GAINING GROUND The Indigenous Movement in Latin America
"With their seizure of half a dozen towns in Chiapas on New Year's Day, 1994, the Zapatista Army of National Liberation-a predominantly Maya guerrilla force-stormed onto the Mexican political...
...Thanks to indigenous activism, the new constitutions in Colombia and Brazil enshrine a number of indigenous rights...
...In the current battle over indigenous land rights in Brazil, private landed interests have proven adept at steering the judicial and political system to their advantage, chipping away at established constitutional protections in the process...
...Even as they become active at the national level, the movements generally continue to practice a grassroots model of consensus-building and decision-making...
...As one observer in Ecuador comments, "there are many reasons to believe that at the heart of the present crisis of civilization, the hour of indigenous people has arrived...
...The current era, marked by the two phenomena of democratization and neoliberalism, offers new opportunities but imposes new constraints...
...Constitutional rights have become another focal point of indigenous organizing...
...A principal demand of indigenous organizations in both Guatemala and Ecuador is the revision of the constitution to recognize those countries as plurinational states...
...Before 1980, indigenous organizing was largely confined to local communities...
...Constitutional rights, however, translate unevenly into on-the-ground protections...
...Organizations which united different indigenous groups were not common...
...The government was forced to sit down with indigenous leaders at the negotiating table and revise the law to incorporate their concerns...
...As this NACLA report details, indigenous peoples are forging strong national movements that are bringing together local organizations and regional federations...
...Many indigenous representatives find themselves relegated to the margins, while others fall victim to state co-optation...
...While the Zapatistas have captured the lion's share of public attention in the United States, indigenous movements throughout the hemisphere have been asserting their presence in national politics in unprecedented fashion in the 1990s...
...The movement is not immune to the vices of "politics as usual" either...
...While democratization has opened up new spaces for civil organizing, the nearuniversal embrace of neoliberalism poses lethal dangers to rural indigenous economies...
...For the region's indigenous movements, economic issues-in particular, indigenous land rights-are inextricably linked to their cultural survival...
...Today, the emphasis is on the natural linkages between the two...
...With their seizure of half a dozen towns in Chiapas on New Year's Day, 1994, the Zapatista Army of National Liberation-a predominantly Maya guerrilla force-stormed onto the Mexican political stage, raising issues of democracy and justice that the national government had hoped could be forgotten...
...Many have abandoned the sterile debate over whether ethnic identity or class is more important...
...The agreement breaks much less new ground on economic issues such as control of natural resources and land redistribution...
...With the traditional left in decline, indigenous groups have stepped into the breach in many countries, becoming protagonists in the struggle against the neoliberal onslaught...
...A nationwide indigenous mobilization in Ecuador in 1994 foiled the government's attempt to ram through a neoliberal agrarian reform without any public discussion...
...Political in-fighting and caudillismo continue to rear their heads...
...This February, the government and the Zapatistas signed an indigenous-rights accord which recognizes the "autonomy" of Mexico's ten million indigenous citizens, and their rights to multilingual education and "adequate" political representation...
...Since local and national Congresses will have to carry out the changes, it remains to be seen how meaningful the accord will be in practice...
...Indigenous organizations have also begun to try their hand at electoral politics...
...Indigenous people who became involved in politics usually did so under the banner of the traditional left, which considered the indigenous struggle to be subordinate-or even inimical-to the larger class struggle...
...Given the historically high voterabstention rates in indigenous communities-fueled by a deep distrust of traditional politics as well as needlessly cumbersome registration and voting processes-this is a tough row to hoe...
...They have also built alliances with other progressive sectors both at home and internationally...
Vol. 29 • March 1996 • No. 5
