Correspondence: More on Iraq
A neglected war There are two wars in America's history that are usually ignored: the War of 1812 (1812-14) and the war with Mexico (1846-48). Thank you for David O'Rourke's excellent...
...If the weapons of mass destruction aren't affected, what's the point...
...Manuscripts Wanted MANUSCRIPTS WANTED...
...As I studied it, however, it seemed to me that Commonweal had nothing to say to its readers and U.S...
...Julian reworks this twelfth-cenfury Cistercian teaching to provide a melioristic mercy equally important to her work...
...1-800-695-9599...
...The writer is executive editor for Bibles at Oxford University Press...
...George Worgul Scripture, the Soul qf Theology: The Role of the Bible in Theology qune 22-July 10) Dr...
...303-457-3330 Ministry Program DESIRE LAY MINISTRY...
...Maureen O'Brien Marriage and Family in America: A BehavionTl, Humanistic and Theological Analysis (June 22-July 10) Dr...
...The burdens of office I picked up your February 27 issue in my parish library, and noted the editorial ["Free Riders"] describing Iraq's president as a ruthless dictator in control of weapons of mass destruction...
...E-Mail: jvcnw@aol.com...
...Isn't it true that no nation should go to war against another without a reasonable hope of success...
...Catholics of a certain age will read this book with waves of nostalgia and memory washing over them...
...You mention the threat "presented to the stability of the entire region" by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction...
...What is that "entire region" willing to do about it...
...Applications for September are being processed now, but will be accepted through May...
...Box 3928, Portland, OR 972083928...
...She offers us a real chance to Deepen Your Theological Insights for Ministry SUMMER 1998 Ministry in America: Three Mini-Courses _9 Theological and Historical Foundations (June 22-25) _9 Spirituality and Theological Reflection (June 29-July 2) _9 Issues and Opportunities (July 6-9) Dr...
...Undoubtedly, the Spirit has unlimited power to make understanding of the church available to its members, but the ability of individual imperfect members of the church to receive such understanding is less certain...
...Watching her sell God or books, you are seeing an extraordinary salesperson who knows God and her audience...
...Phone (412) 396-6531 coming soon...
...should do," it says, but fails to come up with one specific moral limit for our enlightenment...
...Questions on Iraq Your editorial of December 5, 1997, ["The Least-Bad Solution] rightly stated that "there are no good answers to the problem posed by Saddam...
...Commonweal was remiss in not mentioning this in its last paragraph...
...Richard McCormick has made clear that now that Vatican II has brought the church into the modern age, on occasion we all have the obligation of respectful dissent...
...Despite claims to the contrary, we cannot pinpoint most of our bombs...
...JAMES G. MOEGLEIN, O.S.C...
...Her final choice to opt for mercy is therapeutic for many...
...she translated), Sister Madeleva, Martin D'Arcy, Ronald Knox, Hans Kting, Charles Davis, Hubert Van Zeller, Edward Schillebeeckx, Karl Rahner, Caryll Houselander, as well as movements galore: Cana, Christian Family Movement, Integrity, Catholic Interracial Council, the Catholic Rural Life Movement, and, preeminently, the Catholic Evidence Guild...
...L A S S I F I E B Part of the family Thank you for sending us a copy of your issue of March 13, with its Last Word article, "Among the Monks," by Nancy G. Westerfield, describing her and her husband's stays with us here at the Crosier Renewal Center...
...My own admittedly limited observation is that loyal dissent found today among many Catholics has followed such consideration...
...Are (Contim~ed on page 4) Commonweal 2 April 10, 1998 (Continued from page 2) we really being honest here...
...A great contribution to the advancement of the kingdom of God could be made by both dissenters and those the dissenters take issue with by keeping uppermost in their minds and hearts the teaching of Christ echoed by Saint Paul in the thirteenth chapter of First Corinthians concerning love for one another...
...What if China so threatened Burma...
...I fervently wish that the ideas presented could be brought to the attention of all alert Christians...
...E-mail <ndcpl.l@nd.edu...
...Director of Christian Formation QUEEN OF PEACE COMMUNITY, Gainesville, Florida, an 1100+ family parish, is searching for full-time professional to integrate seamless programs of formation for Pre-School-Adults...
...O'Laughlin Auditorium Free and Open to the Public (Reception following Presentation) SAINT MARY'S COLLEGE NOTRE DAME, IN RATES: $1.10 per word...
...But apart from fiddling with the liturgy, nothing much happened after the council...
...10115...
...Attn...
...As you declared in a later editorial ["A Fragile Fix," March 13, 1998], "there are moral limits to what the U.S...
