The U.S. Military Bases: Will They Stay or Go?
Lindsay-Poland, John
Negotiations over the fate of the bases have sparked a heated debate in Panama about the trade-offs between national sovereignty and the economic benefits of the U.S. presence. On September...
...invasion of Panama...
...Panama now has one of the most unequal distributions of income in Latin America, behind Brazil and Chile...
...The bases directly employ about 4,100 Panamanians, with another 11,000 employed through contractors for services, goods, construction, and personal expenditures by the 7,000 U.S...
...The TorrijosCarter Treaties, signed in 1977 6NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS John Lindsay-Poland coordinates the Fellowship of Reconciliation Task Force on Latin America and the Caribbean, and edits the quarterly Panama Update...
...Southern Command chief General Barry McCaffrey proposed last summer to keep 5,000 troops in Panama...
...military presence, primarily for economic reasons...
...The experience of domestic bases shows that military toxic contamination often stalls or thwarts the development of military facilities for civilian use...
...Air Force coordinates a radar system from Howard to locate unauthorized planes flying between the coca 8 NACIA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS NACIA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS 8UPDATE / PANAMA fields of Peru and Bolivia and labs in Colombia...
...Other sectors of Panamanian society are, however, staunchly opposed to keeping the U.S...
...The "low road" of inviting Taiwanese or other foreign companies to set up low-wage industrial parks with 50-year renewable leases 'anamanians hailed President Carter and Gene )f the Panama Canal Treaties on June 16, 1977 -the probable fate of Ft...
...military brought about $305 million into the Panamanian economy in 1994 (excluding pension payments), accounting for 4.5% of the Gross National Product...
...elections could distract administration and Congressional officials from an issue perceived as secondary...
...military withdrawal...
...The old guard of the partyincluding PRD president Gerardo Gonzalez, former Assembly president Balbina Herrera, and chair of the Assembly's Foreign Relations Committee Oyd6n Ortega-publicly oppose a new base agreement Vol XXIX, No 5 MARCH/APRIL 1996 7UPDATE / PANAMA because they favor Panama's complete demilitarization and they see greater economic benefits from civilian use of the bases...
...These pressures could crowd out long-term strategies that consider environmental and social-justice concerns...
...Leaders in a Panamanian town where the Southern Command built a road told GAO investigators that the U.S...
...Polls consistently show about 70% of Panamanians favor a continued U.S...
...Indeed, the United States suspended the radar program for ten months in 1994 because of concern that the U.S...
...A number of progressive businesspeople also want the bases to leave to allow for new economic and urban development, including tourism and maritime services such as ship repair...
...troops intervened...
...On September 6, 1995, presidents Bill Clinton and Ernesto P6rez Balladares told the White House press corps that their two countries would pursue "informal talks" on whether to keep U.S...
...soldiers patrol the Panama Canal...
...A high-level contingent of two dozen officials accompanied P6rez Balladares to the United States, Japan, the Philippines and Taiwan in the fall, where the first item on their stated agenda was grooming potential investors for the "reverted areas...
...We have fought for a century for sovereignty over our lands, and now we are going to turn over those lands to a foreign country for another 70 years...
...asks Radil Leis, a Panamanian sociologist who managed singer Rub6n Blades' presidential campaign in 1994...
...communities struggle with the effects of domestic base closures...
...Helms' efforts are countered by concerns in U.S...
...The value of these civic operations was seriously questioned by a General Accounting Office (GAO) report in 1994, which cited shoddy work, lack of long-term goals, and use of unqualified personnel for construction...
...The turnover of the canal on December 31, 1999 is not in debate...
...military intervention, not only in Panama, but throughout the region...
...The wording leaves a wide margin for interpretation, which the Pentagon Complicating the transfer process is the issue of toxic waste on the bases, which may thwart their development for civilian use...
...Given this uneven playing field, the coming period will test the United States' commitment to decolonization...
...government was only using the road project as a propaganda tool...
...The report last fall that a post-1999 presence would employ only about a thousand local citizens was a rude awakening for many Panamanian pragmatists...
...Manfredo also supports using military housing to help meet Panama's dire housing deficit...
...political circles that it is politically dangerous to maintain bases in Panama while many U.S...
...After students raised the Panamanian flag in the canal zone (consistent with a federal order), U.S...
...The fundamental template for that relationship was the 1903 treaty which gave the United States control over the 10-mile-wide canal area "in perpetuity" and the power to police Panama's people...
...Even though Congress does not have the authority to negotiate military-base agreements, Senator Jesse Helms has agitated for a new base agreementif not outright abroeral Torrijos at the gation of the Canal Treaties--ever since the treaties were ratified in 1978...
...A protocol signed after the treaties were ratified allows for a continued military presence if the two countries decide it is in their interests...
...PRD opponents of the bases spearheaded a unanimous resolution by the Legislative Assembly to move the offices of the Organization of American States (OAS) to the former military bases...
