The Packaging of Obama
Gray, Kevin Alexander
Books The Packaging of Obama The Audacity of Hope: Thoughts on Reclaiming the American Dream By Barack Obama Crown. 384 pages. $25. By Kevin Alexander Gray My wife, Sandra, warned...
...And of course the issue is not of shared values...
...Throughout, Obama proffers an unnaturally romantic view of the Democratic Party for a person of his age...
...I’ve spoken to a couple of writer friends who attended an Obama event and in both conversations the comparison to John Kennedy was bandied about...
...And while the book is technically well written with aspirations to inspire, Obama falls far short of the mountaintop...
...Or “Keep the Faith, Baby...
...Obama’s face is everywhere...
...What is lacking here is devotion to principles, which Obama constantly sacrifices on the altar of “shared values...
...But of course he was only three years old and living in Hawaii when Lyndon Johnson went on national television to give a speech so that Hamer’s image and the MFDP challenge would be off the airwaves...
...And he goes out of his way to comfort whites with a critique of black Americans that could tumble out of the mouth of William Bennett...
...At the top of Obama’s shared values matrix is his Christian faith, his heterosexual family, the American flag, and the Democratic Party...
...At its core, this is what The Audacity of Hope promotes, instead of any fundamental progressive change...
...With Jackson’s phrase, all could demand a seat at the Democratic Party table...
...Or softening a rightfully deserved blow as when he describes racist southern Senator Richard B. Russell as “erudite...
...King set out to change the social, economic, and political structures of this country...
...So, if you are searching Obama’s book for hints or even the language of the kind of change that means something in a structural and systemic way, it’s not there...
...There was much to dislike about them even before the days when they authorized then-FBI director J. Edgar Hoover to bug Dr...
...He is also a contributing editor to Black News in South Carolina...
...Is it an orchestrated, consciously plotted pretext to inoculate a politician from the perceived liabilities of race, lineage, and inexperience...
...Hamer’s fight was a precursor to the candidacy of Shirley Chisholm, the first black to seriously run for President in 1972 (if you exclude Dick Gregory’s 1968 bid...
...As a political tome, The Audacity of Hope is kind of a new and improved, better-written version of Clinton’s long-winded speech at the ’88 Democratic Convention in book form...
...Overall, the treatise reads like a very, very long speech of sound bites and clich?s arranged by topic and issue and connected by conjunctions, pleasantries, and apologies...
...Gray served as 1988 South Carolina coordinator for the Presidential campaign of Jesse Jackson and as 1992 southern political director for Iowa Senator Tom Harkin’s Presidential bid...
...Clinton picked up the phrase, and it is now a standard part of the political lexicon...
...It’s like he did not have a clue about the 1964 struggles of Fannie Lou Hamer and the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party...
...While people may indeed have a shared reality—which means we witness the same things—we don’t always feel, understand, process, or react to what we witness in the same way...
...Take, for instance, his praise of Reagan, hedged as it is by criticism of the “John Wayne, Father Knows Best pose, his policy by anecdote, and his gratuitous assault on the poor...
...Given all the policy disasters of the Bush Administration, what troubles Obama about the Bush era is not so much the policies Republicans championed but “the process—or lack of process—by which the White House and its Congressional allies disposed of opposing views...
...The simplest example of not having a “shared understanding” is the difference in how blacks and whites view the police...
...No one in their right mind could believe that the United States places a Muslim on an equal footing with a Christian or Jew...
...His destruction of the welfare system, his embrace of capital punishment and other punitive and discriminatory crime policies, his bowing to Wall Street all made him palatable to many Republicans...
...But he suggests that what’s broken can be fixed versus being replaced altogether...
...The shame of Obama’s lack of depth is that Hamer’s conflict over representation pretty much set the table for how the Democratic Party deals with blacks today...
...The Audacity of Hope: You can’t chant it in a crowd like, well, “Keep Hope Alive...
...This country will never elect a man named Hussein President...
...I know it is ill-advised not to take heed of her warning...
