CORRESPONDENCE
CORRESPONDNew Orleans, La. To the Editors: I hope not to be tarred as reactionary if I express mild shock at David P. Chandler's bland "Transformation in Cambodia" [Apr. 1]. Too bad Mr....
...I f it is not always the sacramental encounter with the mystery of the infinite, it is at least sacramental encounter with the mystery of one's deepest self, where, Coleridge might add, God also dwells (120-121)..It was Coleridge who formulated the need for a way of thinking where two realiti~ ".he seen and the unseen, the verifiable and the mysterious--could exist simultaneously, and where we cotdd ~limpse even in the clarity'of the sensed reality a glimmering presence, religious, literary, and personal...
...Poaddoms Open TEACHER OPENINGS, all fields, levels, Iocaflena...
...page 329: CCPD Network Letter/LNS...
...v IM...
...Single copy 75c...
...This book is for all who worry about how to ~ the truths of the spirit in the face of a seemingly indisputable materialism...
...4~14...
...PALS, Rex 841-K, Winone, MN 1~II7...
...COMMONWEAl., 2~ Madison Ave...
...i n l l ~ t 7 DIGNITY, an organization of gay end Catholics, working for a mo~ Informed theology and pastoral approach to mxuallty...
...F r l e , , d l 7 Mmd~dlmn FRIENDLY MUTUALISM--.lu ICropofkle's spirit...
...Rays...
...Had I read Cnmbodge: nnnde zdvo beforehand, I would certRinly have altered the paragraph in my article that runs from page 209 to page 210...
...Wrifp Sister Merinene, COLLEGE MISERICORDIA...
...ldtu~am SACRED" SCRIPTURE: Ninth AMuai Institute, August 7-I2, 11ff7...
...alto r service...
...C l a s s i f i e d RATES: 10c a word, one time...
...O O O O O O O O 0 IN BRIEF THE SYMBOLIC IMAGINATION: COL~x~e A~D THE ROZ~SCTIC 'I3tA~mO~, by J. Robert Berth, SJ., Princeton University Press, $I0...
...According to Lacouture, they "have invented something original, auto-genocide...
...Berth explains that the symbolism of that age as it continues into ours "is always at least the sacrament of the human experience, including man's experience of the numinous...
...Writ*: NCPS, ]34 W. kerdsley Ave., r-ikhort, Ind...
...Foreign $33.S0...
...MlaroEInls from Vol...
...Commonweal is Indexed In Reader's Guide to Periodical Literature, Catholic Poriodical Index, nod /ark Review Digest...
...To characterize the Detroit Conference, as some critics have done, as a radical putsch was to miss the point that the Detroit process, in tune with the historical occasion that inspired it, was no more radical than democracy itself...
...Write: Diructor...
...What made Chandler's article so disappointing is his almost total failure even to suggest the horrors that are besetting Cambodia...
...Buaper Sdeker "lt's lawful to kill au umbore child FOR CONYENIEHCE...
...Free literature...
...The sad paradox of Detroit may be that the participants may have expected that on the controverted issues there was an American theology in the making that would lead the bishops to speak up to Rome Commonweal: 323 and has been destroyed by the emergence of a new kind of patron...
...111016...
...I should add that my article was written several months before Lacouturr review, which appeared as the April 1 Commonweal was on the press, but it profited from Father Ponchaud's earlier research, which had appeared in Le Monde and in Mondea Asia~uea...
...but its appointed hierarchial leadership--listen as they might to the grass roots and concerned as they are on social justice issues--have their theological ears cocked most sensitively to Rome...
...ANYA TAYLOR OOOOOOOOO CORRESPOHDENCE (Continued/ram page 323) happened in Cambodia since 1975 is more chilling, really, than our own bombing of the country between 1969 and 1973...
...Write: DliF...
...After Auschwitz and the Gulag, we might have thought this century had produced the ultimate in horror, but we are now seeing the suicide of a people in the name of revolution...
...Coleridge, that shipwrecked man who thought at the crossroads of religion, philosophy, science, and art, asked us to befriend the mysteries in and through the symbols that embody them...
...Brown, Ca)llin~ MacKeezia...
...For box numbers add S0c Per InsorlloL Classified payable wltk order...
...Dallas, PanesylvNia 11~12...
...Send $i.00 to Vallmor's, los 32SO, West Haven, Conn...