...No one doubts that unexploded mortars and rockets are hazardous to human safety, but to find and dig up the munitions is expensive, and if not done properly, it risks erosion and silting of the canal...
...The Southern Command has been reluctant to turn over information on the toxics problem requested by the Panamanian government...
...military bases beyond 1999 also fits neatly into the external economic policy of the governing Revolutionary Democratic Party (PRD...
...Since 1980, the country has been racked by the debt crisis, a two-year U.S...
...The present negotiations between Panama and the United States regarding a future U.S...
...retorted Charlotte Elton, of the Panamanian Social Action and Research Center...
...invasion, and a series of structural-adjustment measures...
...It also has one of the highest foreign debts per capita in the region...
...Within days of entering office in 1994, the President agreed to a U.S...
...The forced reform in August, 1995 of Panama's Labor Code, for example, was carried out largely to attract foreign investment, on the premise that Panamanian capital alone cannot pull the country out of its economic ills, nor make productive use of former military bases...
...Davis, one of two bases that reverted to Panamanian control last September -is met with chagrin by nationalist groups working for U.S...
...military bases in Panama beyond 1999, when the Torrijos-Carter Treaties call for their departure...
...canal-zone workers tore it down, and U.S...
...T he United States is also divided about keeping the military bases...
...Through a tripartite commission with Panama and Japan, however, the United States continues to exer- cise strong influ- ence over decisions about the future construction of a third set of locks for the present canal or of a separate sea-level canal...
...base, a measure which became tremendously unpopular among Panamanians after the Cubans rioted and tried to escape confinement on the base...
...and Latin American militaries, to support the drug war in the Andes and Central America, and for "civic action" operations in collaboration with other Latin American armies...
...Ironically, former President Guillermo Endara, himself sworn into office on a U.S...
...laws requiring clean-up...
...Some bases are sure to close in any case...
...The U.S...
...has shrewdly exploited...
...6 NACIA REPORT ON THE AMERICASUPDATE / PANAMA U.S...
...BY JOHN LINDSAY-POLAND U.S...
...The continuation of some U.S...
...Yet without a clearer idea of the environmental condition of the facilities it is inheriting, Panama can neither plan intelligently for the bases' use nor negotiate a clean-up agreement with the United States...
...The bases also supplied weapons to the Nicaraguan Contras, and provided logistical support for the 1989 U.S...
...We don't want a dragged-out Philippines-style process," said one National Security Council official...
...Using National Guard units that rotate into the region for a few weeks, the Southern Command annually runs dozens of projects to build roads, dig wells, and repair school buildings...
...If the bases' future is not resolved by November-a probable scenariothe elections may replace Clinton with a Republican president more sympathetic to the notion that the banks of the canal are a part of the United States...
...McCaffrey-who has since been appointed drug czar by the Clinton Administrationargued that the bases were important for defending the canal in case of war and for the regional drug war (about a thousand drug-surveillance flights were staged from Howard Air Base in 1994, and multinational military exercises are carried out on another air base in Panama...
...blockade in 1988-89, the U.S...
...Nicolds Ardito Barletta, the conversion agency chief, claims that civilian use of the bases should generate 150,000 jobs and $1.5 billion in revenue for Panama...
...It incited a flurry of intense debate in Panama, however...
...The White House also favors using the bases in Panama to deploy "humanitarian missions" throughout Central and South America...
...bases, suggested that some military bases stay for ten years as a "security incentive for foreign investors...
...The U.S...
...On the other hand, the 1996 U.S...
...Marines steamed from Panama to fight in Mexico and Nicaragua in the 1910s and 1920s, and put down a renters' strike in Panama City in 1925...
...At stake in the discussion over the bases' future is not only Panama's decolonization, but the symbolic and actual role of the U.S...
...It was the current ruling party which was ousted from power by the action...
...Colonel Donald Holzwarth, architect of the Southern Command's environmental strategy, said that releasing some environmental documents "begs a thousand questions" and is "inherently stupid...
...military in the region...
...Fernando Manfredo, Jr., a former canal administrator who was involved in putting together the plan, advocates developing a second "free zone" across the canal from Panama City, based on the multi-billion dollar Col6n Free Zone, a warehouse facility where goods are not taxed...
...To make up for the inevitable economic loss, Panamanian authorities have demanded that the United States begin to pay rent for use of the properties...
...The bases themselves are located in and around the terminal cities of Panama City and Col6n, where half of Panama's population lives and where most of the country's economic activity takes place...
...forces are there or not...
...military bases in Panama were first established during the construction of the Panama Canal in 1914...
...P6rez Balladares' own party is divided...
...Those treaties mandate the transfer of the Panama Canal to Panamanian control on December 31, 1999, by which time all military bases and facilities are also to be turned over free of charge...
