Open Forum: The Tyrant in the Dock
Schneider, Cathy
On November 25, the eve of the fiftieth anniversary of the universal declaration of human rights, the British Law Lords gave human rights activists around the world a reason to celebrate. By...
...The only agreement reached between Pinochet and opposition leaders was to participate in a national plebiscite according to the rules set by Pinochet's own 1980 Constitution...
...Periodicals postage paid at New York, NYand additional mailing offices...
...II A.EIA 4 NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS Executive Director Pierre LaRamre Editors Fred Rosen, Jo-Marie Burt Art Director Viveca Yrisarry Business Manager Marisa Maack Editorial Assistant Bernardo Ruiz Advertising Coordinator Leila Mead Webmaster Greg Shapley Staff Assistants Eric Fichtt, Bianca Gomez Board of Directors Albert Bildner, Oscar Bolioli, Maria Canino, Josh DeWind, Marc Edelman, Rick Edwards, Mark Fried, Fred Goff, Eric Hershberg, Susan Lowes, Don Reasoner, T.M...
...ratified the precedent first set at Nuremburg and endorsed by international conventions, that those guilty of crimes against humanity-including heads of state-will be tried where they are found, or will be extradited to a state willing and able to try them fairly...
...The resulting inability of human rights lawyers to try Pinochet for his crimes in Chile led Spanish prosecutor Joan Garces, a one-time advisor to Salvador Allende, to initiate a case against Pinochet in Spain, where the law defines genocide, torture and terrorism as universal crimes and authorizes Spanish courts to prosecute them anywhere in the world...
...Learn about the Revolution's history and its present...
...Yet, even now, Washington balks at the prospect...
...The Chilean transition was not the result of a pact between two equally matched adversaries...
...Secretary of State Madeline Albright stated: "The citizens of Chile are wrestling with a very difficult problem of how to balance the need for justice with the requirements of reconciliation...
...UK Subscribers: Order from Latin America Bureau, 1 Armel Steet, London EC1R 1UL(Tel...
...Foreign Subscriptions $42/year for individuals ($75/two years, $105/three years...
...Perhaps it is the damning secrets they contain...
...Travel from Habana to the Sierra Maestra...
...Over 70% say it would not distress them if Pinochet never returned to Chile...
...What is the untold story of CIA's relationship with Chile's secret police during the 1970s...
...514-933-67971...
...The United States, however, has been conspicuously silent or "absent without leave," as one trenchant observer put it...
...What then are the real reasons for the U.S...
...According to the lower court's exculpatory logic, he wrote, even Hitler's "final solution" would have to go unpunished "as an official act deriving from the exercise of his functions as head of state...
...Meet with artists, activ- ists, writers and religious ) leaders...
...Views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of NACLA...
...For more information, please contact : Pierre M. LaRam&e Executive Director NACLA 475 Riverside Drive Suite 454 New York, NY 10115 (212) 870-3146 CUBA Following the Footsteps of Che: See Cuban society firsthand...
...Peter Yarrow Editorial Board Emelio Betances, Roger Burbach, Marc Chernick, Carmen Diana Deere, Elizabeth Dore, Jonathan Fox, Jean Franco, Annette Fuentes, Duncan Green, Linda Green, Jack Hammond, Maria Hinojosa, Peter Kornbluh, Deborah Levenson, Deidre McFadyen, Mado Murillo, Paulo Strgio Pinheiro, George Priestley, Gerardo Renique, Helen Safa, Cathy Schneider, Hobart Spalding, Carlos Viias NACLA Report on the Americas (ISSN 1071-4839) is published bimonthly by the North American Congress on Latin America, Inc...
...In other words, Washington claims that providing evidence against Pinochet will undermine Chilean democracy- a claim which did not move Straw in his decision to let the extradition hearings proceed...
...reluctance to declassify the secret documents and turn them over to Spain as evidence...
...Pinochet's defeat in the plebiscite paved the way for Chile's transition to democracy, but it also implied recognition of Pinochet's Constitution--and with it, guarantees of lifelong immunity from prosecution for the General himself...
...According to recent polls, 68% of Chileans would like to see Pinochet stand trial and more than two-thirds would like to see him punished...
...NACLA) 475 Riverside Drive, Suite 454, New York, NY 10115...
...fear is that the next time the Europeans charge someone for crimes against humanity it will be Henry Kissinger, Gerald Ford or George Bush...
...For individuals: CanS50 (Can$85/2 yrs., Can$115/3 yrs...
...policy towards the region...
...Given this situation, Chilean officials may secretly hope that the problem is taken out of their hands...
...Bequests and donations to NACLA are tax-deductible...
...What was the U.S...
...This points to the second faulty premise of the argument that justice and democratic stability are at odds...
