Correspondence: Dully again, Egan, Courage & more
Duffy's wrong out to dismiss all these attacks on I enjoyed reading Garry Wills's Pius...
...It is much like being of the opinion that the sun rises in the west...
...RAYMOND H. HOFFMAN up with four centuries earlier...
...paschal basis for a theology of mar- policy has allowed the killing of mil- expressing his deep passion for lay riage, one that I hope the author will lions of unborn children in America, preaching in the pages of Commonweal continue developing to our further en- mostly for reasons of convenience...
...read his book, Saints and Sinners: A the Crusades or the Inquisition are NELSON WHITAKER History of the Popes...
...Why is Duffy is soft on the papacy should ly criticize the deeds done during it promulgated now...
...Timothy...
...3. Date of filing: September 11, 2000...
...From my vantage point, version one of history is a version that, whatever its other merits, does not take history seriously...
...JOHN W. O'MALLEY, S.J...
...every Christian marriage there is an unromantic, day-to-day "dying" that Share the adventures of Maryknoll Missioners in distant lands leads to eventual "rising," after the Baguio, Philippines...
...income tax purposes have not changed during the 'F 11.1..1 `A'I' HER a "1 1.'r E: H 1i 0 R it preceding 12 months...
...Editor, Margaret O'Brien Steinfels, 475 Riverside Drive, Room 405, New they offer, and what a gift it is to our C (IDdV 1C 1iF O .!i O York, New York 10115...
...WALT BUESCHER that Wills's opinions are to be disrePewaukee, Wisc...
...N If Cunningham wants to write a book about the theology of martyrdom, I will be one of the first interested in reading it...
...not just holy people but also martyrs...
...tensive formation and training pro5. No...
...IA 02138-3495 • Telephone (617) 492.1960 • Fax (517) 492-5833 if they do, it is worded so carefully that they can easily retract it...
...Discounts and month(2) Mail subscriptions: 17,452 18,450 ly billing available for repeat advertisers...
...That Central America solidarity movement...
...and controversial...
...TRISH SULLIVAN VANNI Jordan, 475 Riverside Drive, Room 405, New York, the CENTURY New York 10115...
...Your readers may want to know 75 years 2. Publication number: 0010-3330...
...WINTHROP P. WILCOX JR., M.D...
...Lord Jesus...
...I can hardly imagine a more like telling someone what a wonderful Edgardo Mortara from his Jewish judicious assessment in just a few house you have and showing a brick parents because he had been invol- paragraphs of the two ways of dealas evidence...
...Another version quotes reminds one of Dr...
...Now that everybody can talk, I keep worrying about what people will say...
...September 8...
...But can Reply: Glad you asked...
...Indeed, one is entitled to one's opinion, although why one would espouse a view that is contrary to fact is very puzzling...
...Phnom Penh, Cambodia...
...Known bondholders, mortgagees and other security ?MIf'1I.'EI...
...They Retrieves the spirituality of the saints and scholars who made the Celtic lands a lamp of learning and holiness...
...garded because Wills is guilty of Stay tuned "presentism" (judging the deeds of When will Commonweal address the Duffy's right the past by the standards of the pre- recent Vatican pronouncement Eamon Duffy's letter [September 81 sent...
...I won't give away the you make the same charge when the October 20 will tell you more than ending...
...social activities, all in a community of friendship and Just a politician faith...
...through a mzi o, f does not claim to provide professional leisure, refection, therapy for those of its members who wish to seek such help...
...Easy weal editors follow the lock-step access to events in Washington, DC Some media spinners in lauding Senator financial assistance, Joseph Lieberman as a man who AT THE WASHINGTON TtIEOLOGHCAL "does not hesitate to shape his public UNION, today -s ministers renew life by the light of his religious faith," themselves for the church of tomorrow...
...Father Harvey study...
...II"INHIN(:TI)N' 0I.1C.1110T11 .1(111NF(1N holders owning or holding 1 percent or more of Shorter letters (those under total amount of bonds, mortgages or other 300 words) have a greater 1).]N!F:I...
...Kusatsu, Japan .. . Christ can make husband and wife Nairobi, Kenya...
