The Politics of Rescue

...Instead, the metaphors are ominous: they are "bogs" and 38 • DISSENT The Politics of Rescue "quagmires...

...Today, when every death is televised, democratic citizens (the soldiers themselves or their parents) are unlikely to support or endure interventions of this kind...

...I am not sure that any very forceful intervention is politically possible without it...

...But acknowledging their status and function poses the question that has to be answered before they are sent anywhere, at the moment their mission is being defined: is this a cause for which we are prepared to see American soldiers die...

...That is why American politicians and military officers have insisted that there must be an exit strategy before there can be an intervention...

...So it's the political right that has defended both, while the left has acquired the habit of criticism and rejection...

...Nor would a UN army with its own officers, capable of acting independently in the field, always find itself in the right fields (that is, the killing fields...

...This might be taken as a triumph for the old principle of nonintervention, except that the reasons on which the principle is based, which I will rehearse in a moment, do not appear to be the reasons that move governments and politicians today...

...Now this moral necessity seems to have become a practical, political necessity...

...And so long as we can't be sure of its ability and readiness to do that, we will have to look for and live with unilateral interventions...

...gets answered every day, but with no sign that the judgments it requires are actually being made...

...No doubt, the "civilized" world is capable of living with grossly uncivilized behavior in places like East Timor, say—offstage and out of sight...

...It is much easier to go into a place like Bosnia than to get out, and the likely costs to the intervening forces and the local population are much higher than in the classic humanitarian interventions of the recent past...

...But this is a formula for failure...

...Even those who supported humanitarian interventions in the past have emphasized the moral necessity of a rapid withdrawal, leaving any ongoing use of force to indigenous soldiers...

...or that stalemate will free the UN's bureaucracy to pursue a program of its own...

...Many people on the left will long for a time when this necessary American role is made unnecessary by the creation of an international military force...

...Morally and politically, a division of labor is better, and the best use of American power will often be to press other countries to do their share of the work...

...The soldiers who were not soldiers became, in effect, hostages of the Serbian forces that controlled the roads: subject to attack if anyone challenged that control...

...Conceivably, this expansion has saved lives, but only by creating in the process a "prison-house of nations," whose subsequent history is a long tale of prison revolts, brutally repressed...

...most often, however, they will depend on global powers like the United States and (we can hope) the European Community...

...The resolution won't be stable unless it is locally grounded...

...Their aim is profoundly negative in character: to put a stop to actions that, to use an old-fashioned but accurate phrase, "shock the conscience" of humankind...

...No doubt, governments must think about such things: political leaders have to maintain their domestic support if they are to act effectively abroad.* But they must also act effectively abroad when the occasion demands it, and they must be able to judge the urgency of the demand in the appropriate moral and political terms...

...Hence the general search for a quick fix, as in President Clinton's proposal (never very vigorously pursued) to "bomb the Serbs, arm the Bosnians...

...Can we assume that there are states ready to take the initiative and sustain it...

...WINTER • 1995 • 35 The Politics of Rescue States) merely watch and protest...

...Relatively small contingents of soldiers will be sent to help out in cases where it isn't expected that they will have to fight—thus the United States in Somalia, the Europeans in Bosnia, the French in Rwanda...

...we (on the left especially) have reasons for it, which derive from our opposition to imperial politics and our commitment to self-determination, even when the process of self-determination is something less than peaceful and democratic...

...But this time, though it will obviously come before the much heralded leap from the realm of necessity to the realm of freedom, is still a long way off...

...And what if there are overlapping sets of victims and victimizers, like the Somalian clans and warlords or, perhaps, the religious/ethnic/national groupings in Bosnia...

...It might be a way of controlling the economically or politically self-aggrandizing interventions of single states...

...Similarly, the African states and the Western powers stood by and watched the Rwandan massacres...

...Exit strategies can rarely be designed in advance, and a public commitment to exit within such and such a time would give the hostile forces a strong incentive to lie low and wait...

...In much of the world, bloodless intervention, peaceful peacekeeping is a contradiction in terms: if it were possible, it wouldn't be necessary...

...It is probably equally futile to name the states and the cases, though that is what I mean to do, on the principle that even futility is improved when it is made less abstract...

...Whenever the filthy work can be stopped, it should be stopped...

...The vast numbers of murdered people...

...The question, to intervene or not...

...Liberation should always be a local initiative...

...would be avoided...