...Chandler hadn't read Franfois Ponchaud's carefully researched book, Cambodge, annde zdro, reviewed in the March 31 issue of The New York Review o ! Books (hardly a reactionary journal), or at least Jean Lacouture's account titled "The Bloodiest Revolution...
...389 VERflE: Nellie Hall 33G T I l E MACBINING OF AMERICA: Robert L. King 840 UIVIVEi~JJlTT PRESS BOOIKS: C r t t l e s ' $haleetions: Walter Arnold, Jean Bethke Elshtain, Norris Merchant, Bernard Murchland, John Ratio, John P. Sisk, Bruce Vawter 343 CBARTING RELIGIOUS LANDSCAPES: Paul R. Messbarger 34T BOOKS: Eric Cochrane, Anya Taylor 849 ILLU.~PRATIONS: Front cover: Naranjo/Exceisior (Mexico)/LNS...
...Pro*registration necesMry...
...The 182 Detroit proposals emerged after the widest consultation in the history of the American Church...
...In fact, that would inevitably 'be part of .the "Call to Action" problem, the 200-year old American Catholic difficulty in knowing to what degree the community's values, theology and discipline could have roots in American culture...
...Sic, thirteen times, Twelve words minimum...
...page 328: Richard Bennett/LNS...
...Instead of seeing the Romantics as the first orphans after the death of God, as J. Hillis Miller, Harold Bloom, and M. H. Abrams have seen them casting old religious experience into new psychological terms, Barth believes that Coleridge, Wordsworth, Blake and Carlyle should be seen seeking to recapture the unified sensibility of traditional Christianity, before the dissociation of sensibility set in and material philosophy obliterated the mysteries of the spiritual life...
...7c, three times...
...I~1~ Telephone: (212) MU 3-204~ A review of Pub/is Affairs, LJtorofure and the Arts...
...Thus the study of architecture can no longer expect any help from those who are paid to direct it...
...Heflong P.O, 7NI9, N. Gechar DR., Auxin, India (Airmail 31r or c/o Seleden Idiuiom0 144 ~vllin Shlalt, New Eacl~lle, New York Ira01...
...According to several accounts, this mindless bombing stiffened the will of the radicals in the revolutionary movement, snulted out the possibility of a cease-fire (which was never great), and gave our own form of government as bad a name as the present regime in Cambodia gives to socialism, according to Jean Lacouture...
...This request may still be crucial...
...Ammm For _9 new misslot In North India Sehnlaes are building a ~11 pirilh church, rite only one wltbiu two thousand square miles...
...o~ 1 ~0.60 (, ~ sro) t-o~ a-ono-yoer 8UO Ir 8 ~tlng with ~ currcmt issue...
...mo~hly iu advance for more than tkme times...
...page 331: 5tars & Gripes/LNS...
...14k)l~y bllck If I ~ pilINr Allow6w~mks...
...In one sense the Church has become very American in that its members share the dominant American .values--competitiveness, equality, patriotism and the thirst for economic prosperity...
...DAVID CHANDLER J lf Vou ton you II Iove...Vk'lql [ATlm, The L ~ (~Nt~_9 des lug wnn _9 u u l x c18 o limgmKle, $4:( 0 ~.S...
...M. Ahem, RIc~rd Clifford, Robert ICarris...
...I, 1924, to date available through University Mlcre~lms...
...200 N. Zeeb Read, Ann Arbor, Mich...
...June I9-24...
...he laments, we now have "tasteless moneylenders and politicians of the stamp of Robert Moses and Mayor Daley" (p...
...BIBLICAL iNSTITUll, TrinEIy Colle~le, krihial~NI, Vermont OS401...
...Pr/~ed In the USA and published biweekly by Commonweal Publishing Co...
...Perhaps the problem is that our horrors, inflicted from miles above the earth, are h~der for us to visualize, and easier to live with than the concept of thousands of murders, face-to-face...
...REPLY: The price I pay for seeking an historical perspective, I suppose, is to be found "bland" and "disappointing," In trying to explain rather than to judge the new regime, moreover, I concealed my personal feelings, which are embedded in the last paragraph of the piece...
...It can no longer hope to have any effect upon what is actually built...
...REV...
...P. Elanchl, S.D.I., Gatholir Church...
...C. J. MCNASPY, S.J...
