Correspondence: 'Cider House,' Catholic medicine, etc.
CORRESPONDENCE the deplorable state of Irish Catholi- be right. But he fails to consider...
...a correct diagnosis of the HMO dis- Clarke E. Cochran's February 25 arti- LORING W. BATTEN, III ease when he acknowledges that cle on Catholic hospitals ["Another Port Washington, N.Y...
...Manuscripts Wanted Pilgrim's all EDITED BY PATRICK JORDAN AND PAUL BAUMANN Like Eamon Duffy ["Confronting the BECOME A PUBLISHED AUTHOR...
...leaders need to respond to the con- strict coverage with arbitrary regula- Another year, I was lying in a corricerns of their members for insuring tions not related to a patient's welfare...
...It certain- Cochran's recommendations in "Anly does not for Rose...
...Church's Past," January 141 1 am very Quality subsidy publisher accepting manCOMMONWEAL much moved by the phrase in the uscripts...
...i kk)L OF THEOLOGY Although my ears heard nothing of social justice ministry, missions, and what he said, some inner sense detect- spiritual direction, to name a few...
...Scholarship awards are based on need and merit...
...some sign, any sign, indicating to the ing's homage to Planned Parenthood J. MURRAY ELWOOD world that "we are among you" has and NARAL (National Abortion Strafford, Pa...
...Cider House Rules is a propaganda film tinued quality of Commonweal's for- It can be persuasively argued that for abortion...
...only form of physical Catholic witness I respectfully disagree with your Unlike other publications of its she or he will experience outside a March 24 editorial assertion that The genre, the topical appeal and the con- largely negative media...
...to what kind of cluded an explicit affirmation of life...
...T1 IF EDITORS Happy e-mailing...
...tion to patients as persons, a sine qua non of such sacramental/incarnational A bonanza compassion, Catholic health care must Here's a raised pint of Guinness to include commitment to palliative and Commonweal for the splendid issue of hospice-type care for the dying...
...PHILIP E. DEVINE ly billing available for repeat advertisers...
...12-word mini75 years counsel, but I fail to see how it mum...
...River Forest, Ill...
...ideas...
...The writer is Roman Catholic chaplain Second, as an expression of devoat Wesleyan University...
...Catholic identity But I'm sticking to it...
...Correspondent John Hazard asks conclude that the Catholic church is Larch is no poster boy for any cause, [March 10]: "...Catholics may wonder virtually absent from everyday modabortion or otherwise...
...It may Roman going to pray for an Episcorenewed versions of the great "labor be that health care and profit-taking palian being operated on by a Jewish schools" to instruct those who lead are ethically and morally incompati- surgeon...
...Address inquiries to: Office of Admissions, Yale Institute of Sacred Music, 409 Prospect St., New Haven, CT 06511 PHONE(203)432-5180 FAX (2,03) 432-5296 E-MAIL ruth.lackstrom@yale.edu WEBSITE http://www.yale.edu/ism Commonweal 36 April 21, 2000 Observe, judge, act my experience, none of the actions Holocaust ethics Thanks to John Hill and Barry Hillen- that members took arising from the Jewish scholar David Novick has rebrand for their illuminating profiles of social inquiry-integrating all-white minded us of the difficulty anyone Reynold Hillenbrand [March 10...
...The film makes why any kind of [clerical or religious] ern life...
...morally profound...
...In Commonweal 37 April 21, 2000 sponse to the Holocaust as I can imag- C L ASS I F I E D Celebrating ine...
...On the ever, that painting the rectory base- cover painful moral dilemmas, and top floor I found the room...
...that it is the children of the church, I7.1X"IF:,.l'.11.1,AIIAN J}:.1>' 11N'1'lIIc...
...But consider Wear the collar for yourself how easy it would be to this: the apparently kind and gruff Dr...
...1-800-695-9599...
...JOHN DAVID grounds that it is illegal, is hardly Alexandria, Va...
...Next time you Rights Action League) at the Acade- walk through an airport or mall, judge my Awards ceremony...
...Those twenty-minute prep Sabbatical Program sessions, no surprise, were a means of JESUIT personal formation, and I count my- For further inonnation please contact: self among those (as John Hill said so School of Oflit< olA[liliissitms well) "whose lives he touched...
...sages dealing with ar Issues of faith, Catholicism MARIAN BURKHART and Protestantism, New York, N.Y...
...PesMarch 10...
...Phone: (617) 492-1960 Referring to the decline of monsign- Fax: (617) 492-5833 or's influence and YCW participation An International Web Site: www.wjst.edu in the 1963 lunch-counter sit-ins, Hill writes that "Hillenbrand supported Theological Center financial aid is available...
...Then everybody rose, recited a closing prayer by embodied in a variety of apostolates: heart, the priest gave us a blessing, education, hospital and university and he quickly exited-no small talk, W[-'F S TON JESUX I chaplaincy, parish ministry, peace and no chitchat...
...10 persquares with Cargas's protest against cent, 6 times...
...VAILE SCOTT This sustained me through a time Are HMOs DOA...
...Visit our Web Site at www.SimonSays.com Commonweal 38 April 21, 2000...
