EDITORIALS:
CORRESPOND- NEWS & VIEWS: 74 CORRESPONDENCE: 75 ...
...COLLEGE in which castration is one of the most MISERICORDIA, Dallas, Pennsylvania 18612...
...Daly may be trying to con- Flushing, N.Y...
...48c, three times...
...Kilby's introduction to his deja vu...
...ples...
...Thanks for is considering the issue of amnesty for Vietnam-era draft evaders and your articles on hunger and poverty deserters...
...Discussion and study of destrian...
...With shield en in religion or the Church-like her review her book...
...Steinfels implies...
...the sword...
...what bread and Eucharist is all about...
...a thoroughness we are now fighting...
...Daly's new book is a creative ologist, among, others, review the book...
...ligion (1971...
...One or two years...
...Lewis have not reached any desirable imagined archetypal situations, that Commonweal has to be held responlevel of sophistication since his death draw the reader in with a sense of sible for this dirty trick and an equal in 1963...
...1], is inaccurate family and its homes, and shots of Ox- the daily commuter in his fictions, his and misleading...
...Daly outdoes them all...
...But Philadelphia, Pa...
...the significance of Dr...
...At Ecumenical Conference But on to matters of importance: the cost of honesty...
...11365...
...As accustomed as we have become to esty in arguing that Dr...
...1,000 BUSINESS CARDS, $5.95...
...Daly's book she would know that MARGARET O'BRIEN STEINFELS fels as reviewer [Feb...
...Daly is setting herself up as earth...
...the President's power to pardon, saying: "There can be no question that Renew my subscription...
...Draft resisters, in his view, had made a serious mistake Father...
...Copyright © 1974 Commonweal Publishing Co., Inc...
...20009...
...your choice of Margaret O'Brien Stein- Dr...
...Dig Wells I read it three times...
...The letters Beyond God the Father: Toward a 181, the relationship of the photos of of "Jack" Lewis, as he signed himself, Philosophy of Women's Liberation is, natural scenery to any advance in our counterpoint the cosmic melodrama in my opinion, a philosophical work of knowledge about Lewis is tenuous...
...Daly's feminist views...
...Why A careful reading of Beyond God the fiction by Lewis draws the reader in and did Commonweal choose an anti-wom- Father: Toward a Philosophy of Womforces him to accept the author's posi- en, a non-theologian, a "man's woman" en's Liberation will, I believe, support tion, even in all its hyperbole, or reject to review a feminist theological work...
...11 on Dr...
...Lewis certainly a review...
...But O'CONNOR, SUELZER, COLLINS, MINEAR.,EAR...
...Her 'Transposition," Lewis once pitied the bogged down and discouraged by their purpose is not to condemn, nor is it man whose "world is all fact and no repetitious setbacks...
...author-Martin Marty's in the Critic...
...C, 57-22 163rd Street, This failure to see the woman-ques- 3. Dr...
...important commissions, but when the as the ones we are presently struggling Vocations subject matter is women, anyone's view- with...
...Accepting meaning in fact in read C. S. Lewis because he fought this to construct a philosophy of sisterhood...
...Commonweal legitimately perceptive-both readable and think- could have had a theologian, philoso- PEACE CORPS & VISTA NEED YOU...
...Single copies 50c ical opposition to birth control...
...Following Senator Taft to the witness chair was Robert F. Froehlke, Cincinnati, Ohio Army Secretary under President Nixon in the closing stages of the Vietnam To the Editors: Commonweal Magazine war...
...arship about it...
...Ladies, it is a broadside...
...Five-bedroom house and salary...
...What siah...
...Join the universal struggle But Dr...
...Like a gospel, a does she know about theology...
...That is not Bruce Mauie, ACTION, OCP Box P-5, Washingviewer not been a specialist in the area scholarship, it is polemic...
...But because of the it and be damned with the Calormenes, And why did Commonweal print such gravity of her remarks, I think it inWeston, and all the rest...
...Our un- most avoids reference to the European stitutions, beliefs, and believers upon derstanding of Narnia and the universe war going on as it is being written, the women, as "fantasy" is irresponsible...
...think they will be soon...
...Lead-off witness was a man who must surely be a typical voice [Feb...
...Marieb's and Farians' small Catholic monastery of the English Benedictine Congregation with an active and varied minisletters are any example...
...fled the country rather than fight in Vietnam "because the draft and the Mary Daly's book, Beyond God the killing is over...
...BOOKS: Robert Leiter, William E. May, Gerard Reedy 90 To the Editors: I think Ms...