...He offers no boldness...
...King, after which the top cop and closet cross-dresser (no disrespect to cross-dressers) in turn authorized his agents to try to prod King into killing himself...
...For instance, before it became evident that Al Sharpton’s effort in South Carolina was going nowhere fast, she coined the now-popular phrase “scampaign” to refer to the reverend’s run...
...Not that I am a fan in the slightest regard of John and the early Robert Kennedy...
...The book arrives amidst the hype of an upcoming and wide open Presidential race, the collective angst over the country moving in the wrong direction, an economy that working people know isn’t as good as they are being told it is, and a war that has washed away—at home and abroad—the country’s preexisting false sense of moral superiority...
...And The Audacity of Hope places Obama squarely in the DLC camp, even if he never applies for a membership card...
...or “Power to the People...
...And he actually wrote of reforming the system of campaign finance, increasing electoral participation, and eliminating the Electoral College...
...They’re just there in the middle and never ending, with a stop sign as the only relief...
...Now San (as we call her), who has worked in retail sales selling ladies shoes throughout her working life, is not an overtly political person...
...But the book is like those two solid yellow lines on a two-lane mountain road...
...And, there is no shortage of opinion about him, which makes it difficult to read his book and sort things out without atmospheric bias...
...With San’s admonition in mind, I tried to table her (and my) Oprahtainted, media-hyped preconception of Barack Obama so that I could read The Audacity of Hope with an open mind and with the same hopeful spirit as the title seeks to portray...
...Or is it all just talk, posturing and positioning for personal political goals...
...As the line in Ethan and Joel Coen’s 2000 movie, O Brother, Where Art Thou, goes, “Everybody’s looking for answers...
...Clinton’s “common ground” was with the Democratic Leadership Council...
...Sometimes it may take reading the entire book, down to the last page before you realize how telling or appropriate a title is...
...An older white gentleman standing next to me said, “Ya know his middle name is Hussein...
...She is one of those old-timey, “salt of the earth” types...
...That perhaps explains why some (with motives good and bad) in the black community complain that he “is not black enough,” or “he has no respect or appreciation for the past,” or “he is the amalgamation of everything white folk want a black man to be,” or “he’s a white boy being scripted by smart-ass white boys...
...Jackson’s Straight from the Heart, which many people contributed to, still holds up as a record of where progressives stood at a particular point and where many progressives stand today...
...Ross Perot’s United We Stand at least tried to confront some familiar problems such as the federal debt...
...Profiles in Courage is a historical marker in a way Audacity of Hope will never be...
...Or accusing his mom of having an “incorrigible, sweet-natured romanticism” about the ’60s and the civil rights era as he waxes nostalgic about Hubert Humphrey’s Democratic Party...
...Many people value religion, but which religion has more value...
...As proof that the United States government values Christians over Muslims, consider that the United States is at war with an Islamic country...
...Give Obama credit for copping to the fact that his “treatment of the issues is often partial and incomplete...
...In the end, all he offers is the promise of a “hope” that he will manage the process better than the other guy or gal...
...It there anything in it that will help stimulate measurable change...
...He opines that if we would all just recognize our “shared understanding,” “shared values,” and “the notion of a common good” that life (or politics) in the United States would be better...
...Reagan spoke to America’s longing for order, our need to believe that we are not subject to blind, impersonal forces, but that we can shape our individual and collective destinies...
...Obama gets a lot wrong from start to finish...
...Nonetheless, it comes as no surprise that The Audacity of Hope is number one on the New York Times bestseller list...
...By contrast, Clinton wanted the Democratic Party to renew its “common ground” with those who left the party with Strom Thurmond and the Dixiecrats and those who jumped ship when Ronald Reagan rose to power: white men...
...Many of the social or cultural factors that negatively affect black people, for example, simply mirror in exaggerated form problems that afflict America as a whole: too much television (the average black household has the television on more than eleven hours per day), too much consumption of poisons (blacks smoke more and eat more fast food), and a lack of emphasis on educational attainment,” he writes...