...moral commitments...
...Let us recognize that all of Race and justice, us-from popes to peasants-are sin- July 1, 2000...
...But his prescriptions special care I received at Saint Francis for remedying the situation assume Hospital in Roslyn, New York...
...That's a nice town...
...ticles and topics prethe Church and women sented in the maga Catholics and Hollywood Correction Because of a zine...
...He did once point out, how- not have to wait until the 1930s to disthe Young Christian Workers...
...should be thought of as evange- clerical garb serves no missionary who nightly etherizes himself to sleep, lism...
...CHARLES FELT the rules restricting the taking of A severe looking priest up front Skokie, Ill...
...For additional information call 212-662at its most The writer is professor of philosophy at 4200 or write COMMONWEAL, 475 Riverthoughtful- Providence College...
...It may be, how- surgery when a Brother John greeted managerial dedication with moral ever, that the HMO disease is more me: "How about this: Here's an Old ideals in medical care, we also need "systemic" and is in fact DOA...
...Fundamental to being returns to the orphanage, he will not "Catholic" now is to welcome the perform abortions...
...The writer is professor emeritus of med- health-care resources, for prescription "The process isn't as bad as some may ical ethics and humanities at Northwest- drugs, long-term care, treatment of have told you...
...Discounts and monthIntellectual Tradition Waldheim...
...Hearing impaired and too proud to wear a hearing aid, I Answering the call to ministry can be could make out nothing...
...evangelizes ubiquitously through the Then there is Homer...
...evangelistic value...
...in health care should be understood GERALD P. COHEN, C.S.C...
...Our apologies...
...The seven to ten, twenty-something males in attendance were leaning on Answer the Call their folding chairs as far as gravity would allow...
...In beaches, helping to organize retail faces in drawing lessons from the the summer of 1955, I climbed the an- clerks, precinct work on behalf of can- Holocaust-including those drawn in tique stairs of Saint Clement's social didates-were ever Hillenbrand's Edward Gaffney's review of Harry center in Chicago in search of an 8 P.M...
...I will \ eston Jesuit School of Theology always be grateful for the synthesis of 3 Phillips Place, Dept...
...You live in Port ern University Medical School...
...Ii.1IEI,1N,:TO\ F:I.IY.1I;K'rIT Toll N,-N by Duffy against the pope's statement presentations, yoga, sharing, and music...
...Brother John just as management needs to respond health-care system to replace private said, "Of course we are," and I went to patient-oriented concerns, labor so-called insurance programs that re- upstairs with a lighter heart...
...Catholic ecumenical commitment I would venture that when Homer since Vatican II...
...F:I ,II II'' Mercy Center, Burlingame, CA 94010not the church itself, that have done 5540...
...The nurse did James L. Connor, S.J...
...human life, is about as perverse a rewas speaking very softly, only slightly louder than a confessional whisper...
...How to Heal not have to take time for me...
...ed that a special dynamic was operating between listeners and speaker...
...650-340-7480...
...Humanity did apostolate movement I had read about, process...
...You'll get in soon," she said...
...In principle, Hazard ought to purpose, especially in a culture that and eventually to death...
...will exchange mes Abortion and euthanasia That is what pilgrimage is all about...
...garb...
...Weston Jesuit School of Theology can The body language of the listeners, help you prepare for a life of ministry or the quiet intensity of the speaker, further your present ministry...
...The I' 11.1..1 f'.11 H K - 1% .11...
...Yes, I heard a John Irv- mat and writing always inspire...
...1011Y 1.1 I1 '.l'V .1.11'[]1'1...
...Clark E. for those who undergo one...
...that the ethical and moral symptoms are two examples: With respect to James L. Conner's he describes reflect a malady I was checking in at dawn for fine account of efforts to support amenable to healing...
...She stabs her fa- other Identity Crisis" should have inther and runs away...
...Weston Jesuit offers the following Later, as YCW section president, I degrees and programs: was privileged each week to prepare the social inquiry part of the meeting Master of Arts in Spiritual Direction (observe, judge, act) with "Monsign- Master of Divinity or" (as he was referred to by members Licentiate in Sacred Theology with a combination of respect and af- Master of Theological Studies fection), whenever weather (his suburban parish being some thirty miles WESTON Doctorate in Sacred Theology distant) or his health (migraines) per- Master of Theology mitted...
...We are all equally children of the church, members of the Mystical discussion In a collection of engaging and Body of Christ, and all of us sinners provocative essays culled from group defile that body...
...emphases...
...side Dr., Rm...
...throwing out the rule book, especially and the meeting was winding down...
...To join, simply And much more transcription error, the last phrase of Alvera M. Sams's letter (Cor- send an e-mail mesrespondence, March 24) was gar- sage to commonwealAvailable wherever bled...
...provision and just distribution of to talk...
...the plan, though it wasn't his idea...
...How "CAVE OF THE HEART," a contemplaLiberal Convictions, Catholic Traditions can a devotee of Chaucer feel other- tive seminar retreat June 6-11, 2000, is a wise when the liturgy recalls what the depth encounter with the spiritual tradiCF Ea .. C. r5 r FAOM church historically is-a parade of tion of India...