...Such love is for Julian the ultimate meaning of our Lord's life (love was his meaning...
...Theology degrees...
...That may make irrefutable philosophical sense, but such advocacy hardly evaluates war "with a whole new attitude" as called for by the Vatican II document Gaudium et spes and the American bishops' pastoral letter, "The Challenge of Peace...
...A review of the relevant history would demonstrate how, ever since Vatican II, liturgy has become more reflective of the patterns of the early church...
...Space does not permit a lengthy discussion of that thesis...
...The mercy of the Holy Spirit is for Julian a kind of therapy challenging the blame she knew to be part of church doctrine...
...Rather than deploring the existence of dissent, we should rejoice that much thought is being given by many individuals to important issues...
...The life of Maisie Ward overlapped with some of the most significant moments in modern Catholicism...
...The wrenching changes in the aftermath of the council left them somewhat bewildered and hurt...
...Thank you for David O'Rourke's excellent article ]March 13] on the United States and Mexico...
...Suffice it to repeat what our mothers often told us as children: "Two wrongs don't make a right...
...Do those peoples whom we seem to think are threatened believe there should be an armed assault on Iraq...
...E ~E...
...As Saint Paul wrote in First Corinthians, "All of us have been given to drink of the one Spirit...
...If so, where are they and why are we there practically all alone...
...The complaints of keen observers are good fodder for committee discussions...
...Regent of Studies, Foundation House/Oxford or Registrar/GTF/USA...
...General sessions with John Baldovin, S.J., Maxwell Johnson, and Theresa Koernke, I.H.M...
...she has certainly been part of ours...
...Internet <http://www.nd.edu/-ndcpl...
...Land Sought f o r Retreat ! Shrine OUR LADY OF SOLITUDE MARONITE HERMITAGE is looking for a good-size location in solitude for a monastic hermit group with retreat center...
...creators In his comments on "liturgical horrors" [Correspondence, March 13], Philip E. Devine fails to mention whether he has been involved in his parish liturgy committee...
...It also follows from these extensive efforts by Catholics, both dissenters and nondissenters, that there is a substantial opportunity for the Holy Spirit to speak to the church through its many members...
...DONALD KRAUS New York, N.Y...
...The writer is prior of the Crosier RenewaI Center...
...You admit that U.S...
...This book, marred by very few errata, fills in a gap in the history of Anglophone Catholicism, and for that reason alone we should receive it with appreciation...
...It seems to me about as "collateral" as the bombing deaths in Dresden and Tokyo more than fifty years ago...
...For details contact: Theology and Pastoral Ministry Duquesne University Ask about our Pittsburgh, PA 15282 online courses...
...We would like to have a shrine in honor of Saint Sharbel with Adoration of the Most Blessed Sacrament...
...policy makers, other than "do good and avoid evil...
...Do you seek a simple lifestyle in community with your peers7 Do you desire a deepening of personal spirituality that flows into service of those in need...
...DAVID BELLEFEUII.LE-RICE Olympia, Wash...
...How to read Julian is a question of perspective...
...McCormick on dissent Thanks for Richard McCormick's "The Church & Dissent" [February 27], especially for its references to documents of the Second Vatican Council...
...Center for Pastoral Liturgy, Box 81, Notre Dame, Indiana 46556 USA...
...Carolyn Whited, SHF, 503-3358202...
...The pretechnological Julian saw life as a mixture of weal and woe...
...E-mail ministry@duq.edu "recover" from the morbidity that eventually sapped the life of the passio domini tradition, only to reappear in later Jansenism...
...True, the icon of Jesus' passion is always before her, but so is the trust that we are linked "substantially" to the Godhead...
...Couched as it is in the rejection of "therapeutic" theologies, the article omits an aspect of Julian that readers would profit from...
...Telephone 219/6315435...
...George DeSchrijver, SJ (Visiting Scholar from Louvain University) Credit and audit students welcome...
...JAMES R. WORSLEY, JR...
...Residential program...
...In fact it strengthens the reviewer's major point, that in present-day moderately conservative religion, a revival is considered to be a withdrawal from the "'contamination of the modern" and a consequent lack of "loving concern for others...
...Fellowship FOUNDATION HOUSE/OXFORD and Graduate Theological Foundation/ USA, offering Oxford Foundation Fellowships for short-term residence...
...ROBERT ENGLERT Lindenhurst, N.Y...
...We just happen to be living during a period of the greatest liturgical change in centuries...
...Write: Bill Phelps (211) Saint Edward Home, 3131 Smith Rd., Akron, Oh 44313...
...12 woM minimum...
...Discounts 5 percent, 3 times...
...One must admit that here is an original, and a great one...
