The Mysterious Flame
McGinn, Colin
gap between neurons and experiences." MIND...
...mind...
...Basic Boobs, S24,242 pp...
...Advise U.S...
...Discounts 5 percent, 3 times...
...12-word mini- quality and productivity...
...Eventually, describing how the advent of computsaying much...
...To put this anit with a strictly materialistic scientific other way, mind-body dualism is conhe nineties were to con- world-picture...
...itself difficult to believe...
...Write: DELTA cant diocesan or parish administrative ex- experience...
...A couple of days is thought about the world"-as if con- I retired four years ago after more later that student received her diploma sciousness and the world could be clean- than thirty years of teaching at South- from SWTSU and went into the world ly separated and studied apart from one west Texas State University...
...Need excellent communi- five years relevant experience...
...The problem with mate- ly, that we are "constitutionally unnot burdened by jargon, The Mysterious rialism is that "there is a deep logical equipped" to solve the mind-body probFlame is a fascinating read from begin- lem, "rather as the cat's mind is not up ning to end...
...McGinn does what the best to discovering relativity theory or evophilosophy has always done: make us lution by natural selection...
...glaston Parkway, Douglaston, New York Commonweal is sponsoring 11362-1997...
...but whether McGinn's view reveals extraordinary, and we pulsing, throb- ture of the nation, all the administrathe limits of human intelligence as it has bing beings-ashes from ashes-not a tion's attention went to faking the latevolved or the limitations of his own bad piece of work ourselves...
...We 3 graduate credits • Dr...
...with a track record of strong management Bishops on health care and welfare-reskills...
...but it is difficult to imagine that there is a mechanism, and so we a more pleasurable way of being initi- "can avoid being drawn into religious ated into the current debate about the mysticism about consciousness...
...Why not con- became the dime-a-dozen clerks Philosophy, in this light, is about com- clude, instead, that matter (whatever whose main function was to keep the ing to terms with our finitude...
...In this model the students were San Marcos, Tex...
...Here several questions 600 Forbes Ave...
...1967 as the vehicle for updating priests CATHOLIC VOLUNTEERS IN FLORIafter the Vatican II, the Institute has re- Benefactors Sought DA seeks full-time Executive Director...
...This notion leads McGinn to speculate, at the end of his book, that genetic engineering may offer us a way to over- Distance Learning Courses come the mind-body problem: that, if we could only produce a human being with Offered to Ministers Everywhere through DUQUESNE UNIVERSITY enough introspective power, we could Fall 2000 dispel the mystery of our nature and see that "deep down we are quite ordinary, Health Care Ethics (CD-ROM) difficult as that may be to believe...
...self-awareness...
...detail-oriented, yet able to On-line formation...
...David Kelly could, that is, become conscious of the Theology of Ministry (online through the World Wide Web) material genesis of consciousness...
...PhilosoM.I.T...
...dualists that McGinn's own solution to these probor, more precisely, how the brain gives "there is no possibility of reducing the lems, what he calls "naturalized mysterise to the mind...
...One senior student's enon the one hand, is the world with all its Wilton, Conn...
...ness," with statistics about the climbHe gives the latter possibility very little Bernard G. Prusak is a graduate student in ing rate of retention and graduation...
...Discounts and month- pation in long-range publishing planning...
...Diocesan Happy e-mailing...
...McGinn inwonder at how strange the world is...
...none went to thinking about the qualireader wonder whether he had some- ty of the product coming out of the how blocked out the past hundred years CORRESPONDENCE dumbed-down system that resulted...
...15 percent, 12 times...
...20017-1194...
...Fax: ence, 3211 Fourth Street, N.E., Washingboth the ongoing education and forma- 847-940-7031...
...Position available Salary $26,000-$30,000 and benefits...
...but the im- gained control of college administra- high schools, and now in our colleges portant question in philosophy is what is tions, and the watchword became to and universities...
...knowledge cation, organizational, planning, and in- of Catholic social teaching...
...tire answer was: "They could check objects and properties, existing inde- the computer [sic] work and see how pendently of us...
...The group Job Opening DEVELOPMENT...
...proval from their diocesan bishop or reliuscripts...
...its young people to achieve and learn...
...Even hi-tech instruments like The Mysterious Flame does mere meat turn itself into conscious PET scans," McGinn observes, "only Conscious Minds in a awareness...
...First, what does McGinn Pittsburgh, PA 15282 mean by introspective power...
...It also becomes question- they became fast friends, until Dad ers had changed the job of managers able when used to pretend that "there, died a year later...
...hiring and su- Catholic Conference, 3211 Fourth Street, mum...
...e-mail: resumes@ncpayment required...
...Advise U.S...