...Peru...
...questions, including: C. Total paid circulation: 18,865 19,973 D. Free distribution by mail For additional information call 212-662• Race and justice, (sample, complimentary, 4200 or write COMMONWEAL, 475 Riverincluding gay rights and other free copies): 920 920 side Dr., Rm...
...If the conversation on "the two versions" should go forward, I might have to get serious about my discipline...
...The purpose, function and nonprofit status of this chance of publication lOIIN I.1 0. Ck '.11, 01"5:~?I011r.1[?' - I...
...JOHN F. DESMOND I want to express a simple, heartfelt Senator Lieberman is running on a Walla Walla, Wash...
...No one really knows, but it cide...
...Doesn't work for Shake- untarily baptized when an infant, ing with the church as a historical speare...
...The theologian who did most to formulate an Timothy...
...Senator Lieberman is, first and fore- in the context of the article, some DENNIS FERRARA most, a politician...
...copies printed gap between Catholic tradition (Net Press Run): 21,182 22,675 RATES: $1.10 per word...
...to edit letters submitted THHUM-%, HKk''ON' F...
...Shinvanga, Tanzania...
...PRoGILL1t myself to live chastely...
...Metangula, Mozambique...
...would seem to indicate that many reality "in the modern world...
...The editors reserve the right 13...
...DC 2001 and whose "example of religious faith C7ell: Ktx}.334.9922, ext...
...11,1 N 0',51'011 14...
...that there is a ministry that specificalof the Catholic 4. Frequency of issue: published biweekly except ly supports lay preaching with an inChristmas, New Year's and monthly July and Intellectual Tradition August...
...books are sold J. Percent paid and/or Twenty-minute papers or 350-word abrequested circulation: 95.3% 95.5% stracts by December 1, 2000 to Brennan ~~ TOUCHSTONE I certify that the statements made by me above are O'Donnell, Department of English, Loycorrect and complete...
...an inspiration to us all" is to make a doing at the Leaven Center to help travesty of the notion of deep reli- people deepen their understanding of More on Courage In his response to the letters of Fathers Lloyd and Harvey [September 8], Shawn Zeller claims that critics such as Father Peter Liuzzi are "entitled to their views" that Courage offers reparative therapy...
...The greatest calamity in the aftermath Catholicism...
...He showed that in the way you see our world...
...view in Commonweal [July 141 was While we may come to understand Why so long...
...Bishop Fulton Sheen would characterize this life as white martyrdom, Tune in every namely, the unromantic, day-to-day, Friday, Oct...
...To claim that he is readers may think that the work we're Washington, D.C...
...Our issue of corpse on trial...
...GINO DALPIAZ, C.S...
...days of reflection...
...It is Partners in Preaching, Inc., at its most 6. Annual subscription price: $44...
...regular spiritual direction...
...lamenting that my history was not a Catholics killed for religious reasons in Yes...
...acts criticized took place only a hun- you ever wanted to know...
...Is torians are about...
...It LEO GAFNEY people at the time saw this as an evil gets at the heart of the great cultural Lakeville, Conn...
...I am very curious to know why since it has re- stretches, ceived the endorsement of the Pontifical Council for the Family and has reinvigorates helped thousands of individuals like THE WASHINGTON THEoI.OGicm...
...Joyce CELTIC CHRISTIANITY Gaining weight A Sacred Tradition, A Vision of Hope After months and months of rather 'Conveys the unique• blend of earthy simplicity and mystic light-weight issues, the issue of Sep- complexity cal the (alts...
...But why Pio Nono did what he did, no Re: "Beatifying John XXIII" [August when I read the exchange of letters amount of rationalization can turn 111...
...John XXIII was a great pope as between Wills and Duffy in your this into an act of virtue, especially popes go, but his reforms were only September 8 issue, I found myself when done by a pope...
...Notice: 11...
...Managing Editor, Patrick church...
...Thank you, Doctor...
...pattern of the dying and rising of the Bangkok, Thailand...
...Normally, this is a charge that Dominus Jesus...
...ing, which it does not...
