An Interview with Subcomandante Marcos
McCaughan, Michael
Since the January 1st uprising of the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN), Subcomandante Marcos-the guerrilla force's most visible leader-has emerged as an articulate spokesperson for the...
...Doesn't it seem to you that the government could-with some political sleight-of-hand and minor changes--convince the country that nothing has happened in Chiapas...
...In addition to this, you need areas that are propitious for political work...
...There definitely has to be a change...
...You need geographic conditions of isolation, security, depopulated zones, places where you won't be detected...
...The government is giving a bandaid that will allow it to recompose its image, to reach the August elections in a good climate, to recover its prestige...
...If we had signed a peace agreement, the causes would remain...
...People are going to question not only the whole economic and political project of this country, but the ascendency of neoliberalism in all of Latin America...
...Are the government's proposals the price, then, that it is ready to pay to silence the indigenous peoples...
...They thought that this was the way to calm things down...
...Don't give too much weight to the EZLN...
...It has to do not only with the Zapatista uprising, but also with the collapse of the myth of Mexico's entrance into the First World, of the supposed apathy of the Mexican who will put up with anything...
...Why in Chiapas...
...This invariably leads you to ask yourself: and you, what are you going to do about it...
...You can keep a certain social prestige or status for sure, and still bet on good will and charity...
...after Chiapas, there would be another Chiapas...
...It's not a blow-up where you say it's now or never...
...Then the principal element of our army appears, the other initiators: the indigenous campesinos from the area who got to know some of the compaiieros that began organizing here...
...I believe the fallacious notion of the end of history has finally been destroyed...
...It doesn't mean that they are going to kill you or anything, but that to turn back would mean to surrender...
...Marcos was interviewed in the liberated zone inside Chiapas' Lacand6n jungle by Irish journalist Michael McCaughan in March...
...Why was there so much pressure on the government to sign a peace accord...
...Things are out of order...
...This was worthwhile...
...Since the January 1st uprising of the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN), Subcomandante Marcos-the guerrilla force's most visible leader-has emerged as an articulate spokesperson for the country's dispossessed...
...rather, you have to prepare before acting...
...The panorama narrows at that point, but there continue to be various options in states such as Oaxaca and Guerrero...
...In this case, turning back gives you a certain distance...
...The project of preparing a war, an armed struggle, means that you have to think everything through...
...How does the EZLN hope to achieve changes in the economic order when a process of market globalization exists from which it is impossible to separate yourself...
...The Mexican government has requested, cajoled and bullied the national media into giving as little publicity as possible to Marcos...
...Chiapas has called attention to itself because of the form in which it shines, because of the novelty of its armed movement, and its ideology...
...It shows that the government still has a lot of room to maneuver: they can negotiate with an armed group, stop a war, bet that the compas are going to go away with those false promises and sign a peace agreement in exchange not for highways, hospitals and schools but for only the promise of them...
...Camacho realized that he had to turn to them and make them attractive proposals...
...We insist that armed struggle is the only way, because we've tried everything else and it got us nowhere...
...It meant starting over again, being another person, someone who is authentic...
...a moment near the beginning of the dialogue, [government negotiator] Camacho realized that it was the indigenous peasants who were in charge of the Committee and not Marcos...
...A dictator, then, a dictatorship...
...They were not going to respond to the offer of an embassy or prerogatives of this type...
...when your head aches, it doesn't cure the illness, but only relieves the pain for a little while...
...It is going to reach crisis proportions...
...Now, anywhere you look, any protest is necessarily against the government...
...Pronasol has the mentality of a son of a bitch that sees the indigenous people as children, as ill-bred children...
...They think that these people whom they've deceived for so long are now going to allow themselves to be deceived yet again...
...You begin to take steps-first becoming interested in a situation, then understanding that there is injustice, then trying to understand the roots of this injustice...
...You realize that you had to be prepared to act in accordance with your beliefs, and put all this in the balance-I mean on the one hand, the sacrifices, the things you had to give up, and on the other, being authentic, "true" as we say...
...I see it as an attempt to influence them without resolving the fundamental causes, which are the lack of democracy, of freedom, and of justice...
...It was forgotten that the causes that led to the uprising still exist...
