Innocent Ecstasy
Modras, Ronald
elites found the revival of Thomism and thoritatively in the pastorals on nuclear Kurtz's study makes it clear that neo-scholastic philosophy and theology weapons and the...
...No one has stated the situation more seventies lost any sense of original sin...
...None...
...Why then am I distresCort's criticism that Gutierrez has sed...
...original sin to physical pathology and i.e., the neo-scholastic position that reli- In a chapter on "Catholic Sensual- religion to a health regimen...
...At least 2 stock): Commonweal Foundation, 15 Dutch St., New York, don't accuse Gutierrez of being secretive years relevant experience in Latin NY 10038...
...Managing Editor, Anne Robertson, gram (Costa Rica...
...of Posiitfons issues published annually: 22...
...They have been vic- The National Association for Lay Ministry timized for centuries precisely because Suite 2-67 (R) their traditions of communal ownership 1125 West Baseline Road Mesa, AZ 85202 were not and are not recognized by the Spanish and their descendants...
...ments: French fluency...
...Gardella draws a the Vatican on the magisterium, nar- husband if she herself had not experi- line connecting the victory over sin rowly defined, is still at issue, e.g., the enced climax...
...have legal title to the land...
...trees Diste~sfdng insist.nc...
...1 certify that the statements made by me above are society in which private ownership of the NYC benefits...
...While liberation theology...
...3. Frequency of issue: Biweekly, except politicians...
...Letters of not more than Spiritual Classics on Cassette - "Brother rendered in a riot over inhuman prison 250 or 300 words naturally have a better Lawrence: The Practice of the Presence conditions...
...elites found the revival of Thomism and thoritatively in the pastorals on nuclear Kurtz's study makes it clear that neo-scholastic philosophy and theology weapons and the economy...
...tion of womanhood in Mary are de- revolution in Europe (Holland, Britain, scribed as...
...If we are to Such literature is indicted for increasing ing a sociological analysis of the Mod- believe Peter Gardella, they have all both the amount and explicitness of disernist controversy, and drawing out the helped to shape America's contemporary course about sex...
...It is Cort, not Gutierrez, the place of the people he criticizes...
...Al- Evangelical Christianity made its conversus the modern consciousness of the phonsus Liguori's opinion that, without tribution to the cause of guilt-free sex historical and contextual character of all incurring guilt, a woman could bring her- with its zeal to promote emotional conhuman utterances...
...Most are engaged in the formation and support of various types of NATIONAL co-operatives, just as Cort himself advo- ASSOCIATION cates...
...2. Returns from news agents: 813...
...It allows the author to move, sometimes in the same paragraph, Commonweal Editorial, October 18, 1985 from Catholic to Protestant, evangelical to mainstream, from the Middle Ages to the Victorian era, allowing inferences to replace argument, and association to Six months for $9 for new subscribers serve as a substitute for careful defini- w.r.w~w----rw-r~ ----w.~a~~a.wrrww.wa.~rwir I tion, whether of original sin or ecstasy...
...The Indian heritage of Peru and most other South American nations (and of JOIN THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR LAY Gutierrez himself) was based in localized MINISTRY, A VOICE FOR YOU, A NETWORK forms of communal property.The peas- THAT SHARES YOUR CONVICTIONS...
...The Welfare State has in "every Marxist is a frustrated agrarian...
...Cort's call for Gutierrez and other lib- Each 60 min...
...gious truth is universal and unchanging ity," Gardella makes much of St...
...politics of an activist Peruvian theologian vate ownership for its own sake...
...This is a recur- changed his mind since he expressed it in that deals not only with the social teachrent stress in the book cited, and it in- 1973...
...copies printed (Net Press Run): 22,115...
...I hope he himself will make that preference for profit-sharing, participacratic society" (p.49...
...But many have only squat- private ownership...
...Gardella states his thesis in the first Seventh Day Adventist, was convinced A comparison and contrast between sentence of the Introduction...
...Bishop Francis Kenrick through religious experience and what he question by Rome about the right of the wrote of the husband's duty to assist his calls the victory over sin through sexual U.S...
...COMMONWEAL, 15 Statement of Ownership...
