Open Forum
Marichal, Carlos
HOW THE POOR FINANCE THE RICH The heartiest dishes at the UN Conference on Financing for Development, the high-level get-together held in Monterrey, Mexico this past March, were those served...
...These investments are not usually considered development aid to rich countries, but that is precisely what they are...
...Even more to the point is Nobel laureate James Tobin's call for a small tax on all global transactions in order to make short-term speculation more costly...
...Without doubt, these debt payments have resulted in a net transfer of resources that has helped underwrite the economic growth of the richest countries...
...The menu of financial achievements, by contrast, was worthy of an austerity diet...
...60/year for institutions ($100/two years, $142/three years) Foreign Subscriptions $42/year for individuals ($75/two years, $105/three years...
...The case of Mexico is not unique...
...Translated from Spanish by Deidre McFayden...
...The wealthy countries arrived in Monterrey touting their readiness to offer a few more crumbs of aid to poor countries with the ostensible goal of mitigating the enormous poverty in the world as if they were participating in a charity drive to dispel protests...
...There is, for example, the proposal by financier George Soros to create an international credit insurance corporation-essentially a global version of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation-that would charge a small fee on all international bank transfers and use the proceeds to bail out countries in financial crisis...
...policy towards the region...
...Fax: (212) 870-3305...
...071 278 2829) L25 for individuals (f45/two years, L60/three years...
...Then there are the suggestions of former World Bank chief economist Joseph Stiglitz to make more active use of the enormous monetary reserves accumu4 NACIA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS Director Fred Rosen Editor JoAnn Kawell Associate Editor Margot Olavarria Business Manager Marisa Maack Production Manager Marisa Maack Advertising Coordinator Jordi Pius Llopart Staff Assistant Benjamin Plimpton Board of Directors Albert Bildner, Joan R. Dassin, Josh DeWind, Rick Edwards, Fred Goff, Eric Hershberg, Peggy Hutchison, Pierre LaRamie, Susan Lowes, Deidre McFadyen, Don Reasoner, T.M...
...Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY and additional mailing offices...
...for using new resources to promote development...
...E-mail: nacla@nacla.org Website: http://www.nacla.org NACLA is an independent nonprofit organization founded in 1966 to research the political economy of the Americas and U.S...
...If we don't insist on keeping track of these deposits, most discussions of financial reform like those at Monterrey make little sense...
...70/year for institutions ($122/two years, $175/three years...
...A growing number of economic studies have concluded that the "Tobin tax"which has enormous popular and international support--could be introduced in financial markets without provoking a crisis...
...for institutions: Can$80 (Can$135/2 yrs., Can$185/3 yrs...
...To take another example, many oilproducing countries-which are classified internationally as middleincome--annually invest immense sums of money in the international financial markets...
...government declared that they would promote a miniscule increase in traditional development aid...
...Scruggs, Robert M. Siegel, J. Michael Turner, Steven Volk, Susan Wood, Peter Yarrow Editorial Board Alejandro Bendafia, Emelio Betances, Roger Burbach, Jo-Marie Burt, Marc Chernick, Elizabeth Dore, Marc Edelman, Jonathan Fox, Jean Franco, Mark Fried, Marcial Godoy-Anativia, Jack Hammond, Luis Hern ndez Navarro, Maria Hinojosa, Peter Kornbluh, J. Patrice McSheny, Mario Murillo, Paulo Sergio Pinheiro, George Priestley, Cathy Schneider, Hobart Spalding, Carlos Vilas, Coletta Youngers NACLA Report on the Americas (ISSN 1071-4839) is published bimonthly by the North American Congress on Latin America, Inc...
...For individuals: Can$50 (Can$85/2 yrs., Can$115/3 yrs...
...Call for student rates or check our website...
...Views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of NACLA...
...NACLA) 475 Riverside Drive, Suite 454, New York, NY 10115...
...The financial markets in London, New York, Paris, Frankfurt, Zurich and Tokyo benefit the most, being closely linked to the many off-shore tax havens that attract an enormous amount of money from the wealthy of the First and Third Worlds...
...ut it's also important to keep in mind that the very manner in which the economic and ethical issues have been cast in the recent official discussions is wrongheaded...
...What the leaders of the most advanced countries don't want to recognize is that their own economic development over the last 20 years has partially depended on financing from low-income countries and, above all, middle-income countries such as Mexico...
...While the precise amount of money that has left Latin America can be debated, it remains crystal clear that rich countries owe as much to less developed countries as vice versa...
...HOW THE POOR FINANCE THE RICH The heartiest dishes at the UN Conference on Financing for Development, the high-level get-together held in Monterrey, Mexico this past March, were those served at the many lunches and dinners for the 50 or so heads of state-including George W. Bush, Vicente Fox and, for a while, Fidel Castro-and the thousands of officials in attendance...
...Mexico during the last 20 years is a prime example of the transfer of resources from the Third World to more advanced nations...
...The Monterrey proposals do not seek to adjust this immense imbalance at the global level...
...Canadian Subscribers: Order from Social Justice Committee, 1857 ouest de Maisonneuve, Montreal, Que., H3H 1J9 (Tel...
...But the official document does not call for seeking new ways of financing development, even though there is no scarcity of ideas out there...
...Tel: (212) 870-3146...
...A recent book on globalization by Mexican academics John Saxe Ferndndez and Oscar Ntfiiez documents the enormous transfer of economic surplus from Latin America to the wealthy countries during the last 25 years through debt service, one-way monetary transfers, capital flight and profits remitted from direct foreign investment...
...Postmaster: Send address changes to NACLA Report on the Americas PO Box 77, Hopewell, PA 16650-0077 or visit http://www.nacla.org Subscription Information $32/year for individuals ($55/two years, $75/three years...
...L47/year for institutions (L85/two years, L1 20/ithree years...
...In this sense, we shouldn't be talking about offering handouts but of coming up with more equitable forms of development...
...If we don't have the will to discuss the need for this transparency in public forums, we can look forward to more discussions of little meaningful content whose goal is essentially to maintain the status quo at the global level...
...The first step in future proposals to reform the international financial system's architecture must be the shining of a flashlight on these global financial flows, both legal and illegal and in all directions...
...Both the European Union and the U.S...
...If we tack on the more than $150 billion that Mexican individuals and companies invest in the United States and Europe, we see that more money leaves Mexico than comes into the country...
...514-933-6797...
...SPANISH ++ ENGLISH TRANSLATION SERVICES "* Latin American Studies * Social Sciences * Historical Documents * Journalism "* Legal Documents * Advocacy Accredited by the American Translators Association Spanish to English English to Spanish www.gis.net/-andyk pcolt@mindspring.comI L DDr n '.I1II]l II A OPEN FORUM lated by most Third World countries...
...The core document issued by the so-called "Monterrey consensus" contained few concrete proposals Carlos Marichal is professor of economic history at the Colegio de Msxico in Mexico City He is the author of A Century of Debt Crises in Latin America (Princeton, 1992) and has been a frequent contribu- tor to NACLA...
...Since 1982, the Mexican government has made close to $300 billion in payments on its foreign public debt, which began as no more than $100 billion in loans...
...UK Subscribers: Order from Latin America Bureau, 1 Amwell Street, London EC1R 1UL (Tel...
Vol. 35 • May 2002 • No. 6