...Consider: if some powerful state or regional alliance had rushed troops into Rwanda when the massacres first began or as soon as their scope was apparent, the terrible exodus and the cholera plague might have been avoided...

...But what if the trouble is internal, the inhumanity locally and widely rooted, a matter of political culture, social structures, historical memories, ethnic fear, resentment, and hatred...

...But no one really wants the United States to become the world's policeman, even of-lastresort, as we would quickly see were we to undertake the role...

...Still, we will, and we should be, more widely involved than other countries with fewer resources...

...In cases like this one, the politics of rescue is certain to be complex and messy...

...Should the United States, as the world's only or greatest "great power" be nominated agent-of-last-resort...

...The very idea of a "failed state" will seem patronizing and arrogant to a group like, say, the Rwandan Patriotic Front, which hasn't yet had a chance to succeed...

...Give up the idea 36 • DISSENT The Politics of Rescue of an external and singular evil, and the "in and out" test is very hard to apply...

...The question is especially hard for people on the left who are appalled by what happened or is happening in Bosnia, say, or Rwanda, but who have long argued, most of us, that the best thing to do with an army is to keep it at home...

...It is a good thing, again, when these are undertaken by local powers like Vietnam...

...Humanitarian interventions are not justified for the sake of democracy or free enterprise or economic justice or voluntary association or any other of the social practices and arrangements that we might hope for or even call for in other people's countries...

...Despite all that I have said so far, I don't mean to abandon the principle of nonintervention— only to honor its exceptions...

...Its presence or absence would depend on decisions of a Security Council likely to be as divided and uncertain as it is today, still subject to great-power veto and severe budget40 • DISSENT The Politics of Rescue ary constraints...

...This is not to say that soldiers should be sent recklessly into danger...

...So the question is: who can authorize and constrain these interventions, set the ground rules and the time frame, worry about their strategies and tactics...

...Putting Soldiers at Risk This last question is probably the crucial one in making intervention increasingly difficult and unlikely...

...Many people on the right see no point in intervention today when there is no material or, for that matter, ideological advantage to be gained...

...And a small but growing number of people on the left now favor intervening, here or there, driven by an internationalist ethic...

...And it isn't enough to wait until the tyrants, the zealots, and the bigots have done their filthy work and then rush food and medicine to the ragged survivors...

...Behind this preference is an argument something like Rousseau's argument for the general will: in the course of a democratic decision procedure, Rousseau claimed, the particular interests of the different parties will cancel each other out, leaving a general interest untainted by particularity...

...So it does today among small groups of concerned people, some of whom end up supporting, some resisting interventionist policies...

...I am strongly inclined, sometimes, to give a positive answer to this question (whether volunteers or conscripts should bear these risks is too complicated to take up here...

...There is no external aggression to worry about, only domestic brutality, civil war, political tyranny, ethnic or religious persecution...

...Probably so...

...Rwanda might have been a candidate for trusteeship...

...the masses of desperate refugees—none of these are served by reciting high-minded principles...

...And that has made it difficult for them to justify the measures that would be necessary to stop the killing and the ethnic cleansing...

...But this demand is effectively an argument against intervening at all...

...But this isn't a wholly attractive idea, for its result is very likely to be stalemate and inaction, which cannot always be the general will of international society...

...The Rwandans, it turned out, had no local or global neighbors until they were dying by the thousands on foreign soil and on television...

...The test of a genuinely humanitarian intervention, on this view, is that the intervening forces are quickly in and out...

...Nonetheless, given what is now going on in Southeast Europe and Central Africa, morally serious people have to think again about the human costs and benefits of what we might call "standing interventions...

...We are extraordinarily dependent on the victim/victimizer, good guys/bad guys model...

...For now, though, the agent-of-last-resort is anyone near enough and strong enough to stop what needs stopping...

...So it seems best that people who have lived together in the past and will have to do so in the future should be allowed to work out their difficulties without imperial assistance, among themselves...

...these were grown-up Boy Scouts, doing good deeds...

...Sometimes, the United States should take the initiative...

...On the standard view of humanitarian intervention (which I adopted when writing Just and Unjust Wars almost twenty years ago), the source of the inhumanity is conceived as somehow external and singular in character: a tyrant, a conqueror or usurper, or an alien power set over against a mass of victims...

...Insofar as it is necessary, we have to acknowledge the real status and function of the men and women whom we send to do the job...

