The CUT: New Unionism at a Crossroads
Rodrigues, Iram Jácome
Brazil's new trade unionism faces a basic paradox: at the very peak of the CUT's ifluence in the broader political process, n increasingly bureaucratic pragmatism threatens the labor...
...These processes are posing new challenges to union power everywhere...
...They were first-generation industrial workers who shared neither ties to the traditional left nor the nationalistic ideological vision of the pre-1964 populist trade unionism...
...After 1978, opposition to the existing authoritarian union structure merged with broad-based resistance to the military regime...
...He was soon to become the labor movement's most effective spokesperson...
...This strain of unionism was largely patterned on the metalworkers union in Sao Bernardo do Campo...
...They fear that this discord could eventually lead to the loss of the CUT's unique trade-union identity...
...All the while, they continued to construct a different model of trade unionism by doing VOL XXVIII, No 6 MAY/JUNE 1995 on-the-ground grassroots organizing in an effort to strengthen unions at the factory level...
...A wave of strikes broke out in 1978, first in Sdo Bernardo do Campo before spreading throughout the country...
...5-30...
...Both of these currents maintained a close relationship with the progressive sector of the Catholic Church...
...It was made up of one delegate from the rural sector, seven delegates from the industrial sector (three of them metalworkers), five bank workers (all from government banks), three officials from government-owned companies, and nine government employees...
...The only way to strengthen the union movement is to maintain an organized broad base of support in workplaces...
...Even though rural workers constitute more than a third of workers at the CUT grassroots (approximately 6.5 million out of 18 million), this sector is practically absent from the CUT's executive board, and thus absent from the prism of internal democracy...
...4 (Sao Paulo) July-September, 1994...
...t the Fifth National CUT Congress in May, 1994, a 25-member National Executive Board was elected...
...7. See Adriana Lopez and Alvaro Comin, "Delegados ao CONCUT: um perfil," De Fato, Year 2, No...
...Workers began to retake the initiative in relations with the state and management...
...The second congress, two years later, was attended by 5,564 delegates, whose organizations represented 12 million workers at the grassroots (Unions in Brazil represent all of the workers in their jurisdiction, regardless of whether they are dues-paying union members...
...In the Brazilian transition to democracy, the labor movement thus emerged as a key political actor...
...Of the five and a half million rural workers, over 600 thousand were union members...
...The challenge faced by the Brazilian trade-union movement is no different than that faced by its sister movements around the world: to maintain its strength in the face of the relentless attack from increasingly mobile international capital...
...From time to time, this may require a stance of compromise and accommodation, but no trade-union movement can survive the abandonment of workers at the grassroots...
...Those in the second major current of the new labor activity called themselves "independents...
...The Third Congress marked the beginning of a shift in the vision of the CUT from a movement to an organization...
...The new trade unionism has thus come face to face with a basic paradox: at the very peak of its influence in the broader political process, it may be losing its effective workplace presence...
...irn Brazilian unions have not confined themselves to wage demands or other narrowly defined labor a matters...
...During those five years, the CUT built from within and asserted itself toward the outside...
...b) the single union: in a particular territory, only one union from a particular category, such as metalworkers, may represent those workers...
...Brazil is no exception to the global restructuring of production and the fragmentation of labor which that restructuring has brought about...
...Equally notable, the CUT leadership is made up primarily of middle-class workers...
...3 The first current was made up of trade-union activists who belonged to socialist political parties...
...5. See Le6ncio Martins Rodrigues, CUT: os militantes e a ideologia (Sao Paulo: Paz e Terra, 1990), especially Chapter 1, "A formacao da CUT," pp...
...The leftist tendencies within the federation regarded these moves as a blow to the internal democracy of the CUT...
...This current reflected the new profile of the working class, which was a product of the economic and social changes through which the country had passed during the dictatorship...
...Thus when they began to reorganize, unions were able to finance congresses, seminars, leadership training courses, trips around the country to build contacts between laborunion members, and so forth...
