Disarmed and Dangerous by Murray Polner and Jim O'Grady
O'Brien, David
PHIL & DAN AT WAR Disarmed and Dangerous The Radical Lives and Times of Daniel and Philip Berrigan Murray Polner and Jim O'Grady David O'Brien On February 12,1997, at 4:30 in the morning, Philip...
...They were first arrested together for the pioneer draft board raid, "the Baltimore Four," in 1967...
...His anger overwhelmed the love of their mother, Freda, and made leaving home easier...
...The gifted moderates now seem convinced that they helped "our" side "win" the cold war, while the Berrigans still prefer, in Dan's words, "to be as marginal as possible to madness...
...It is only then, when discussing Phil's vocation, that the biographers mention that Dado left copies of the Catholic Worker around the house and helped set up a Catholic Interracial Council in Syracuse...
...It began as fairly modest efforts to awaken the lay apostolate and challenge the church's own racism, then to respond to Pope John XXIII and the council, then to confront their country's bloody war in Vietnam...
...Still, the bonds of family remained tightly drawn, for life...
...Later they seemed to despair of the civil faith, and so their Catholic faith seemed deeper, perhaps more sectarian, because it no longer had that American trust in the people and hope for their future as its intimate companion...
...The heart of the book spans the years of intense protest, from Dan's exile to Latin America for upsetting Cardinal Francis Spellman to the Harrisburg conspiracy trial for an alleged plot to kidnap Henry Kissinger...
...A Maine judge thinks Phil is the conscience of a generation, and one Jesuit told Polner and O'Grady he thinks Daniel "the greatest Jesuit since Ignatius...
...Even leaders of the old Catholic peace movement had reservations about the tactics of the Berrigan-led "ultraresis-tance...
...On the most important issue of their time, nuclear weapons, they faced the truth while far too many spent their talents seeking ways to justify the unjustifiable...
...Berrigan and Lewis-Borbely go back a long way...
...Since then, they have spent a lot of time in jail, seven-and-a-half years for Berrigan...
...Their dad, "Dado," never brought home much money, he brooded over his failures, bullied his wife and sons, and long after he was gone he took hard shots in the sons' memories...
...The authors make plain that, while brother Jerry became an ally and at times a co-conspirator, the other Berrigan brothers had little sympathy for their radical actions...
...Both loved being part of the church, and were hurt that some Catholics seemed more angry at them than at the warmakers...
...Murray Polner and Jim O'Grady have done a public service by reconstructing the "radical lives and times" of the two best known of the six Berrigan brothers...
...By then they were hardly alone...
...They helped move their church on questions of war and peace, they inspired other good people to do good work, they loved their friends and family, they stayed the course...
...The authors know that the Berrigans differ from other famous radicals because they are Catholic, very Catholic...
...Amid the conformist self-congratulations of fifties' Catholicism, restless and relentlessly honest men like the Berrigans created discomfort, not least for themselves...
...PHIL & DAN AT WAR Disarmed and Dangerous The Radical Lives and Times of Daniel and Philip Berrigan Murray Polner and Jim O'Grady David O'Brien On February 12,1997, at 4:30 in the morning, Philip Berrigan, Tom Lewis-Borbely, and three others entered the grounds of Bath Iron Works in Maine and hammered and spilled blood, their own, on the missile launch tubes of a billion-dollar Aegis destroyer...
...Berrigan's brother, Jesuit Daniel, now seventy-five, appears regularly at protest vigils in New York, and ministers to cancer and AIDS patients...
...And they are undoubtedly a certain type of Catholic, with that deep assurance that can deal with defeat...
...They are also very American: They said more readily in the sixties that they wanted to save the country from continuing dishonor...
...But the ties of blood, and simple fraternal affection, are extremely strong...
...When not in jail they live with their families in poor neighborhoods, Berrigan in Baltimore and Lewis-Borbely in Worcester, Massachusetts...
...The nearly twenty-five years since the trial take a smaller proportion of the book, though we learn of the Plowshares antinuclear actions, like that at Bath, of controversies over the Middle East, Vietnamese human-rights abuses, abortion, of Daniel's growing commitment to pastoral care for the dying, and the commitment of Phil and his wife Liz to raise a family while spending considerable time in jail...
...His missile-hammering days may be behind him...
...Dan loved the Jesuits, he seemed to thrive in an academic environment like Cornell University, he was a very good poet, and he enjoyed the company of some powerful people...
...Both men seem eligible for much forgiveness because they had such a tough dad...
...And the faith was passed on, sending Daniel off to the Jesuits and Philip to the Josephites, after a full taste of war...
...This last section is understandably the least satisfying: We would like to know more about these men as they have lived their beliefs after the spotlight went off...
...Family life for the Berrigans in upstate New York in the Depression-era was hard...
...There is no hagiography here...
...And Phil, the authors show, had his own vulnerable points: He needed Dan as he later needed his wife, Elizabeth...
...The authors describe faults, impatience, occasional hyperbole, touches of self-righteousness, but they also make clear that Dan and Phil have acknowledged them...
...Phil still murmurs the Jesus prayer while painting houses and prays from the Scriptures of the day's liturgy...
...It is possible that only on those margins, with people like these, that alternatives to madness can be imagined, a necessary step to the much desired renewal of our country and our church...
...According to press reports, Judge Field said of Philip Berrigan: "He is a moral giant, the conscience of a generation...
...Polner and O'Grady make it clear that it was never easy for Dan or Phil...
...But it was never enough, less because they were radicals, which they were, than that the nation's capacity for violence, and self-deception, was far greater than anyone suspected...
...But he worried about unmerited suffering and his more relentless brother pulled at him...
...But these Berrigan brothers and their friends are, among many other things, stubborn...
...A few hours later, West Bath District Court Judge Joseph Field set a probable cause hearing but refused to jail the protesters...
...In the end, the authors think Dan and Phil did what they set out to do, to challenge the "moral rot" of national policy: "Despite their imperfections...the Berrigans honored the country and the world in this, the bloodiest century in human history...
...But the book is "life and times" history, better at describing events colleagues, background, and strategy than at probing the depths of motivation or even searching the great body of Berrigan writing for clues to their inner life...
...a surprising Catholic peace movement captured national attention, and the church at all levels began to face the problems that had long troubled them...
Vol. 124 • April 1997 • No. 8