...political reality and lift the world...
...Guatemala, but in our own time, in OnNew York, N.Y...
...L...-- -------rarrr-w~wrsr---1 10 October 1986: 539 of Latin America, liberal, privateSalaueed & realistic property regimes have deprived Indians of their communal holdings (some of BECOME A 1986 New Holstein, Wis...
...2) The conflict between status in an organization and sets of nuanced manner of describing the rela- science and religion has abated, and the ideas, worldviews, or theologies...
...I share the popes' power . . . the desire for a truly demo- news...
...of God...
...And As for Gutierrez on class struggle, on the basis of a few brief political state- yes, liberation theologians do sometimes Cort presents no evidence that Gutierrez ments in those theological documents censure peasants intent on private own- or any liberation theologian condemns all translated into English, Cort should ership, when the privileged few who employers as unjust or enemies...
...bishops' conference to teach au- wife to climax in such a situation...
...I am distressed because I believe Free booklet: TITUS BRANDSMA: FRIAR abandoned reform for revolution is Cort "reads into" Gutierrez far more AGAINST FASCISM...
...Such bickering brings to mind that campesino...
...Hardly any of the OECD vide for credit, technical assistance, or third-world peoples to establish "dic- countries fails to subsidize its agricul- security against debt, and loss of holdings tatorships of the proletariat (politburo)" ture...
...it cisms of liberation theology...
...I have found no basis Such criticism assumes the needs of the John XXIII through John Paul II which at all for Cort's charges against Gustavo poor are prior to title to property...
...As for the suggestion that the nationalization, "a truly democratic sosocialism, why would he insist that the Latin American peasant, still in the ciety," and "a society that exercises no term "socialism" requires "the use of majority, doesn't want a piece of land of kind of coercion, from whatever source" cautious language and careful distinc- his own, this is an original idea that cries (p...
...The dele- tasy that once private ownership of pro(1970-1973) and Nicaragua when they, gates at the convention of Christians for duction is eliminated, we will see "a new in principle at least, have insisted on Socialism in Santiago, Chile, did not man" and a new society where "the state "mixed economies" and the retention of agree with you, even though they obvi- will wither away...
...Direct all inquiries to: Mr...
...Masters In Agricul- immediately thereunder the names and addresses of stockholpopular projects of Gutierrez et al...
...CHRISTINE GUDORF rity holders owning or holding I per cent or mere of total America...
...implications for an analysis of social ethic of guilt-free sex...
...ants Cort seems so concerned for are not being urged by liberation theologians to turn to state capitalism from private own- For information, write: ership systems...
...From Catholic moralists Sylvester Graham prescribed his cracker root problem is still that of authority - and Victorian physicians to obscure for the same reasons...
...To urge Gutierrez to clarify his position would be a worthy contribution...
...T. HOWLAND SANKS, S.l., is Dean of the Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley...
...evitable...
...This book that children begotten in passion would the Modernist controversy and the con- describes how Christian influences, become obsessed with sex themselves...
...Under a ludicrous shibboleth, "It doesn't matter often happened, those who had legal title liberal capitalist regime, land is in fact "a what you believe as long as you're sin- to the private property in land had only to commodity like any other...
...Small holders must now defend themselves Lot him go to Poru state...
...But the fear stitutions such as the World Bank...
...The risk to ing regime...
...suspicion that all passion is tainted...
...He intends, 1 15 Dutch St., New York, N.Y...
...Kurtz then outlines the likewise held responsible for the sexual various forms of control, both informal Ronald Modtras revolution...
...E. Total distribution (sum of I acknowledge that he found a "smoking C and D): 19,433...
...2. Mail subscriptions: 17,772...
...since they do not have the means to do so, which are both tragic and inevitable in The unfortunate rivalry between liber- historically the liberal state had neither Latin America under a liberal landholdation theologians and the Holy Office is the intention nor the desire...
...If Cort wants to know St., New York, NY 10038...
...Bishop Francis Kenrick of flourishing genre of "anti-Catholic porThe author achieves his three-fold goal Philadelphia, John Kellogg of nography" capable of finding its way of showing how orthodoxy is constructed the corn flake, and Sylvester Graham of into the most proper of Protestant homes...
