Correspondence
CORRESPONDENCE between the public and the Catholic church Getting it...
...that kind of in- Gays and women are not "the enemy," vantage with a firm that is fighting them for market share across their product line...
...they would be at a competitive disadone's human rights to it...
...I want to add a thought to the con- "no comment," on the one hand, and on institution...
...Second-class postage paid at New York, N.Y...
...0 males to defend their own sense of selfworth...
...To the Editors: I've read numerous artiIn his final paragraph, Mr...
...Those spared alive without your help...
...These views, in my opinion, versation about confidentiality in these the other the revealing of the identities ignore relevant facts and rest on unproved types of cases ["Priests & Sex," November of victims and accused...
...American workers would be betmy, agriculture and trade...
...Gays and les- your sisters and brothers, mothers and faFictions is an ambitious and insightful ex- bians are simply right to protest a policy thers, friends, neighbors...
...That's the crucial issue Baltimore, Maryland 21298-9664 ~ ADDRESS facing the UAW, conveniently overlooked 50 CITY STATE ZIP by Mr...
...are risking their own lives to bring food ican firms compete and pay benchmark Fighting among numerous military factions and medical supplies to the Somalis...
...Microfilm from Vol...
...Labor unions, like companies, die each month...
...Two thousand every day...
...Why sponse from officialdom that they resort- evasions...
...Devastated Somalis, means more than just goodwill - it means as aggressive in defending their markets desperate for sixty thousand tons that children and adults who are staring of food every month, face the horror death in the face will have a chance to see through technology and the jobs it supports...
...CORRESPONDENCE of macho superiority...
...Box 1700 tain on that practice...
...in short, human ploration of how Catholic culture in the that punishes them for what they are, not beings deserving of respect...
...tomorrow...
...We need to extend that new Paul Valerry...
...Carlin ac- cles on the Caterpillar-UAW struggle but (Continued from page 2) knowledges that institutionalism is not a none so onesided as Kevin Kelly's does concern for defending one's rights pro- good enough reason to reject women in "Labor's Metamorphosis" [January 15...
...THE EDITORS CAROLSTANTON 2: 26 February 1993 Commonweal and others are glossed over...
...heritage...
...For all of these stitutionalism needs a healthy infusion of not even for bishops and generals...
...Why would people take stitution was the first and most formidable and pastoral environment...
...p. 29, Jean Charlot...
...is a great need for reassurance for the because they have a "profound personal victims, the victims' families, and for commitment to promoting and defending the public at large...
...mitted to the good of the institution, as the mer chancellor of the New York City It is the same for the church...
...10, 14, 22, Baloo, Rothco...
...While New York, N.Y...
...Pattern bargaining is a relzszon lumnttohelpslapthesuffering...
...To the Editors: I have just read the edito- lem will prove to be the healthiest of in- To the Editors: David R. Carlin, Jr., writes rial in your issue of January 15 ["Live & terventions, we will continue to suffer ["Bishops & Generals," January 15] that Let Live...
...And claimUnited States has created a consistent, for doing anything "contrary to good order ing what you believe is your due is not a though complex, alternative to what and discipline...
...cover-ups...
...Serials Data program No.: ISSN 00103330...
...Single Copy, $2...
...WHAT DOES THAT MAKE STARVATION...
...what they subscriptions, U.S., $36...
...than a consistent "no comment...
...portunity to reassure the public that poli- are now serving in the armed forces, even The reason so many victims felt they cies are in place, that the incidents are though, if their orientation becomes known, had to go public was their perception that being handled by responsible people, they are automatically subject to dishonthe official church was not taking their ac- and that there are opportunities for peo- orable discharge, with its long-term negacusations seriously...
...Commonweal Foundation...
...the phrasing of his admission adds new Caterpillar's prime competitor, which In my view, supporting an institution injury: "If your enemy advances a legiti- signed a less costly labor agreement than (whether the military, the priesthood, or mate claim on you, you have no choice the UAW demanded of Caterpillar...
...that's a lifetime...
...Unfortunately, the trade-off of poor worker morale resulting from declining the contract becomes the lesser of two evils...
...bad" motive...
...aia ic of the days when large corporations were Here's my conMbuhon of., FYesI l E:1'2O E' Other cozy with their unions and could pass CATHOLIC RELIEF SERVICES_ Your gift -ofanysize -can make a difference...
...Tens of thousands practice...
...It makes little sense to bargain for a structure that reduces competitiveness and jobs...
...by the bullets are at the mercy of famine, Make a generous contribution and ter served if other large corporations were as drought and war combine to wipe out make a difference...
...bank...
...Rothco...
...of starvation...
...The posing of assumptions...
...foreign, $41...
...dollars by International Money inists' 'panentheism,' but as Johnson the Catholic church we are finally real- Order or b check on a U.S...
...forshould have read: "The essayists in Speak- cannot accept is the institutional secreeign, $72...
...It was often it publicly and then do it, over and over living duplicitous lives if they did not sinonly after repeated efforts to get some re- again...
...Correspondence, January 15 & such questions creates a very real op- Gays and lesbians, as everyone knows, February 12, 1993...
