CORRESPONDENCE:
CORRESPOND- NEWS & VIEWS: 122 CORRESPONDENCE: 123 ENCE GROUNDS FOR HOPE: John J....
...thropological material is too skimpy to such if they accept a homosexual ori- Therefore, its task is to proclaim both judgment and reconciliation-and to have relevance...
...Watergate has so obviously intruded itself abroad that Secretary of Defense Schlesinger was JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON, M.S.W forced to use a press conference to state that President Nixon "would do Bellingham, Wash...
...He has happily Church in today's world...
...Pope Paul's dilemma "that he PEACE CORPS & VISTA NEED YOU...
...Commonweal: 123 has collapsed the Niebuhr brothers, tain oversimplifications, such as this Has science mentioning Richard in the text, and summary of Paul's teachings: "Love citing two of Reinhold's books and one God and your neighbor, and do what abolished the of Richard's...
...policies of "the Vatican" can be more where, often for the sake of the agmore laity and women are needed...
...WRIGHT, MURPHY- in sending me your issue containing "the system," as Secretary of the PonO'CONNOR, SUELZER, COLLINS, MINEAR...
...JOSEPH GREMILLION These are all views I expressed in As a curialist turned tepidly jourmy open letter to Father Hebblethwaite, nalist, I timidly put myself in jeopardy Commonweal welcomes letters on published in The Tablet, London, 13 by this pronouncement: Changing "the subjects treated in its pages...
...Louis, Missouri 63141...
...My own professional practice, both Second class postage paid at New York, N.Y...
...ferences and ordinaries...
...Life After Death For those who appreciated Haring's Don't publishers have editors anymore...
...A PRACTICAL MAGAZINE for everyone broken taboo...
...Write Sister Marianna...
...The author pur- As a Jungian therapist and a child by Robert S. Paul ports to show that a wholesome har- psychiatrist, we are responsible to our mony of religion and sexuality, found individual patients (or their families) In a world in which the major issue conin many primitive and non-Christian to help achieve the greatest wholeness fronting us seems societies, has been spoiled in the West or potential...
...Meanwhile, he says, "intrepid dinate all these bureaus...
...The Vatican" is foundation and apex...
...Join the universal struggle at a higher level of consciousness...
...I as Hebblethwaite says, truly a very large his centuries-old burden, and of not believe that the Curia does need con- institution...
...The sinner importance of the Substitute Secretary breaks the taboo, denies his guilt, seek- of State, Archbishop Benelli...
...He knows shrewdly to realize that our society is in grave that an arms pact, dressed up and loudly trumpeted, could go far towards straits...
...Write Father Luke Rigby, Box 27311, State, the Holy See, the Pope, the St...
...Two pages later Plato is himself culprit...
...B. EERDMANS 219 I PUBLISHING CO...
...offers much support for Father Baum's by Commonweal Publishing Co., 232 Madison Ave., New York, N.Y...
...MSGR...
...dress myself to several of the issues I am very pleased to find Father HebTeacher Wanted PREMONTRE HIGH SCHOOL, a boys' school of blethwaite's present article much more raised by Father Hebblethwaite, with the Norbertine Fathers at Green Bay, Wisconsin serious and responsible than was his special relation to the role of the 54303, is accepting applications for a teaching position in the religious education dept...
...4950 Commonweal: 141 If we look at constitutive homosex- sexual...
...dren...
...It is such today has (indeed) become unbearunknown territory, somehow off-limits able," to whom shall this burden of • M mentally to Catholics otherwise well- authority, in faith, love and service, be versed in Church affairs-bishops in- transferred...
...COLLEGE Notre Dame, Ind...
...An- (in Eriksonian terms) may be denied and the urgent question of survival...
...Advertising Manager weal for publishing it...
...No translator, how- of consciousness and aloneness so that WM...
...ever, can be held responsible for cer- one may discover the truly "Other...
...nothing to compromise national security in the long run, irrespective of any To the Editor: For a long time we have political disputes that exist within the United States...
...Satanizing of Women...
...Expenses paid- understand the implication of the ditions of the Roman Curia which "is medical, travel, vacation, living...
...But am I, an American in a hundred countries, ready to take m. A. RELIGIOUS philistine, from backwater bayous, an on more authority...