...They do not intervene and then stay put for reasons of their own, as the Vietnamese did in Cambodia...

...I concede that the Nigerian-led intervention in Liberia is not an entirely happy precedent, though it has probably slowed the killing...

...Rescue the people in trouble from their troublers, and let them get on with their lives...

...If we had more trust in the effectiveness of the United Nations or the various regional associations, we could require international or at least multilateral endorsement, cooperation, and constraint...

...But humanitarian interventions and peacekeeping operations are first of all military acts directed against people who are already using force, breaking the peace...

...The public debate has had a different focus—as if there were (as perhaps there once were) a large number of states eager to intervene...

...its risks must be accepted...

...As with individuals in domestic society, so with states in international society: if all of them are consulted, each will veto the self-aggrandizing proposals of the others...

...When should the world's agents and powers (the United Nations, the European Community, the Pan American Alliance, the Organization of African Unity, the United * I will not consider here what they have to do, in a democracy, to act legally or constitutionally abroad— another question, for another time...

...Active opposition to massacre and massive deportation is morally necessary...

...Would we be ready then for a more direct and long-lasting military intervention—and if so, with what sort of an army...

...But many governments and many more politicians seem increasingly inclined to find the question easy: the answer is not...

...Who will, who should, do the "standing" and pay the price of the possible but often invisible victories...

...One of the reasons for the weakness of the United Nations in Bosnia has been that many of its representatives on the ground do not believe that the model fits the situation they have to confront...

...In many cases, nothing at all will be done unless we are prepared to play one or the other of these parts—either the political lead or a combination of financial backer and supporting player...

...What About "Humanitarian Intervention...

...In all these cases, it may well happen that the quick departure of the intervening forces is followed immediately by the reappearance of the conditions that led to intervention in the first place...

...Pay the moral price of silence and callousness, and you will soon have to pay the political price of turmoil and lawlessness nearer home...

...The first is a kind of trusteeship, where the intervening power actually rules the country it has "rescued," acting in trust for the inhabitants, seeking to establish a stable and more or less consensual politics...

...there is little chance that it will be consensual unless it is locally produced...

...But behavior of that kind, unchallenged, tends to spread, to be imitated or reiterated...

...It is also possible, of course, that some coalition of states, cooperating for the sake of shared (particular) interests, will have its way...

...A friend comments: you would stress the wariness more if there were a Republican president...

...Two forms of long-lasting intervention, both associated in the past with imperial politics, now warrant reconsideration...

...Even in the case of a brutal civil war or a politically induced famine or the massacre of a local minority, the use of force in other people's countries should always generate hesitation and anxiety...

...Help them, and then leave them to manage as best they can by themselves...

...They are right to feel driven...

...In Somalia, the United States made the undertaking but was unprepared for the long haul (perhaps the long haul was not called for in this case: no one is reporting today on conditions in the Somalian countryside, so we don't know...

...anyone who can take the initiative should do so...

...It is very hard these days, in the Western democracies, to put soldiers at risk...

...Now obligation is seconded by interest...

...It is true that right now there are a lot of exceptions...

...I will consider this possibility later on...

...Internationalism has always been understood to require support for, and even participation in, popular struggles anywhere in the world...

...In the face of human disaster, however, internationalism has a more urgent meaning...

...The United States should have intervened in Haiti months before it did, though the probably necessary protectorate would best have been undertaken by a coalition of Central American and Caribbean states...

...The second is a kind of protectorate, where the intervention brings some local group or coalition of groups to power and is then sustained only defensively, to ensure that there is no return of the defeated regime or the old lawlessness and that minority rights are respected...

...As I have already acknowledged, interest and obligation together have often provided an ideology for imperial expansion or cold war advance...

...Enduring the Intervention Even the risk of a blocked exit and a long stay...

...In the aftermath of the cold war, no comparable ideology has that capacity...

...It is harder to say who should have stopped the killing in southern Sudan or East Timor: there isn't always an obvious candidate or a clear responsibility...

...They will be ineffective unless there is a willingness to accept the risks that naturally attach to military acts—to shed blood, to lose soldiers...

...I would have supported both these policies, thinking that they might produce a local solution that, however bloody it turned out to be, could not be worse than what was happening anyway...

...the norm is selfdetermination...

...But not for these people, the victims of tyranny, ideological zeal, ethnic hatred, who are not determining anything for themselves, who urgently need help from outside...