...Kearney, Neb...
...Scholarships available, with speical consideration for applicants from minority communities...
...This kind of rhetoric is more suited to a "rag," not the country's leading Catholic journal...
...Appropriate degrees, or commensurate experience expected: a working knowledge of Liturgy is helpful...
...They stress, ultimately, that Saddam Hussein is responsible for the whole present mess...
...Do statements from the Vatican and the bishops on Iraq have any validity for us when our forces are poised to strike unilaterally if Saddam reneges on his accord with the UN...
...This is particularly true of teachings such as those contained in Commonweal 4 4 April 10, 1998 Humanae vitae, which so directly affect so many people...
...bombing is "unlikely to destroy much, if any, of the regime's biological and chemical capability...
...This gutsy nun has redefined dissent in her church as she assaults Vatican iI and does not hesitate to take on a bishop...
...Workshops and working sessions focus on liturgical and pastoral issues about Eucharist...
...The whole cast of characters is here: Christopher Dawson, C.C...
...MATER DEI INSTITUTE at Gonzaga University, Spokane, WA 99202-1849.1-800-986-9585 ext 6012...
...I have e-mailed copies of the article to some of our other monasteries and religious communities in this country, to our provincial superior in Saint Paul, and to our master general in Belgium...
...Interested applicants send rOsum6 by 4/20/98 to: Terry Jackson, Queen of Peace Church, 10900 SW 24th Avenue, Gainesville, FL, 32607, FAX (352) 331-7347...
...The sense that "all is well" is rooted in the hopeful belief that all of us are deeply grounded (substantially) in the Trinitarian love...
...Chevy Chase, Md...
...CATHERINE WENTHEN Syracuse, N.Y...
...It still astounds me to hear of the BOSTON COLLEGE Catholic School Leadership Program Offering state certification at one of the nation's leading Catholic universities Three 2-week summer sessions: June 29-August 7, 1998 Academic year study available The Catholic School Leadership Program at Boston College offers opportunities to teachers, counselors and administrators to renew Catholic schools for the 21st Century...
...threats to bomb targets in Iraq unless United Nations inspectors were given free access to all sites they wish to visit...
...The fact is that the one scenario of action the United States considered in the crisis, had "diplomacy" failed, was bombing by Navy cruise missiles and bombardment by the Air Force...
...Commonweal 46 April 10, 1998...
...Eventually Frank and Maisie settled in Jersey City, where they lived modestly...
...William Thompson Theologies of Liberation (July 13-July 31) Dr...
...10 percent, 6 times...
...All that is good, God creates, all that is evil, God suffers...
...It is not as witty or as moving as Wilfrid Sheed's memoir of his parents, Frank and Maisie (1986), where Frank Sheed gets more fully drawn...
...Of course our presidents stand apart from Saddam in many respects, but in terms of mass killings of civilians, where's the difference...
...If you are able to commit for one year, are in good health, and can provide a share of modest living expenses: contact us today...
...WILSON Stow, Ohio From the editors: But would she be even more effective as the contemplative she set out to be...
...Of course, their actual or potential victims were not Americans, so consider Lincoln, a truly great man who nevertheless presided over the savaging of portions of our own South...
...ActuaIly, the "poet" in question is the author of the Letter of James, and the course of action recommended has more to do with aiding the oppressed than with sexual purity...
...As the article indicates, such dissent should only follow after "prayerful, arduous, reflective, informed" consideration of the questions at issue...
...each of us is responsible for his or her own spiritual life and for the communal life of the church...
...Though the Pentagon assures us that its bombs are 90 percent smarter than they were seven years ago, they are still not smart enough to distinguish between a combatant and a civilian, which makes their use ipso facto unjust...
...334 South Main Street, Philippe, WV 26416...
...Musical celebration with Notre Dame Folk Choir...
...Our Lady of Solitude Maronite Hermitage, Inc...
...Thank you and God bless you for what you can do...
...Unspotted by the world' David J. DeLaura's interesting review of The New Religious Humanists ]March 13] contained an allusion to "the impulse to live (as a poet once put it) 'unspotted by the world.'" Professor DeLaura equates this with "calls for a return to sexual purity...
...In fact, in view of problems being encountered by our fellow believers in the God of Abraham, it seems evident that many Jews and Muslims would also benefit from many of the thoughts expressed in the article...
...Can we now pretend that this is moral or necessary...
...Martindale, Dorothy Day, the Baroness de Hueck, the Abb6 Godin (whose Is France Pagan...