...Obama touches all the hot button words like the “nuclear option,” “strict constructionists,” and the like but never really says anything deep or brave or new other than to remind us that the hot buttons are really hot...
...His infatuation with his party seems at times deeper than his understanding of the civil rights movement, which comes across as antiseptic...
...I was at the bank talking politics, among other things, with Maria, the head teller...
...Writes Obama: “I understood his appeal...
...But I’m afraid people are going to discount Obama not for what he says, but for who he is...
...The daily body count dispels that notion...
...The hope in Obama’s title is for a mixture of Kennedyism, Reaganism, and Clintonism packaged as the new face of multicultural America...
...It’s somewhat reminiscent of Jesse Jackson’s “common ground” theme that he built his ’88 campaign around...
...So then, why write the book...
...The book has no soul...
...It was the same appeal that the military bases back in Hawaii always held for me as a young boy, with their tidy streets and well-oiled machinery, the crisp uniforms and crisper salutes...
...Under Bill Clinton, U.S...
...Although we now know that John F. Kennedy did not write Profiles in Courage, the book is one you have on your shelf that you might look through on occasion and actually enjoy rereading...
...In the end, the feels trapped in a valley of buzzwords, catch phrases, and insider jargon, with words like “halcyon” thrown in for good measure...
...The answers are no, no, yes, yes...
...Chisholm continued Hamer’s fight for a greater black and female voice in politics and government...
...In this country we all know the answer to that question...
...As I spoke in my usual unrestrained and audible way, so as to let anyone hear me without having to eavesdrop, Obama’s name came up...
...But when she doesn’t like a person, there is usually something wrong with that person...
...Consider that Muslims in this country are subject to increased government scrutiny and racial, ethnic, and religious profiling...
...The book is surprisingly short on substance...
...On cue, Obama plays the Kennedy card throughout his book, tossing in passages from Profiles in Courage...
...King’s “third way” is far different than Bill Clinton’s “third way,” promoted by Obama and all those around Hillary, who tout the Clintons as the second and third coming of Camelot...
...But the use and meaning of Jackson’s phrase has changed over the years since Clinton co-opted it...
...Then there’s the collapse of the two-parent black household, a phenomenon that . . . reflects a casualness towards sex and child rearing among black men...
...It all sounds pleasant, but it’s surely not new...
...Pleasantries like wishing for a return to the days when Republicans and Democrats “met at night for dinner, hashing out a compromise over steaks and cigars...
...Shared values” and “the notion of a common good” pretty much amount to the same thing in Obamaspeak...
...Not everyone writes a book before running for the Presidency...
...So long as we rediscover the traditional values of hard work, patriotism, personal responsibility, optimism, and faith...
...He described the change as a “third way” beyond capitalism and socialism...
...I can agree with Obama on the need for a new kind of politics...
...The title of a book usually tells the story...
...To which I could only respond, “Well, the country elected a man that is insane...
...But some do, and those books reveal things about the person and the time...
...Clinton’s “common ground” pushed aside those whom Jackson brought to the party...
...troops weren’t trapped in Iraq, but just as many, if not more, Iraqis died as a result of his policies...
...But The Audacity of Hope plays on the creation of a Kennedy-like mystique...
...The Clinton “third way” is Republican Party politics in slow motion...
...Yet, does Obama’s book provide any real answers...
...By Kevin Alexander Gray My wife, Sandra, warned me, “Don’t be hating...
...It’s how we rank our values...
...Kevin Alexander Gray is lead organizer of the Harriet Tubman Freedom House Project in Columbia, South Carolina, which focuses on communitybased political and cultural education...
...Jackson’s “common ground” meant bringing together a coalition of workers, women, men, blacks, progressive whites, gays and lesbians, environmentalists, anti-apartheid activists, those opposed to Ronald Reagan’s illegal war in Central America, farmers, Latinos, Arab Americans, and other traditionally underrepresented or unrepresented groups...
Vol. 71 • February 2007 • No. 2