...Deadline: June 1, resources to achieve optimum editorial 2000...
...This book us because of the way our minds have may not tell you everything you wanted evolved, but the successes of science in to know about consciousness but were other fields give us reason to feel secure afraid to ask...
...Further and deeper, why Visit our Web site at UUQ UESNE would the upshot of knowing how mind http://www duq.edu/liberalarts/undertheology/index.html NIVERSITY arises from matter be able to convince Commonweal 2 9 May 19, 2000 C L ASS I F I E D RATES: $1.10 per word...
...Catholic exchanges messages dealing EDITORIAL DIRECTOR-Loyola Press, Bishops on international economic and with articles and topics prea growing Chicago textbook publisher, other foreign-policy issues...
...knowledge of Catholic social join, simply send an e-mail our instructional product lines (print and teaching...
...Catholic side Dr., Rm...
...Diocesan lay employees also Executive Director eration mail or fax resume, with salary re- require prior approval from the local bishDIOCESE OF BROOKLYN seeks an Ex- quirements, to our representative: Don op...
...done with such claims-what further operate every university "like a busi- ALFRED E. BORM claims they are used to support...
...here, on the other hand, Dumbed down correct it dones [sic...
...For consid- considered...
...Responsibilities include managing from the local bishop...
...tion of the clergy and the education and e-mail: resumes@nccbuscc.org EOE formation of lay ministers...
...developing and maintain- N.E., Washington, D.C...
...10 per- pervising staff...
...minimum Manuscripts Wanted ment is a plus...
...of debates over epistemology, logic, and How bad does it get...
...Maureen O'Brien McGinn presents this genetically engineered consciousness as only "a theo- For more information, contact: retical possibility," and qualifies it with Pastoral Ministry Program ethical qualms...
...ness...
...ment and support, service-site develop- Mississippi Delta mission...
...ly billing available for repeat advertisers...
...ton, D.C...
...In short, "the mechahere presents both the problems and his nism of consciousness is a mystery" to positions in a popular idiom...
...Office of ecutive Director for its Pastoral Institute...
...This posi- request written approval from their dioce- subscribe@egroups.com tion works with content specialists and san bishop or religious superior before marketing to guide editorial development application can be considered...
...Similarly questionable is was a witness to the inception of the It is hard to be very optimistic McGinn's claim that "I form my concepts system described in Paul Trout's arti- about the future of a nation that of consciousness through examining my cle ["Teacher Evaluations," April 211, chooses to squander the potential of own inner states, that is, through acts of and its disastrous consequences...
...Master's preferred...
...3 graduate credits • Dr...
...Requirements: Bachelor's terfaith partnerships, and tutor potential better in an appropriate discipline, signifi- degree, one year lay volunteer/mission high school dropouts...
...matter finally "is," composed as it is of customers happy, as indicated on their This is a noble conception of philoso- particles, waves, and force fields) is quite evaluations...
...mind, as it is called, is on the whole res- He thinks of what he is doing as "proolutely naturalistic, which may be why viding a map of human knowledge and it is little represented at Catholic uni- its limitations," and bringing us to recversities but thrives at institutions like ognize "our cognitive limits...
...TONY WIGGINS in business...
...He has written several uralistic worldview, even if necessarily technical treatments of this topic but beyond its ken...
...Materialists argue that "there is and mind...
...Founded in Executive Director M/F/D/V...
...another...
...Catholic ConferThe Pastoral Institute is responsible for bridge Lane, Lincolnshire, IL 60069...
...terpersonal skills, with sound PC literacy gious candidates must request written apQuality subsidy publisher accepting man- (WORD, Excel) and a creative attitude...
...If sex was on the brain then, more re- nothing more to the mind than the brain Most of The Mysterious Flame presents cently the hot topic has been "mind"- as currently conceived...
...McGinn wants Commonweal 2 8 May 19, 2000 us to acknowledge that the problem is us that we are "quite ordinary...
...Two Job Openings an e-mail discussion group POLICY ADVISOR INTERNATIONAL until July 1, 2000...
...Clergy/religious candidates must message to commonwealmedia) in religious education...
...In that context, the brain thinking clearly about it...
...For additional information call 212-662- Requirements include progressive expe- POLICY ADVISOR HEALTH/WEL4200 or write COMMONWEAL, 475 River- rience in editorial and book production FARE ISSUES...
...Letter of interest and resume by resume: CVIF Executive Director, PO Box June 1, 2000 to Rev...
...There I a college graduate...
...1-800-695-9599...
...discussion diocesan guidelines...
...The fact is that consciousness-this ism is that "it cuts the mind off too radpulsing throbbing with which all cre- ically from the brain," resulting in both ation groans-is strange, strange stuff, phenomenological embarrassment and Bernard G.Prusak and it is not at all evident how to square conceptual incoherence...
