IN WHOSE INTERESTS?
Gosse, Van
The most intriguing and still-unanswered ques- Ition regarding the Central America solidarity movement has to do with its private allies and sponsors outside of the left. It is no revelation to...
...I would contend that this connection was no accident, anymore than the strange insistence of traditional Democratic Party leaders such as Tip O'Neill and Jim Wright in pressing for negotiated solutions in Central America can be attributed to the former's "sentimental connections with Maryknoll nuns or the latter's egomania...
...In the foreign-policy elite, in the investment community, in the Council on Foreign Relations, and finally therefore in Congress, a perspective had developed that looked at military or paramilitary intervention in the Third World-and militarism in general-with a skeptical eye...
...It is no revelation to note that Reagan's re-staging of Vietnam in Nicaragua and El Salvador enjoyed less than overwhelming support from the propertied classes in this country...
...The lessons of the 1980s-how to confound and adapt to the prevailing trends in the North-may turn out to be very useful...
...Given the unipolar world we now inhabit, where no great or even mid-sized power is likely to act as an insurance agency for social revolution, movements for justice in the poor regions of the world will have a very limited margin within which to maneuver...
...A true united front of capital, such as existed from roughly 1945 through the Tet Offensive in 1968, would have easily snuffed out the FSLN, the FMLN and much else, whatever the cost...
...In Right Turn: The Decline of the Democrats and the Future of American Politics (New York: Hill and Wang, 1986), Thomas Ferguson and Joel Rogers argue that there are specific sectors of capital (especially real-estate interests and some multinationally focused invest- ment banks) which periodically support peace organizing and anti-interventionist or anti-mili- tarist liberal candidates because it is isn their political-economic interest to do so...
...If that were not the case, there would have been no need for back-alley operations carried out by second-rank lone rangers like Oliver North...
...Not at all...
...The not-inconsiderable merit of the Central America movement is that it suggested how far those contradictions could be pushed...
...The whole point of the contemporary practice of solidarity-unless one believes it is merely the mouthing of slogans and the giving of unwanted advice about how to make the proper kind of revolution-is to operate as a counter-hegemonic force within the United States, using the advantages provided by political contradictions here to benefit the struggle there...
...Most of the money presumably went to the Wash- ington-based human rights community, though smaller sums were also directed to more radical forces if they were demonstrably effective...
...They marshal con- vincing evidence to demonstrate that these sectors "invested" in the Nuclear Freeze movement of the early 1980s so as to blunt what was seen as an unproductive and dangerous trend towards mili- tary confrontation with the Soviet Union...
...Many of the foundations-like Ford and Rockefeller-which have supported and influenced the Freeze and other social movements since the 1960s, also invested in the Central America movement...
...But after Vietnam, no such consensus was possi- ble...
...Most solidarity activists, if they knew of it at all, were puzzled by the 1992 Republican attempt to smear Hillary Clinton as a "radical leftist" because she had chaired the board of the New World Foundation when it gave CISPES a modest grant...
...Is this hypothesis intended to suggest that the solidarity movement, or its friends in Central America's revolutionary movements, were bought off or duped by the discrete charms of the "liberal bourgeoisie...
Vol. 28 • March 1995 • No. 5