...Old and well-earned suspicions of American power must give way now to a wary recognition of its necessity...

...Or what if the trouble follows from state failure, the collapse of any effective government, with results closer to Hobbes's than to Kropotkin's predictions—not quite a "war of all against all" but a widely dispersed, disorganized, and murderous war of some against some...

...But the process can work in other ways too, as when terrorist regimes in the third world imitate one another (often with help from the first world), and waves of desperate refugees flee into countries where powerful political forces, not yet ascendent, want only to drive them back...

...Nor is the history of trusteeships and protectorates particularly encouraging: the contemporary horror of the Sudanese civil war, for example, is no reason to forget the oppressiveness of the old "Anglo-Egyptian Sudan...

...The standard answer on the left, and probably more widely, is that the best authority is international, multilateral—the UN is the obvious example...

...Bosnia provides a classic example of a serial rejection of the undertaking: everyone deplored the war and the ethnic cleansing...

...WINTER • 1995 • 41...

...No doubt, there are still identifiable evil-doers, but now, let's say, they have support at home, reserves, evil-doers in waiting: what then...

...When should they protest and then intervene...

...If this question gets an affirmative answer, then we cannot panic when the first soldier or the first significant number of soldiers, like the eighteen infantrymen in Somalia, are killed in a firefight...

...It is likely to require a much more sustained challenge to conventional sovereignty: a long-term military presence, social reconstruction, what used to be called "political trusteeship" (since few of the locals—at least, the locals with power—can be trusted), and along the way, making all this possible, the large-scale and reiterated use of force...

...Under whose direction...

...Imagine that they took those measures, as (in my view) they should have done: wouldn't they also have been required to take collateral measures against the Croats and Bosnian Moslems...

...Soldiers are destined for dangerous places, and they should know that (if they don't, they should be told...

...Haiti today [October 1994] might provide a test case, since the U.S.-led, multinational force serves as the protector of the restored Aristide government— and that role is likely to be an extended one...

...But the troops would still be there, probably, and no one would know what hadn't happened...

...It seems futile to say what is also obvious: that some states should be prepared to intervene in some cases...

...In practice, we should probably look for some concurrence of multilateral authorization and unilateral initiative—the first for the sake of moral legitimacy, the second for the sake of political effectiveness—but it's the initiative that is essential...

...none of their interventions, with the possible exception of the last, would have been authorized by the UN...

...It is also hard to say how responsibility passes on, when the obvious candidates refuse its burdens...

...We see the sequence most clearly in Hannah Arendt's description of how European brutality in the colonies was eventually carried back to Europe itself...

...I am going to focus on the arguments for and against "humanitarian intervention," for this is what is at issue in the former Yugoslavia, the Caucasus, parts of Asia, much of Africa...

...And if not by us, the supposedly decent people of this world, then by whom...

...The intervention then has an aim that is simple as well as negative: remove the tyrant (Pol Pot, Idi Amin), set the people free (Bangladesh), and then get out...

...Remember the biblical injunction: "Do not stand idly by the blood of thy neighbor...

...I concede that these successive payments are not inevitable, but they come in sequence often enough...

...Which States Should Intervene...

...They are not focused on the costs of intervention or, for that matter, of nonintervention to the men and women whose danger or suffering poses the question, but only on the costs to their own soldiers and to themselves, that is, to their political standing at home...

...The lives they saved would be speculative and statistical, not actual lives...

...Bosnia for a protectorate...

...The presumption against intervention is strong...

...Is anyone ready for this...

...These days, for reasons we should probably celebrate, countries in trouble are no longer viewed as imperial opportunities...

...The ideology of the cold war once provided a set of terms, not in fact always appropriate to the cases at hand, but capable of overriding domestic considerations...

...But that meant: we have to wait for the popular struggles...

...no one was prepared to stop them—and no one is prepared now to reverse their effects...

...Yes, the norm is not to intervene in other people's countries...

...With the transportation technology at our command, we are probably near enough, and we are certainly strong enough, to stop what needs stopping in most of the cases I have been discussing (though not in all of them at once...

...The European Community or, at least, the French and British together (the Germans were disqualified by their aggression in World War II) ought to have intervened early on in Bosnia...

...Where the policies and practices that need to be stopped are widely supported, sustained by local structures and cultures, any potentially successful intervention is not going to meet the "in and out" test...

