The Stripping of the Altars
Oakes, Edward T.
erything is argued: exhibits are...
...CLASSIFIED M A R C H 2 2 - 2 8 Priesthood DEPTH, HEIGHT, WIDTH AND LENGTH OF CATHOLIC SPIRITUALITY: DESIRE PRIESTHOOD...
...14.95 paper Broyard's way HISPANIC WOMEN Prophetic Voice in the Church Postage and handling Red Bank, N.J...
...Catholic education ["From Ghetto to HillI find it very difficult to see Broyard top," February 12] makes a few assumpas Marget described him: "supercilious, tions about American Catholics that are It doesn't add up superficial, and affected...
...sympathetically portrayed in his plays...
...Seeing the transformation et claims that this study will be of interest Bear in PJ's...
...This hook gathers the heat of Willialus' religious writings, addressing such topic...
...What friends OX...
...Summer Course GW'cdnesday 6:30 pm, Saturday 4:00 pm and Sunday, 8:45, 10:30, 12:00 & 5:15...
...334pp...
...St...
...1 (800) Justice, Peace, Ecology and Global Awareness...
...Compelling...it is rich fare...
...smart enough to dismiss most of the talk But there was, and is, a group of that came from the pulpit, and all the talk American Catholics whose roots are not that came from the Boss Tweeds in Roman in the city, who lived, and live, in the coun- collars who ran the urban chanceries...
...Commonweal 12 March 1993: 29 First, he talks about Catholic ghettos, pre- since there were no Catholic schools, but sumably urban since they were large also by choice...
...58.95 paper makes me look to Broyard for guidance...
...B1701 $24.95...
...9 95 paper [January 15] of Anatole Broyard's han- STATIONS OF THE CROSS dling of his fatal disease in his book A Latin American Pilgrimage Dororhe Soellc Intoxicated by My Illness...
...Duffy massively documents a widespread opposition, across all social classes, to Protestantism during the reigns so of Henry VIII and Edward VI...
...Pittsburgh, Pa...
...Oh...
...Second, Mr...
...3. Or call (or fax) with MC/ VISA/ AMEX card...
...Four days order the lasr diary entry, King Alfred Professor at the University Archbishop Romero was assassinated while celebrating Mass...
...To write that TRANSFIGURATIONS " [tjoday, our most secure knowledge of Theology and the French Feminists dlteri by Clt...
...trrl1C the world is mathematical" undermines the and 5usuwr 5urnonarru security of our directly lived experience ,5~~ t • plores the challenging work of this genera• t i s most notable French feminists...
...They the public schools not only by necessity, did not make use of the Catholic schools in the cities because their urban, ethnic quality felt so foreign...
...Eamon Duffy reform of the liturgy under Thomas Duffy sets out his case in two parts...
...They looked to the parish enough to support institutions, and assumes priest only for the sacraments...
...For the book The book ends at 1580, so the role of under the Cranmer thumb is like watch- does indeed show just how fragile instituSpain's diplomatic machinations, not to ing an earthquake in slow motion...
...Ado Maria lsasr-Diaz and Yolanda loran s costs are additional...
...Homily at the 12: 15, 1:00, 5:15 Mass Monday-Friday...
...S.C 144pp...
...How much American THE FRANCISCAN FRIARS Catholics were in fact starving for more SISTERS OF THE ATDNEMENT Madison Avenue English in the liturgy is AND ANO THEIR ASSOCIATES, a question that, among many others, one OIRECTDR...
...in the sixteenth century, poetry is a mere St...
...It will help Perhaps Marget has had personal expe- us to learn again what we have to mourn rience with terminal cancer that caused her and what we have to celebrate.'' -MICIIAEI...
...involved in Catholic institutions other than the parish church are a minority...
...Armand I)asscs•illc, 01-A-1, Cap...
...The book setting out this surveys (what seems like all) the evidence Edward T. Oakes daring argument is almost crushingly about popular attitudes toward the instilarge, but as the reader begins the plunge, tutions of Roman Christianity throughout it soon becomes clear why Duffy must bear the land of England...
...Like my parents, and grandparents, and Some were, like me, Irish in name...
...One's position on specific texts can vary, of course...
...MARIA i IARRIS NEW...
