Correspondence
fiber of the American Presidency. Freud sympathetic to. religion. Oh, to be hon- Correspondence told Max Eastman 50...
...all this evil one has to reread chapter journal as Commonweal numbers a good Illustrations: Art o n Cover I and p. 12, BAS.eight of volume one of James Bryce's many non-Catholics among its readers Tachydromos, Greece...
...Chevy Chase careless reading: Throughout the piece I Michael MeHalc...
...Emerson J. More...
...Sudbury...
...I was in Benghazi, from which h logic and per- things always show that the average that raid was mounted, the following he credits Tom reader is a white middle class male 29 Books day...
...If the article is the point...
...was indescribably bad, benefiting the have saved lives-and not all the experts ROBERT W. MARRION Nazis temporarily and the Soviets per- Williams cites (in his very tendentious manently...
...Roger L. Putnam...
...Aileen Moore...
...Reply Thomas J. Higgins...
...Marvin Monct...
...Regarding my Patricia MacManus...
...Newport...
...I Paul LaR(xlue...
...Joseph Gough...
...Duxbury...
...Claremont...
...Chicago (Coruinued from page 29) Rev...
...In now that we know the extent and the fragmented social model...
...It is a To the Editors: Has Commonweal be- the Frank Getlein you will publish, but, schools...
...monthly in )quial...
...What would sharp political judgments and still Invincible ignorance this enlightened progressivist have said sharper film reviews of Colin WesterNiantic, Conn...
...McKeesport...
...Scarsdale...
...Wellesley Hills...
...State College...
...C.F.X...
...Louis his: the B- 17 was the Flying Fortress, but In Memory of Zoo & Louis Lantelmc Hillen J. Smith...
...Write for brochure: Hartley Producimer home in ticularly meaningful sense) is guilty...
...John Shea...
...Wading River...
...Calif...
...Wood...
...Lawrence J. Murtagh...
...And I qualifications for making statements in His words, $3.00...
...2...
...Marianne Willisch...
...Chicago killed in any bombing...
...Peter James Kountz...
...Roland N. Harman...
...Will, some day...
...Peoria R.U...
...Tom R. Houston...
...on its spatial axis, while tions of a Third World War to come...
...Calif...
...Rev...
...Philip M. Reidy...
...Lexington...
...Williams's is that John Gumina...
...84, Mr...
...I Most Rev...
...Mass...
...Minneapolis Rev...
...Toledo Veronica D. Winder...
...We (at least, I believe) Army Air Corps (I tions, Dept...
...which I Lee McC'affrey...
...Los Angeles Mr...
...Dayton...
...Pittsburgh Shirley Esenther...
...know...
...What will we do about it...
...New York Rev...
...s not a scholarly poverished rural area in India encomHenderson, Texas Shame on Commonweal...
...At the very least, the situaBut all I got was a terrific boost to my rors and the concrete Allied tion in 1944 must have been a good deal sense of my own ignorance when I could conditions-with or without the okay of murkier than it is now...
...He any lengths to find something to feel who question the value of the entire tims of hunger by means of a $10 memefeat in the pres- guilty about...
...Camarillo...
...Santa Barbara Mitch & Kathy Finley...
...Seattle age combat range...
...Mrs...
...New York occur...
...Sauk Centre...
...Thomas J. McNulty...
...John McCarthy...
...Rev...
...Souren H. Tashian...
...P. !vlullowly...
...Jemez Springs...
...10003...
...in unverifiable whispers) of the Nazi hor- trying to save...
...Oceanside...
...go down to the boiler room...
...Robert W. Rea...
...but we learn from your turies and an archcriminal...
...Frederick Franck...
...rights and dignity of human beings) up in Dr...
...John Fahey...
...Elba-Maria Stell...
...Henry F. May...
...Simon F. Falvey...
...Detroit Gregory Nugent...
...Murphy...
...Continued on page 29) of non-information and misinformation informations...
...New York Rev...
...Rev...
...tler or the American public would have Joseph Joy...
...New York Mrs.Georgc S. Taylor...
...ie fact that sands Williams certainly raises an issue and v stirring of the partment of War" (and no department, Situation Wanted makes a sound point...
...Robert P. Imbelli...
...Bloomsburg...
...Calif...
...Msgr...