...These are arrangements that are hard to recommend and that would, no doubt, be hard to justify in today's political climate...

...Massacre, rape, ethnic cleansing, state terrorism, contemporary versions of "bastard feudalism," complete with ruthless warlords and lawless bands of armed men: these are the acts and occasions that invite us, or require us, to override the presumption against moving armies across borders and using force inside countries that have not threatened or attacked their neighbors...

...Hence the practice of "humanitarian intervention"—much abused, no doubt, but morally necessary whenever cruelty and suffering are extreme and no local forces seem capable of putting an end to them...

...The Europeans in Bosnia, it has to be said, didn't even wait to panic: they made it clear from the beginning that the soldiers they sent to open roads and transport supplies were not to be regarded as soldiers in any usual sense...

...How did the old empires ever get soldiers to go to such places, to sit in beleaguered encampments, to fight an endless round of small, wearying, unrecorded battles...

...There are some useful, and to my mind justified, contemporary examples: India in East Pakistan, Tanzania in Uganda, Vietnam in Cambodia...

...This article was first delivered at a conference on rescue at the New School for Social Research in New York City in November 1994...

...This is no doubt the hardest question, but it isn't, curiously, the one that has attracted the most attention...

...One reads the newspaper these days shaking...

...Still, nonintervention is not an absolute moral rule: sometimes, what is going on locally cannot be tolerated...

...The useful role played by the UN in Cambodia (organizing and supervising elections) suggests the importance of strengthening its hand...

...This is rescue-in-advance, and it will be resisted by those local elites who believe that the need for rescue will never arise if they are allowed to take charge—or who are prepared to take charge at any cost...

...But it wasn't the UN that overthrew Pol Pot and stopped the Khmer Rouge massacres...

...Ever since Roman times, empires have expanded by intervening in civil wars, replacing "anarchy" with law and order, overthrowing supposedly noxious regimes...

...It's not possible to wait...

...Soldiers are not like Peace Corps volunteers or Fulbright scholars or USIA musicians and lecturers— WINTER • 1995 • 37 The Politics of Rescue who should not, indeed, be sent overseas to dangerous places...

...And the European governments became in turn the opponents of any such challenge...

...But in this post-imperial and post—cold war age, these positions are likely to be reversed or, at least, confused...

...Multilaterafism is no guarantee of anything...

...They are not quite apologists for the Serbs, who have (rightly) been condemned in many United Nations resolutions, but they do not regard the Serbs as wholly "bad guys" or as the only "bad guys" in the former Yugoslavia...

...What's Bosnia to them or they to Bosnia/that they should weep for her...

...Better to stay home than to intervene in a way that is sure to fail...

...With what weapons systems, what strategy and tactics, what willingness to take casualties and to impose them...

...But what if the quick fix failed, brought on an ever more brutal civil war, with no end in sight...

...The aim in all these countries (though we experimented briefly with something more in Mogadishu) is not to alter power relations on the ground, but only to ameliorate their consequences—to bring food and medical supplies to populations besieged and bombarded, for example, without interfering with the siege or bombardment...

...Should we put soldiers at risk in faraway places when our own country is not under attack or threatened with attack (not Maine or Georgia or Oregon) and when national interests, narrowly understood, are not at stake...

...Interventions of this sort are probably best carried out by neighbors, as in these three cases, since neighbors will have some understanding of the local culture...

...the men, women, and children dying of disease and famine willfully caused or easily preventable...

...Intervening armies won't be defeated in these sticky settings, but they will suffer a slow attrition—and show no quick or obvious benefits...

...It may still be better than the unilateral initiative of a single powerful state—though in the examWINTER • 1995 • 39 The Politics of Rescue pies with which I began, India, Vietnam, and Tanzania, local powers, did not do entirely badly...

...And yet, sometimes, they ought to be supported and endured...

...The reason is simple enough: all states have an interest in global stability and even in global humanity, and in the case of wealthy and powerful states like ours, this interest is seconded by obligation...

...For how long will decency survive here, if there is no decency there...

...The Organization of African Unity, with the financial help of Europeans and Americans, should have intervened early on in Rwanda...

...sometimes we should help pay for and even add soldiers to an intervention initiated by somebody else...

...They may also, however, have old scores to settle or old (or new) ambitions to dominate the neighborhood...

...only disasters that might have occurred (but how can we be sure...

...But that's not always easy...