The Unexpected Way by Paul Williams

...He stops almost as soon as he begins...

...What is learned will of course be different in each case...

...He continues to hold a professorial position in Indian and Tibetan philosophy at the University of Bristol in England, and was for many years known in Europe not only as a scholar of Buddhism, but also as a practitioner and an instructor of others in practice...

...It doesn't match Augustine or Newman for literary elegance or theological acumen (few books in any genre do), and it is not Merton's equal in the psychological insights produced by that author's obsessive (hyperscrupulous, some would say) concern for the state of his mind and soul...

...Paul J. Griffiths teaches at the University of Illinois at Chicago...

...Justin's and Augustine's conversion narratives are perhaps the most familiar examples from the ancient church...

...He is certainly not ecumenical, and what he writes shows a deep joy in what for many cradle Catholics is cause for shame and embarrassment...

...The same unapologetic directness is evident in his discussions of such disputed (among Catholics as much as between Catholics and non-Catholics) topics as the reality of hell and purgatory, the impropriety of artificial contraception, the incompatibility of the Christian view that the cosmos is created by a good God with the (usual) Buddhist view that it is a be-ginningless product of human action (karma), and the relative impoverishmerit of Protestant churches as compared with the Roman Catholic Church...

...Yet in its own way it is as interesting as any of these, and it has a feature which makes it unique among conversion narratives: it depicts a conversion from Buddhism to Catholicism, not from Anglicanism, as did Newman's, nor from Christian-influenced paganism, as did both Augustine's and Merton's...

...He would agree with (though he does not quote) Newman's view that dogma is the fundamental principle of the Catholic religion, and that "religion as a mere sentiment, is-a dream and a mockery...

...He expounds the doctrines of the Incarnation and the atonement, for example, with a refreshing directness and a clear awareness that although there are theological subtleties and disputes his training has not equipped him to address, there is nonetheless a core of orthodoxy that he can and does affirm with clarity, verve, and assurance...

...Naturally, some Buddhists will find annoying his argumentative dismissal of some central tenets of their tradition (though I suspect that Western Buddhists are more likely to be annoyed than, say, traditional representatives of the Tibetan Buddhist schools who will probably be amused...

...Naive enthusiasm can be as problematic as weary cynicism, and all converts need (as Williams clearly sees) to be led into the mysteries by those who have long inhabited them...

...If it is, then Williams could be an important contributor...

...This, too, is something the church needs: as Catholic thought was transformed by its appropriation of the Egyptian gold of Aris-totelianism in the thirteenth century, so it may be transformed by the riches of Buddhism in the third millennium...

...In this book, though, he is mostly concerned to show how clear and deep are the divergences between Buddhism and Catholic Christianity, and this is important to emphasize against the easy syncretism of our times...

...What matters most to Williams is that he takes what the Catholic Church teaches to be true...

...He is a man of obvious intellectual gifts and burgeoning theological interests...

...Paul Williams's book is one more in this genre...

...The same should be said about the stories told by Catholic converts: the church has often been nourished and sometimes transformed by such narratives, and some of them are among its literary and theological monuments...

...in more recent times John Henry Newman's Apologia and Thomas Merton's Seven Storey Mountain are probably the most widely read among English-speaking Catholics...

...But in the late 1990s, he experienced an intellectual conversion, went through the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults, and was received into the church as the second millennium turned into the third...

...It is more likely that other Catholics will find what Williams says both unacceptable and distressing...

...There are many others as well, ranging from the coolly intellectual (Avery Dulles's Testimonial to Grace) to the deliberately down-home (Scott and Kimberly Hahn's Rome Sweet Home...

...Paul J. Griffiths The blood of the martyrs, the old saying has it, is the seed of the church...

...These range from the abstrusely technical to his Mahayana Buddhism: The Doctrinal Foundations, which may be the most widely used introduction to Mahayana Buddhist thought in the English-speaking world...

...They remind jaded, bored, and conflicted Catholics how surprising and delightful the faith can appear to someone freshly bathed in the baptismal waters...

...He is certainly among the half-dozen most widely read living interpreters of Buddhist thought to the West...

...but this is precisely the kind of question it would be fruitful to ask and answer at length, with care, and with the kind of precise technical knowledge that Williams has...

...Gratitude and joy are the main threads in the fabric of this book, and this explains why conversion narratives have been and continue to be so important for the church...

...All converts know the experience of being asked by cradle Catholics, in a puzzled tone, why anyone who wasn't already burdened with Catholicism would take it on...

...He may become a serious contributor to the enterprises of Catholic philosophy and theology, and if he does, his contributions will inevitably be flavored by his knowledge of Buddhism...

...He is right that Buddhism and Christianity are utterly incompatible in everything of moment...

...It is hard to see, from such a position, why anyone would find membership in it a burden or a problem...

...It was at least necessary (and probably sufficient) for his conversion that he should become convinced of that...

...Paul Williams is an English baby-boomer, born in midcentury and raised with the attenuated Anglicanism common to most of his generation and social class...

...He was baptized and confirmed in the Anglican church as an adolescent, but soon ceased to practice...

...None of this is to say that new converts see the church more clearly than those who have been in her embrace since before they can recall-and this is true whether that embrace is seen as tender or boa constrictor-like...

...For Williams, Catholicism is true, and the church, therefore, is a great gift...

...Perhaps all cradle Catholics should be required to read at least one conversion narrative a year, just to remind them of who and what they are...

...Perhaps, though, it can be allowed that the long-married have as much to learn about marriage from newlyweds as the other way about...

...In part because of its unabashed affirmation of the importance of doctrinal orthodoxy, the book is likely to infuriate many...

...This is a book to be grateful for in times like these...

...There are also hints of the fruitfulness that Buddhist concepts and patterns of argument might have, if applied to the tasks of Christian theology...

...It will be interesting to observe Williams's future work...

...He has a doctoral degree in Indian Buddhist philosophy (with a focus on Madhyamaka, for those who care about Buddhist scholastic affiliations) from Oxford, and has published many books and articles on Buddhist thought...

...They confront an unbelieving world with the fact that the gospel in the hands of the church can still seduce some of its cultured despisers into submission...

...I hope the church will find ways to encourage such contributions by Williams, and that he will find time and energy to make them...

...He became interested in Buddhist thought and practice as a young man, and because of his intellectual gifts proceeded to study the languages and literatures of the Indo-Tibetan Buddhist tradition, achieving a high degree of mastery and sophistication...

...but this does not mean that the thought of the church cannot be seeded by Buddhist thought...

...He hopes, he says, to have become a "reasonably orthodox" Catholic, and the book's discussions of the central doctrinal claims of Catholic Christianity show that he has indeed done so...

...His book is a record of the intellectual conversion, and (to a lesser extent) of the practicalities involved in becoming Catholic in England at that time...

...To the convert-and certainly to the kind of convert that Williams seems to be-this question is deeply puzzling...

...Williams's straightforwardness about all this is certainly appealing...

...Williams begins to sketch, for example, how Christian understanding of the unaccept-ability of prideful self-righteousness might look, if done with the help of the battery of Buddhist concepts developed for the presentation of the doctrine of no-self-the idea, that is, that none of what we take ourselves to be essentially and permanently is in fact what we are...