...See also Eder Sader, Quando Novos Personagems Entraram em Cena (Sao Paulo: Paz e Terra, 1988...
...2. Ricardo Antunes, A Rebeldia do Trabalho (Sho Paulo: Editora Unicamp/Ensaio, 1988), p. 17...
...Founded in 1983, the CUT-one of three labor federations in Brazil-was a product of the mass trade unionism that had developed in the industrial region of greater Sdo Paulo since 1978, especially among the metalworkers of Sdo Bernardo do Campo...
...From its foundation in 1983 until May, 1994, the CUT president was Jair Meneguelli, a metalworker at the Ford Factory in Sdo Bernardo do Campo, and former president of the Metalworkers Union in Sdo Bernardo do Campo and Diadema...
...This restructuring amounted to the construction of a rational "business-style" union...
...Indeed the Brazilian experience runs counter to an international trend of labor-union decline, reflected in the widespread drop in unionization rates...
...Today, the CUT is emblematic of the country's "new unionism...
...Meneguelli was replaced by Vicente Paulo "Vicentinho" da Silva, another leader from Sio Bernardo do Campo...
...This opposition began to appear in fits and starts as early as the late 1960s among such groups as the Metalworkers Opposition Movement in Sdo Paulo (MOSMSP...
...The most striking fact in the governing board's composition is the overwhelming presence of state employees, who make up practically 70...
...7 From the wave of strikes in 1978 up to the birth of the CUT in 1983, labor organizing proceeded feverishly...
...2 Proponents of the "new unionism" denounced the existing labor-union structure, advocating free negoti- ations between management and labor without gov- ernment interference...
...8 It also reflects the over-representation of middle sectors within the organization, and hence a growing gap between the grassroots and leadership...
...c) the so-called union tax: an obligatory fee collected from all workers, unionized and non-unionized, equivalent to one day of work a year...
...o caso da CUT," in Eli Diniz, Jose S6rgio Leite Lopez and Reginaldo Prandi (eds...
...The strength of unionism in Brazil is inextricably linked to the wider role that unions have assumed in Brazilian society...
...Starting in the mid-1970s, workers awakened from a long political dormancy and began to express opposition to the military regime's economic policies, which were squeezing the wages of the poor and the middle class...
...In the October general elections last year, although Lula once again lost, the PT elected two governors, Vitor Buaiz in Espirito Santo and Cristovam Buarque in Brasilia, along with a significant number of state and federal deputies...
...The fourth and fifth congresses, in 1991 and 1994 respectively, continued to reflect the shift within the CUT from a more confrontational stance toward a new willingness to negotiate...
...4. See Heloisa de Souza Martins, "Igreja e Movimento Operario no ABC (1954-1975)," Ph.D...
...They were, however, scattered, often out of contact with their parties, or at odds with them...
...This resulted in a decline in the proportion of congressional delegates who came out of the trade-union opposition of the 1970s-generally the more left-leaning part of the CUT...
...From that point on, the federation began to adopt a vertical, administrative structure, which was complex and, in that sense, bureaucratic...
...Nevertheless, the Sdo Bernardo do Campo metalworkers continue to have the most authority and legitimacy within the CUT...
...Seventeen of the board members are men, and eight are women...
...Three currents came together in the formation of the CUT: the traditional left, "independent" unionism, and church-based activism...
...Despite the CUT's militance at various points in its history, the dominant forces within the organization today are increasingly seeking compromise and negotiation...
...Of the 11 million urban workers, 3 million-about 25%-were union members...
...4 They influenced labor activism by speaking of the dignity of the worker-that is, seeing the worker not simply as a tool for creating wealth, but as a person endowed with certain rights...
...In the early 1970s, these leftist activists took stock of their militant past and tried to reach out to the "masses"-either through organizing in poor neighborhoods, or by taking jobs in factories...
...Gradually throughout the country, these new "independent" leaders came to fill the vacuum in the traditional union apparatus...
...Lastly, the Third Congress decided to hold congresses every three years instead of every two...