...If "we" (in some comfortably NEW AGE FILMS...
...Brooklyn...
...Mundelein...
...Geneva...
...etc...
...Calumet City...
...fighter, period...
...La Jolla...
...Rev...
...Berkeley E.G...
...Nov...
...Brookfield...
...Milwaukee Rev...
...The responsibility for the sac- Index of American Periodical Verse, and Book Review Digest...
...Baltimore the P-38 was not "a fighter, period...
...Frances A. Murphy...
...not to Auschwitz and back (4) To refer to For box numbers add 60c per insertion...
...Vincent Hope...
...Katonah...
...Chevy Chase use the correct term, War Department...
...Akron Ind...
...Otto C. Stegmaier...
...Roosevelt...
...Philip Murnion...
...Catholic social model as stressing the which not only would have saved Jewish First of all, the article seems to be whole over the part "in the form of tradi- lives (and millions of other lives) but patently absurd...
...Calif...
...James Reese...
...People of that kidney read a cite qualified authorities or what are his JESUS WAS A TEACHER...
...Pasadena Joseph Manning...
...Most Rev...
...Westfield...
...6. P. 215 of The Ariny Rev...
...Erroneous insofar as American (February 1974) Europe since 1918 had primarily a judgment about them, then (no less than British) bombing was any- no legitimate governments, i.e...
...large hall has to serve as church, school, their church...
...Mrs...
...San Francisco qualifications for saying the bombing John J. Magee...
...Mrs...
...Mr...
...Williams knows that it Yet Jewish lives could have been "kings" and the "kings" philosophers needs no ghost, o r even Saturday Review saved-not all but many, many...
...60c, twelve times...
...Garrett Raymond H. Schmandt...
...Thomas J. Gumbleton...
...Schlingerman...
...Catholic social thought is station, but from powerful Allied trans- sneers at -there was a war on...
...Pebble Beach Helen M. Ranney...
...I pity him...
...Chicago Noel E. Sherry...
...Chicago Daphne Hoffman Mebane...
...Peter's Barque should not though in different degrees has to be laid rofilm, 300 N. Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, Mi...
...Vivian Mercier...
...John T. Fagan...
...Jimmy Carter...
...To the Editors: No doubt so excellent a be considered or returned unless accompanied by a Yet to come to the root of so much of stamped, 'self-addressed envelope...
...Bernard M. Harcarick...
...Von Kuehnelt-Leddihn makes a Mass...
...the Free World and the Americans them- So, the interesting question is that: to Bombing Auschwitz...
...tion camps and not only the truth relating ERIK VON KUEHNELT-LEDDIHN Copyright © 1979 Commonweal Publishing Co...
...Maspeth...
...Winston-Salem Rev...
...24) has some interesting implicasociety...
...Encino...
...Thomas J. Kennedy...
...JOSEPH EULIE ington James G. Herrmann...
...Rev...
...West Islip...
...C, Cat Rock Road, Cos Cob never met a Jewish pilot, only navigators Conn, 06807...
...63c, six times...
...is advance for more than three times...
...people of Cambodia...
...Dr...
...ing a lives-saving deal for unconditional Rev...
...misinterpretations and Commonweal is indexed in Readers Guide to and anything but the world's listening miscalculations of the Free World will go Periodical Literature, Catholic Periodical Index, post, (here the words of Ronald Knox on and on...
...very directly, to the readers of Comthe 1943 Ploesti raid parenthetically as Classified payable with order...
...Minn...
...pability to put Auschwitz out of business, Combat Hunger iat Dooley might I conclude this: Catholics will go to with miniscule damage to the war effort . . . " ? There are serious military scholars Join 23,000 others concerned over vicfor the CIA...
...Mrs...
...Vero Beach...
...James T. Villani...
...Minn...
...Jerry Vo orhis...
...Wash...
...the Allies at the door of Berlin...
...Rev...
...19 January 1979:29 Steven L. Englund...
...Ann Arbor war effort, my authority is common Stephen Manning...
...Williams's bland assurance that the m another thirty example of the we-are-all-guilty re- East 16th St., N.Y., N.Y...
...Msgr...
...Denver Marie T. McDonough...
...5) Finally, where does Williams ed an instrumen- years old...
...Washington for articles such as Mr...
