Confessions of an 'Anti-American': Responds
Walzer, Michael
AQUICK WORD from a third Michael. I agree entirely with the second Michael's response to the first, but want to add a few comments as co-editor of Dissent. Instead of arguing about the state of...
...and that's why we are happy to print Wreszin's response to some recent Dissent articles...
...we should be arguing about what ought to be done, and how to do it, before we rush into the streets...
...Wreszin gives no sign of having thought much, no sign of having worried at all, about how to fight against internationally organized terrorist movements...
...we want to be usefully engaged with our fellow citizens...
...Is that really what he wants...
...88 n DISSENT / Spring 2003...
...Pretending that the police were just waiting to be called was a way of opposing the Afghan War, but was it a serious way...
...This is the dial 911 answer to 9/ 11...
...It's a curious response...
...Instead of arguing about the state of the left, Michael Wreszin writes, "We should now be in the streets...
...That's what we do...
...But he does defend one (in my opinion, bad) left response to 9/11: "the hijackers . . . should be treated as criminals and hunted down as such...
...When he writes as he has written here, how can he expect his fellow citizens to believe that he is concerned about their safety...
...Call the cops...
...that's why we run a magazine...
...But we want to get the criticism right, and we want it to be effective...
...We are still in the same business...
...But there he sits banging away at his computer, and banging away, and banging away...
...But it could never have been the whole story...
...There is, indeed, an old left view that international society should be, and one day will be, just like domestic society...
...It's not our only business...
...He berates us for being exactly like the old Dissent, which wasn't heated enough in its opposition to the Vietnam War (there were disagreements among the editors then too...
...But right now it plainly isn't...
...And that sometimes requires us to criticize people who get American politics and society wrong and who do not display a "decent respect" for the opinions of other Americans...
...We've been attacked...
...and he berates us for not being enough like the old Dissent and asks us "to return to its initial vision...
...They should be fought "just as organized crime is [fought] at home...
...And the critique that I made of this response in Dissent last year ("Five Questions About Terrorism," Winter 2002) is that it involves the pretense that international society is just like domestic society...
...Wreszin doesn't say much in the way of substantive argument...
...Mostly, as Wreszin knows, we print harshly critical pieces on American politics and society...
...There were no police that we could summon up to deal, say, with terrorist training camps in Afghanistan...
...When Dissent was founded, in 1954, Wreszin's counterparts were equally sharp, though perhaps less rhetorical, in condemning its "initial vision," which entailed a sustained critique of the existing American left...
...MICHAEL WALZER is co-editor of Dissent...
...And he is right...
...Of course, police work by many different (and differently competent) national police forces is an important part of our response to 9/11...
Vol. 50 • April 2003 • No. 2