...NY 10038...
...Alphonsus Liguori, bacy and the confessional gave rise to a sponse by the "dissident insiders...
...really was a self-conscious movement with a social structure, sharing a broad outline of ideas, a desire to reform the The sensuous Christian Roman Catholic church, and a loose network of "members" held together by INISCEIT ECSTEUT Though Kenrick would more than likely conversations, correspondence (Kurtz HOW CHRISTIANITY GAVE AMERICA demur, Gardella reads this as "an details the evidence for this), distribution AN ETHIC OF SEXUAL PLEASURE explicit shift of concern from conception of writings, reviewing books, and finan- to pleasure...
...A Conjustice in present Latin American sys- party...
...3) The controversy flicting parties...
...Gardella recognizes the problem of historical causality and admits that the COM ON WEAL contemporary attitude toward sex did not result from any single factor...
...7. Owner (If owned by a read the newspapers, and explore the corporation...
...drop...
...in his debt...
...meet Marx's criticism of wage labor as Gutierrez contributed but was not the Booklet dehumanizing...
...I agree with his concern about English & Spanish fluency...
...Commonweal: 540 In response to Cort's criticisms I can that is their only hope of protecting their not necessitate opposition to any and all only urge him to follow the advice in his land tenure...
...2. Mail subscripcomplete elimination of private own- tions: 17,332...
...For information: The Rev...
...If the campesino resisted, as tion by the rich and powerful...
...2. Returns from news agents: 802...
...Those Or call: 602-839-9785 few peasants who possess land deeds do desire registered titles (for some nations have blocked title registration in whole regions for over fifteen years) because 10 October 1986: 541 profits of the enterprises in which they agree with Cort's criticisms of many Human Resources, Catholic Relief Servwork, but in management decisions as statements made by the Christians for ices, 1011 First Avenue, New York, N.Y...
...Private property has never meant family farms, small businesses, and wide 40 distribution of property as it once meant The book that commemorates the Peace Corps'25th Anniversary in the U.S...
...which had survived three centuries of COMMONWEAL ASSOCIATE To the Editors: Though intrigued by the Spanish rule), and by subjecting all land number of outraged responses to your to the vagaries of the market, eventually Patron Member $200 or more May 9 editorial and to Edward Sheehan's deprived campesinos of their land...
...Total number copies printed (Net Press Run): Latin America (N.Y.C...
...The evangelical belief that Commonweal: 538 perfection could be attained in a moment quality which it inherited from Chris- original sin and has made its own impact of religious ecstasy helped to remove the tianity's zeal to overcome sin and experi- on popular American culture...
...remarks on the different kinds of prop- are helpless to prevent this, and given our Cape Breton, Canada erty, as well as with the same pope's socio-economic regime, some of them To the Editors: With respect to John C. censure of unbridled competition under prefer it...
...2) The issue tells the story of the "struggle to over- science and religion led him to reduce of the nature of religious truth remains - come original sin...
...To Father McGovern: I second -most the voice of, and ruler of, the "masses...
...Again, this is not to historical context outside the church is scholar, and for the critic who wishes to contend that such an identification of not the same as that of the nineteenth remain a "deviant insider...
...in business, public administration, eco- tary and other free copies: 1,100...
...So ence salvation...
...It may, in fact, be true that Latin against multinational corporations or na- Cincinnati, Ohio American peasants, like most peasants, tional industrial enterprises funded by in- To the Editors: After reading John Cort's have a strong desire for land...
...The reforms President P. W. able, to free contraception from associa- Botha announced in a series of disappointing tion with free love and socialism which addresses this summer fell decidedly short would have otherwise barred its ac- of substantive change...
...27, We Drink from Our Own Wells...
...Even here in cere...
...Gardella regularly equates original sin "Power," he said recently, "must be given with sexual concupiscence...
...But at this point, I believe that "Savor just a little of what the Peace Corps generation felt back there so Cort reads into Gutierrez far more than long ago, the joy of hearing a new idea, a challenge, from an exciting Gutierrez states...
...3) The emphasis by self to orgasm after intercourse with her version experiences...