...This is the context out of which the CUT emerged to take such a prominent role in the Brazilian labor scene...
...downs and stoppages occurred, but were usually confined to a single shop...
...Between 1983 and the Third National Congress in 1988, the CUT successfully built an organized labor militancy...
...The CUT 1. The corporative labor union model developed in the 1930s, which-despite some changes introduced in the 1988 Constitution-still ties trade unions to the state, is based on the following elements: a) monopoly of representation granted by the state...
...As a catalyst of popular aspirations, these Catholic movements formed one of the pillars of the reorganization of the labor movement...
...By April, 1993, 1,878 unions were counted as CUT affiliates, representing sixteen and a half million workers...
...This "democracy of tendencies," they argue, contradicts the democratic set of ideas championed by the new unionism...
...This predominance may-aside from the merits of the case-have something to do with the labor federation's considerable resistance to the idea of privatization and the shrinking of the state apparatus...
...Almost 60% of the delegates to the 1994 congress, for example, were university lo...
...Between 1974 and 1978, slowNACI3A REPORT ON THE AMERICAS 30REPORT ON BRAZIL S;o Bernardo metalworkers on strike in 1991, protesting the lay-of 1,200 Ford factory workers...
...Rather, they have become involved in a broad spectrum of issues including industrial policy, company competitiveness, productivity, the effects on workers of the shift to services, social policy, and regional integration [see "Labor and Mercosur," p. 32...
...3 This social movement, which over time became a political movement, gave the working class a way to become involved in public affairs...
...Unlike the situation in many other countries, however, the trade-union movement in Brazil has been able to grow in influence and expand despite an economic environment that is unfriendly to labor...
...The traditional trade-union structure was corporatist and authoritarian.] Union leaders-the so-called "pelegos" (collaborators)-had close ties to government and management...
...The broad mass movement of the late 1970s and early 1980s against the military dictatorship created two major tools for labor organizing: the Unified Workers Central (CUT) and the Workers Party (PT), both of which went on to have a great impact on public life...
...The CUT still has the loyalty of those workers but, at the peak of its strength, dramatic tensions are present at the heart of the organization...
...The large corporatist labor unions were run like "businesses," and besides their labor and political muscle, had considerable fiscal resources...
...It was led by young workers, many of them migrants from poorer areas, particularly the Northeast...
...He resigned after being elected a congressional representative for Sio Paulo in the October 1994 general election...
...The CEBs, rooted in the everyday practice of the people, organized groups of people who demanded their basic rights as citizens...
...dissertation, Department of Social Science of the Faculty of Philosophy, Literature and Human Sciences of the University of Sao Paulo, 1986 (mimeo...
...In November, 1989, he ran for president of Brazil, receiving 39% of the vote in a runoff against Fernando Collor de Mello, the eventual victor...
...This tendency's dominance is reflected in the organization's presidency...
...Through amendments to the organization's by-laws, labor-union council delegates were given priority over grassroots representatives, and the number of representatives elected to the CUT congress was changed to reflect the number of affiliated unions and not the categories of workers represented...
...Brazil's new trade unionism faces a basic paradox: at the very peak of the CUT's ifluence in the broader political process, n increasingly bureaucratic pragmatism threatens the labor federation's effective workplace presence...
...5 Since its founding in 1983, the CUT has grown significantly...
...The current process is thus one of deep institutionalization, and hence of greater professionalization, impersonality, and bureaucratization within the CUT...
...O Brasil no Rastro da Crise (Sao Paulo: ANPOCS/HUCITEC/IPEA, 1994), p. 40...
...This movement-style, liberating, socialist, conflictive period-called the organization's "heroic" phase-ended with that Congress...
...This requires a certain degree of militance...
...Translated from the Portuguese by Phillip Berryman...
...By the early 1980s, these leftwing activists continued to be active in the f of labor movement in small everyday battles both in factories in the country's major industrial centers-most notably in the South and Southeastand in rural regions such as the North and Northeast...