...While the official position of the Chilean government is that Chilean democracy depends on Pinochet's return home, the Chilean public thinks otherwise...
...Postmaster: Send address changes to NACLA Report on the Americas PO Box 77, Hopewell, PA 16650-0077 or nadanada@nacla.org Subscription Information $32/year for individuals ($55/two years, $75/three years...
...for institutions: Can$74 (Can$125/2 yrs., Can$170/3 yrs) Call for student rates or check our Website NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS 4 PLAS REEME NAL IN YORWL f you are a strong supporter of NACLA--someone who subscribes not only to the Report, but also to NACLA's mission to educate the public about U.S...
...role in Operation Condor...
...For 25 years the U.S...
...Fax: (212) 870-3305...
...policy and events in Latin America-please remember NACLA in your will, lifeinsurance policy, tax-deferred gift plan, or irrevocable trust...
...Perhaps the real U.S...
...First, the insistence that Pinochet's trial would undermine a negotiated settlement between Pinochet's supporters and opponents is based on a misreading of the Chilean transition to democracy...
...Lord Steyn concurred...
...Plus: MEXICO*ARGENTINA COSTA RICA9BRAZIL GLOBAL EXCHANGE 1-800-497-1994 1 www.globalexchange.org that the United States would prefer that Pinochet be allowed to return to Chile, U.S...
...E-mail: nacla@nacla.org Web site http://www.nacla org NACLA is an independent non-profit organiza- tion founded in 1966 to research the political economy of the Americas and U.S...
...The Spanish courts have been pleading with the U.S...
...L43/year for institutons (L78/two years, L103/three years) Canadian Subscribers: Order from Social Justice Committee, 1857 ouest de Maisonneuve, Montreal, Que., H3H 119 (Tel...
...Faith & Religion in Cuba March 28 - April 5 Health & Healing April 8 - 17 Cuba at a Crossroads June 12 - 20 Art, Culture & Voodoun: Investigate the many fac- ets of this vibrant culture...
...071 278-2829) L25 for individuals (Lf45/two years, L60/three years...
...In fact, the claim that there is a conflict between the goal of seeking justice in the case of Pinochet and that of preserving democracy in Chile is entirely fallacious...
...Scruggs, Robert M. Siegel, George Vickers, Steven Volk, Susan Wood...
...The British have Cathy Schneider teaches at the School of International Studies at American University She is the author of Shantytown Protest in Pinochet's Chile (Temple, 1995...
...55/year for institutions ($92/two years, $130/the years...
...citizens Charlie Horman and Frank Teruggi, the activities of the six military dictatorships participating in Operation Condor and their efforts to annihilate the left, and the planting of the terrorist bomb that killed former Ambassador Orlando Letelier and his assistant Ronnie Moffit in Washington, D.C...
...Tremble tyrants," trumpeted a Paris newspaper...
...government has refused to declassify documents related to the Chilean military coup, the creation and operation of the Chilean secret police organization DINA, the murder of U.S...
...government since 1997 to turn over these files as evidence of Pinochet's engagement in international terrorism...
...It would have cooperated with Pinochet supporters and would not have to risk their wrath, nor would it have to deal with domestic pressure for a trial...
...But it is extremely unlikely that Pinochet supporters would allow the General to stand trial, let alone be sent to prison-and they have been engaged in a frightening campaign of intimidation against democratic politicians, relatives of the disappeared, and English and Spanish journalists based in Chile...
...I think significant respect should be given their conclusions...
...Though appeals are keeping extradition on hold, the ruling by Great Britain's highest court was immediately celebrated throughout Europe as a breakthrough in international human rights law...
...In what many saw as a signal to British Home Secretary Jack Straw Continued on page 42 I om Pedro Monreal: Haroldo Dilla: Guillermo Mil6n: Juan Luis Martin: The Economic Transformation The Emergence of Civil Society The Growth of Anomie New Debates Comhur.ing J4Iar Ne tTm .. .11T...
...The return to civilian government in Chile was the outcome of sustained underground resistance and four years of widespread open protest in the mid-1980s...
...Torture, terrorism and genocide, Lord Nichols argued, are no more a public function of a sovereign than "murdering one's gardener...
...65/year for institutions ($t 12/two years, $160/the years...
...Finally, if Pinochet is returned to Chile, both domestic and international pressure to try him would be very strong...
...If the current government continues to seek Pinochet's freedom, and Pinochet is nevertheless sent to stand trial in Spain, it faces a win/win situation...
...By a margin of three to two, the Lords overturned a lower court ruling giving the Chilean Senatorfor-Life Augusto Pinochet immunity from prosecution under the argument that he was head of state at the time his crimes were committed...
...Tel: (212) 870-3146...
Vol. 32 • January 1999 • No. 4