...Chicago exchange my military-hardware error for Rev...
...Robert T. Mulligan...
...Msgr...
...Rev...
...3) "The most selec- aren't the UN, the U.S., the Soviet journalism, interested in prison, social 11v have a better tive American bombers of the day were Union and the Peoples Republic of China justice work...
...People like myself...
...Washington Rev...
...Bronx...
...about F.D...
...Minneapolis guilty about the Holocaust...
...Charles McManus...
...Holy Family Church, Khliehriat 793200, M. Williams (November 24) is the footstep or two, Meghalaya, India (Airmail 31c) or Salesource of my concern...
...Linacre Joseph G. Gladis...
...I could quote innumer- ments with a spiritual-moral authority...
...I don't believe the P-38 ~edy neglects to (Continued from page 2) was ever fitted with dive brakes, or that it RATES: 70c a word, one time...
...1. 1924, to deserve an added meaning: "He who rifice of millions of Jews indeed- current issues available through University Mictravels on St...
...Chicago Anne Perkins...
...Thomas M. Santa...
...James O'Donohue...
...Pickman...
...And I bet political, ideological and humane- diabolic speed of the killings, might one every other reader knows exactly what he humanitarianism terms the Allied policy conclude that bombing Auschwitz would means...
...history teaches: learn...
...Mass...
...Mexico City As for the intemperate Mr...
...New York James P. Tierney...
...Evanston sense...
...myself raised the very troubling prospect James F. McNulty...
...writing skills (25 articles published in conWilliams's piece is full of this kind of didn't Mr...
...Mass...
...Why CATHOLIC SISTER with Ph.D...
...William B. Neenan...
...24) 1 least because as Henry Kissinger told the a decision made), as most of them, like found partly erroneous and partly beside foreign Ministers of the EEC in Brussels Roosevelt, are now dead...
...Unsolicited manuscripts are,,Lelcome but cannot all Germans...
...Mass...
...New City...
...Msgr...
...Until and unless the "philosophers" are But surely Mr...
...A. Ruiz de la Orden...
...Warwick...
...Mass...
...Funds are needed to expand J in the vernacucome a National Enquirer of the Left...
...13) seemed like a good idea...
...Msgr...
...War Department, then, not the "De- Auschwitz Bombed...
...Bisbee...
...to the concentration camps, familiar to Detroit, Mich...
...Commonweal: 2 heir nationality...
...Try a little...
...John Tuohey...
...To the Editors: I do not understand what the inane and self-defeating uncondi- But your general-interest article Joe Holland means in his letter (Dec...
...As gross technical inaccuracies of "Why J. W. DEES meeting center and even crowded dorh was significant mitory...
...Philip S. Kaufman...
...Devon...
...Calif...
...Denver Paul & Maude Farrell...
...Dees, I'll Paul Kozak...
...Claremont...
...and "his type" are simply substituting a fashionable, nur time...
...And that is, in esidency...
...The issue concerns the question: Rev...
...would've had a miniscule effect on our Rev...
...Williams apply the lesson we temporary journals, including COMshould have learned from the Holocaust suspect references...
...His pro- monweal...
...R.P...
...If Brian Murphy has to go to neapolis Rev...
...New York Rev...
...Canada Mary Hoffman Smith...
...Address: Rev...
...Spokane...
...Msgr...
...Calif...
...Arthur J. Shields...
...Mrs...
...Mass...
...any lengths" to feel at least a little Dorothy N. Kelly...
...Worcester...
...Mrs...
...did say the P-38 armed with bombs "was Rev...
...Rev...
...anything or enough for the suffering Walter T. Grady...
...Horace Williams...
...Ossorio...
...Topeka...
...T. Kenneth Mattimoe...
...Philadelphia And whether you're pushing 40, 14, or Park...
...Oh, to be honCorrespondence told Max Eastman 50 years ago that he est, we may slide past the recipes for (and considered Woodrow Wilson not only judicious criticisms of) the latest steps in the greatest fool of this, but of all cen- the Vatican Rag...
...Christiane Hoppe...
...Sensitive iniurch a remarka- childishly referring to parents, police- "cheap shot" charge...
...Washington Hester M.E...
...10016...
...New York Nina Polcyn Mo ore...
...Mass...
...Pittsburgh Dr...
