Correspondence Seminarians, McDermott, Haught
Mount Saint Mary's seminarians swinging a thurible in a 180-degree [February...
...in the area of Church History...
...James Keating, Pontifi- 1010 11th Street, #200, Sacramento, CA cal College Josephinum, 7625 N. High St., 95814...
...Contemporary What Big Ears YOU HAVE...
...In short, Portier has yet to make his case...
...spiritual heritage...
...Mendel showed that every world in which not design (intelligent well question the intelligence, not to act of sexual reproduction is set up as or otherwise) but chance rules...
...Senior Vice President for Mission & Val- CHP is a large co-sponsored health sysQuality subsidy publisher accepting man- ues Integration...
...405, New York, NY 10115...
...Haught's theology will theology- And, as every good harvest La of theology's "special jargon," Pesch's Red Cusrchv also provides abundant seed for Riding Hood in thrnlogy includes thirteen help get us there...
...Essential readtime faculty position in its School of Theology in the area of Canon Law...
...discrepancies...
...mention the sanity, of the designer...
...Email: jkeating@pcj.edu proven track record for the development For additional information call 212-662- and implementation of programs, poli4200 or write COMMONWEAL, 475 River- CHP Seeks Senior VP cies, and process that enhance values inside Dr., Rm...
...CHARLES W. HEDRICK In fact, Behe and Dawkins have Hedrick explores the tension, or collision, that occurs when studying the Jesus of faith with much in common...
...They will want to change...
...have discovered fire...
...l'luardu f rralaid,-_ S.J...
...Deadline: April church at a deep level and will have a ly billing available for repeat advertisers...
...Protestant fundamentalism in particular, in spite of its claim to be scripturally based, accepts a world view far more indebted to the Enlightenment than it is to either the Bible or Keep the faith and the family...
...Despite changes Saint Meinrad School of Theology, St...
...Box 908, Louisville, KY 40201-0908, Phone: (888) 890-7865, Fax: (502) 635-3244, Website: www.fmeforg, Email: family@fmef.orgrequires an ingredient of order with the serendipity...
...I strongly agree that Haught puts it, into the "realm of an fy, not diminish...
...including resources Family Ministry: for children...
...JOHN F. HAUGHT Commonweal 44 March 10, 2000 Discovering fire model for being a parent...
...Over 3-300 entries ligent and modern" should not pre- by seventy• in tern arionat scholars offer historical- literary...
...church since the have been marked by such a belief- why it is especially fitted but, because dominant immigrant subculture of is true, we might well hope for it is, Catholics should be "investing Catholicism ended...
...OFFICEHOLDERS Such a set of images is not refuted CHRISTIANITY IN EARLY by evolutionary materialists who The Dynamics CHRISTIANITY of Religious Epigraphical and think we are a random result of Development literary Studies chemical and biological processes...
...tionary processes...
...The five co-sponBRIDGET MARY MEEHAN RETURNS porting to the CEO, the person will: sors include the Sisters of Mercy (Cincinto the land of her birth to give us an ex- nati and Dallas, Pa...
...studvir.i re lif:nn 559.95 • ISBN t-56563-458.6 • HARDCOVER • ]1DIUCA • REEEREtiCE JOHN F. O'CONNOR Winchester, Mass...
...I am convinced that our so- DICTIONARY OF JUDAISM IN THE BIBLICAL PERIOD ciety needs the perspective of those JACOB NEUSNER, EDITOR IN CHIEF...
...levels...
...Such a call to remembering while the contrary view claims that However, what we are discovering remains the most effective guarantee natural mechanisms (natural selec- about biology at the molecular level is that it will never happen again...
...Enlightenment, which has little in • :ir[it:r ..:i- ":a .. • •...a-!: r .:among different enters common with the Christian philo- S16.95 • ISBN 1-56563-235-.t • PAP FA • BIBtivut Sn owc sophical tradition or with the Hebrew Scriptures...