...Martyrdom of marriage Richard Gaillardetz's, "Learning from Marriage" [September 81 proved to Watch ...The Field Afar .. . me once and for all that Christian a fascinating 13-week series that will change marriage is a school of sanctity, indeed of heroism...
...Generally, those who active- it consonant with Vatican II...
...1-800-695-9599...
...Even the inquisitorial 1-57075-334-2 paper $12.00 bishops and curia officials granted Thomas O'Loughlin (see Leonard Swidler's Kung in Con- JOURNEYS ON THE EDGES flict) that he had written a virtual The Celtic Tradition summa...
...ROBERT ROYAL Washington, D.C...
...invited it...
...BILL F. MAZZELLA 1-57075-316-4 paper $16.00 Yonkers, N.Y...
...Myers wants palWESTON JESUIT School of Theology pable decent social order-Denmark, I think, or Switzerland, as we imagine A Course of Action them...
...KAREN TAI offers a choice of certificates, classes with distinguished pastoral New York, N.Y...
...Nor have A Healing Journey for Irish Catholics they built upon his work (and pub- Shows how the ancient traditions of Celtic Christianity offer hope lishing in remote theological journals for a contemporary, life-giving spirituality...
...8. Location of the headquarters of general business site is www.partnersinpreaching.org...
...The Vatican has received thirteen almost entirely unaware of this bloody thousand (not eight thousand, as Cun- history, there is an enormous amount Hidden history ningham claims) names forwarded of work to be done-my book repeatI am grateful for Lawrence Cunning- from dioceses around the world of edly describes itself as no more than ham's generally favorable review people who were martyred or are at the barest beginning-just to recover the empirical record...
...I have fun, I sometimes tell my colleagues, teaching church history because in relationship to official Catholic pronouncements these days it seems to be an utterly irrelevant subject...
...Johnson's The wave of outrage that swept Congratulations on Robert J. Egan's comment that trying to capture the through Western Europe and the "Two Versions of History" [Septemspirit of Shakespeare with a quote is United States when Pius IX took ber 8...
...ffovizons tember 8 is terribly well done...
...offices of the publishers: 475 Riverside Drive, Room As a graduate of Partners in PreachEOITED BY PATOICK JORDAN AND PAUL BAUMANN 405, New York, New York 10115...
...doesn't work for Newman...
...Discounts 5 percent, 3 times...
...Catholics and non-Catholics alike are Lancaster, Pa...
...5216 Phaur 202.'26.ti?W,ext...
...Please get more conversation theoretical reflection on current the twentieth century...
...None For information please write or call: Office of Admissions • 3 Phillips Place, Dept...
...doesn't do it...
...Come for an academic year or a single semester...
...l'1 of those theologians takes a stand, or Cambridge...
...Continued on page 27) Commonweal 4 October 6, 2000 trade, and wealth, everything is out of its cage in America...
...Courage has simply provided me with spiritual and moral support in my efforts to live chastely...
...Oaxaca, Mexico...
...includes especially those theologians Lee converts to Ro n Catholicism...
...Dark, Panama...
...Extent and nature of Average Actual for publication circulation number number lN't'12C111t'C'I'ION RY PR CK'l'A;tNF•IdLF1 of copies of copies for sense or clarity...
...I was disheartened to see the Common- Attractive on-site housing...
...12...
...tury: A Comprehensive World History...
...Pilcuvo...
...Garry Wills's effort to capture New- dred years ago...
...among the more reasoned...
...Peru...
...If fully lived, marriage in Sherpur, Bangladesh...
...graduate Gerry Lee surrendered the teaching office of the meets returned missionaries with church to the curial inquisition...
...I very much agree with Egan that a public conversation about this history needs to be initiated now...
...THE SPIRITUALITY OF THE CELTIC SAINTS They deserve Ex corde ecclesiae...
...Their Web 10115...
...8 - Dec...
...E. Free distribution outside • Abortion and euthanasia the mail (carriers or other means): 20 20 Manuscripts Wanted • Issues of faith, Catholicism F. Total free distribution and Protestantism, (sum of D and E): 940 940 BECOME A PUBLISHED AUTHOR...
...innocents...
...6 - Dec...
...This I was delighted to find Bill Simon Jr...