...H. Fantin, S.D.B., wasn't Auschwitz bombed...
...George G. Higgins...
...when he writes of a "cyclical-organic issued in collaboration with the (rebuffed (Nov...
...Mrs...
...Springfield...
...Fairfield...
...Films Cruel grotesqueries characterize the ;hapters, Deedy sponse...
...Conn...
...I'll take all passes 75 villages and 30 village Ll sketches...
...Frank J. McCabe...
...The term "selective" as (Continued on page 31) 10016...
...Orange...
...Washington Rev...
...La Jolla...
...Pittsburgh Jean Vass...
...by Roger in some special New Paltz, N.Y...
...Calif...
...d. If some of his Indeed, you no doubt have your demogblack comedy...
...Joseph L. Quinn...
...A.J...
...Indeed, it very interesting to me, and a discussion mitters the German People could have might have seemed strange in the exof it in relation to Hixson's provocative been informed in precise terms (and not treme to bomb the very people you were article (Oct...
...bership in Bread for the World...
...I Rev...
...widespread anti-Semitism in the U.S...
...Why wasn't Auschwitz tion on its temporal axis and collectively would have not laid lovingly the founda- bombed...
...10 sermons the instrumental great many magazines...
...Lloyd Williams...
...Box 6843, Denver, Colorado 80206...
...Pittsburgh Rev...
...203) 869-1818...
...Magnolia...
...Dees...
...New York Peter Smith...
...ROGER WILLIAMS / 9 January 1979:31...
...Leo Mahon...
...Sarasota...
...Kensington...
...WashEdward S. Herman...
...Editor...
...John...
...New York...
...O.S.B...
...New York Iowa "As a fighter-bomber with a bomb load Rev...
...Rev...
...Not vious reason is clearly that which author its thought/action leaning is toward cog- from the miserable, little Vatican radio Roger M. Williams so unaccountably nitive vision...
...tames T. Vocelle...
...The P-51 Mustang was the most Classified effective dive bomber we had when fitted hey have everywith dive brakes...
...And that is the basis of my n Henry O'Con- undefined sense) are "all" (perhaps groups or religion classes...
...BRIAN MURPHY proposition...
...Second-class postage paid at, New York, N.Y...
...I feel miserable...
...Nevertheless, are not even the War Department "said" we to learn nothing from this event...
...Bedford...
...Pittsburgh Wilfred Owen...
...Kansas City Rev...
...Ohio Rev...
...college students and their professors Kathryn M. Giorgio...
...New York arms over the genocide in Cambodia...
...Arlington...
...New York of 2.000 pounds, the plane had an averAlfred R. McCauley...
...I COMMONWEAL, 232 Madison Ave., nable, his argu- raphic readership studies, and those New York, N.Y...
...Nazis could be hit without damage to eking easier John sponse to the Holocaust...
...refer him to Vol...
...surrender, though I doubt that either HiMrs...
...48106...
...They hysterical, and pseudo-moral self- and bombardiers), and, then, on this grisly structure, Williams builds his puny New Mission Station Jatican II neces- flagellation for analysis...
...El Paso Air Force in World War 11...
...To the Editors: I read with interest Roger nds of time...
...Dorothy Gallagher...
...heim...
...Donald W. Mcllvane...
...8) tional surrender formula he should have "Why Wasn't Auschwitz Bombed...
...Ministry" CM, P.O...
...olvement in In- had attained the age of 6 when World such as, "The United States had the can war itself pos- War II ended...
...Los Angeles Rev...
...Brighton...
...George A. Wilt...
...Mrs...
...His other Rev...
...accepted it...
...I do not have the faintest idea and rejected) German opposition a condi- tions for your understanding of your what he means when he describes the tional surrender or even a Peace Formula readers...
...Kansas City Mrs...
...selves are "stuck" with American lead- whom is the article addressed...
...tyranny and genocide will continually Rev...
...Dwight A. Jackson...
...Surely, the reasons Helen Niven...
...Kansas City allegations of factual error result from Anne B. McGlinchy...
...Kathleen M. Wilson...
...in history, anything, much less ". . . said curtly...
...Fort Wayne...
...Helen Kirby...
...Mrs...
...Haddigan...
...Min- Rev...
...Wilmont...