...It seems to me that as they feel Call or write for Bulletin are very devoted to Christ, His Church sufficiently mature as institutions and (215) 527.2100 (x 575) and all His human family, and with truly ready to exercise more authority, Chairman, Religious Studies many of the same frustrations of clear- the Spirit will move them to ask for its VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY ances, coordinations, channels and exercise, with an insistence measured Villanova, Pennsylvania 19085 checks which I have found in the ad- to their recognition of their serious re- on Philadelphia's Main Line ministrative offices of other large in- sponsibility...
...Nixon is quite capable of 'the most cynical deeds that mative, was never discussed nor proven...
...Thanks to Dignity and Father Baum...
...ers...
...14 a year...
...Not only ingly, St...
...lier work led us to hope for, there is sexual couples the freedom to adopt or What's more, that faith also insures a clearer understanding of man's nature none...
...Peter Steinfels 126 A NO-CONFIDENCE AMENDMENT: Henry S. Reuss 127 WORK WHILE YOU STUDY: Joel C. Millonzi 129 Homosexual Taboos THE SCREEN: Colin L. Westerbeck, Jr...
...48c, three times...
...If then, why not sible implications and results...
...India him occasioned by his criticism of Arch- rhetoric of Vatican II...
...dropped the name-calling, gossipy for- I will be giving particular attention Year-Round _Cards mat which he had assumed for a Sun- to the Roman Curia because it is inUNICEF YEAR-ROUND CARDS-colorful international collection of notes, postcards, "minis" and day supplement of mass circulation-a deed such a key element in "the sysmulti-lingual mix-and-match messages...
...Actually I am surprised and disap- Because supposing that, as Father pointed that writers and thinkers, clergy Hebblethwaite states, "the load placed V I LLANO\'a and lay leaders, give so little attention on the shoulders of a monarchial Pope L NIVERSITY to the reform of the Curia...
...man Curia after seven years of absorbMISERICORDIA, Dallas, Pennsylvania 18612...
...Observer Review, to which he now reWill you help...
...Furthermore concern that he might bargain short on critical intermutuality seems extremely premature...
...Paul...
...Removal of the homosex- to be the very survival of humanity, is by males who, out of fear of women, ual taboo, without proof that this will it still worthwhile to maintain an active misrepresent nature, Christ and, surpris- relieve the guilt of practicing homo- Church...
...Here indeed is the priAND MODERN LITURGY, P.O...
...E. T. DEWANE, O.Praem., Principal...
...Presumably, Nixon is One does not need to be a wise man not going to scuttle detente, a boast of his foreign policy...
...portunity to exercise his full potential For anyone asking searching questions as a sexual human being...
...pleasure from my "higher authorities...
...Editor JOHN DEEDY: Managing Editor gay clients, I want to applaud Father RAYMOND A. SCHROTH: Associate Editor ANNE ROBERTSON: Editorial Assistant COLIN L. WESTERBECK, JR.: Movies JOHN FANDEL: Poetry Gregory Baum's article, "Catholic BRIAN WICKER: Great Britain ALAIN WOODROW: Paris HENRY TEN KORTENAAR: Rome JOHN COONEY: Dublin Homosexuals" [Feb...
...His new article on "The Vatican" one place for the constitutive homo- A society which encourages them to raises substantial issues in a more seri"come out" and accept their homosex- ous vein: tension between authority and uality in an outward way will deny freedom...
...But some bad that phase unless there is a strong inbooks are so bad they cannot be ig- ternalized prohibition not to act out KINGDOM COMET nored: ergo, these sentences on The these feelings...
...more so now when his stakes are infinitely higher...
...Why not locate cially among Apostolic Delegates and journalists" must remedy the lack of it in Rome if the Chief Pastor and Nuncios, who are around-the-world ex- such a system, and in doing so "put Head Overseer still resides there...
...Dept...
...arguments...
...Earlier there had been reason to speculate that yes to themselves" must be open to Watergate had begun to creep into the political considerations of foreign the homosexual "yes" to be honest nations, including members of the European Economic Community, But and valuable...
...Certainly it still carries on too bodies, beginning with national bishops' David O'Brien J. Massyngberde Ford many of the trappings of a Renaissance conferences, as a whole and one by one princedom...
...The book falters, early, in idea of life DEATH books should have caught that if the a section on Greek Eros...
...He will be desperate for dramatic effect-which, of course, is sponsibilities...
...If anything should palled at his recent polemic, "Catholic be a given in the United States, it is trust of the President to act in the best Homosexuals," in your magazine [Feb...
...151 and Common- EDWARD S. SKILLIN: Publisher JOHN BRUBAKER...