...plained a few years back that twentyI know John Cort well enough to know eight acres of prime farm land were going that he is quite familiar with Pius XI's under asphalt every day...
...STEPHEN SETTLE to the 1920s and '30s...
...Demonstrated managerial capability, at by mail, carrier or other means, sample complimentary and other free copies: 1,348...
...besides speaking and with order...
...The peasants who is "imposing European abstracMore specifically, before criticizing the want land to farm...
...a social revolution which organizes ring often in Cardinal Ratzinger's criti- Write: Brandsma Office, PO Box 65, Dapopular, participative social structures...
...F. 1. Office use, left over, unaccounted, nomics or related field...
...Kurtz's study thus enaOne further contribution Kurtz makes has shifted from doctrinal issues to prob- bles us to keep some perspective on to our understanding of the Modernist lems of morality, e.g., contraception, present controversies, and for this we are controversy is to firmly establish that it abortion, homosexuality, and divorce...
...Management and Circulation (am of August 12, 1970: Section 3685, Title 39, United States Code...
...33577, (813) 955weeks the threat of a military coup se- insistence on "the masses appropriating 4263...
...Even if they capitalism are wasted in the socialist From the institution of liberal private did, they could not afford the lawyers camp he claims...
...His state- Florida...
...well...
...This is hardly a new opening paragraphs and put himself in ters' rights, whether based on five years idea in theology...
...pact of science and technology (the au- Correspondence With all these precursors in the popu- tomobile, the pill, a naturalistic view of lar culture, it was left only for Margaret sex as a function), or taken some cogni- (Continued from page 514) Sanger to proclaim the gospel of redemp- zance of Jewish tradition which knows but to prophetically read the "signs of the tion through sex...
...Auricle Productions, Dept...
...Each cleric has shown that he can call in the soldiers...
...calls for nationalizing all property, nor Cort vastly overrates the possibility for for placing all power in the hands of one "Building Genuine Community...
...Which is too bad, for percent of the population controls 71 per- not directed to Father Gutierrez's ac- his influence, for many good reasons, is cent of the land (Michael Todaro, Eco- tivities in Peru, which are surely worthy substantial and will probably remain so...
...Country Representative (Haiti...
...in Latin America 1.3 To Christine Gudorf.• My critique was ward conclusions...
...B. Paid Circulation: I. Sales through dealers and carJuly 111...
...The Battle for Nicaragua," I was de- Under this regime land becomes a com- Charter Member $100 lighted to discover in that same July 11 modity like any other...
...There will their respective interests with a particular century - the church is not facing a remain "elective affinities" between the set of ideas was a conscious or malicious grave political crisis and anti-clericalism interests of groups with a certain social act...
...fear Gutierrez has not thought these quesunderstand Gutierrez's desire for a radi- To Jordan Bishop: No argument...
...D. Free disfield experience in Latin America...
...the Hebrew tive share in the exercise of political biguously democratic," that is good prophets, and Moses...
...A. No...
...1. Title of publication: COMMONWEAL...
...in bad years serve only to legitimize totally divorced from the agrarian ideals Not only do most Latin American re- further losses of land, losses which are of self-determination amid commun- gimes not protect small landholders, poignant enough in Iowa or Ontario, but ity...
...I would welcome that since I find him too COME AS YOU ARE vague and utopian...
...rien, IL 60559-5341...
...One wonders if he would Gardella has done an impressive too St...
...C. Total paid circulation: 18,333...
...D. Free distribution Detroit, Mich...
...identifying female ecstasy France), given more thought to the imwith religious fulfillment...
...monthly in advance for more granting interviews, he is known to be a than three times...
...We more women and men in decision-making must bring Indo-American socialism to and leadership positions, life within our own reality" (A Theology of Liberation, p. 90), he might have got- If you support a collaborative approach to discussing ten a clue that Gutierrez and his compan- church issues and reconciling church conflicts, ions do not feel limited to the European choices of private property or state If you think lay consultants should be present at the 1987 Synod on the Laity in Romecapitalism which Cort recognizes...
...Masters tribution by mail, carrier or other means, sample complimenership and about democratic institutions...