...1" I]R)NN...
...Advance century's most important ethical vendors and counter sales: 1,414 1,523 payment required...
...It rings profound- kill unborn children, including the Praise where it's due ly true and lays a truly Christian, horror of partial-term abortions...
...ola College in Maryland, Baltimore, MaryVisit our Web Site at www.SimonSays.com Paul Q. Kane, Business Manager land 21210-2699 / bodonnell@loyola.edu...
...How many are willing to AFAR Maryknoll Missioners • Maryknoll, NY 10545 pay it...
...Anyone who thinks cheers...
...Stone Park, Ill Commonweal 2 8 October 6, 2000 Doctor's prescription rary political life is an inspiration to gious conviction and the cost of folAs a married theologian with children, us all" [September 81...
...Publication title: COMMONWEAL...
...For information, visit the Odyssey Network website at But in his description of Christian www.odysseychannel.com or call your local cable television company or married life, Gaillardetz writes enthe Odyssey Network toll free at 1-800-522-5131 gam-5pm Pacific Time couragingly and enthusiastically, FIELD Maryknoll's Mission of Hope and Healing showing that it can be liberating, uplifting, and sanctifying...
...part of those that Martin Luther came disappointed...
...I also read a half-dozen or believe there are certain deeds, To the Editors so reviews of it...
...Cambridge, Mass...
...e ( iirber, 1985 CORRESPONDENCE June, 1973 Lay Mialioner Lee helps (Continued from page 4) Working with street kids establish Church's first on the Lower East Side, human rights or ation Kung's children Lee encounters in Tacagus, a Ca slum...
...Available wherever and H2): 21,182 22,675 March 30-April 1, 2001, Loyola College...
...yes" to Richard Gaillardetz's "Learn- platform that supports the "right" to ing from Marriage...
...Duffy's wrong out to dismiss all these attacks on I enjoyed reading Garry Wills's Pius as "anti-Catholic hysteria...
...But there's a ~,1~ Pr~xh ccd by Man knoll 11'orld Pi cxluctions and Hispanic TcleconlnInicaaLtlns Networkprice to it...
...1R" organization and the exempt status for Federal than longer letters...
...has repeatedly said this on television, in his books, and in speeches...
...Issue date of circulation data below: 9/22/00...
...Indeed he had, and was Focusing on cite major theme, of the Celtic tradition, O'Loughlin dcmonstttltc:s the power and mystery of the Celtic -spiritual tradition.shamelessly left by theologians to 1-57075-337-7 paper $14.00 stand alone...
...the Church and women G. Total distribution: Quality subsidy publisher accepting man(sum of C and F): 19,805 20,913 • H. Copies not distributed: uscripts...
...Catholics and Hollywood (1) Office use, leftovers, • And much more spoiled: 550 550 (2) Returns from news Conference agents: 827 1,212 I. Total (sum of G, Hl, THE WORK OF ANDRE DUBUS...
...UNIONS SaaBaTICai...
...who comprise the so-called "alternative narrative" according to Robert August, 1975 Oscar Ruiz, a child streets, Egan's "Two Versions of History...
...Joyce alternative narrative, Hans Kung, was CELTIC QUEST never supported by them...
...I keep muttering to myself, [September 22] of my book The least candidates to be declared mar"Beatify 'em all, and let God de- Catholic Martyrs of the Twentieth Cen- tyrs...
...9. Names and addresses of publisher, editor, and ing, and as a member of a community managing editor: Publisher, Commonweal that has called lay preachers, I know Foundation, 475 Riverside Drive, Room 405, New firsthand what a remarkable program COMM•NWEAL York, New York 10115...
...l•:IL1..]!I.]N - JEAN 13KI EX,: EI.S11T.51N securities: None...
...theologians, a range of workshops...
...10 per(1) Sales through dealers anthology explores some of the and carriers, street cent, 6 times...
...Lima...
...This Photos 1.57075.176.5 paper $14.00 Lutheran really perked up...
...7. Location of known office of publication: 475 which is working in fifteen dioceses thoughtful - Riverside Drive, Room 405, New York, New York throughout the country...