...One mo- tional Christianity can be in the face of demention Guy Fawkes, is perhaps not given ment, the world is at peace, and all and termined opposition from the powers that its rightful due...
...Bartxam J. Mac flallrc Primavesi's radical assessment of the The growing body of scholarship on women ecological challenge leads her to find in DAVID L. SMITH from the early church through the struggle Genesis a basis for a profound rethinking for Ord]rtauorl...
...cannot help asking after concluding this CONTACT...
...I thoroughly STRUGGLES FOR enjoyed this work and found it to be im- SOLIDARITY tique of the contemporary penchant to mens:Ir helpful ---PFTEP C JiODCOSON Liberation Theologies in Tension collapse all categories of knowledge into 24 pl...
...And although Pius V ex- sundry are going about their business, be...
...by the printing press and the devotions ennot just the dearth of biographical details Duffy leaves no aspect of his difficult couraged by the clergy...
...Soot hgatc I Intel, 31st St...
...For the most part, they had no desire was home, and they didn't feel out of place...
...Mug{ rc Krnr...
...Archbishop Roinero of Liverpool, says of that line and this de- is revered throughout the world as a fearless defender of the poor and a man of bate: "If that line, in context, does not ex- uncompromising...
...But if a Boston narrow to the point of distorting reality...
...One need only think of, for example, communicated Elizabeth in 1570, this too and suddenly (as history measures these the policy of the shoguns in Japan in the is ignored, rather to the detriment of things), the landscape has been completely seventeenth century, or the disappearance Duffy's thesis, though he makes clear that transformed, and not a stone is left atop of Christianity in North Africa outside of both before and after 1570, "dislike of another...
...Edited by l orrnc M. GGctz and guy O. Costa the psychological...
...512.9) paper TO GENESIS our beings," it sounds like an oxymoron...
...160 pages ' S 10.95 pa in, r ~ Courageous Incarnation 3 New Ebitions b~: Monica Furion 1 In in tinwc;?, Work C,ilb,oobg an6 Aging hf Merton:A Blogra by Fredrica Harris Thompsett iii Christian uncertaintiesAut or o "Setting each of these (childhood and age, work and love) in the i Contemplating Now context of the Incarnation is to give a I I Christians a lovely gift...
...Anthony Messenger Press local religious bookstore...
...VOCATION GRAYMD4R, P.O...
...This is a work of revisionist his- there was close lay engagement with the disputes in the history of tory so daring, so innately interesting, so structures of the Roman church...
...erything is argued: exhibits are properly labeled, witnesses duly subpoenaed and AN EARTHQUAKE IN SLOW MOTION cross-examined, all to drive home this single point: that the Roman-affiliated church in England from 1400-1580 was not the decadent branch of corrupt priestcraft and popular superstition so beloved of the conventional wisdom of historians, a THE STRIPPING OF THE ALTARS penned in just that one, five-beat line church that was nearly ready to fall off, Traditional Religion in England, 1400- sums up, for Duffy, the attitude of the vast needing only the pruning shears of the 1580 majority of the English people toward the Reformers...
...I have are wits...
...they are part of III...
...But, the other side says, don't forget the sympathetic treatment of Catherine of Aragon ARCHBISHOP in Henry VIII...
...Thik volume provides a unique look into the life and press sadness about the course which the world of one of the outsrandmg figures of c nrcmhorurv ( lr)olico;m...
...This constitutes the second part, and here again we encounter revisionist history at its most imaginative and exciting...
...GEORGE SHEEHAN, M.D...
...Essential Writings in Spiritua(it~ ad Tyeo(ogg FROM COWLEY Edited by Charles Hefting The Inany sided genius of Charles Williams--poet, novelist, and Dante scho lar-.lltio ex hrcssvs itself in numerous reflections on religious themes...
...LENTEN PROGRAMS We feel no nostalgia for an urban ghetto because we did not know it...
...175 pages ' 510.95 paper 4* Travelling In Each edition: 124 pages ' $9.95 paper Ask for these titles at your local bookstore...
...Cranmer, Henry VIII's loyal archbishop first deals with the fifteenth century and of Canterbury...
...I(0 page, ' S 10.95 paper NEW...