...printing: 1134...
...1 His occasional attenuations not- Please send the next 6 months of commonweal to: withstanding, he still maintains that our Name American sexual ethic has a religious Address...
...friend and advisor to leading leftist Dutch St., NYC 10038...
...If of the condemnation of that simple iden- not, the explosion we have been fearing will tification at the Council of Trent...
...tions through to their complex and awkcal transformation...
...F. t .Office use, left ova, unaccounted, spoiled after To the Editors: I was distressed by John ence...
...MICHAEL CANDELARIA for contraception is traced to her association with socialists, Sanger articulated her message in religious language drawn from Catholic and Methodist influences in her background...
...I am also willing to admit Gutierrez might confirm what Cort interprets him to hold (though I do not THE PEACE CORPS STORY think so...
...I can ously would have liked to...
...popular culture...
...Why has he supported both Chile have a vote on the question...
...This entire trend has developed to Socialism in 1972 (a document to which 10022...
...spoiled after printing: %5...
...E. Total distribution (sum of C cad D): least 2 years relevant overseas experi- 20,168...
...They that he would have taken greater account have to sit together to discuss their future...
...temporary conflict between theologians working through popular culture, led his breakfast cereals were designed and and the Vatican hierarchy (e.g., Kung, Americans to seek ecstatic pleasure and promoted to preserve the race from deSchillebeeckx, Boff, Curran) seems in- to expect freedom from guilt in their sex- cline with their anti-aphrodisiac effect...
...A better way must be tried...
...Requirements: Eng- 15 Dutch St., New York...
...succintly than Zambia's Kenneth Kaunda...
...If Father Gutierrez is moving to- ing of the popes, but with that of many cludes political democracy: "an effec- ward "a socialism that is more unam- others, including Jesus...
...chance of being published...
...Require- Average number of copies each issue during preceding 12 months: A. Total no...
...JORDAN BISHOP and "the right of the peasant to own land, Today in Latin America the old terfree from the fear of expropriation by the ratenientes are on the defensive...
...Small Business Projects Coordinator for Actual number of copies of a single issue published nearest to V 'Christians and the Class Struggle," filing date...
...Writing theology which is monthly Christmas-New Years and July and August...
...Dr...
...In the last few cited by Cort, continued rather with an Ave., Sarasota, Fla...
...sociological ambivalence will remain for helpful in defending an unchanging and Some differences: (1) The socio- the Vatican hierarchy, for the priesttimeless orthodoxy...
...My article political management (The Power of the on this essential question if he had was a small part of a forthcoming book Poor in History, p. 38...
...The Second Vatican Council adopted a posi- of these conclusions are based on the fact Modernist controversy is partially ex- tive attitude toward the modern world that they are rooted in social structures plained by this increasing affinity on both rather than the defensive posture at the and not in the personalities of the consides...
...young adventurer, and the greater joy of watching that idea become a ARTHUR F. McGOVERN, S.J...
...Catholic social teaching extending from associates in Peru...
...occupancy or five hundred...
...few are intent on pri- tions" on the peasants...
...5. Location of the headquarters of general business offices of the publishers: 15 Dutch St., New his Peruvian politics to U.S., French, or seeking the following positions for its Latin York, NY 10038...
...If Cort were aware of Gutierrez's oft stated approval for the sentiments of Peruvian Marxist If you are personally and professionally committed Carlos Mariategui: "We certainly do not to lay ministry, wish for socialism in America to be an If you believe that church structures should involve exact copy of others' socialism...
...To Michael Candelaria: I did not warmly the suggestion that Gutierrez But is it fair to interpret Gutierrez as mean to imply that Gutierrez opposes clarify his views on "the masses appromeaning this...
...vendors and counter sales: 1,048...
...2. Date of filing: September 29, 1986...
...Significant riers, street vendors and counter sales: 1,001...
...they are open...
...Peru's President Garcia was one would expect to find them stated 30, 31, and November 1, 1986, Sarasota, elected on pledges of socio-economic re- somewhere in all his works...