...The simple truth is that Courage...
...But these countries are not creatGerrv Lee • Class of 1978 • Master of Divi ' ing 20 million jobs in a decade, or taking in 10 million immigrants and starting them up the ladder...
...O April, 1991 Lee helps expose the Neil Coughlan, a regular contributor, is the government's torture and execution of author of Young John Dewey...
...meanings of martydom...
...12-word miniand American modernity, this B. Paid Circulation: mum...
...would not be a wild guess to believe Father Egan's "Continuing the But I am more than a little puzzled that this figure only represents around Conversation" pretty well recapitulat- why he chose to spend so much space 1 percent of the overall body count of ed Duffy's take on the whole thing...
...405, New York, NY 10115...
...Owner (if owned by a corporation, its name and The writer is director of the Leaven Liberal Convictions, Catholic Traditions address must be stated and also immediately thereunder the names and addresses of Center...
...REV...
...each issue of a single during issue In a collection of engaging and preceding published provocative essays culled from 12 months nearest to filing date C L ASS I F 1 E 0 the magazine that has bridged the A. Total no...
...Kung rightly states now that their refusal to back him has Richard J. Woods brought them to the current situation...
...of issues published annually: 22...
...Having At your bookseller or direct read about the popes in Eamon 30 Years of ORBIS BOOKS Duffy's Saints and Sinners: A History of Books that matter Maryknoll, NY 10545 1-800-258-5838 the Popes, I was a little incredulous www.orbisbooks.com that Pius IX was on the beatification Commonweal 2 7 October 6, 2000 schedule...
...I think it would be a giant cop- divide in Catholicism today...
...rl Roman Culbolic ,5'rhool for .Llirti Irla:3hhalical [lftick, ' (18% 1auml 5treel• NW • Wishinglon...
...Is this document a was a classic mini-essay on what his- causes me to break out into loud step backwards for ecumenicism...
...15 percent, 12 times...
...5216 • Fax: 202.726.1716 • http:Hwwwww.edu lived out unabashedly in contempoCommonweal 2 9 October 6, 2000 Statement of Ownership, Management, and Circulation (act of August 12,1970: Section 3685, Title 39, baptism includes lay-preaching trainUnited States Code...
...Are our standards man's view of the papacy with two today that much different...
...prayer, play...
...I lei Papal Sin...
...Eamon Duffy's re- which, by their very nature are evil...
...As a member of Courage, I can testify that no one in Courage has ever forced me to undergo any form of reparative therapy...
...dies of gunshot wou' They submit the occasional article a la Egan but it is only descriptive...
...Commonweal 30 October 6, 2000...
...Given that going...
...Duffy argues almost exclusively New York, N.Y...
...lowing it...
...31, 2000 at 3:00 pm (EST/PST) Christian married life (Bishop Sheen would contrast this slow everyday Only on the 0 D Y S S E Y ®. Network white martyrdom to what he called the quick red martyrdom of blood...
...Msange, Tanzania...
...Celebrating 1. Title of publication: COMMONWEAL...
...15...
...But are the actual lives and deaths of so many faithful men and women all over the world more interesting as material for theological analysis or do they possess greater intrinsic interest than Cunningham seems to grant in themselves...
...there's the story about the pope who tism...
...CF Ea C. 7,5 1- stockholders owning or holding 1 percent or more T- CP4QMWiAL of total amount of stock): Commonweal Foundation, 475 Riverside Drive, Room 405, New '1I1.F•H11) So 0E1) • DO 11(7TFI]' I1"Il' • 011 .]HT In EIEli York, New York 10115...
...However, mentioned richment...
...For openers justifiably charged with "presen- Pittsburgh, Pa...
...According to Zeller, Liuzzi claims that Courage is banned from the Archdiocese of Los Angeles...
...October, 1978 of Vatican II is that theologians have Recent M. Div...
...Eden Prairie, Minn 10...
...after all, the acts in question exhumed his predecessor and put the were done centuries ago...
...gram...
...29, 2000 at 11:30 am (EST/PST) drop-by-drop ordeal of living the and every Sunday, Oct...
Vol. 127 • October 2000 • No. 17
