Notebook Planned obsolescence
Gallicho, Grant
NOTEBOOK ti PLANNED OBSOLESCENCE The wrong prescription for Medicare reform don't take a lot of drugs. Pop an Advil here, a Tylenol there. Dose up on NyQuil when the going gets really rough. On...
...and Part B, which pays for outpatient costs and doctor visits...
...Actual coverage and costs are left to be determined by the private insurance companies that will administer—and profit from—the drug benefit...
...This has health-care analysts worried...
...If either occurs, it's clear that Medicare as we know it—knew it—won't be around when people my age need it...
...The new-and-improved Medicare is a wind-fall for private insurance companies and drug manufacturers (75 percent of whose 2002 campaign contributions went to the GOP...
...Sooner or later, seniors who live in that hole will demand that it be filled...
...It seems Bush either wants to implode Medicare or he wants to make it impossible to fix...
...Still, the main beneficiaries won't be the impoverished, or even my grandmother...
...Douglas Holtz-Eakin, director of the Congressional Budget Office, estimates that Medicare 2.0's costs in its second decade will be between $1.3 trillion and $2 trillion...
...She's put off not only by the new law's byzantine rules and qualifications, but also by a truism that's never failed in her eighty-four years: If something looks too good to be true, it probably is...
...She's not...
...N III I/u rrlis rirwr~ii~tl alit}r --ihr IYI 0RIIIH CItt rnwrl'om/ 1, the lop pH( t' I() ( /I, Rye /or II...
...Many analysts see this cost inflation as a foregone conclusion: they know that entitlement programs are notoriously expansive...
...Should Medicare become "insolvent" and legislators be forced to choose between cutting benefits and raising taxes, which are they likely to pick...
...While the new Medicare Act covers 75 percent of drug costs up to $2,250, it covers nothing between $2,250 and $5,100...
...As for those struggling drug manufacturers, Medicare 2.0 bars the government from negotiating prices with them, even as it goes on haggling with other members of the health-delivery system: doctors, hospitals, and medical-equipment makers...
...This is a rigged game...
...The big winners are private insurers and drug companies...
...Not bad...
...In fact, there are no set prices in the law...
...My grandma isn't very happy about that...
...If only that pro-vision had been written into the act...
...Not that the new law doesn't have its upside...
...If a drug company hits on a "superdrug"—medication that proves a necessity to some sector of the prescription-drug market—that $400-billion cost estimate for the new Medicare will start looking mighty low...
...This leaves plenty of room for insurers to put a squeeze on seniors with extremely high drug bills...
...This will be achieved, as Jonathan Cohn succinctly put it, by "using Medicare funds injudiciously" (the New Republic, "The Medicare Law's True Cost," December 15, 2003...
...According to the new law, if Medicare's actuaries conclude that, for two consecutive years, general revenue composes greater than 45 percent of the total Medicare budget, the program will be declared "insolvent," and Congress will have to either reduce benefits or raise payroll taxes...
...Medicare comprises two programs: Part A, which covers inpatient hospital costs...
...That's going to be expensive...
...She has one of those monthly pill organizers—four rows of seven small interconnected plastic boxes, each marked with a day of the week and filled with whatever meds she has to take for a given day...
...In fact, my grandmother is pretty suspicious of Medicare's revisions...
...The former slides all too easily into health-care rationing, while the latter could constitute political suicide...
...Part A gets its money from a trust that's funded by payroll taxes...
...Yet under the new law, seniors who participate in Medicare's drug-benefit program are prohibited from buying Medigap policies to fill in the "doughnut hole...
...So, it seems only sensible that someone like her should be thrilled by the prospect of President George W. Bush's Medicare act, which adds a prescription drug benefit to the tune of $400 billion over ten years...
...So why the sudden, uncharacteristic Republican support for an exploded entitlement program...
...The act grants $12 billion to private insurers to help them compete against Medicare...
...On the list of heaviest (legal) drug users in the United States, I rank pretty low, much farther toward the bottom than, say, my grandmother Janet...
...In the debate leading up to the passage of Medicare 2.0, some appealing numbers were bandied about: for $35 a month, Patient X could get a 10-25 percent discount on the retail price of prescription drugs...
...GRANT GALLICHO SCHWADRON Commonweal 7 January 30, 2004...
...The very poor will benefit by being exempt from the estimated $420 annual premium and having nearly all of their copayments covered by the government...
...Medicare beneficiaries have traditionally purchased "Medigap" coverage to make up for Medicare's limitations...
...Instead, it merely says that premiums and copayments have to be "actuarially equivalent" to those numbers, which means such payments can vary from plan to plan, provided the average amount paid by beneficiaries matches the figures outlined in the law...
...the administration predicts the number of Medicare recipients who buy additional private coverage will jump from 12 percent to 35 percent of all beneficiaries by 2007...
...Part B's money comes largely from general tax revenue...
...Second, not so obvious: many critics believe the new Medicare law is designed to eventually eviscerate the program...
...Sound conspiratorial...
...First, the obvious: porkbarreling...
...Even better for them, "IIri...
Vol. 131 • January 2004 • No. 2
