WHAT DO I KNOW?
Feldman, Michael
WHAT DO I KNOW? Michael Feldman The Republican Bill of Rights Notes from the Republican Congressional Working Committee on the Constitution. Chair: As you know, we're already well into the...
...Five has that problem with due process we talked about...
...Can't this be addressed through zoning...
...Not abridging the freedom of responsible speech," I like, and I think we need to insert something before "press" as well, but I don't think we should use "responsible" again...
...The second...
...Let's pencil in a million and see if they salute...
...Guns...
...In fact, only MacNeil/Lehrer picked it up, and they were afraid—in the present climate—to make a big deal about it...
...OK, that's the first ten...
...Why don't we put the "we won't pay for the little bastards"—you know, the welfare proposal—in here...
...Overall, religion needs to be in there, but I don't like to lead with it—too controversial...
...As for "no excessive bail or fines," OK, but where does it say anything about acceptable collateral...
...Obviously, we're not going to do anything cruel or unusual, and if we do, that's where term limits kick in...
...I'll mention it at the NRA Donor...
...Once again, the main point, the protection of private property rights, is buried at the bottom of a lot of language protecting the rights of criminals...
...it's only ten amendments...
...We could turn down the volume more than just a few db's by eliminating it altogether...
...The Democrats thrashing about nearly pulled us under when they introduced the Fourth Amendment on the floor and we were compelled to vote it down, but, although that was premature, I don't believe any damage was done...
...This...
...Is this a problem...
...I don't know about you, but I think the phrase is cruel and unusual...
...Any in particular give you trouble, let me know as soon as possible, as the printing takes about three weeks.B Michael Feldman is the executive producer and host of Public Radio International's "Whad'ya Know...
...The seventh (and this is a good example of what we're up against with tort reform)—the right to a "trial by jury where the value in controversy is more than twenty dollars"—that needs upping...
...Anyway, now that we've made it clear that what's reasonable is a judgment call on constitutional law by the arresting officer (who should not have to explain it verbally while making a bust, like Miranda), I think we've laid to rest the vagueness...
...Waters it down...
...Eight...
...You know what they say, one of the two things you don't talk about...
...I run my business like this, I'm out of it...
...With base closings, I could see it being a question, but it's a waste of an amendment, especially so high up...
...A lot of due process is really just the process of doing it...
...You don't put people on death row to make more lawyers...
...Grand jury, self-incrimination, double jeopardy, etc., would all be better off in a manual or something...
...I don't know if there's anything like "pre-existing conditions" or acts of God for rights, but if there is, I think we ought to put it in there just to protect ourselves...
...Nine is just a disclaimer—"if we have any other rights we have them"—although you couldn't write an insurance policy that way...
...Right now, a guy steals a hose reel he gets a trial by jury...
...Once we get rid of the backlog of jury trials—in this next amendment—the trial judge will be free to referee...
...Anyway, looking at the whole package, I say we keep the title "Bill of Rights," especially as we're adding "and Responsibilities," although we will refer to it collectively as the Armey/Hatch Act, and we naturally hope the legislative title will catch on with the media...
...or to the people," at the end, no...
...See, that should be first...
...Here we go, "cruel and unusual, cruel and unusual...
...Now, to get down to brass tacks, Amendment One, religion—window dressing, really, you can't really come out against it, although the language we're adding, "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof in school" should make a difference...
...A speedy and public trial—six—sure, and what about broadcasting it on public television and radio (I just came up with this) with the profits and product tie-ins going back to the Corporation (for Public Broadcasting) to replace the current entitlement...
...Also, "right to counsel" needs looking at, particularly with that train killer doing such a credible job of defending himself...
...Three—no soldiers shall be quartered in a house...
...Property rights reads a lot stronger without them...
...Taking the Fifth" would then mean taking whatever means necessary in defending your home...
...The other part should read something like "a warrant would be nice...
...If there's some way of writing it so it's not ambiguous, you know, the militia part— you clearly don't have to join a militia to "keep and bear Arms"—that needs to be cleaned up, but I love the capitalization...
...It might be helpful to say "rifles and guns" or specify barrels and bores, automatic, semi-automatic, magazine sizes, etc...
...People assume these things are prioritized...
...I don't see what this is doing in here...
...The nice thing about it is it's unobtrusive...
...Maybe "counsel available," or "counsel applied for," is what we need...
...Kind of like adding our signatures to the Constitution...
...Half a million you still get product-liability juries and nobody needs that...
...in fact, from what I've read about some of them, we're a lot more reasonable...
...I'll tell you one thing, not only should they not allow barbells in prison, they should throw out the law books...
...I don't think we're any more "unreasonable" than the Founding Fathers...
...are reserved to the states," now should read on your copies, "the powers not delegated to the States, are reserved to the U.S...
...The sixteenth is Easter, so I figure the seventeenth through the nineteenth should be ample for the Bill of Rights...
...Legitimate," maybe, or "mainstream...
...Jefferson used to run around the woods naked with the help when he wasn't founding the Democratic Party...
...Sure would hate to see those two boys separated...
...Chair: As you know, we're already well into the second hundred days, and we've set aside the second week of April to reconsider the Constitution...
...And ten, "the powers not delegated to the U.S...
...Four, search and seizure—most of this has already been updated on the floor— it's always been a matter of what's "unreasonable...
...although the "reserved to" still sounds wrong to me, but I don't want to mess with original intent...
...The death penalty is now humane and common, so it's exempt anyway...
...We'll be looking at the others in the next round...
...We've already got "peaceably" in the right to assemble, so that's nicely qualified...
...I think a hundred thousand is low...
...Way up...
Vol. 59 • April 1995 • No. 4