...Send resum6 to REV...
...It is this consciousness phatic conclusion: "no use blaming ininterested in liturgy resources: songs, poems, art, that allows one to be whole and aware dividuals where the system is at fault...
...Volunteer the individual the support and encour is criticized as bitterly on the right as your skills & experience in developing nations agement to understand his uniqueness on the left...
...Institutes Vatican Reform Roman Curia...
...255 JEFFERSON AVE S E GRAND RAPIDS...
...Carroll Stuhlmueller, James Reese and Robert Karris...
...10017...
...wholeness...
...ELLIOTT WRIGHT Dea1TH Philosophy IN 'I HP If we can place the author in a legiti- SCCLIL IR by Russell Aldwinckle mate class, namely, that of persons 000 000 000 CITE Immortality: whatwho are skilled in communication if anything-does it mean to contempowith hearers and readers who need CORRESPONDENCE rary man...
...Homosexuals' relationships develop the same interactional patterns WATERGATE'S NEW DIMENSION and problems as those of heterosexual Secretary of State Kissinger is back from Moscow without the "conceptual couples...
...Few if any readers the Christian West is accused of invent- after death...
...away from our night school bishop Benelli last year in the London judge this presumption...
...Five-bedroom vated by the open letter I addressed to push toward implementing some of the house and salary...
...Father Peter Hebblethwaite's piece, tifical Commission Justice and Peace...
...result from unhealthy views of sex is life is certainly open to question...
...Bedination is required...
...required...
...ing), the argument is stumbling, incon- potential to be creative and generative The church is given to the world, and everything it does bears on humanity sistent and excessively generalized...
...The discussion of how entation prematurely...
...Single copies 50c problems are those of any human being-compounded by our society's op- ••••••••••••••••• pression...
...And still it plays such a key of Bishops, perhaps as represented • role, despite and because of the ag- through the Synod...
...tinental, regional and national, provinChurches to inject fresh concepts and I agree with Father Hebblethwaite's cial and diocesan, vicariate and interpastoral experience, then return to their desire for some system through which parish curias are burgeoning everylocal communities after a few years...
...Revs...
...thorities" have now granted me a sabWe are launching a safe-shelter housing program...
...menical field...
...But let others FIRE burning 15 ft...
...And which for Father Hebblethwaite small Catholic monastery of the English Benedictine Congregation with an active and varied minis...
...in Contemporary Theology and The Law of Christ, a quandary exists...
...To call it a and lay groups, and to pastoral coun- (June 17-22) court tout court is quite astonishing to cils at various levels...
...Box 5050, Grand style which, to my mind, ill-suited the tem" which Father Hebblethwaite so Central Station, New York, N.Y...
...and ideas, plus informative articles...
...To combinations Philip Scharper James Coriden this seven-year veteran of courtier in- of these...
...The continue to look for the more rigorous contraception and to abort results in Christian faith, he insists, both detheological synthesis that Miring's ear- mands and makes possible a confideath for the new life...
...Allowing homo- dence in personal survival after death...
...Homosexuals' emotional US and Canada...
...BOX 329R, Commonweal...
...With reconciliation as its task, the church cannot inconclusive, and the claim that wars for the structure of redeemed human be written off as irrelevant-for it holds mankind's only hope in a chaotic world...
...show men that it is possible to live as and why men came to fear women is The use of mutuality as a criterion humans one with another...
...Throughout his political career he has His suggestion that we should perhaps put personal considerations first, and there is little reason to believe that remove the taboo on homosexual rela- the practices of a lifetime would be dislodged when his political survival is tionships which are characterized by at stake...
...more inter-office coor- enough, unfortunately for Father Heb- bear, in faith and love and service...
...Printed In the USA and published weekly, in a Catholic social agency and private, except biweekly Christmas-New Year's and June to mid-September...
...Write: Director...
...tensions of the Curia...
...Write FOLK MASS of the "Other...
...national issues is hardly preposterous when the case can be posited that the Baum is irresponsibly poking around interim agreement on offensive nuclear weapons, reached during Nixon's at a taboo, not fully aware of the pos- Moscow trip of 1972, reflected his reelection interests...
...level of consciousness...
...breakthrough" he expected with the Soviets on control of nuclear weapons, Psychotherapy oriented toward growth and what Father Baum so well but, unfortunately, with some unmistakable evidence that Watergate has crossed the ocean and now become a factor in the policies of nations dealing describes as the clients' right "to say with the United States...
