Four Hasidic Masters and Their Struggle Against Melancholy:
Riemer, Jack
remembering others," Lewes was not Comtean Positivism to an English audi- cance too rare. Hock Guan Tjoa has as-...
...REV...
...10019...
...35226...
...I TMUST have been such a remarkable out of fascination less with the exotic As one ofthe most vital and energetic scene when these lectures were given than with a deeply felt common element at Notre Dame...
...Five: philosophy...
...A few Sundays ago, during the 10 A.M...
...Although Fr...
...This is the theme of Hock lems of Life and Mind (1874-79), com- S. Haight gives to the pattern of George Guan Tjoa's book about him.Lewes was born to comfortable pleted by George Eliot, which attempts a Eliot's life in the Letters...
...of Notre Dame, $'7.95, 140 pp...
...For Wiesel, that his world was filled with turmoil and to whom...
...It is not an abstract system of men seemed bestial, all life seemed dull...
...Torah contains irony and its truth...
...even if some 25 May 1979:317 Classified RATES: 70c a word, one time...
...And then Wiesel explains the tale in RABBI JACK RIEMER is Scholar-in- words that are a succinct summary of Residence ofthe Congregation B'nai Amoona what Hasidism is all about: "What did in St...
...He STRUGSLE AGAINST NELANCROLY could use in teaching others, and not in was both an original thinker as well as a EJie Wiesei order to judge how he told his tales, but popularizer and earned the respect of his Univ...
...These Rebbes whom same obstacles...
...Committed to research and teaching...
...biography in its day...
...82001...
...Proregistration necessary...
...It i s . . . looking at the future, looking into time...
...He learned " a meaningful vision of man and 178-page index to all 9 volumes...
...Experience in law enforcement and some experience in corrections...
...theFormightly arti- orful intellectual enterprises, but inevitaWhen Turgenev writes to her on cles on Darwin (1868), which provided bly one wishes that the kaleidoscope had Lewes's death that "All your friends, all been g~ven the final missing satisfying learned Europe mourns with you," one an informed contemporary commentaryon the question of natural selection thatturn...
...Israel Baal Shem Tov would be coming SIDNEY CALLAHAN is assistant professor of to our town...
...When read with the mind and heart they are found to be a rich and deep look at the friendship that existed between these two extraordinarily creative men...
...And strangely, I was ' l " II?film (•PIPUpf) He has written extensively on nineteenth- able to go home, to open the Talmud, and century fiction...
...When I entered he was just finishing Illusion of Eve and Parenting...
...monthly in advance for more than three times...
...COMMONWEAL, 232 Madison Ave., NYC 10016...
...In Eastern trum ofhis writings, Mr...
...And yet, as Elie Wieseldemonstrated at Notre Dame,and as is becoming more and more clear to many sensitive people, to a society such as ours that is so fragmented, that needs so much to create a sense of community, to a society that has so much scientific knowledge andso little senseofpurpose, to a society that is able to set foot on the moon but does not know how to lift a head up from the ground, to such a society thestory ofHasidismand its efforts to give man dignity and joy and purposeon this planet speaks with power and with relevance...
...Father Hesburgh, the president Jew, the Jew was the devil to the priest...
...TERRY BROWN Bishop Patterson Theological Centre P.O...
...He turned around and saw awarded a Guggenheim Fellowship to write me, and I was convinced that he was Microficlle her third book on Erasmus's theological seeing me, me and no one else--but so CAN BE OBTAINED FROM was everyone else in the room...
...The Life and Works of Goethe sembled some ofthe fascinating pieces of "'She is a Mediaeval Saint with a grand (1855), which was a benchmark literary George Henry Lewes's various and colgenius...
...As Hesburgh describes it, these very high as a philosopher, Huxley as a J a c k R i e m e r were people who were listening, not just physiologist...
...It is a sense of being bound up the only remedy I know...
...in 1939, the Society of the Catholic Commonwealth...
...when the first 30 pages give a lively ac- his years in the village of Sighet...
...Classified payable with order...
...tute for the reading of Lewes's books...
...Box 19 Honiara Commonweal: 318...