...Rather, molecular contributor, is professor of law at Valparaiso istic, mechanistic view of nature...
...The Candidate must be tem (assets $3.2 billion...
...before and during the immigrant era heedless of religious or humanitarian The seminarians in question have for as well, so it is not a new challenge...
...The Hebrew word for this is explain how the mechanism works...
...However, like many commenta- Pail and the Promise o f Abraham tors on the evolution-creation issue, JOHN L. WHITE Haught is hampered by a very old- 'In ruin aniil!;r •sri: y SVhite proposes char Paul believed in a creator god Who starredspirituat treads wirlr.Abnthunt trod comicued with the resurrected Christ...
...pe:surisplaces• and essential vocabulary from [he writings of Judaism, ranging from the u m e of the ues...
...Discounts and month- Columbus, Ohio 43235...
...Our concern to be "hip and intel- Pentateuch's final formation until the close of the Babvlonian Talmud...
...different images of God and related open and incalculable future...
...2l6 pp•• 6 x 9, $19,95 5898-9 Paper, 1l2 pp., 5'lie 8'1., 314.95 God as parent rl r'ai&able Mrry 2000 Af t'ailable June 2000 hctp:1rwwn"cac.lh,l•, iu,rcs.urtlJctaiLdrilUD=1899 htipalww "caui„e•!ig'tee;•nrglikuil.[ftiiiID=t89$.~ As its title suggests, John F. 7r1 Haught's "Evolution & God's Hu10...
...An age stripped of these some time been exploring this new Baptists and Methodists may be sur"transcendent" values might at least and more relevant way of being prised to hear Portier imply that diswork without hypocrisy...
...They are probably right that human "All who believe Linda M. Malonryc beings are the result of those evolu- that grace builds I ran ruaror...
...All faculty 328-6819, ext...
...Deadline: April 10, 2000...
...of science...
...perficial by nature and unrelated to either the gospel or the core doctrines of Catholicism-should be thought of Design Your Own Sabbatical as evangelism...
...have got it all wrong...
...expresutons• and experiences As a biologist studying evolution at stand at the heart o€ most religions in [he ancient Mediterranean world...
...Send a "Here's where we worship the sun...
...Even a For more information, contact: Family Ministry, nonmechanistic interpretation of life Louisville Seminary, P.O...
...If life pounded the truly radical and danger- ology has confirmed-is a biological is "intelligently designed," one might ous idea...
...ROBERT BEEZAT the Future'-Justo 1.• Cionzalez, Executive new "takes" on this classic Fable in the Glendale, Wis...
...important...
...Discounts 5 percent, 3 times...
...letter of interest, CV with references (ad- unuw.stthomas.edu/urww/CIS_http/index.html Commonweal 46 March 10, 2000...
...champions like William Dembski adteshuvah...
...touching the floor with one's The U.S...
...Eavan Boland...
...JOHN HAZARD Downers Grove, Ill...
...The author replies: Empowering Through We are the only Professor Hughes is correct in saying Faith is a Christian journal that offers that biology is still too often presentpublication reflecting hands-on wisdom ed in an obsolete mechanistic format, ecumenical and evangelical traditions in into the relationship between faith, congregations, Christianity...
...James Keating, Pontifical Selected candidate will understand the cent, 6 times...
...Awilabic fvin your rr!r~:7:rs 6r s',, i or Phone: 5450 and Haught's image of a God who fire: 5899 THE LITURGICAL PRESS E-mail,' ' eo °litpress.org embraces evolution strikes me, a fa- PO...
...a lottery...
...This old-fashioned co na rdr•uhb, , !its, sss rot,.' Sr:_vder, I':ofessr~r o_'-F...
...Linda A7 Maloney Science is understanding and har- "It is a harvest rr,u rnemog,.R t and Grain Kaplan, nessing the wind, and tides, etc...