...some- cases attempted to mitigate the Memberships are tax-deductible What he did not concede, however, is harshness of the impact of this regime on that Marxists purposely exploit the small landholders when crops are too bad legitimate hopes and frustrations of or too good...
...Editor, Peter Steinfels, 15 Dutch Gutierrez's politics, let him go to Peru, Associate ilairectorICentral America Pro- St., New York, NY 10038...
...Although her crusade about sexual guilt without a doctrine of times...
...makes lively reading:" ----Publishers Weekly The author replies: "A wealth of anecdotes...
...A PO Box 3157, Morganton, NC 28655major cause for Rome's opposition is that RATES: 75¢ a word, one time...
...Both tionship between interests and ideas...
...68¢, three 3151...
...is one of many targets of the Peruvian Gutierrez never, to my knowledge, Conference guerrilla movement, Sendero Luminoso...
...Hugh Sidey "Coates Redmon's often humorous account of the unique character of the Corps...
...Marxist-Leninists have made themselves Central and South America...
...forms" in Central America in the 1870s the dreams of many peasants, indi- But one expects a socialist to use and 1880s, and indeed throughout much vidualistic land reforms that do not pro- socialist, not capitalist arguments...
...Peas- "Christians and Class Struggle," I am of expropriation by the state does not ants whose land is taken over often do not sure that Cort's talents for defending have a large place in their experience...
...Such scenes were Canada, an Ontario Member of the be sincere, though at times sincerely normal in the Andean countries right up Legislative Assembly (MLA) comwrong...
...tape, $9.95 postpaid, both eration theologians to be open about their Classified for $17.95...
...time of Modernism...
...64¢, six times...
...it does urges that workers not only share in the Gutierrez, either in the many social/ political projects which have spun off from Gutierrez's Bartolome de Las Casas Center in Lima, or among the many students and followers of Gutierrez who work in the church, in social work, and in politics in Peru...
...That revolution, however, is than is stated, a failing I also find occur- Dachau martyr's resistance to the Nazis...
...In a similar vein, magisterial and papal authority versus novelists and Margaret Sanger, Gardella Horace Bushnell's efforts to reconcile the authority of the scholar...
...The small are gobbled alternative is to work until they Cort's assumptions concerning peasants up by the big...
...John Harvey Kellogg, a leading change and social movements...
...Classified payable secret in Peru...
...First, some similarities: (1) The ual relations...
...There is no basis either in Gutierrez's writings or his praxis for Cort's FOR LAY JIL state capitalism charges...
...Kirkus Reviews To Paul Sigmund: We Drink from Our Own Wells is indeed a deeply spiritual by COATES REDMON meditation on the poverty and martyr- Now at bookstores dom of Latin Americans struggling HARCOURT against injustice...
...stonewalling rather than foundation buildSo it is, we are told, that first liberal ing...
...M. Scott Peck, October tems...
...Robert Stull, Institute for Christian Studies, form now stalemated by the opposition of ment on elimination of private property, Church of the Redeemer, 222 S. Palm the rich and the army...
...I many forms of private property...
...they can sell farm land to develCort's article on liberation theology, I an individualistic and liberal regime of opers and retire on the proceeds...
...One wishes to all the people of South Africa...
...amount of bonds, mortgages or other securities...
...through conflicts about heresy, provid- the cracker have in common...
...City , State, Zip RONALD MODRAS was co-author of the 1 01 prefer a full year's subscription at $28 MAO/" 1 Catholic Theological Society's Study, Human Sexuality...
...preferred) in development related field...
...Ontario farmers Kaybo true, but...
...4. Location of known office of publication: 15 Dutch St., oblige him to also write tracts explaining Catholic Relief Services - U.S.C.C., is New York, NY 10038...
...10038 1 1 he says, only "to tell a plausible story...
...Also, I have too much respect for his intelligence to believe that he would 10 October 1986: 543...
...15 Dutch St...
...Requirements: 21,200...
...It is alienable and Sustaining Member $50 issue yet another balanced and realistic often - in hard times - alienated, not critique of liberation theology, this one only in Mexico, Brazil, Peru, or Commonweal Associates by John Cort...
...private property...
...nomic Development in the Third World, of our admiration, but rather to his writ- JOHN CORT p. 260...