...MARJORIE O'ROURKE BOYLE has just been his prayers...
...Single, 36...
...Worlds that had existed side by pages give, for the most part, a duller set probably never heard of Naftali of Rop- side and nevertouched in Eastern Europe of summaries and excerpts from the spec- shitz or Pinchas ofKoretz orany of these came together in Indiana...
...Friendship" and "concern" are the begged for help...
...down of miracles which so many think is theirjoy and intheir distress and of being "Woe unto me," said the disciple, "I what Hasidism was all about...
...Mail in order...
...hope--the greatest miracles of all...
...His books include Jewish Reflec- Pinhas of Koretz try to teach his young tions on Death (Schocken...
...One: not togive up...
...I open the Hasidism, and which are also miracles, ship, this relationship between Rebbe Talmud and contemplate it but aimlessly...
...he founded and edited literary journals and FOUR HASIDIC PIASTERS AND THEIR techniques of story-telling that they did a bit of stage-acting on the side...
...Publisher's list price...
...On the platform Elie that linked them together with the Victorians, Lewes doesn't translate verywell as a "Mind" only--especially inWiesel, scion of Viznitz, who but for the speakerdespite all the many obvious cul138 pages of text, and more especially Holocaust would haveprobably lived out tural differences between them...
...H e is the was able to go on . . ." author of Paul Tillich's Theology of the Church ( W a y n e State...
...Then one day I learned that Rebbe at Stanford University in California...
...that came to hear what he had to say to contemporaries: John Morley "put him them...
...It is a He pleaded with the Rebbe to tell him miracles, but about friendship and friendship and a concern for people and what to do...
...Call collect (307) 638-0884...
...Salary negotiable...
...Box 2085, Cheyenne, Wy...
...Write Peter Sperling--Book, Dept...
...A disci- own, others have gone through the same r a r e . ple once came to Pinchas of Koretz and sorrow and endured the same anguish...
...I wallowed in commonweal doubt, I was locked in despair...
...What could be more parochial, more provincial, more isolated than this sect...
...Invoiced with shipment plus postage less than three books...
...doctors of the soul were themselves often When I was your age I stumbled over the sick with despair...
...Tennyson, Browning, and other eminent Victorians...
...MI C R O PHDI"D D I V I s I o n George Eliot's Mythmaking...
...who never heard of Goethe or Voltaire, who were neverheard ofby Beethoven or Kant, who dressed in special clothes in order to stress their differentness from the world outside, who spoke no language but their own Jewish one, who read in no cultures and who spoke to no society but their own...
...I am interested in corresponding with any of your readers, Roman Catholic or otherwise, who may have known Fr...
...Smyth was quite critical of the (pro-Vatican I1) Roman Catholic Church for its politics and theology, it seems possible that he may havehad contact with individual Roman Catholics on the political left...
...Two: one charismatic people rose to heights of sad...
...Perhaps one problem in reviewing such a bookis to try to do it "In Brief...
...Torah is the answer...
...small colleges fine...
...for God...
...He enjoyed the that the presentation ofdetails is too fre- achievement of The George Eliot Letfriendship of Dickens, Carlyle, Mill, quentand the elucidation of their signifi- ters...
...Sadness, happyness, and into ournew freedom...
...63c, six times...
...Louis...
...One who reads the "letters" with the mind only might think them sketchy or "thin...
...Tjoa makes the figures that Wiesel brings to life in these Europe the priest was the enemy to the mistake oftrying to have his booksubsti- lectures...
...Correspondence (Continued from page 290) I must confessthat we allow our children to read orwrite during Sunday Mass should the sermon or service become too long, provided: of course they are sufficiently discreet about it...
...And so Rebbe away at his spirit as much as or more than Pinhas of Koretz invited the student to come closer, and then said with a smile:"Know, my young friend, that what is he uplifted theirs...
...M a r r i e d P r i e s t s--- - CORPUS-National Association Resigned/Married Priests...
...GREGORY J. RYAN F a t h e r S m y t h Solomon Islands To the Editors: I am gathering materials for a bookon the American Episcopalian Marxist theologian, F. Hastins Smyth (1888-1960) and the religious community he founded in Cambridge, Mass...