...Commonweal 30 May 19, 2000...
...Office of Human Resources, U.S...
...We offer an outstanding work environ- gious superior before application can be ment with excellent benefits...
...This, too, seems to make In the 1970s a wave of conservatism That is what we have done, first in the perfect sense at first blush...
...leadership ability, excellent communica- cial management, and computing skills tion skills, sensitivity to a multi-cultural en- (Windows, MS Office...
...The what we actually sense or suffer or feel problem, as McGinn puts it, is "How or think...
...Going on and on about the give us the physical basis of consciousMaterial World brain's complexity only begs this ques- ness, not consciousness as it exists for Colin McGisin tion, which fundamentally is how sen- the person whose consciousness it is...
...cbuscc.org EOE M/F/D/V...
...Advance ing policies and procedures...
...Unfortunately for the fuphy...
...but it is not clear what Duquesne University he has in mind...
...and partici- 541-3412 (fax...
...Knock your head against a wall if were to sex, according to ly rejects, both materialism and dual- you wish to ascertain the unity of brain philosopher Colin McGinn...
...202cent, 6 times...
...This is viewed as customers, and the faculty with us-that "the enemy is within...
...Marshall, The Marshall Group, 31 Cam- Human Resources, U.S...
...Master's preferred...
...from conceptualization through publica- lay employees also require prior approval tion...
...He writes, for example, that (Continued from page 4) exam I once asked a class in computer "thought is clearly not the same as real- after, Monsignor Cullinan hung up his literacy to write a paragraph or two ity...
...tradicted by the everyday facts of expesciousness what the sixties McGinn discusses, and rather quick- rience...
...202-541-3412 (fax...
...The way McGinn argues for this theTo begin with, the philosophy of sis further reveals his presuppositions...
...0 est glowing balance sheet of the "busiphilosophical biases is an open question...
...Send 8/1/00...
...That is true enough, but it is not stole for the day, and left...
...Knowledgeable in vironment, excellent educational planning Catholic social teaching...
...Recently embarked on developing a revital- sponsibilities include volunteer recruit- DONATIONS BEGGED for struggling ized lay ministry preparation program...
...mind to the brain, because they are sep- rianism...
...Clergy/reliBECOME A PUBLISHED AUTHOR...
...might be asked...
...Michael J. Hardiman, 702, Goldenrod, FL 32733...
...Three religious The candidate must be a practicing Catholic ment, fundraising, public relations, and Sisters serve small rural parish, Hispanic with a demonstrated fidelity to the magis- office management...
...Good communication, nego- CATHOLIC MINISTRIES, Box 307, Roseperience, organizational and collaborative tiating, interviewing/assessment, finan- dale, MS 38769...
...Requires 3-year commitment...
...And sometimes he made this philosophy at Boston University...
...Extroverted, selfskills, good interpersonal relations, and cre- motivated, personable leader with confiative approaches to adult education and dence, patience...
...thought...
...To seeks experienced manager in this handson editorial leadership opportunity for perience...
...ism...
...20017-1194...
...sists that there does exist a fact of the McGinn's question is what sense we are matter, a truth out there somewhere, to make of "the fact of consciousness," and all the evidence we have suggests "the having of sensations, emotions, feel- that this is consistent with a secular, natings, thoughts...
...tience comes from matter, however com- Correlatively, the problem with dualplex...
...Consciousness studies takes its phers have knocked their heads against bearings from what McGinn calls the the mind-body problem for the past sev"secular scientific view of the universe," eral hundred years, so it stands to reaand has been given much of its excite- son that there is either something about ment and urgency from the advance- it that resists our advances, or somement in brain sciences over the past thing about us that prevents us from twenty years...
...What Phone (412) 396-6531 • Fax (412) 396-4904 would his super-introspect be intro- E-mail: ministry@duq.edu D1 specting...
...Office located in sub- farm workers, prisoners, interracial, interium of the church, a master's degree or urban Orlando...
...minimum five years relevant ex- sented in the magazine...
...Familiarity with media develop- lated issues...
...On a final language...
...MIND MATTERS Knowing everything there is to know about how the brain works-how its raw materials ignite the flame of consciousness-teaches us nothing about has often been referred to as "meat...
...This is the thesis, to put it baldWritten in a style lightened by wit and arate realms...
...E-mail: group President, Pastoral Institute, 7200 Dou- cvif@mindspring.com, Fax: (407) 331-6446...
...405, New York, NY 10115...
...Deadline: June 1, 2000...
...communicate vision and excitement of Salary and benefits are consistent with service...
Vol. 127 • May 2000 • No. 10