...Become a Commonweal Associate @ CENTER FOR SPIRITUALITY SAINT MARY'S COLLEGE presents The Fourteenth Annual Madeleva Lecture in Spirituality "Quotidian Mysteries: Laundry, Liturgy and Women's Work" by Kathleen Norris Author of Dakota, The Cloister Walk and (March '98)Amazing Grace...
...There are moral limits to what the U.S...
...Julian's Showings does center on the image of the crucified, and Bauerschmidt's precise article introduces many to this aspect of Julian...
...Take a stand The March 13 editorial, "The Fragile Fix," was an attempt at a balanced analysis of a dangerously complex issue...
...Both currents come from God and both reflect the desire for God...
...D Lawrence S. Cunningham teaches theology at the University of Notre Dame...
...For additional information call 212-662-4200 or write COMMONWEAL, 475 Riverside Dr., Rm...
...Both editorials imply, however, that what progress has been made in this situation came about because of credible U.S...
...Discounts and monthly billing available for repeat advertisers...
...Nothing in the immediate context associates this particularly with sexual purity...
...Do you want to work for social justice in solidarity with others...
...Mother Angelica is truly the first woman ever to successfully dominate the televangelist world...
...The full quotation reads: "Religion that is pure and undefiled before God, the Father, is this: to care for orphans and widows in their distress, and to keep oneself unstained by the world" (New Revised Standard Version...
...Even Rome is afraid to tackle this remarkable lady...
...ANDREW GALLIGAN Tracy, Calif...
...Bauerschmidt has chosen to focus on the passion, but readers ought to know that for Julian the central icon of the cross is accompanied by the doctrine of "Mother Jesus," who will never leave her children...
...As we face our own death, there is both a fierce need to continue the work of restoring the creation and a knowledge that we must let go Commonweal ~3 April 10, 1998 of it...
...II ;tl :11 ~i.'tl ",l...
...Unfortunately, history is replete with examples of teachers and dissenters who, in their zeal for asserting their perceptions of truth, have lost sight of Christ's teachings concerning love, from which almost no one dissents...
...Try to name anyone who might be able to match her job performance...
...Devine stop traveling from church to church, become actively involved in the liturgies in one parish, and be a "cook" rather than a "critic...
...Elders Wanted...
...Older translations use the phrase DeLaura remembers, "unspotted from the ]or this] world...
...Julian transforms the passio domini motif of her time and she knows that her confidence goes far beyond what was permitted to her by the church...
...True, but this calls for some context...
...Have not other presidents threatened mass murder on a world-threatening scale...
...How well the members of the church are listening today will be better judged from the perspective of a hundred years from now than from our present close-up view...
...I thought DeLaura might be interested in how appropriate his allusion turned out to be...
...The first Elder Corps communities will begin in September 1998...
...She has obviously done a lot of research and talked with a fair number of Maisie's contemporaries...
...If Saddam Hussein is a mass murderer, were not also Nixon, Johnson, Truman, and Roosevelt, who as commanders-in-chief presided over mass bombings of civilians...
...PAUL FERRIS Annapolis, Md...
...Sin is a lack or "nothing" because God "suffers" it rather than creating it...
...Are we going to start a war whenever anyone threatens to use such weapons, or whenever a UN accord is broken...
...The process of dialogue among church members has characterized the development of formulations of doctrine from the earliest years of the church...
...Dana Greene's biography is a loving one...
...February 27] presents Julian of Norwich's comforting message as a disturbing call to share in the compassion of the crucified...
...ANN W. FEI),[),IS Hampton, W. Va...
...Notre Dame Center f o r Pastoral Liturgy PASTORAL LITURGY CONFERENCE "Church and Eucharist: the Many Presences of Christ...
...Special rates available...
...The preconciliar liturgies, which dominated youth for many of us, had their origins in thirteenthcentury Europe, and were decidedly nonparticipatory...
...I am optimistic enough to believe that unprecedented numbers of Catholics are making a sincere effort to receive understanding from the Holy Spirit...
...I recommend that Mr...
...And what would be accomplished besides once more damaging an already pitiful social infrastructure of a hard-pressed people...
...JESUIT VOLUNTEER CORPS: Northwest invites mid- and upper-age women and men to serve as charter members in the Elder Corps...
...The United States is only the unhappy and reluctant player in what Commonweal refers to as this "high-stakes poker game...
...Dialogue & dissent Commonweal and Richard McCormick have performed a great service to the church by presenting "The Church and Dissent" [February 271...
...Please contact Father Bernard Grunewald in any way you may help...
...The obligation of dissent As one baptized in 1926 and trained to love Holy Mother Church in the 1930s, it was not difficult for me to receive the "received wisdom...
...JVC: NW Elders, P.O...