...and disciple, a relationship in which each I remain riveted to the same page, to the At the onelevel what could seem more affected the other...
...For him there is nothing, there is nothing there, set him aside.., stopthe train and let him o f f . . . the guys who do not go all the way to the real poem betterstop the train and get off, and they already have, they were never on the train in the first place...
...S i t u a t i o n W a n t e d CATHOLIC HISTORIAN seeks Catholic College position for ancient history, Christian archaeology, or Great Books...
...are not formal factual discourses, alBaedeker to point out such highlights of And it was right because by then though they are obviously the product of the touras the popularBiographical His- Wiesel had somehow succeeded in form- much learning and offirst-hand acquainttory...
...I tried study, prayer, meditation--in vain...
...visitor...
...No sening to be French peasants discussing has a sense in reading the present study tence could more acutely describe the apocryphal wines...
...It seems to be a puttogether with all other human beings in all the answers...
...tions, so all-pervasive are my doubts that ship and hope, which are the real core of At the heart of Hasidism was this kin- my mind finds no anchor...
...YOUNG WOMAN with Bachelor's degree in Social Welfare and Master's degreein Criminal Justice desires teaching position with Catholic college...
...66c, three times...
...They're to be enjoyed...
...in the middle of one of the lectures them, not as excursions into a quaint pastbut as keys to his own spiritual situation For readers interested in a walk Wiesel broke from his text and through the gallery of his canon, how- exclaimed: " I marvel...
...Write: Director...
...B i b l i c a l I n s t i t u t e TRINITY COLLEGE, Burlington, Vermont 05401, June 17-22, MEIER, NEWMAN, FISCHER, DALEY, STENDAHL...
...Send applications to: Cathy Stoltz, 1142 AIford Ave., Birmingham, AI...
...10010...
...Smyth or the S.C.C...
...But in the midst of all their joking and carrying on (the various pseudonyms they use to sign these letters are punch lines all by themselves...
...Hasidism is the opposite of sol- "Go and study," said the Rebbe...
...Presently at state university, Great Books Series...
...the Prob- This is precisely the turn that Gordon genius too...
...BEST SELLERS by mail...
...One lars ofnineteenth-century life...
...perhaps the greatest miracles of all...
...He wrote criticism, novels, plays, and biography, treatises on Miracle of friendship & hope philosophy, science, and psychology...
...Volume 9 consynthesis of"seasoned empiricism" and cludes with 30 pages ofAddenda and middle-class parents in 1817 and edu- "religious rationalism" and tries to find Corrigenda to volumes 1 to 7 and with a cated in England and abroad...
...30] "In Brief"--just to be sure I got it right the first time...
...Box 2649, Chicago~ 60690...
...A Greek well enoughto read the tragedians things...
...But then it bound up with God in his joy and in his c a n ' t study...
...ofPhilosophy (1845), with its anti- ing his audience into a community, into a ance with the primary sources...
...Stephen J. Kelleher, Sacred Heart Church, 457 West 51st St., N.Y.C...
...This is what happened at Notre Dame, and through this book, in which those lectures take written form, this is what can happen to us...
...C-8, Lexington, Ky...
...He learned French well than the observations of Chaldean context, "twentieth-century academia is enough to chat with CharlesLamb Kenny shepherds, which produced no As- re.composing for us the smallest particu"in Burgundian patois ," both "pretend- tronomy in centuries of watching...
...P&P Enterprises, P.O...
...These happening to you also happened to me...
...I felt less alone...
...He tells ofhow tened to these Hasidic tales and heard pect...
...Contact Msgr...
...D i v o r c e d C a t h o l i c s REMARRIAGE AND EUCHARIST Lecture-discussion dates now available for Fall 1979-Spring 1980...
...Mass, I looked over my six-year-old's shoulder as he wrote the following verse: "The Unknown face of G o d . . . is love, joy, life, and death...
...lifetime's work of inestimable historical easily and to call Thomas Francklin, who In his book Sea-side Studies Lewes value thus comes meticulously to an end...