...entirely paralyzed, was confined to small-scale, largely invisible, local activity in certain sectors of the labor movement...
...If CUT unionism fails to become more broadly organized within companies, its more general representative bodies-the trade unions and the CUT itself-will weaken since they will be removed from the everyday activity of workers...
...In the early 1980s, there were about 80 thousand base communities, involving approximately two million "believing and oppressed" people...
...graduates, in a country where 32 million people-more than 20% of the Brazilian population-are illiterate...
...Many leftists, for example, feel that the ordinary non-militant worker no longer has a role in the organization...
...The iron boot of the military dictatorship prevented mass resistance...
...rowing out of the reorganization of the labor movement in the late 1970s and early 1980s, the creation of the CUT represented the fulfillment of one of the Brazilian labor movement's longheld aspirations...
...6 By the Fifth Congress, in May, 1994, the CUT had approximately 2,300 affiliates, which represented around 18 million workers at the grassroots...
...In 1984, the CUT held its first congress with 5,000 delegates...
...6. Data from the CUT general secretariat, April 13, 1993...
...For others-primarily CUT moderates who are more narrowly focused on labor issues-the political skirmishing among the tendencies reflects an excessive politicization...
...The 1988 Third Congress formalized changes that were already underway within CUT trade unionism...
...The upshot was the creation of what has been called a "democracy of tendencies," which has left many of VOL XXVIII, No 6 MAY/JUNE 1995 33REPORT ON BRAZIL CUT president Vicentinho addresses a metalworkers rally in Sio Pau those tendencies unhappy...
...He is the author of Comissao de Fabrica e Trabalhadores na Industria (Sio Paulo: Cortez/Fase, 1990...
...They represent the majority tendency within the organization, called the "Labor Articulation...
...In addition, the Congress decided that participants in future national congresses were to be elected in state congresses...
...That same year, the Sdo Bernardo metalworkers held their first congress where they defined the main programmatic principles for union activity: collective bargaining, freedom for unions, and a basic labor law containing their fundamental rights...
...These CEBs became a channel for the expression of a broad collective sentiment of social revolt and critique of the existing political order...
...Workers' calls for labor-union freedom along with their protests against declining wages and workplace authoritarianism became a struggle not only for new workplace rights, but for a more genuine citizenship...
...The CUT has moved from a rather radical conception of trade unionism, starting with the strikes in 1978 and the harsh critique of the traditional laborunion structure at the heart of the new unionism, to a more pragmatic conception...
...Iram Jacome Rodrigues is a sociologist and professor in the Department of Economics at the University of Sao Paulo...
...The Church, closely woven into the country's social fabric, built a movement of Christian base communities (comunidades eclesiais de base or CEBs) throughout 31 0 4REPORT ON BRAZIL the country...
...The CUT: Jew Unionism at a Crossroads Union activity in Sdo Bernardo do Campo was also the cradle of the Workers Party, the CUT's sister organization...
...and d) the legal power of the labor court system...
...While its main bases of support have remained there over the past 12 years, the CUT has managed to grow very rapidly, greatly expanding its social and political influence in the process...
...This, in effect, was a "funnelling" process of the representation of the workers, since in practice it prevented a grassroots worker not represented in any of the CUT's internal tendencies from being elected to the national congress...
...Because of the country's ongoing political crisis and the consequent weakness of the party system, trade unions have gone beyond their own specific interests to become effective social and political actors and, in one case, to form a major political party...
...3. Le6ncio Martins Rodrigues analyzes this process, its various stages, and the more general reasons for it in "As tendencias politicas na formacao das centrais sindicais," in Armando Boito Junior, O Sindicalismo Brasileiro nos Anos 80 (Sao Paulo: Paz e Terra, 1991...
...8. Iram JAcome Rodrigues, "Perspectivas do sindicalismo no Brasil...
...Luis Inicio "Lula" da Silva was elected president of the Metalworkers Union in Sgo Bernardo do Campo in 1975...
Vol. 28 • May 1995 • No. 6