...and the medieval about the Bard, but also Shakespeare's own case, it seems, to the hunches and surmises doctrines of Christian eschatology were protean imagination: why are friars so of his putative jury...
...HER STORY Ecology Feminism, and Christianity To make such a claim, he must bypass the Women in Christian Tradition ANNE PPL•taAVl SI abstract nature of his discipline...
...An afternoon of prascr and reflection...
...He Another remarkable feature of the book Pillar, a particularly ironic desecration)- particularly bemoaned the phrase "and is the combination of skills which Duffy forms a kind of Greek chorus to the text, there was no room for them at the place has marshaled to establish his thesis...
...They, and I, went to administered, and they sent their children state or private universities-again by "We seem to be the only hippos here...
...One renowned This diary chronicles the daily work of Archbishop Oscar Romero of El Salvador Shakespeare scholar, Philip Edwards, the from March 31, 1978, through March 20, 11980...
...Perfect for c'atec'humcnate/ '[LL[\M W11.1.1MON con ii riiiau iii ticla c...
...Carlin's assumption that Catholics "generally" are connected with Catholic educational institutions is incorrect...
...7th Ave...
...S[5.95 paper and his proposal for a mathematical corA brcakrhrough- A wonderful work, one Available April 1993rective remind me as a psychologist of that is likely to have an impact comRieff's Triumph of the Therapeutic, a cri- parable to Models of God...
...59.95 paper ~r9anic Prayer luasg a ppeal lea if Posh ~lfg Sisters anb Brothers CU ltivatino Yot2r Re (ationsf ip lvith Gob V Reclaiming a Biblical Ibea of Commtinitg by Nancy Roth, Illus by S. Mangam What a lovely hulk Organic prayer i1, by Verna Dozier & James Adams written with gunrleness, humor, and a A Rihle study program which deep hasic toughness...
...DAVID K. O'ROURKE, O.P...
...51 a.y5 paper Arullufde MuF !0555...
...The Yale University Press, $45, 654 pp...
...Susan John's redefines relationships between the pictures are inure than a fitting sexes in a Christian community, and accompantinent...
...Speakers are Marv I;lizabcth'lix}mev I)unnc and I)as id Parente from perience and do not prize...
...no...
...As authentic a faith experience as I've To the Editors: I am sure that others be- ever read The book truly presents...
...12 noon to 4:1)0 pm...
...vision...
...to the public schools...
...Director, Mater Dei, E. by Fr...
...John The Baptist Church Centro Pro Unione, Rome, Mon...
...When Raymo writes, "We ourselves about women in Christianity available: FROM APOCALYPSE are mathematics incarnate-to the core of CFTTY Ih131:12G '2 [spp...
...aesL9dwt NEW...
...to be anything other than small-town They helped to build, they taught in, they American Catholics...
...They were that we all had our roots there...
...Mathematics provides READINGS IN HER STORY Leading liberation theologians address the us with a most denuded reality, a world Women in Christian Tradition often-undiagnosed misunderstandings and Edited by Barbara 1. MacHalr+c map models of mutually affirming stripped of its rich texture and varied qual- theologies I6 pp...
...73): "Bare, ruined choirs where late the sweet birds sang...
...Registration deadline: May 1, 1993...
...And only with "Well, eventually, everything comes to an end...
...juggernaut of history had taken in England Hardcover, 552 pages...
...the liturscholarship is the debate rich in admonitory tales for today, so gy was widely understood even though it over whether Shakespeare against the grain of received wisdom, that was in Latin...
...To the Editors: Professor Raymo's review of Pi in the Sky [January 291 demonstrates how positivism and scientism continue to permeate our culture...
...A friend of C.S...
...TEACH...
...They except when it came to choosing spousliked it there, it felt like home because it es...
...titles you wish to order...
...Summer Course in Ecumenism: "Introduction to the Ecumenical Movement" presented by the Atonement Friars at the St...
...1 ].say paper of sin and redemption...
...184pp...
...a Catholic counterculture we didn't exA day of reflection and discussion...
...as the theology of romantic love, the holiness of sex, and the hearing of zinc anorher's hurdens...
...But great-grandparents, they lived, died, and they were not consciously "Irish Catholic," are buried in small-town America...
...To order direct from St...
