper strategy to do so...

...Unfortunately, the attempt to use limited war theory to shape U.S...

...Army adviser, Lt...

...Not surprisingly, Vietnamese Communists exploited that post-Diem instability and adopted a more aggressive and ambitious stance...

...and that the rejection of certain military options—the mining of Haiphong Harbor, the use of ground troops to interdict the Ho Chi Minh Trail—was proper given the fear of Chinese intervention...

...For the most part, orthodox historians have covered the war as if the only important decisions were made in Washington and Saigon...

...Conditions continued to deteriorate, forcing Kennedy's successor, Lyndon Johnson, to consider an American escalation of the war to save South Vietnam...

...interests...

...Moyar describes Lodge's duplicity: He told the president that he was unable stop the anti-Diem coup, but it was Lodge who instigated it in the first place, in defiance of Kennedy's wishes...

...actions...

...The only man in South Vietnam who could reestablish order was Diem, but Ambassador Lodge insisted on further acts of conciliation, which led to further disorder...

...If Tri Quang was not a Communist himself, he was at least an agent of influence...

...political leaders to consider military options for Vietnam in the context of nuclear deterrence...

...forces in strategically advantageous positions in the southern part of North Vietnam or in Laos...

...This point was driven home to me in 1983 when the late Douglas Pike, the foremost American expert on Vietnamese communism and an early proponent of Vietnam revisionism, delivered a paper at a Wilson Center symposium on the war...

...Their mission was to provide the president an assessment of the regime of Ngo Dinh Diem, the president of the Republic of Vietnam...

...Citing Communist documents, Moyar shows that they were honest enough to acknowledge their lack of success in the period leading up to the 1963 coup, as well as the fact that the Diem government was killing and capturing Communist cadres in unprecedented number, leading many survivors to defect...

...It should, at the least, reopen the debate about America's Vietnam enterprise, reminding us that countries are not destined to win or lose wars...

...that the South Vietnamese government was hopelessly corrupt and did not command the allegiance of the South Vietnamese people...

...So why has Diem been depicted the way he has...

...But it was Lodge who proved to be heavy-handed and closed-minded, vices that led him to support the ouster of Diem as part of a personal vendetta...

...involvement...

...But the air campaign was severely constrained, a fact that became increasingly apparent to Hanoi...

...The central idea was that rational actors on both sides would limit the steps they took in order to avoid the escalation of a crisis...

...Ho Chi Minh understood the coup's import immediately: "I can scarcely believe that the Americans could be so stupid," he remarked...

...And by far our greatest mistake was to acquiesce in the November 1963 coup that deposed and killed Diem, a decision that "forfeited the tremendous gains of the preceding nine years and plunged the country into an extended period of instability and weakness...

...In addition, many American reporters relied on a Vietnamese journalist named Pham Xuan An, a Reuters stringer later revealed to be a Communist agent whose very mission was to influence the American press...

...It is generally accepted, even by orthodox chroniclers, that the coup and the subsequent assassination of Diem and Nhu were mistakes of the greatest magnitude...

...A brilliant young scholar with a Cambridge doctorate who is currently teaching at the Marine Corps University in Quantico, Moyar is representative of a small but increasingly influential revisionist school that rejects the fundamental orthodox premise that America's involvement in Vietnam was wrongheaded and unjust...

...The axioms of the orthodox view concerning the Vietnam war are well known: that Southeast Asia in general, and South Vietnam in particular, were not vital strategic U.S...

...South Vietnamese cities where he spoke primarily to opponents of the South Vietnamese president...

...Indeed, under Diem's leadership, the back of the Communist insurgency had pretty much been broken by 1960...

...This contention is supported by the fact that, in 1972-73, Richard Nixon employed many of the same options available to Johnson in late 1964, and these steps would most likely have preserved the independence of South Vietnam had it not been for the action of Congress in 1974-75 to completely cut off all military support to our ally...

...John Paul Vann...

...Much of the criticism of the Diem regime's military policy was fed to them by the maverick U.S...

...Pike then made an extraordinary claim by comparing the effects of the constrained air campaign in 1965 and the "Christmas bombing" of 1972...

...Sheehan and Halberstam, in turn, greatly influenced the new U.S...

...Pike observed that "the initial reaction of Hanoi's leaders to the strategic bombings and air strikes that began in February 1965— documented later by defectors and other witnesses—was enormous dismay and apprehension...

...Moyar provides evidence that many of the "Buddhist" protesters were, in fact, Communist provocateurs...

...that Ho Chi Minh was not a true Communist but a nationalist...

...Could Moyar possibly be writing about the same war that is described (in the orthodox view) as, at best, a strategic error and, at worst, a brutal imperialist war of aggression—in any case, a tragic mistake...

...The primary weakness of the orthodox school, Moyar demonstrates, is its constricted historical horizon...

...Far from providing a balanced picture of the war, they pushed a decidedly anti-Diem view, and their prejudice was so transparent that a 1963 congressional mission described the American journalists as "arrogant, emotional, un-objective, and ill-informed...

...Unsurprisingly, he concluded in his report that if Diem and his brother Ngo Dinh Nhu remained in power, the Diem government was certain to fall to the Viet Cong, or the country would descend into religious civil war...

...When Johnson was weighing his options in Vietnam the United States was only three years removed from the Cuban Missile Crisis...

...I happen to agree, but I don't think Moyar sufficiently appreciates the immense pressure on U.S...

...One of Johnson's fears was that, if the United States invaded North Vietnam or Laos to interdict the Ho Chi Minh Trail, China would intervene...