...C, 207 East 21 St., N.Y., N.Y...
...40508...
...his most recent book is to plunge into my studies once more...
...Hardcover-Paperback...
...What must I do, Rebbe, parochial than a pietistic movement that and spirit and meaning out of his heart to what must I do...
...Old Mansfield Road You s e e , " said Rebbe Pinchas of Koretz, Wooster, Ohio 44691 RONALD MODRAS is currently a Visiting "the questions remained questions, but I Scholar at Harvard DivinitySchool...
...As of Notre Dame, captures something of Now in Indiana the priest was the stua result the very engaging Lewes comes the drama ofthe scenein his very moving dent, the companion-in-search, who lisacross less happily than one would ex- introduction to this book...
...I R E V I E W E R S tried penitence, solitude, silence--in JOHN AHERN isassistantprofessor ofItalian vain...
...Twice I read Michael True's review [Mar...
...unedited) Not bad, not bland...
...And in Notre Dame and Ropshitz...
...must not think that one is alone and that friendship andconcern for eachother, for The story with which this book begins one's inner tragedy is exclusively one's their disciples, and for the world that is sets the tone for all that follows...
...Vita on request: Dr...
...And so these men who A permanent could move others to joy were them- record of selves stricken with melancholy...
...Experience teaching all Western Civilization...
...translated Sophocles badly, "one of the derided lists ofdetails that crowded Vic- "In its editorial scruple and appetite," most astonishingblock-heads in the rec- torian books and journals as "no better George Steiner wrote recently in another ords of poetry...
...suspects that Lewes was nearly a grand so vexed the Victorian Age...
...They ever, this book should serve as a Jew doing here?--But it is right...
...The Rebbe gave hope same problem...
...we find out about subjects that were of interest to Mortonand Laxand others, namely: solitude, ecumenism, race, peace and the condition of poetry.What need for Brother Patrick Hart to "shore up" these letters...
...I, too, was filled With everyone elseleaned on were themselves doubts and questions...
...Curiosity led me to the ON psychology at Fairfield University Graduate place where he was receiving his followSchool of Education...
...What is a Hasidic What exactly are these lectures...
...So shaky are my founda- turns out to be an affirmation of frienddistress...
...B o o k s STILL LOOKING for abook?Free Search Service...
...flourished a century ago in the villages of his people, but there were more of them When a Jew can provide no answer, he Eastern Europe, a movement led by men than there were of him, and they wore at least has a tale toshare...
...Ph.D in Roman History and has published...
...Arnold thought him out ofrespect but out of fascination, and strongest as a dramatic critic...
...The inmethod.JOSEPH WIESENFARTH is professor of Eng- tensity of his gazeoverwhelmed me, and f1 BELL 6 HOWELL lish at the University of Wisconsin-Madison...
...And they stand alone...
...Joseph Merriman, 521 E. Main St., Apt...
...Her books include The ers...
...M. F. O'NEIL/CLEARY An anti.brief Wall, N.J...
...a good story in Hasidism is not about ideas or a conception of the Deity...
...Four: God is everywhere, even Hasidism is not a theology or a sadness, that all words seemed empty, all in pain, even in the search for faith...
...Hock Guan Tjoa has asfanciful, it seems, when he said of her, ence...
...Priests and count ofhis varied careerand the last 108 the audience priests and nuns who had Rebbes...
...They are metaphysical bias, which introduced group that came not in order to learn essentially the retelling ofa saga and the Commonweal: 316 recreation of a special moment in Jewish the only ones without a Rebbe to lean on, questions are without answers, to go on history, a moment in which a corps of and so their lives were often dark and asking them just the same...
...It is I like that last sentence for its gentle itude...
...To the Editors: Since November I have read A Catch ofAnti-Letters by Thomas Morton n and Robert l a x five times...
...Indeed, Morton speaks to something much like this when talking about Lax's poetry: "Let us for the moment set aside the reader ofyourbook who will not play all or nothing and will notattend to every bit of black and white, etc...
...The disciple confessed Three: one must know where to look and key motifs of this book...
Vol. 106 • May 1979 • No. 10