...Only with high-tech investment can AmerEvery day in Somalia is a living night- Your support is a lifeline...
...11, 21, Ross, Rothco...
...CRS workers mare that's horrifyingly out of control...
...InterGiving Hope To A World Of Need tNAME national competition has closed the curSomalia Emergenc Fund ' P.O...
...derlies a great deal of the very best Roman wisdom to the larger public, within and pp...
...What is really at stake is an old labor A million and a half people are in dan- To charge your contribution, call ger of starvation...
...But has virtually collapsed the nation's econo- we can not keep these starving victims wages...
...of "radical individualism," which makes nications director with direct and recent When the media (or concerned peo- them indifferent to the good of institutions...
...thing Fundamental Is Afoot" [January 29] these cases, seems to cover otherwise pas- and at additional offices...
...Yearly pears in the third column on page 19, People understand sickness...
...If any other) does not mean deriving one's but to give him his due, even if he advances Caterpillar agreed to the UAW's terms, personal identity from it or subordinating the claim from bad motives...
...20, 1992...
...JIM McCRE Quentin Anderson called the American If I may speak of my own experience From the editors: Other aspects of this doctrine of "the imperial self...
...26, 27, Punch, Catholic theology of this century...
...church leaders are indeed being re- reflects the gay movement's philosophy To the Editors: I am a diocesan commu- sponsible...
...7, 20, ing of God's revelation to the world un- their families...
...this is the price we pay for past cerely want to be part of the institution...
...shows, some version of that understand- izing this when it comes to victims and Illustrations: Cover, Emil Antonucci...
...Copyright © 1993 was changed...
...Canada, $66...
...Special two-year rate: U.S...
...We need to say such risks and suffer the mental anguish of obstacle many victims faced...
...This commitment, he says, Orlando, Fla...
...1, 1924, to current issues available through University Correction Because of an editing up" in the minds of people who have Microfilm, 300 N. Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48106 error, the meaning of a sentence in Luke come face to face with the frustrating and and on Microfiche from Bell & Howell, Wooster, Timothy Johnson's review/essay "Some- impenetrable mask of secrecy which, in Ohio 44691...
...outside the church family...
...Canada, $39...
...All Canadian and foreign subscriptions ing the Christian God worried about fem- cy which makes them feel invisible...
...vide proof positive of a radically individ- the priesthood or gays in the military, but Not once does he mention Komatsu, ualist and anti-institutional spirit...
...If gays and lesbians can carry out UAW overreaches military assignments as well as straight men, what happens to the male mystique Amarillo, Tex...
...In must be paid in U.S...
...1.800-SEND-HOPE have to change...
...The denial by the in- ple to air their larger concerns in a safe tive consequences...
...And right now, for Somalis, The death rate is staggering...
...in the long term the "outing" of the prob- Piedmont, Calif...
...I would suggest that this is a (Continued on page 30) ed to our society's communal laundromat, more productive and healing response Commonweal is indexed in Reader's Guide to the media...
...Congratulations...
...experience of handling the public aspects ple outside the media) ask questions, in Carlin's terms, "they could care less" of several incidents of sexual abuse by the the choice of response is not limited to about the well-being of the military as an clergy...
...CORRESPONDENCE between the public and the Catholic church Getting it right Gays in the military in the arena of clerical sexual abuse...
...It raises the right issues and from the results of our past denial and the real reason military leaders do not want sets the right tone...
...Kelly JOHN MARMADUKE L 30: 26 February 1993 Commonweal...
...They will need to what they conceive to be the rights of gays The price of evasion hear out loud, and more than once, that and lesbians...
...It is not Periodical Literature, Catholic Periodical Index, A very real credibility gap does exist the fault of the media that "no com- Index of American Periodical Verse, Book Review ment" has come to be translated "cover- Digest and Book Review Index...
...wage increases on to the consumer...
...they are difficulties, American Catholic Arts and the "individualistic spirit...
...I understand Caterpillar has invested billions in state-of-the-art manufacturing to prevent losing market share to Komatsu...
...The family alcoholic or the fam- openly gay and lesbian people admitted FRANK J. MACCHIAROLA ily abuser may proclaim reformations, to the armed services is that those pushThe writer is dean of the Cardozo School but for family members it is only new be- ing for this change of policy are not comof Law at Yeshiva University and a for- havior that will heal the lack of trust...
...Many corporations that have acceded to the UAW's pattern bargaining have subsequently seen layoffs and declining growth...
...There generals are, but are advocating change school system...
...Your involvement food sources...
...Readers in the military-eight years with the Air issue are discussed in columns by David who once imagined that all Americans are Force-it taught me that the exclusion of R. Carlin and John Garvey, pages 8 and the direct intellectual descendants of uncloseted homosexuals from the military 9, respectively, an "Editor's Notebook," Cotton Mather, Emerson, and Whitman serves mainly to perpetuate self-serving page 4, and an article by George M. will discover the new world of a diverse myths cherished by white heterosexual Anderson, S.J., page 16...
...The sentence, which ap- toral faces...
Vol. 120 • February 1993 • No. 4