...if we are fucked up, it's precisely because nobody comes here...
...You begin by helping out in small ways, taking logical steps, without pressure, by your own initiative...
...You know that it's a mirage, a deception...
...Years from now, whether or not the EZLN is still around, there is going to be protest and social ferment in many places...
...They told us that the uprising represents something that they wanted to say, and now they have found the words to say it, each in his or her respective country...
...What would you say were the roots of your personal rebellion ? It's a process...
...It's something that you know is not going to resolve the roots of the problem...
...Those independent Mexican magazines and newspapers which published Marcos' letters saw their circulations skyrocket...
...Instead of giving his kids a spanking like they deserve, the father-who is so understanding and generous-is going to give them candy after getting them to promise not to misbehave again, right...
...But, at the end of the road, you come to realize that you had the authenticity that you really wanted...
...On this road, everything was the opposite of what you left behind...
...Did you have any idea what would follow after having made this choice...
...I began to see the consequences of following the road of commitment, even if those consequences were disguised in the illusions of youth and spontaneity...
...When the government realized that the indigenous peoples don't have land or hospitals and all the other things they are asking for, it was logical that they offered them hospitals, schools, highways, etc...
...In any case, it's a ploy to buy time, locate the leaders, divide them, and later break them up, eliminate them, or buy them off...
...I think civil society got duped by the government's promises...
...After the San Crist6bal peace talks, people thought the peace accord was imminent, that it was only a question of paperwork because they were going to ask the communities, and they were going to say yes because no one can say no to such a marvellous offer...
...The myth has exploded that this country is at peace and contented with a government that makes the people suffer...
...Translated from the Spanish by NACLA...
...It wasn't what we were expecting now at the three-month point...
...here there are mountains where you can go...
...This authenticity was different from the other things that you had left behind, that you had betrayed, that you had abandoned, that you had killed...
...And the response of civil society...
...You can't talk about only Chiapas in that context...
...Mounted troops of the Zapatista army...
...The moment arrives when you realize that you are arriving at the point of no return as a human being...
...Chiapas is the tip of an iceberg which lies beneath the entire country...
...It will provoke a chain reaction of disasters and a readjustment of international policies...
...Why armed struggle...
...Evidently, the urgency of trying to force a peace treaty comes from the political calendar...
...You have to put together an army in conditions of secrecy...
...They said to us: why don't you come here...
...The government wants to be able to say: we've already subdued the guerrilla, we've got them under control...
...It meant abandoning everything, everything in every A Zapatis sense: name, family, prestige, future, adulation...
...You are a good man, then, in the social sense of the word, but you figure out that you'll have to make concessions, accommodations, small compromises that begin adding up...
...Right now, nothing is the same, nothing will ever be the same again-including the government, which will have to change the way it does business...
...His regular letters to the Mexican public are razor-sharp critiques of Mexican society and Salinismo...
...This same discontentment with authority runs throughout the country...
...So it was these campesinos who proposed Chiapas, and so this is how we ended up here...
...It's only when armed struggle erupts that the country becomes affected and is shaken, even at the level of international relations...
...At ta army batallion in the Lacand6n jungle on May 15, 1994...
...Has the government offered to buy off the peasantry...
...it's nothing more than a symptom of something more...
...Is this also the mentality of the National Solidarity Program (Pronasol...
...People lack experience to understand the government...
...He had to find another price for them...
...More than anything, it's like an aspirin...
...Does this mean, then, that the EZLN is in the vanguard of a new wave of armed social movements...
...In short, they want to take away the movement's social base with that promise...
...I know this because when we rose up against the government, we began to receive displays of solidarity and sympathy not only from Mexicans, but from indigenous peoples in Chile, Argentina, Canada, the United States and Central America...
...It's at that moment that you have to choose...
...Up until the time of Colosio's assassination, Salinas continued handling things as if the government would fulfill our demands out of the goodness of its heart, not because it was a duty...
...You're not going to form an army just by acting like other guerrillas...
...It's there where you stop and say: okay, I'm either going to go ahead, or I'm going to turn back, or I'm going to look for another way forward...
Vol. 28 • July 1994 • No. 1