...Why for new apostolate June, 1979...
...being ". . . to some, ill fated...
...Austin...
...It is not better today either, but argument) agree even on that...
...A.E.P...
...Ariz...
...Outremont...
...Mrs...
...William McManus...
...66c, three xception of one, ejects are of Irish Clearly, then, the article is addressed, could carry two 1,000 bombs, certainly times...
...Washington Why aren't the "idealistic" American Donald Gancer...
...And' only now, not even grasp the meaning of "a linear- the Nazi Ally of the 1939-41 period...
...able truly "devastating" examples...
...Bettendorf...
...that camp inmates would have been Rev...
...Unlike (as Plato demanded) the mixture of editor, come from the grave to tell us the Vatican, notoriously a world-center amateurishness and callousness, the mis- this...
...Western Springs...
...F.S.C...
...If I have mis- Rochelle, N.Y...
...Thomas Mannion...
...Schumacher, Oregon...
...Younger...
...Chicago unable to get to Auschwitz and back...
...Paul Lackner...
...Thomas Troyer...
...for not doing Rev...
...govern- we learn no more than that there has been thing but precise...
...an effec!8 as strengthen- There is a more sobering conclusion: strategic bombing effort in WWII, I tive means of influencing national food know the limitations on bombing accurish subculture, the article is a rather melodramatic policy...
...Jamaica...
...Hard...
...Narberth...
...In one my opinion, an appallingly immoral re- their victims is vicious nonsense...
...Washington Brother Thomas More Page...
...Wilmington provocative suggestion about substitutMr...
...would assume he's devoured, to wit, Miriam McCaffery...
...Kevin C. Sullivan...
...used here has no military meaning whatn and nationality Correspondence soever...
...and this guy's a Senior A NEW SALESIAN mission in an imEditor of the Saturday Review...
...Bronx...
...William Mannion...
...Great Neck...
...John J. McClafferty...
...Instead of using beck, Jr...
...Louise Wray Moro...
...And bombed in 1944...
...Oak Park...
...London, Washing- Serials Data Program No.: ISSN 0010-3330...
...Wall...
...must have known about the extermina- ton and even of Moscow...
...Rev...
...Helmut & Margaret Golatz...
...Microfilm from Vol...
...New life for study entire piece...
...Ann Arbor Joseph G. Grassi...
...Kathleen Margaret Waters...
...Texas Rev...
...mate of opinion Myself, I'm pushing 40...
...Thomas Ventura...
...et al...
...John A. Shocklee...
...10801...
...127 Flying MONWEAL) wishes to leave classroom letters on subjects Fortresses (B-24's) . . ." The Flying to current examples of genocide...
...Dr...
...please, no more of the Williams-type their central parish facilities as their one of seven people The "cheap shot" sensationalism and junk...
...BREAD FOR THE WORLD, 207 racy...
...Ncw York another playright excoriate Kurt WaldPa...
...Mary Menig...
...It was a disaster, total...
...Brooklyn...
...Oy vey...
...Gerard Weber...
...Besides of not more than Fortress is a B-17...
...Quarter/ v. Milwaukee conducting marches...
...p. 21, Cheever photo by The American Commonwealth re the who are, like myself, interested in, and Jill Krementz...
...We are wracked sights into Life After Death - Meditation - D'Connell's col- men, politicians, and other authority fig- with the guilt and horror of the Holocaust World's Religions - Holistic Healing - and and reminded of the anti-Semitism of the :)irs, his villa in ures) guilty, then none of us (in any par- More...
...William Leonard...
...Edward Flahavan...
...Certainly Lans, Tyrol, Austria ership, which no European power can not to the people who made the decision To the Editors: The article of Roger M. replace at the present time, last but not (if there ever was, in the sense assumed, Williams on Auschwitz (Nov...
...Silver Spring...
...The ob(collectively...
...I've sian Missions, 148 Main St., New First, the inaccuracies: (1) It was the M. Williams's article, "Why Wasn't rn...
...Yonkers...
...Joseph Zalotay...
...John M. Fleming...
...Write Box 82, COMP-38 Lightnings . . ." The P-38 was a (all self-proclaimed defenders of the MONWEAL, 232 Madison Ave., N.Y.C...
Vol. 106 • January 1979 • No. 1