...A woman's freedom not to use Russell Aldwinckle does not...
...level diatribe a year ago...
...can be suspicioned of a politician...
...My "higher auhas made 64 families living closest to us destitute...
...unbiased judge...
...the enhanced ton, D.C...
...I N THE of Commonweal will gain increment ing "platonic" love in a violation of in their understanding of religion and Plato to undercut the force of Eros...
...Perhaps the Universal curial staff should travel more...
...themselves in jeopardy...
...care for foster children will probably and purpose here on earth-and thereresult in the death of that child's op- by enhances our ability to live meaningfully before death...
...While the basic thesis sexuals, may in fact cause far more worthwhile, says Robert Paul, but imhas validity (at least is worth consider- pain and suffering...
...Box 444, Saratoga, Calif...
...One year (8 issues), $8.00 ($9.00 foreign...
...Conlarly brought in from the local tional councils of churches...
...45c, seven times...
...MICH...
...12 April 1974: 142 strongly blames...
...CORRESPONDNEWS & VIEWS: 122 CORRESPONDENCE: 123 ENCE GROUNDS FOR HOPE: John J. Egan 124 WHENCE THE NEW CONSERVATIVES...
...But these are personal combe lived inwardly, these individuals may day of freedom without corresponding ments already made via open letter and be able to develop their full uniqueness responsibility (the moral vacuum of during a London visit last May with without having to be the scapegoat of Muggeridge) encourages the individual my brother in the Lord, Peter, whom I the latent homosexual...
...closely evaluated, questions asked and giornamento...
...WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEEK GOD as a monk, praying and working in the warm fellowship of a GERALD E. NELSON, M.D...
...To episcopal congiornamento...
...progres- accountability be assured to the awaken- Church will after all need a curia of sives, while advancing in number and ing People of God, as well as to God global scope to oversee and to coorposition, are still outnumbered, espe- Himself...
...June 9-14...
...He could negotiate short by inadvertence as well as (Continued on page 141) through cynicism...
...For box numbers add 50c per insertion...
...too many staff members are lifers ample, on the method of receiving the However, I hate to disappoint the -new men aged 35-45 should be regu- Eucharist, and on membership in na- idealizers of the future Church...
...Augustine, S.D.B., S.J...
...42c, thirteen times...
...To what degree are these Gustavo Gutierrez Langdon Gilkey trigues...
...liness and guilt which accompanies the These lead to Hebblethwaite's emLiturgy NEW...
...Presumably you were moti- ice within the Curia gave a moderate summer programs, especially for low income children, year-round program for adults...
...This time we were ap- a downright insulting one to an incumbent President...
...Is perhaps the celibate priesthood serving...
...I was then still a member system" for the exercise of authority of not more than 250 or 300 words of the Curia and received not one by and in "the Vatican" is directly re- naturally have a better chance of word of criticism or indication of dis- lated to changes within the whole fabric being published...
...of the Church...
...out...
...BIBLICAL INSTITUTE, Trinity College, Burlington, To the Editors: For your thoughtfulness ing and eye-opening experience within Vermont 05401...
...Letters April, 1973...
...in his sin- of the Synod which "has slumped to beClassified fulness and refuses consciousness and ing an occasional, tolerated talking RATES: 50c a word, one time...
...What surprises me is that insisting on more than the new shoultinuing reform: it is still too secretive it is changing so fast...
...UNICEF Cards...
...Most hetero- homosexual to seek relief from pain would have as friend and colleague in sexual individuals have had homosexual and self-denial in relationships which agreement or in debate, past, present, feelings and the capacity to act them are usually self-destructive and self- and future...
...Madras 600057, India...
...havior will result in removing one of 194 pages, paper $3.95 THE SATANIZING OF WOMEN: Religion the strongest pressures on an individual Versus Sexuality, by Demosthenes Sav- to seek a heterosexual orientation...
...Wedded to Mother Church, the capable editor of The Month, the muchuality as a "gift" from God, not to be individual can be creative and genera- admired publication of the English lived outwardly but as an archetype to tive in the best sense...
...Information: broken taboo...
...Has the church ramis, translated by Martin Ebon, Many individuals in a "homosexual abdicated the hope Doubleday, $6.95...
...COMMONWEAL A Weekly Review of Public Affairs, Literature and the Arts...
...But sometimes this is due lieve it or not, several of my former tion is advancing well at the top, but to local Church decisions and not to colleagues and dear friends of the Ronot at the level of middle-management, the Curia, which does suggest options man Curia welcome moves in this diand almost all 'foreigners' are Western- and freedom on certain matters, for ex- rection...
