Lesbians and the Gay Movement in Argentina
Sarda, Alejandra
In August, 1996, the Statutory Assembly charged with drafting a new statute for the city of Buenos Aires unanimously approved the inclusion of a clause recognizing "the right to be different" and...
...They oppose media visibility and are not interested in civil rights struggles...
...Their first struggle is to accept themselves, and for many, this takes a very long time...
...The clause had been proposed by Maria Jose Lubertino, a feminist politi- cian and member of the Assembly who has long worked with lesbian organizations...
...These differences could produce a schism that could take the movement back to its pre-1995 state, when most lesbians refused to work with gay men...
...Yet in many workplaces, if you say that you are a lesbian, you run the risk of being fired and there is nothing to protect you...
...Yet while les- bians had a presence among the many gay, lesbian, transgendered, transvestite and bisexual groups that lobbied the Assembly to include the clause, their par- ticipation was minimal compared to other groups...
...Lesbians could remain in the movement and serve as its "critical conscience" by making sure that the movement in general does not sell itself short when negotiating between the possi- ble and the desirable, between concrete struggles and utopian visions-a tension that most social movements of the 1990s know all too well...
...Lesbians in this country live in circumstances of overwhelming invisibility and silence," says Luciana...
...With respect to domestic-partner rights, many believe that such benefits are meaningless in a society which demonstrates little tolerance for sexual diversity...
...They emphasize employment benefits and marriage, which are middle-class issues...
...It was a symbolic victory, but it has no visible impact on the lives of lesbians today...
...They must go through long and difficult internal processes before they can even consider coming out and demanding more...
...This is exacerbating already existing tensions between lesbians, who tend to favor keeping events free of corporate sponsorship, and gay men...
...Nor do they maintain any formal political relationships with other lesbian groups, although many women from the other political sec- tors of the community attend social and cultural events at The House of the Moons...
...When lesbians do become visible, moreover, they become easy targets for violence, especially in the provinces, where there are no organizations that provide safe spaces for women in such circumstances...
...And the "ease" with which men inhabit public spaces is still being fueled by an educational system that is deeply sexist...
...Lesbians also favor cutting off ties with and publicly exposing bars that discriminate...
...Some of the lesbians who did not participate in the campaign around the anti-discrimination clause are affiliated with The House of the Moons, an organization that sponsors social, cultural and polit- ical activities exclusively for women of all sexual ori- entations...
...They define themselves as feminists and form part of the autonomous current of the move- ment...
...This is partly driven by the economic disparity that has always existed between men and women, which has been dramati- cally intensified by the current economic crisis...
...She is currently the co-secretary of Lesbians, Bisexual and Transgendered Women of the International Lesbian and Gay Association 2 (ILGA), NACI4A REPORT ON THE AMERICAS 40REPORT ON SEXUAL POLITICS Movement in Argentina the experience and gender consciousness acquired in the feminist and women's movements, and propose a line of work within the broader lesbian/gay/transvestite/transsexual/bisexual (LGTTB) movement that promotes visibility and emphasizes public activity...
...Lesbians have also expressed objections to the way in which the movement is confronting the issue of police violence...
...These political gains show that we have not been able to change the system, and so have no other choice but to insert ourselves within it," says Eiven...
...Yet for many women, the desire and incentives to participate in the LGTTB movement have been mitigated by the sexism and misogyny of homosexual men which, despite some genuine efforts to change, remain a widespread problem among male activists in Argentina...
...In general, lesbians feel quite alienated by both campaigns...
...Organizations focus their attack on the police," says Alejandra, "which is nothing but an arm of the state, instead of demanding changes in the structures of power themselves...
...If the orga- nized lesbian movement is to emerge as a positive voice with an agenda of its own, it must learn to reach this vast unorganized sector of women and to incorporate their needs and concerns into its political work...
...Alejandra voices even harsher criticisms: "There is a powerful class bias in these demands...
...These women belong to a sector of the lesbian community that is the direct political heir of the first wave of activists of the Argentinian Homosexual Community (CHA...
...In August, 1996, the Statutory Assembly charged with drafting a new statute for the city of Buenos Aires unanimously approved the inclusion of a clause recognizing "the right to be different" and con- demning all forms of discrimination, including those based on sexual orientation...
...Members of the Gay/Lesbian Youth Group were very enthusias- tic about the campaign, as were some independent lesbians...
...Some of them come together in bars or dance clubs, but they are also a minority...
...The enthusiasm and activism that this campaign sparked among many gay and travesti organiza- tions did not spill over into lesbian organizations and the lesbian community at large, reflecting the current state of the lesbian move- ment in Argentina...
...The broader LGTTB movement is currently organizDing around two different issues-domestic-partner benefits and police brutality against travestis and gay men...
...When they do participate, it is usually in contexts where men set the political agenda...
...Laura Eiven, a feminist and member of Lesbians in Sight, raised questions about the negative impact of such legalistic campaigns...
...But many women, including some who actually participated in the campaign, expressed reservations about its political objectives...
...But this is not the only possible outcome...
...The vast majority of Argentine lesbians are skepti- cal of all organizations...
...None of these organizations recognize that there are other social classes with other needs and interests, and none of them are proposing a more radical agenda...
...Lesbians in Sight was also involved, though they were a bit more distant...
...This has led individuals and organizations, like Lesbians in Sight for example, to shift their priorities towards women's issues rather than gay rights per se...
...They do not participate in either the Gay Pride March or the National Gatherings-the two major events organized by the LGTTB movement...
...Since discrimination itself is not penalized the clause is really meaningless for my everyday existence," says Luciana Kerner, a member of the Youth Group...
...At least for now, this is our only avenue of resistance-and it is a bit too 'legalistic' for my taste...
...Another factor which has kept many on the margins of activity are the increasing disagreements over the directions that activism should take...
...They also bring to their activism Alejandra Sarda is a psychologist and a member of the Written on the Body Archives and Library in Buenos Aires...
...The idea is that if my partner is entitled to social benefits, then I can have access to them as well," says Luciana...
...Outside Buenos Aires, the participation of lesbians in organizations is practically nonexistent...
...This forces many women to concentrate their energies and resources exclusively on subsistence, leaving little room for other activities...
...There are also polemical debates within the movement about whether private corporations should sponsor events like the Gay Pride March, and about how do deal with gay bars that explicitly exclude travestis...
Vol. 31 • January 1998 • No. 4