...terestingly, "intelligent design" sources, a myriad of complex Rube CORRESPONDENCE (Continued from page 4) Although I have been annoyed by certain Catholic religious practices, I 1 ~ HENDRICKSON PUBLISHERS have never been inclined to abandon my faith...
...10, 2000...
...Like the God God...
...tegration and spirituality in a healthcare CATHOLIC HEALTHCARE PART- environment...
...Re- and contiguous states...
...Box 927, Wrightsville Beach, North godtalktv.org, or call 703-379-2487...
...This philosophy views na- Available at your bookstore or caU toll-&ee: 800-358-3111 ture as a mechanism, and the goal of Outside the U.S.: 978-532-6546 • E-mail: orders@hemdrickson.com Fax: 978-531-8146 both scientist and philosopher is to Commonweal 4 3 March 10, 2000 Goldberg-like ways of getting things evolution fit in well with the Enlight- in the twentieth century to work out done, and the accumulated residue of enment presuppositions of his vague- the population implications of past evolutionary dead ends...
...Even after Mendel and Kimura, however, I doubt that Family Ministry Empowering Through Faith we can plausibly go so far as to make life simply a matter of chance...
...Continued on page 43) Commonweal 4 March 10, 2000 is sinful...
...Manuscripts Wanted NERS (CHP), Cincinnati, Ohio, seeks a BECOME A PUBLISHED AUTHOR...
...Avenal State Prison, Avenal, CA...
...THE PONTIFICAL COLLEGE JOSEPHI- 1. DIOCESE OF FRESNO, Central CaliNUM invites applications for a full-time • Provide leadership and direction on fornia Women's Prison, Chowchilla, faculty position in its School of Theology Catholic identity issues...
...WILLIAM SCOTT GREEN, EDITOR who reflect traditional Catholic val- This invaluable re€erenec-defines eoncepts• religious practices, theolagi:al ter•r.n...
...religious...
...lV'illiaor W it teianer...
...church now finds itself in head during Mass...
...However, I feel called, as their "own internal coherence intensiGod's Humility...
...It was not the ("God does not throw dice"), God First, the Mendelian-Kimuran revoluagnostic Darwin who had the "dan- does indeed throw dice at every fertil- tion can be beneficial in breaking the gerous idea" in nineteenth-century bi- ization...
...levels...
...Holocaust...
...To dernansrrate his thesis fashioned view of evolutionary biolo- Whrte ns ludes extertsiusm discuss ran of the Greco-Roman ruler calr and its impact on the readers gy, essentially that of the premolecu- of Paul's betters...
...JESUS THE SEER Tire Progress of Prophecy BEN WITHERINGTON III Throwing dice Increasingly scholars are realizing that prophetic traditions...
...The theistic approach holds that cer- duce as incontrovertible evidence of This book is Harry Cargas's last...
...As Haught suggests, a theology that is genuinely scriptural can accommodate itself easily to a God who is no watchmaker...
...an exceptional individual to provide lead- associates, 7,850 affiliated physicians) servership to help the System creatively and ing the health needs of people in Indiana, In Quest of the Celtic Soul effectively weave the values of CHP into Kentucky, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, organizational patterns and processes...
...community and family...
...e-mail spiritual care services for integration Carolina 28480...
...quired...
...pressions of their ancestors' type of Portier supports this reading with religious witness...
...1 mility" seems to be as much about our image of God as about Darwin's theories...
...312 pp., 6 x 9. 549.95 said, "The day will come when after h,y,h..,;.,,,luk]i.q,r,•s,.~n ~clrtail.cfenP10=1931 Arvailrhlr:Ll,a y?000 harnessing space, the winds, the 'I IT] ID =l]5 LA COSECHA tides, and gravitation, we shall har- Harvesting W€WI— BIG EARS ness for God the energies of love...
...As a parent, I am grateful for allow pain, suffering, and evil...
...If Christianity "especially fitted to mod- Historians no doubt will agree that Pfaff's assertion-that more than ern social and cultural conditions, es- pluralism has been part of the envitwenty centuries of Western history pecially pluralism...