...It would be even less reasonable, in the post-Vatican II environment described by Father McCormick, that large numbers of Catholics would not be giving prayerful thought to different views on doctrinal questions...
...Can we honestly call the killing of civilians--the aged, women, children--"collateral damage...
...Critics vs...
...June 15-18, 1998, on the campus of Notre Dame...
...Information on Eden Plan WRITER NEEDS INFO ON EDEN PLAN for nursing homes...
...9 Financial aid available 9 Renowned faculty 9 Close to metropolitan Boston For further information, contact: Graduate School of Education Boston College, Campion Hall 103 Chestnut Hill, MA 02167-3813 (617) 552-4214 www.bc.edu /bc_org / a vp / soe Commonweal 45 April 10, 1998 wonderful vision of the church that emerged over those few years...
...There is no doubt where Commonweal's sympathies lie...
...Featured 1998 Summer Courses: 9 Foundations of Educational Administration Robert J. Starratt 9 Catholic Schools in the 1990s: Financing and Resourcing Joseph O'Keefe, S.J...
...Need we pit the therapeutic against the technological today...
...Vatican lI was a thrilling revelation...
...BARBARA ZAPSZALKA Evanston, 111...
...Naturally, we look forward to Nancy's next visit...
...You mention that it would weaken "Iraq's conventional military power...
...After the first blush of optimism in the aftermath of Vatican II, there was a general malaise in Catholic publishing...
...I am grateful for McCormick's clear, wise, and gentle illumination of where we are at present...
...This stance raises many questions for me...
...What did we do when Iraq used them oll Iran...
...Anyone with a conscience must acknowledge that to run a substantial, activist state, one must be ready to commit murder on a massive scale...
...it was the way things were done...
...should do...
...NCEA-BC 1998 Summer Programs: 9 SPICE (Selected Programs for Improving Catholic Education) 9 Spiritual Growth Leadership Institute Spiritual and Professional Development Initiatives: 9 BC's Institute of Religious Education and Pastoral Ministry 9 The Urban Catholic Teaching Corps 9 Master's, C.A.E.S., Ph.D...
...Such dialogue has not been limited to participants in church councils or to popes and their advisers...
...Continued o11 page 43) Commonweal 4' April 10, 1998 She also kept up a strenuous lecture schedule and worked with an organization to provide decent housing for the poor...
...DAVID K. REEVES Princeton, N.J...
...Fax 219/631-6968...
...Liturgies are actions of the people in a given community, subject to all the usual human frailties...
...Residential degrees by coursework and supervised thesis (Oxford/Rome/USA...
...405, N.Y., N.Y...
...The Gulf War coalition did that a few years ago, and here it is again...
...Our sins thus have "no substance" (sin is nothing) because in the Augustinian sense they do not come from the God who creates...
...But it does add insights and detail about the life of this extraordinary woman...
...MARIE D. HOFF Boise, Idaho Mother Angelica: An original Re: "Liturgical Confusion" [editorial, January 30]: The story about one great American Catholic woman's rise to power has simply been ignored by most of us...
...ll : II . ! ~il "~ E ~I i (Continued from page 4) If she insists on suffering as the hallmark of love, she also insists that we do not pursue pain, and writes that she can find neither blame nor wrath in God...
...A Vocabulary of Faith Thursday, April 16, 1998 7:30 p.m...
...For Catholics, Father McCormick's great contribution is to put into perspective the constructive aspect of the emergence of dissent following upon the current widespread discussion of possible new formulations of traditional teaching in the light of current experience...
...Subsidy Publisher with 75-year tradition...
...If we "shop" the diocesan smorgasbord of liturgies as consumers, evaluating them with "stars" like restaurant critics, we are far more likely to find fault than if we are full participants...
...The mindset of the Vatican was set in stone...
...they are highly relevant to the discussions we are having today...
...15 percent, 12 times...
...Julian's message(s) Frederick Bauerschmidt's "Will Everything Really Be OK...
...yet isn't that the very purpose of our threats...
...Those who worry about the future of worship might heed the call to help shape that future...
...Good point badly made I agreed with the gist of the analysis by LaVonne Neff ["Powerful Men," March I3] on the arrogance that men in positions of power display toward women, but I found her style vulgar and her crude use of a baboon metaphor unworthy of a journal of Commonweal's literary stature...
...Research degrees by thesis and examination...
...Priesthood...
...Then came Hans K6ng, John Courtney Murray, Henri de Lubac, Yves Congar, and Pope John XXIII...
...Friends become family...
...Advance payment required...
...ALL TYPES...
...1-800-4235983 or fax 219-935-8480 or e-mail gtf@skyenet.net...
Vol. 125 • April 1998 • No. 7