...17( 1iags' - SIO-95 paper NEW !! 112 page...
...to 6 p.m...
...But while I was reading Eamon Duffy's fascinating book on the revolu- RO-MERO tion in religion that swept through England before and through the first part of A Shepherd's Diary Shakespeare's life, this peculiar little de- Translation by Irene B. Hodgson bate kept coming to mind-and above all, Foreword by Thomas E. Quigley that haunting line from one of his sonnets Introduction by James R. Brockman, SJ...
...TAYLOR- Director...
...heir to the final Elizabethan settlement derstatement for a dust cover...
...And they looked to choice, thinking them to be the best...
...53.95 paper "This is the best collection cat primary texts ities...
...My own experience laopp...
...9:30 am to 5:0[1 pm...
...Lewis and Dorothy Savers, Will iii ins similarly brought imagination and passion to the spiritual life...
...He then goes on to show how far and how fast Queen Mary moved to reestablish the ancien regime, and how she was on the verge of succeeding before her death...
...28: 12 March 1993 Commonweal I am dying-albeit slowly-of prostate policeman can call Robert Coles "arrocancer and doing it in my own fashion, gant," no one can be sensitive enough CORRESPONDENCE just as Broyard did in his...
...sons and daughters...
...What I wish I had is Feli Navidad a ti y Prospero Ano Broyard's enormous politeness, his con- Benicia, Calif...
...240pp...
...Anthon And that line is also clearly the best way 1615 Republic Street Messenger Press, call tall-free: 1.800-488-0488, of summarizing the main point of Duffy's Cincinnati, OH 45210 8 a.m...
...of us...
...Address: 2. Enclose prices of titles chosen plus $3.25 shipping...
...2.30 pages ' $12.95 paper L. Rf11iasCkunlnnuin The Preaching Life Goon News o f Jesus by Barbara Brown Taylor Rer'tr0614CI lg the Gaspef QOOD ..One is reminded of Somerset by L. William Countryman Ma ughanl's The Summing IJp and Annie In this short, persuasive iolroduerion to Dillard's The Writing Life...
...All is laid out, ev- almost universally accepted...
...According to a study conducted by the National Catholic Education Asso-, ciation a few years back, more than 50 percent of American Catholics have had no LENT formal religious education at all...
...What only a full lawyer's brief would suffice to ny between the reading habits generated keeps this little contretemps all a-boil is establish its thesis...
...Mass included...
...NEW...
...Among his startling 0 ne of the more amusing, if down on the reader with such relentless conclusions can be listed the following: entirely inconsequential, overkill...
...For Information: Summer 210 W. 31st Street (at 7th Avenue) • New York, NY 10001 • (212) 564-9070 Course, Atonement Friars, 138 Waverly Sensed by the f:apurhin Friars Place, New York, NY 10014-3845...
...I)avid Couturier, OFM, Cap...
...OR Name: 1. Mail in this ad, circling...
...Unwittingly, the supremacy attributed to WHERE SILENCE SPEAKS Feminism, Social Theory, mathematics denigrates all other domains and Religion of knowledge and relegates them to the hicrana Lcc Enckson A brilliant proposal to reorient the whole category "subjective...
...Christian Aid to react in this way...
...AU DEN to Charles Williams NEW...
...THE BODY OF GOD discipline around hearing womens actual Professor Raymo's parody of theology An Ecological Theology voices to create a feminist social theory Salhi Mc Faguc of religion...
...A fit subject for one of Alexander Pope's mock epics, perhaps, but otherwise OSCAR, hardly worth wasting much ink or energy over...
...Nuevo a Commonweal...
...E.S.1), Monday through Friday...
...there was an inner harmowas a Catholic or an Anglican...
...I am a writer...
...633-2252, Ext...
...Anthony Messenger Press hooks are available at your rhapsody of words...
...WORK OF THE ANGELS by Fr...
...The AT ST JOHN'S institutions most Catholics are connected with are civil and secular...
...The,lirnortat (.enter for the L1/itp...
...all the sciences ultimately depends...
...Susan Sr...
...Part showing how relentless the destructive where travellers lodge" (instead of the tra1 is written more or less in the Annales power of the iconoclastic temper could be...
...Catholics LISTEN...
...14.95 paper Available^krfy 1993...