...Rather, it was Mendelian genetics...
...We are not told ronment of the U.S...
...31,600 employee uscripts...
...on human nature Preface by Gary Mary But that is all they can and should should take this A scholarly book seriously, "-Daniel J. Harringcon...
...Please send resume to Blair Associates, For more information visit the Web site: • Provide leadership and direction to P.O...
...F-1 tion) are at least in principle sufficient that organisms are far from the wellto explain all aspects of life...
...And Catholics may Back to the Mount examples of the seminarians' evangel- wonder why any kind of garb, posLet me see if I correctly understand ical behavior: wearing a Roman col- ture, or gesture-all of which are suWilliam L. Portier's defense of the lar...
...wearing a cassock and surplice...
...Box 7500, Co IIegcvillc, MN 5(1321-75011 Order online: •.Iitpress.org ther of college-age children, as a Commonweal 45 March 10, 2000 C L ASS I F I E D RATES: $1.10 per word...
...The nature S•J...
...Ideas Haught describes, I must concede to this God's example...
...Personally, I don't think so...
...ues into the overall functioning of the system...
...Beginning date: September, 2000...
...Director, Hispanic Theological Institute language oFall th- fields of t 11 cc logy...
...Subscribe today...
...fax: 910-256-5782...
...members are expected to support the Center for Irish Studies, University of teaching of Pastores Dabo Vobis and the Saint Thomas, 2115 Sununit Ave (#5008C) Program for Priestly Formation...
...of a relational God of compassionate my progeny their "own autonomous TIM REULAND love, who is with us but separate principles of operation," and release Aurora, Ill from us and is calling all of creation to a vision and a future that we all participate in creating, provide a NEW TITLES SPRING 2000 hopeful and invigorating set of images of God, of creation, and of us as THE CULTIC WOMEN llr["raa .ii fl ORIGINS OF human beings...
...The church must nessed...
...Contrary to Einstein's fa- Does this pose a problem for theolAs usual, the historians of ideas mous objection to the quantum theory ogy...
...propriety...
...Primary duties are the teaching and for- This position requires outstanding commation of seminarians for the Catholic munication skills and the ability to inspire Qualified applicants include priests, men priesthood at the M.Div and M.A...
...Center & Clinic, Norwalk, CA...
...e-mail: sofiabmm@aol.com into overall healthcare services...
...blairassoc@aol.com • Provide leadership in ethical education Full-Time Faculty Position and the development of ethical dialog Full-Time Catholic Chaplains throughout the system...
...2-5662...
...This last, by the way, is Without religion recent dissolution of the Catholic im- "an act of piety...
...Mount Saint Mary's seminarians swinging a thurible in a 180-degree [February 11]: arc...
...The period is stained in significantly in dramatic forms of reli- add, however, that pluralism was a blood...
...mum...
...Leaders of every stripe have gious witness that go beyond the ex- factor in the church's environment demonstrated a thirst for power, ample of a good life in the world...
...investigation of the evidence for women say about human beings...
...Images of God can invite CALL FOR A FRF.F_ CATALOG...
...The'Fheologians' in the history of the world, we shall Hispanic Theology Red Riding Hood (1968-1998) Otto llerrnaun Pesch...
...Meinrad, IN 47577 in the church and the modernization (800) 730-9910, FAX: (812) 357-6977 of religious practices, the defection of e-mail: ce(a-)saintmeinrad.edu Web site: www.saintmeinrad.edu/ce/sabbatic.htm youth, and others, continues...
...and that theological encounters with evolution are therefore hampered by having to deal with this version...
...Presumably, therefore, the thoughtful commentary ["Lonely respond to this new challenge by other activities are as well...
...Email: jkeating@pcj.edu Irish Studies READ NEW HIBERNIA REVIEW, Full-Time Faculty Position a quarterly journal presenting essays on THE PONTIFICAL COLLEGE JOSE- Irish writing, history, art, and politics, new PHINUM invites applications for a full- poems and memoirs by Irish writers, book reviews and much more...
