State of emergency The future often gets to California first, & the future of health care looks bleak
Higgins, Thomas
Thomas Higgins STATE OF EMERGENCY California's health-care crisis The words "health care" and "crisis" follow each other in sentences so often that we have grown numb to the association....
...High on the list of cuts proposed by Governor Gray Davis are reductions in eligibility for the state's Medicaid program (known as Medical) and its program for other low-income families with children...
...Physicians have also shown great ability to maintain their incomes by increasing the volume of their services to make up for caps on reimbursement...
...The care is usually handled in a very expensive setting, such as an emergency room, and the cost is shifted to others with private insurance in the form of a hidden tax built into the pricing structure...
...There is a "tipping point" for most great social issues...
...He is the CEO of a biotechnology company in San Francisco...
...The poor have very little access to even the most basic health care...
...The other is a massive tax cut on dividends he has asked this Congress to approve...
...Policymakers and editorial writers have been talking about a crisis in access to affordable health care for more than half a century...
...The prag-matists begin with the system as it is, and seek to expand coverage by incremental improvements...
...As always, the acid test will be money...
...That was swell in the boom years, but the leverage worked against the state treasury when the economy tanked...
...Many employers are planning to cap their contribution, shifting the burden to their workers...
...Pharmaceutical costs are way up, last year outpacing every other element in healthcare cost inflation...
...Recently, however, the CEO of Blue Shield went much further, proposing that health insurance be mandatory for every individual in California, and requiring all insurance companies to issue policies regardless of risk...
...If so, it may reach the halls of Congress sooner than politicians ever imagined...
...others may drop their coverage altogether...
...After all, just four years ago, the state had a large surplus and was looking to expand its program of health care for the working poor...
...Another truism that finds its way into newsprint all the time is that trends that sweep America often begin in California...
...Health care is pretty high on the hierarchy of needs...
...That leaves the states with the unenviable task of raising revenues to meet the shall I repeat...
...An aging population needs more resources...
...Thomas Higgins was deputy secretary to the cabinet of President Jimmy Carter...
...The answer, of course, is tied to the bust in many sectors of California's economy, like information technology, aerospace, travel, and communications...
...Just as important, across the United States all of the factors in medical cost inflation went into overdrive...
...As with many states, California has a very progressive tax structure that is heavily dependent on personal and corporate income taxes...
...2. In the face of budget shortfalls, county governments have been forced to close many of the public hospitals and community health clinics that were a "safety net" for the uninsured, especially migrants with nowhere else to go for services...
...That vote to increase property taxes was the first since California started a contrary national trend thirty years ago with property-tax limitations...
...More than two hundred thousand people will be dropped from the MediCal program alone...
...This year, legislators are being asked to vote new sales and income taxes for the same reason...
...When they need health care, it is usually delivered later than is optimal for efficacy and efficiency, because lack of insurance means they wait until there is an emergency to be treated for illnesses that could have been dealt with much earlier...
...In California, these national trends are exacerbated by the large number of individuals and their families who fall outside any organized system of care...
...How did California get to this place so quickly...
...Hospital charges are up, in part as the result of increased costs for wages and, in part, because competition has been eliminated in most communities...
...People are starting to speak up...
...No other country in the world pays so much for so little when it comes to health care...
...Are legislators listening...
...Insurance premiums went up an average of more than 25 percent last year, and next year looks to be as bad...
...When state funding is reduced, federal funding about 60 percent of the total expenditure is lost proportionately...
...Attempts at reforming health-care delivery in California have usually been thwarted by a split among progressives...
...MediCal is funded by a mix of state and federal matching funds...
...Absent some major policy initiative, these numbers will continue to climb, but not indefinitely...
...Well, the crisis in health care is about to get almost unimaginably worse everywhere in America, but nowhere as ugly as in California...
...The purists hold out for the creation of a "single payer" system, such as Canada has, that would make government the insurer for all, just as Medicare covers the elderly...
...Many private and even nonprofit providers have pulled out of poor neighborhoods because reimbursement was inadequate, and those remaining are already swamped to the point of breakdown...
...There are several reasons for California's impending meltdown: 1. The state is broke and facing a budget deficit of about $35 billion and counting, more than all other states combined, except New York...
...To many, the cuts in state funding are a false economy, since 100 percent of the cost of care for these newly uninsured people will be absorbed in higher costs to everyone else as the costs are shifted...
...In California, they are about 20 percent...
...Nationally, the uninsured are about 15 percent of the population...
...Although some die-hard critics groused that the plan would mean more pol-icyholders for Blue Shield, the press and political community are taking it seriously, because the current situation is not sustainable...
...With 10 percent of the U.S...
...3. For those whose insurance is tied to employment, a double whammy of medical-cost inflation and a persistent recession has further threatened their coverage...
...that is, to preserve at least a part of the health-care safety net by supporting public health and maintaining vital community health centers...
...One is the 50-percent increase in defense spending over the next five years that the last Congress obediently approved...
...population and more of its social problems, California may be at the inflection point for a national movement to tackle at last the unresolved matter of health insurance for all...
...So far, President George W. Bush has escaped much criticism for ignoring the problem but, though Democrats seem speechless now, it is hard to believe they will resist the opportunity to hammer the point as the middle class becomes more at risk...
...President Bush has two very large uses of national wealth at hand, and neither of them concerns health care for the uninsured...
...Last November, voters in Los Angeles County agreed to increase their taxes in order to save some of their public-health infrastructure...
...Perhaps this willingness to accept higher taxes for the purpose of equitable health-care financing is a new trend...
...Under the proposal, which has gotten widespread and favorable attention, a funding pool would be set up to subsidize those who could not afford the insurance premiums, and it would be financed by single-purpose taxes as well as the general fund...
...This may be the sleeper issue in the next presidential election...
...No one believes these price increases are manageable for companies that have little pricing power for their own products...
Vol. 130 • February 2003 • No. 3