...say the skeptics: then what means the antipapal tone of King John...
...W...
...Elizabeth's systematic dismantling of parochial Catholicism were the people of English Catholicism from Henry's first not just to specialists of the time but to any robbed of that necessary oxygen that inklings of disquiet over the lack of a male student of religion-a rare example of unmakes Christian sacramental life possible...
...June 28 }nrrr rhrrrr6 in th, rite u hrn s n s ahui•J,,+m bane• to Fri...
...offers Jesus' radical redefinition of very spirit of ll„0 hook...
...sides myself were taken aback by the ve- the grit of Hispanic women" hemence of Madeline Marget's criticism -.MARIA ICi1.FSIAS...
...Why was since 1s~~s...~~ it assumed that only the most demotic and colloquial English would serve the needs FOR INFO RMA710N ABOUT of the faithful...
...EXPERIENCE...
...30: 12 March 1993 Commonweal Goob News for Book Lovers THIS SPRING C New...
...of the world, upon which the security of 1 ,)p...
...Not only does this weird cirsembling the relatively "silent" evidence realizes that the book has 654 pages, not cumlocution substitute a clumsy phrase for of wills, tombstones, mnemonic lyrics including the glossy inserts of 141 pho- a perfectly suitable English term, but it also used to teach catechism to the unlettered, tographs intercalated throughout part 1.) cannot help but conjure up the motel chain etc., while part 2 is narrative history at its The publisher's blurb on the dust-jack- Travellers' Lodge, with its logo of a Teddy most thrilling...
...cluding one of Christ's Scourging at the Bible now used in Catholic services...
...ditional "there was no room for them at school of historiography, patiently as- (The $45 price might seem steep until one the inn...
...July 16...
...vast and teeming book: what Shakespeare Commonweal 12 March 1993: 27 What then caused the break with tradition and how did it succeed, seemingly so effortlessly...
...My small point, a famil"Experimenting iar one, is that we have now raised a genwith tradition eration of Catholics who have no sense of the cadence of biblical prose...
...I have people who feel It's good to be human-and to be God's grateful for my writings and wish to do Ghetto...
...NURTURE...
...In many ways to be certain he is not goring someone's (Continued from page 2) I resemble him...
...Or, on a change, Catholic instincts, hope for a Judging by the ample photographs ac- much more minor scale, some of the liturspeedy restoration of the old ways, and companying the text, this metaphor, it gical reforms after Vatican II...
...church family: "Whoever does God's leruLkMt' -MADELEINE L'ENGLE will is coy brother and sister...
...You are the only writer since Dante who has found a way to make poetry out of theology...
...something in return...
...Recognizing M A R C H 2 0 that we are called to be countercultural, THE VOCATION OF THE LAITY IN THE WORLD: we see no particular benefit in supporting The Spirituality of Work...
...COWLEY PUBLICATIONS 28 Temple Place ' Boston, MA 02111 ' 1.800.225.1534 ' 617 423.2354 FAX...
...it's overwhelming...
...Tudor thrift, combined to struggle against seems, can also be taken literally...
...sideration of others, and his sense of To the Editors: David Carlin's column on CAMILLUS THIBAULT, A.A humor...
...For some of us, that is neither a problem nor an anomaly...
...i/l /ir drmi/r...
...try...
...Christian hclief, Countryman seeks to -FRET) CR.\ni1C)C.'K, froth the horeword reintroduce the figure of Jesus and his _ 1 Ier insight, poetic style, and good offer of a relationship of love to each one humor area delight to read...
...What ghetto...
...Phone: Cred Card...
...Under55...
...The sheer Longtime readers of Commonweal the instinctive obedience of well-schooled amount of destruction of statues and fres- might recall (now Appeals Court Judge) subjects, in a conflict not strong enough coes-heads and hands lopped off, choir John Noonan's article several years back for resistance, but which ensured wide- stalls vandalized, paintings defaced (in- lamenting the pedestrian translations of the spread inertia and concealment...
...405 Sinto, Spokane, WA 99202...
...Egypt after the advent of Islam...
...Mass included...
...BOX 300,GARRISON, NY 10524-0300 astonishing and magnificent piece of work...
Vol. 120 • March 1993 • No. 5