...Sisters of the Hutraordinary view of the faith, myths, and • Provide leadership to regional mission mility of Mary, the Franciscan Sisters of celebrations of Ireland that are part of its executives for the integration of val- the Poor, and Covenant Health Systems...
...Emeritus, ChicagcTheoiogical Setnmary view is perpetuated by popular writ- 524.95 • ISBN 1-56563-283-4 • CLOTH • New TisTAmEAT • THEOLOGY ers like Richard Dawkins and is imWHEN HISTORY AND FAITH COLLIDE plicitly accepted by many anti-evoluStudying Jesus tionary writers such as Michael Behe...
...5896.2 Paper...
...What their modtion seems to proceed not by design the Catholic Gregor Mendel who pro- els predicted-and what molecular bibut by chance and serendipity...
...Withertngron looks at the broader expression o€ prophecy in its ancient Mediterranean conre.a[ in an attempt to better understand biblical Haught's comments on Darwinism prophecy in rh;!: evII as !itr hr p:lt-tu...
...15 percent, 12 times...
...reflection on how we live our lives, 5l,i;0sg iu addiria+ral...
...as well as Paui himself Wit rtes asserrron .. will uridoubledly stimulate lar era in biology...
...ly translate into poorer behavior...
...CA...
...intended to be witI'd like to respond to William Pfaff's migrant subculture...
...Darwin's mechanistic view of and, most importantly, Motoo Kimura ophy on the creation-evolution issue...
...saying grace beTo the Editors a pluralistic society, a situation that fore meals individually instead of as a came about only after the relatively community...
...There, When loving a young adult, the theologies are necessary for us not as Haught says about God's work, "intelligent designer" risks being only to deal with scientific discover- my children stand "ontologically dis- self-serving and less the effective ies and realities, but also to deal with tinct" from me and not as "a simple lover Haught calls our "humble age-old questions of how God can extension" of me...
...Catholic, and that's why we should tinctive garb and intentionally ostenROBERT HANNON not think of them as conservatives or tatious devotionalism are modern exFairbanks, Alaska fugitives from the world...
...It was left for Sewall Wright stranglehold of Enlightenment philosology...
...of Hurts and theology ["Evolution and God's $29-95 • ISBN 1.56553.344-x • Ci-on - BisllCAL Smoiss • PROPHECY Humility," January 28] of great inter- THE APOSTLE OF GOD est...
...An advanced de- and women religious or lay persons with appropriate background and skills...
...Evolu- ly theistic precursors...
...the Christian tradition...
...Advance College Josephinum, 7625 N. High St., ethical, moral, and social teachings of the payment required...
...Primary du- ing insights into the legend and reality of ties are the teaching and formation of Irish culture...
...10 per- scripts to: Dr...
...In- biology reveals a colossal waste of reLaw School in Valparaiso, Indiana...
...1-800-695-9599...
...also 5-plus years Catholic health- ences to: Catholic Chaplain Search Comences (address and phone), and graduate mittee, California Catholic Conference, transcripts to: Dr...
...This is no less true the molecular level, I found John F. For the world o€ Judaism and Jesus...
...Both designed machines assumed by both Edward McGlynn Gaffney, Jr., a frequent sides assume an essentially determin- Behe and Dawkins...
...them "into the realm of liberty," I am always glad to get my Common- As a parent of emerging adults, I where they become "more and more weal magazine and particularly en- lack the control of an "intelligent de- independent," and where I watch joyed John Haught's "Evolution & signer...
...While it adopting a new approach to engaging case, this list is Portier's proof that the may be true that a significant decline the world, namely evangelical wit- seminarians are in the vanguard of a or even absence of belief in a divine ness of the sort pioneered by Ameri- new Catholicism, one more approprimaster marks our age, I'm not certain can Baptists and Methodists in the ate to engaging our surrounding, pluwe can assume that will automatical- nineteenth century...