...I wonder, all the same, if what has (Continued on page 3;$1) NEWS ~ VII~WS: 822 CORRESPONDENCE: 823 EDITORIAL: 828 P/ASHINGTON REPORT: NL~on Without D i e t r i c h : Frank Getlein 324 DEATB COMES FOR A CARDINAL: John Cooney 326 CONFESSIONS OF A NON-ADDle: Peter Steinfels 328 WITII HUMANITY AS PAWNS: Douglas Mattern 329 DILACK CALTBOLICS: Christopher Vecsey 3B2 PRESS: J . F . K ~ - - R . I . P . : Thomas Powers BaT MEDIA: The L a s t S y l l a b l e o f Recorded Time: Colin L. Westerbeck, Jr...
...New York, N.Y...
...SCHROTN: Auoclato Editor ANNE M. ROBERTSON, Editorial Assistant COLIN L. WESTERBIECK, JR.: Movlos JOHN FANDEL: Poetry FRANK GIPTLEIN: Washington BRIAN WICKER| Great Erltalo ALAIN WOODROW: Paris HENRY TEN KORTENAAR: Rome DISMOND FISHER: Dublin EDWARD S. SKILLIN: Publlshor Sto~: LINDA P. KAYUER, PAMELA J. FITZGERALD, HARRIETT| BALSKY COMMONWEAL 2~ MAOISO44 AVE., NEW YORK: N.Y...
...n F o r r A Gift Subscription t o Commonweal Commonweal: 351...
...Berth sets the symbolism in literary Romanticism into the wider context of Christian sacrament...
...or 14.60 ( m } f"~ a-ono-y~r mJ~ll~lon, ~Ing with the curr~t issue...
...Ponchaud has kept up on documentation and broadcasts sent out by the new masters of Cambodia themselves and points out their boast "of having eliminated, in a single year, one quarter of their own population...
...MSI6...
...Second class postage paid at New York, N.Y...
...page 334: Malik/Cablelines/LNS JAMES O'GARA: Editor JOHN DEEDY: Managing Editor RAYMOND .8...
...Mowry, Prih:herd...
...Lacouture concludes that Ponchaud's "book can be read only with shame by those of us who supported the Khmer Rouge cause . . . . For may not the most sinister crimes of all be those that betray the principles of socialism and assassinate human hope itself...
...48106...
...0 @ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 DETROIT, CHICAGO AND ROME If last October's "Call to Action" Conference in Detroit the conclusion of an almost three-year process of grass-roots meetings, public hearings, social research and theological exploration in which American Catholics celebrated their Bicentennial with a renewed call for liberty and justice,--was the full-flowering of the "democratic" American Church, this month's response of the American bishops in Chicago to the "Call" shows how much the American Church is still the Church of Rome...
...Copyright 0 1977 Commonweal PubllsMag Co., lar and Canada: $17 a year...
...Money ~ not peli4Nd...
...x ,,v~ . ~ , POSTOFFICE BOX ISTCX yoe:!l love VEIqOATIM, The .l.a~OUage Oua~x oammg wlth afi ml~$ of I ~ , $4.00 ~,S...
...Special two-year rate $29.50...
...02116...
...Foreign $|9...
...National Serials Data Program No.: ISSN 0010-2220...
...In the place of "Teutonic princelings and French Gran Monarques" (sic...
...NITY, 7SS Boylsto~ St., Room 413, Boston, Mass...
...For the first time in our history, and especially in 1973~ we set about to destroy, systematically (using grid coordinates) a country whose people had never fired a shot at us...
...worse: in the name of socialism...
...593...
...Hence, it now serves only one purpose: that of enabling the student, with a TCI guidebook in hand and with Burchard's practical advice in his head, to escape momentarily from the unrelieved drabhess to which he has been condenmed and to refresh his eyes with the sight of the monuments of happier ages in the past when Bernlni was still alive...
...While the reader might wish for more precise and original explanations of individual poems and more' ample citing of primary as opposed to secondary sources, the book hits its stride half way through and ~elis u s where we are, as inheritors of the late eighteenth century endeavor to keep the "numinous" in suspension behind or within the phenomenal...
...S4c, seven times...
...Doaetions should be sent to Ray...
...Allow e weeks...
...They plan agricultural end educational prolech foe the Interior villages end ere starting a mobile medjcul unit "to aid the suffering, especially the lepcws...
Vol. 104 • May 1977 • No. 11