...Participants include Wayne COMMONWEAL Teasdale, Bo Lozoff, Judy Walters, Asha human beings fallible and peccable...
...Organized religion must work to in- feeling twitchy...
...Here of Jesus Christ...
...The group including gay rights ners very much in need of atonement...
...when I needed help...
...T F. K 1i 1:1[ I[ church is much more than the hierar'JII111I.I,YIEI-1JO\ 'EI.l'N 11'.11 [.]I chy...
...It should have read "alcohol hooks are sold subscribe@egroups.com and drug abuse [not use] prevenTOUCHSTONE tion programs...
...A young nurse JAMES F. BRESNAHAN, S.J...
...and controversial...
...Days will capture the rhythm of an ashram with meditation, MII'II.LE'I...
...I re- ment to care for the ill derives from alize this is an idiosyncratic, and pos- their non-Catholic or nonreligious (agsibly overly benign, interpretation of nostic or atheistic), but deeply held, the film, with which few will agree...
...What we need is a universal hope we are all one...
...catastrophic illness, and hospice pro- Washington...
...But he fails to consider the 16 cism, the politics of canonization, the age in which we live...
...W4 work and worship he gave me: my lab Theology Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138-3495 bench became my altar and my research the daily offering...
...it is all of us pilgrims, including popes, cardinals, archbishops, and On-line even permanent secretaries of the IN'11110111'I1,1110N 13" ' ti'f'F:lNI"I' I.ll curia...
...We can only guess...
...THE INSTITUTE OF SACRED MUSIC AT YALE UNIVERSITY A Cross-Disciplinary Center for Music, Liturgy and the Related Arts "Common ground for musicians and ministers, for scholars and practitioners" Degrees Offered through the Yale School of Music Master of Music c/a Artist Diploma Master of Musical Arts w' Doctor of Musical Arts Degrees Offered through Yale Divinity School Master of Arts in Religion cra Master of Divinity Master of Sacred Theology Joint Degrees and Double Majors are offered through the two schools...
...Providence, R.I...
...For the average infuriating blandness of NPR's "Fresh unchurched contemporary North To the Editors Air," " the good old days of the Young American, clerical or religious garb Christian Students, and, yes, even the observed in public places may be the Another take quality of "West Wing's" Catholicism...
...When he does terminate Rose's pregnancy, Homer be- Medical issues comes aware that abortion, in and of A few observations on your excellent itself, cannot secure a livable future issue of February 25...
...011,FitIII .,11:1:II ' 11 l0It'11II1' 11.11' .'I'1'_11i'i" 111'1FEI, But, to me, the censure meted out and Russill Paul...
...crease public support for the adequate walked past, then turned and started Chicago, Ill...
...405, New York, NY 10115...
...I was late ment was not social action...
...Discounts 5 percent, 3 times...
...not primarily in terms of "sectarian" Middletown, Conn...
...CORRESPONDENCE the deplorable state of Irish Catholi- be right...
...whom I learned later was Reynold Hillenbrand, would draw me back...
...the magazine that has bridged the The pope was expressing shame in gap between Catholic tradition his apology, for the offenses of the his- Commonweal is sponand American modernity, this torical church are very much the ofanthology explores some of the soring an e-mail disfenses against Holy Mother the century's most important ethical church, wounded as she is whenever cussion group until questions, includingwe fail her...
...His initial re- power and suggestibility of the visual fusal to perform an abortion, on the image...
...third eucharistic prayer that reminds colzg1FnoNuo Seminar Retreat us we are a pilgrim church on earth the C ] NTURY (ecclesia peregrinantem in terra...
...I was curious about a lay integrity of the observe, judge, act Holocaust [March 10...
...15 percent, 12 times...
...I replied, "Here I would unions of health-care workers that ble...
...She gave Managed Care," February 25] is onto Keep 'em Catholic more than duty called for...
...1.11.1'1"./f\ N. 1 [7111\\N..IK.evil, is based on a curial concept...
...Prizes in Organ Performance and Choral Conducting are available for qualified applicants...
...His reasons for not many participants (doctors, nurses, doing so now extend beyond the le- and other employees) whose commitgalities and personal queasiness...
...Then ask yourself again if it clear that he is a manipulative s.o.b...
...By coincidence, your arti- simists about the economic viability of cles underscored, in one way or an- Catholic health care should be reother, the major themes of many re- minded that it remains a fundamental cent curmudgeonly railings: the gift- form of witness to the healing mission edness of John XXIII's beatification, (Continued on page 36) Commonweal 4 April 21, 2000 CORRESPONDENCE health care is not a business in any Identity Crisis'] reminded me of the (Continued from page 4) traditional sense...
...Advance of the Catholic Pope John Paul II's meeting with Kurt payment required...
...He was always respectful of the James Cargas's Problems Unique to the meeting...
...dor waiting for an angiogram, and more compassionate care...
...Not to judge others is always wise RATES: $1.10 per word...
...grams...
Vol. 127 • April 2000 • No. 8