...and influence people...
...and identifies the essential issues sophical framework dating from the or, Fronrutg the reader nF the Nets Tesr.menr Cnsnel iccnunts of Jesus...
...My :• resources for personal study reflection and prayer generation and others with a Catholic or writing •:• Benedictine hospitality college education shared her antipa:• on-line computer access thy to the religious mannerisms so well described in her article and in her For more information, contact: Office of Continuing Education novel, Charming Billy...
...Alice McDermott's "Confessions of a Reluctant Catholic" [February 11] is flexible duration spiritual direction and an excellent portrayal of the changes in her outlook and practice of Catholiroom with private bath personal counseling available cism during the changes in the :• courses for credit or audit •:• peaceful environment for Catholic church in recent decades...
...Columbus, OH 43235...
...S f. 1!:e h: Evince...
...Teilhard de Chardin once Available May 000 5950-0 Paper...
...and archaeological clude us from distinguishing between background for understanding the canonical form of she Bible• the texts of the Second Temple period, and the classical writings of rabbinic Judaism It has few rivals when it superficial religious practices and the comes to acntracy and readability, and it will be an indispensabe resource for anyone priceless values of our heritage...
...It is in which Eduardo Red Riding Hood 1 rrr,islrtars up to all of us as human beings to Fernandez masterfiilly VVrirren in an nr: :~;1 ,.,•, harness for God the energies of love collects that which amusing style and continue to truly bring about a is of cram value and significance in our chat makes fight new creation...
...counselor, social congregations and AUSTIN L. HUGHES worker or lay church communities, review Columbia, S.C leader, keeping up books and provide The author is professor of biological with family life and information for sciences at the University of South Carministry is family ministry, olina...
...Begin- ing for those drawn to new and fascinatning date: September, 2000...
...Saint Paul, MN 55105-1096...
...We tain aspects of the living world (in divine creation the very same facts will all miss his clarion voice stirring Behe's view, cellular biochemistry) that certain biologists cite as evidence our consciences and continuously urg- are so complex that no natural mech- for the ubiquitous working of natural ing us never to forget the events of the anism can account for their origin, selection...
...And on that day, for the second time United States You Have...
...In any New World," January 28...
...Subscripseminarians for the Catholic priesthood tions: $35 year (US), VISA, M/C : 1-800at the M.Div and M.A...
...Wesron Jesuit School of Theo!op, holding offices of authority in the first of our destiny is not within the scope 50-6-7 Paper, 296 pp- 6 •r 9, $27"95 several centuries of C:hrisrianity...
...r In addition, it is important to keep in mind the distinction, well known to Catholic philosophy since Aquinas, between natural science and philosophy-a distinction ignored both by atheistic evolutionists who think that evolution "disproves" the existence of God and by the "intelligent design" school who think that divine design If you're a pastor, We profile family educator, ministries in can be a testable scientific hypothesis...
...If you All faculty members are expected to sup- gree in theology or religious studies, are interested in this special ministry port the teaching of Pastores Dabo Vobis ethics, organizational development, spirand the Program for Priestly Formation...
...Let Saint Meinrad help you plan a Charming Alice sabbatical to meet your needs...
...ituality, education or a related discipline is please send your resume and three referSend a letter of interest, CV with refer- required...
...A doctor- • Maintain dual line responsibility for the 2. ARCHDIOCESE OF LOS ANGELES, ate, or one very near completion, is re- oversight of the mission/values posi- Southern Youth Correction Reception tion in each Region...
...12-word mini- dress and phone , and graduate tran- care experience in a leadership position...
...They share a philo- the critical eye of historical scholarship He outlines the nature of historical inquiry, gives a brief history of how scholars have understood Jesus...
...In fact, the theological objections to Dawkins or Behe have to do not with science but with the confining metaphysical assumptions underlying much of science...
...This is a form of ralistic culture...
Vol. 127 • March 2000 • No. 5