...An editor of religious you wish...
...Foreign $16...
...To clergy If 1STITUTE man Curia is a court...
...followed and admired the thinking of By historical standards, Schlesinger's seems a gratuitous assurance, and Gregory Baum...
...A fact that no one can deny...
...The climate to- Jesuits...
...In Virginia my biased judgment my term of servCREATIVE PERSON or couple to reside on 300 "The Vatican," I am deeply grateful acre camp site near Richmond, Virginia, to develop [Feb...
...10016 MUrray Hill 3.2042...
...133 VERSE: Edward Proffitt 137 GEORGE ORWELL AND THE AMERICAN CHARACTER: Sunnyvale, Calif...
...On page 16 author did not...
...interests of the country and certainly not to compromise the nation out 151...
...Twelve words minimum...
...One or two years...
...the need for an evaluafor human dignity-through education, skilled trades, agriculture, engineering, business, urban Myth and history seem to point out tion of the papacy without being acplanning, medicine & other fields of community that both the primitive and the saint cused of lese-majeste...
...That the given had to be articulated of the homosexual is due to our soci- demonstrates the sorry pass to which the country has come...
...the courtly tradevelopment...
...Most episcopal conferences are not STUDIES My main experience of the Curia yet ten years old, the Synod not yet (June 27-August 2) is plain hard work by Christians who eight...
...Removing about personal destiny, here is a reasoned and persuasive defense of the IN BRIEF the taboo of overt homosexual be- Christian doctrine of immortality...
...To the universal College cluded...
...That state which we (My emphasis...
...hesitancies in the ecuoverseas and U.S...
...95070...
...Savramis, a Greek, me it denies that whole body of knowl-" At your bookstore or write writes in German and his text may edge which encourage the development suffer in translation...
...For the Catholic Church is, ing the Successor of Peter of some of Commonweal: 143...
...the signs were inconclusive...
...No longer, however...
...batical year during which I will adKATHIVAKKAM Social Welfare Center, Ennore, fers in Commonweal...
...internationaliza- blethwaite...
...To generalates A THEOLOGY Hebblethwaite says "bluntly: the Ro- and provinces of religious...
...SECULAR CITY morality in our time from this book...
...A responsibility of reliev- Resident facilities available for men and women stitutions...
...His hypothesis that the suffering of personal interests of his own...
...If, however, we death is obsolete...
...I too am a critic...
...Katharine Byrne 135 MANDELSTAMS--SEARCHING FOR SIGNALS: John Heidenry 138 To the Editors: As a "straight" family BOOKS: James M. Gustafson, Elliott Wright 140 therapist who has worked with many JAMES O'GARA...
...Copyright © 1974 Commonweal Publishing Co., Inc...
...Must we believe those scienand respond to religious-moral exhor- tists, philosophers, (Continued from page 123) and even theolotation that is in touch with current gians who tell us that theological developments, there is a grate, resulting in disaster for the chil- hope in life after satisfactory resolution...
...SACRED SCRIPTURE: Sixth Annual Institute, August Last month I resigned from the Ro11-16...
...To 88 pages, paper $1.95 allowed to dangle...
...Individuals with the perative...
...Our emphasis on rights and defusing impeachment action, and so has timed a return visit to Moscow freedoms of the individual has resulted for June, when it is likely that proceedings will be coming to a head in in our neglect of the individual's re- Congress...
...Our marriages disinte- the ultimate worry...
...are not quite good enough to demand lescence) will be led to continue in even a brief review...
...Airmail 26c...
...Free catalogue...
...Not fast and far ders, personal and institutional, can and formalist...
...GERTRUD MUELLER-NELSON means "compendiously the Vatican City try, including the conduct of a college preparatory school...
...ety's historical and collective position It is sorrier yet, because the reassurance is not so unnecessary as might that homosexual behavior is not nor- at first be implied...
...20525...
...The saint accepts the lone- shop...
...Some good books phase" (which usually occurs in adoof fife before death...
...the future ing company (mutuality...
...call holiness or sanctity, "Oh happy mordial question: the system of which Vocations fault that merited so great a Redeemer...
...The primitive refuses the exposed to no outside checks on its Bruce Mazzie, ACTION, 0CP Box P-5, Washing- risk and remains whole on a lower competence or efficiency...
Vol. 100 • April 1974 • No. 6