...Others argue that guerrilla threats to the canal could occur whether U.S...
...military operation at that time since the Vietnam War, and one which killed hundreds if not thousands of civilians...
...government might be held liable if data were used to shoot down the wrong plane...
...Today, the bases in Panama are used to train both U.S...
...A provision of the canal treaties requires the United States to remove hazards to human health and safety "insofar as may be practicable" before departing...
...officials want the issue resolved expeditiously...
...request to house up to 10,000 Cuban "boat people" on a U.S...
...Panama's head of state was, after all, removed during the 1989 invasion-the largest U.S...
...Father Conrado Sanjur, coordinator of a coalition of 20 organizations opposed to a base extension, said that instead of discussing a continued U.S...
...Although defending the Canal has always been their purported raison d'etre, the bases have historically served as a platform for U.S...
...jurisdiction...
...In a typical exchange, Nicolis Ardito Barletta, former Panamanian president and chief of the agency overseeing the conversion of former U.S...
...labor law and minimum wages, making them privileged within Panama's labor sector...
...Other potential contamination problems on the bases include leaking underground fuel tanks, PCBs from electrical transformers, and other chemicals that Panamanians say have left mysteriously barren areas on otherwise lush lands...
...In this context, the Pentagon's plan to close bases, in some cases ahead of the 1999 deadline, induces mass anxiety among Panamanians, as it would in any community that believes itself to be heavily dependent on military spending...
...During the civil war in El Salvador in the 1980s, radar facilities in Panama processed infrared photos taken of the Salvadoran countryside, which were used by the Salvadoran Air Force to direct bombing raids...
...military presence, Panama "should negotiate compensation for victims of the 1989 invasion and the clean-up of toxic waste on the current U.S...
...A Defense Department policy issued last October discounts any clean-up of a property after transfer unless it has been explicitly agreed to beforehand...
...troops...
...Complicating the transfer process is the issue of toxic waste on the bases...
...Concurrent with these political movements toward greater sovereignty were economic changes that undercut that independence of action...
...On other issues, P6rez Balladares, a banker educated at the University of Notre Dame in Indiana, has already bowed to implicit pressure to negotiate for what he thinks the United States wants...
...Economy Minister Guillermo Chapman and other cabinet officials give priority to implementing neoliberal economic reforms to pave the way for Panama's entry into the World Trade Organization and the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA...
...Panama's economy, always shaped by its location at a global crossroads, grew more dependent on foreign capital in the 1970s...
...The announcement caused not a ripple in the United States-the New York Times did not even mention it...
...ny examination of current North American and Panamanian attitudes toward the military bases and the canal must consider the troubled history of the two nations' relationship...
...Unlike their domestic counterparts, overseas bases are not governed by U.S...
...An InterAmerican Development Bank loan to Panama financed the creation of a master Over 100,000 F plan for the bases formal signing being transferred to Panamanian control...
...Another road project was criticized by Panamanian environmental groups as ecologically damaging...
...In fact, many poor families have already set up squatter communities in military areas, some still under U.S...
...That conflict, in which 21 Panamanians died, prompted the Johnson administration to commit the United States to a fundamental recasting of its colonial powers in Panama, leading ultimately to the 1977 Canal Treaties...
...The U.S...
...between presidents Jimmy Carter and Omar Torrijos, reversed that template...
...Moreover, key government officials may personally benefit from low-wage export zones established there...
...The base talks helped coalesce an array of human rights, student, religious and labor groups into united fronts...
...The treaties were signed after protracted popular struggle by Panamanian nationalists, especially students who suffered the brunt of the repression during the "flag riots" in January, 1964...
...Panama's nationalist elites have formulated a number of ideas about how to convert the former bases...
...Some Army officials at first resisted McCaffrey's proposal, though they eventually backed down...
...base, came out emphatically against keeping the bases beyond 1999, arguing that the United States will never agree to pay rent...
...An international banking sector and the Col6n Free Trade Zone "-both heavily dependent on foreign capital and trade-were rapidly developed, while international loans financed the construction of populist projects...
...They contended that Panama is not vital to the drug war...
...military presence are hardly between equal partners...
...If some sapper decides to take out Culebra Cut [the canal's most narrow passage], there's nothing we can do about it," says one Army official...
...Is it not rather nineteenth century to use a foreign military to protect foreign investments...
...In any event, U.S...
...Given the country's 30% underand unemployment rate, the government is pursuing options like maquiladora zones because it is under pressure to generate jobs on the former bases...
...Workers hired directly by the Defense Department are covered by U.S...
...Southern Command, responsible for relations with Central and South American militaries, established its headquarters in Panama after World War Two...
...asks Olier Avila of the Service for Peace and Justice in Panama, a human rights organization...
...The Panamanian Army was eliminated from our Constitution, so how can we reject a native army and accept the presence of a foreign one...
Vol. 29 • March 1996 • No. 5