...private ownership of consumer goods or priating the means of production," If Gutierrez believes in Soviet-style houses...
...tions" (A Theology of Liberation, out for supporting evidence...
...G. Total Cort's article on liberation theology (sum of E and F should equal net press run shown in A): 22,115...
...10038 Carlos Fuentes once proposed that tario and Iowa...
...They appear to he ceptance in the American mainstream...
...its name mod address must be stated and also lish & Spanish fluency...
...Protestants in the 1920s and then Catholics and evangelicals in the sixties and...
...course as a "ritual of sexual communion" and sex as a redemptive force with The bloody revolution in South Africa has the "nature of a sacrament," she was begun...
...Peter Gardella cial assistance, the latter mainly from Oxford, $17.95, 210 pp...
...means of production is eliminated...
...But there is nothing in it BRACE that would alter Gutierrez's commitment JOVANOVICH to classical Marxism without the atheistic materialism and the total elimination of the means of production...
...6. Names and addresses of publishes, editor America Region: and managing editor: Publisher, Edward S. Skillin, IS Dutch other audiences...
...That, of take place . . . it will make the French course, is a difficulty with a book that Revolution look like a Sunday school picpurports to be doing a popular study of nic...
...C. Total paid circulation: 18,820...
...Gutierrez's politics are no times...
...correct and complete...
...Liberal and evangelical Protestants are Baron von Hugel...
...self-criticism is good 1857, through the very similar "re- a redistribution of land may loom large in for one's politics as well as one's soul...
...I Lynn Vincent Marshall, Senior Director for Commonweal: 542 the means of production" and their own permit publication in 1983 of an opinion ings as published in English...
...characterized by a mutual reductionism...
...principal author...
...I grant that clear to his readers in North as well as tory management, and co-ownership...
...gun": Gutierrez's statement about "a Full overseas benefits & allowances or Total (sum of E and F should equal net press run shown in A): 21,200...
...B. Annual subscriptions price: translated into other languages does not $28...
...From the 1830s to our own and official, mobilized by the Vatican century, suspicions about clerical celihierarchy and the various modes of re- W HAT do St...
...But ders owning or holding I per cent or more of total amount of tural Economics or related field...
...Bernadette, the screen portrayal have made the same claim and written the amount of research, but he is more inof her by Jennifer Jones, and the idealiza- same book if he had studied the sexual formative than persuasive...
...He toexamine the political/economic projects have land turn their backs on the landless tally fails to deal with the development in supported by that activist and by his in the name of private property rights...
...I welcome criticism of property in the Reforma in Mexico in hired by those who have legal title...
...This is dream stuff...
...experience...
...Bachelors (Master B. Paid Circulation: I. Sale through dealers and carriers...
...Edward S. Skillin, Publisher...
...If these really were his positions, ference Led by Dr...
...Should we The last idea suggests the Marxist phanp. I 11...
...The have a serious problem with some of Mr...
...Gutierrez repeatedly expresses his MINISTRY -1 F political option for socialism, and an indigenous socialism at that...
...The story of a largely true...
...Elective affinity" is a neutral and is not an issue...
...8. Known bondholders, mortgagees and other secuabout his politics...
...verely escalated after Garcia demanded an inquiry into the army massacre of one Cassettes Commonweal welcomes letters on subjects hundred prisoners who had already sur- treated in its pages...
...9, revolutionary politics is ridiculous...
...Fenelon: Spiritual Counsel...
...By exalting interSOUTH AFRICA...
...owning] land came not primarily from It is this background, I think, rather Both Father Gutierrez and Cardinal Rat- the state, but from the fazendeiros, than Marxian dogmatism, that explains zinger indicate a preference for pat, often qamonales, latifundistas, etc., who by the reticence of Gustavo Gutierrez and partisan answers to the timeless issues of fair means or foul (often it mattered not) others to propose the right of the peasant sin and injustice, individual and collec- obtained a legal title to land worked by a to own land "free from fear of expropriative...
...Don't let it be forgot, that once there University of Detroit was a spot...
...Satisfaction Guaranteed...
Vol. 113 • October 1986 • No. 17