...It seems curious to be accused of did not admit to having felt some hesi- Institutes tancy about my review-hesitancy in SACRED SCRIPTURE: Sixth Annual Institute, August a hatchet job by defenders of a book 11-16...
...the United States, he said, must show mercy to the young men who Steinfels' hatchet job [Feb...
...Reply tory school...
...Write: Director...
...Especially in pages 118 to the present work provides...
...Farians has and buckler in place, as heretofore own earlier book-I would applaud been as enlightened as she claims by advised...
...Louis, Missouri 63141...
...Daly's book as liams, in The Place of the Lion, play I do, she has, in my opinion, in reviewwith the notion of something like the 000 000 000 ing that book, unjustly discredited Mary Platonic ideas taking flesh and walking Daly by accusing her of "a blind and (or stalking) the earth...
...If Dr...
...Lewis hiked...
...If he judges the reader harshly, time review by a competent woman religion is a solid start, complementing the options for good he provides are so theologian is demanded...
...Outsiders will except biweekly Christmas-New Year's and June to mid-September...
...Carroll Stuhlmueller, James Reese and the face of the fact that sexism remains Robert Karris...
...April 1-3, 1. My assurances to Commonweal 1974...
...For box numbers add 50c per insertion...
...offers the meaning of life...
...85 HISTORY AND THE HISTORIAN: Richard L. Schoenwald 86 A CASE OF LITERARY MALINGERING: Leonard Kriegel 89 Washington, D.C...
...readers that I did read Dr...
...Expenses paidmedical, travel, vacation, living...
...Lewis can often be quite difficult...
...Busy"ness had me on War criminals are safe enough, then...
...Letters o f not more than 250 or 300 words Virginia tled Toward a Philosophy of Women's CREATIVE PERSON or couple to reside on 300 Liberation...
...It would be naive to COMMONWEAL A Weekly Review of Public Affairs, Literature and the Arts...
...His recommendation: creation menu...
...There was a long list of witnesses before the House subcommittee that theological malnutrition...
...If it is difficult finding Lewis en's Liberation [Feb...
...endemic in our society and the struggle BIBLICAL INSTITUTE, Trinity College Burlington, enthusiastic images...
...tion as a serious scholarly area is almost struct a philosophy of sisterhood, but, Liturgy universal, of course...
...I know many, many etary distances as "God's quarantine or get thrown away...
...Obviously I fancy 7 SUB-SAHARA COUNTRIES stricken with severe droughtl Water urgently needed for drinking, cookwhich did not help raise my opinion ing, bathing, irrigating...
...Nor dragons and death, against a cosmic is of the essence of evil, even of the is she condemning the human race, as background of cliffs and mountains...
...pher, historian, psychologist, or soci- overseas and U.S...
...Daly is a theologian...
...wells and saving human lives to: MISSIONof the book...
...Revs...
...Steinfels to account 29 March 1974: 94 for her irresponsible treatment of the of history, psychology, and sociology...
...have seen, only one was written by Printing effort...
...He at least disagreed with cause they left me uneasy and dis- the Administration contention that action by Congress would intrude orl turbed at my own complacency...
...Two with the details of human infidelity, major importance...
...BOX 329R, Commonweal...
...Write Father Luke Rigby, Box 27311, 4. I would be less than candid if I St...
...this book, my favorites are those of photo of the # 2 Oxford bus that Lewis To the Editors: Much of what Margaret Lewis' fellow "Inklings," Williams, Bar- daily took home from Magdelen Col- O'Brien Steinfels says in her "review" field, Tolkien, and the rest...
...for human dignity-through education, skilled theological effort and requires a com- They chose a historian and I say the trades, agriculture, engineering, business, urban petent theologian as critic...
...religious also implied by Ms...
...Daly's book (DR...
...Worse than that, howford, Cambridge, and various parts of simple humanity is everywhere in his ever, is the cheap portrayal of Dr...
...For Ms...
...some kind of holier-than-thou new mesof disbelief is the last response Lewis Who is Ms...
...WRIGHr` MURPHYpatriarch said about those who live by against it should be supported...
...Commonweal welcomes letters on ARIES OF AFRICA, 1622-21st St., N.W., Washington, D.C...
...In looking book is full of spurious history, of his- planning, medicine & other fields of community over my last two issues of Commonweal tory selectively presented to agree with development...
...ELIZABETH FARIANS, PH.D...
...At the cost of "AGREED STATEMENT on Ministry and Ordination: allowing ourselves all those deceits and Anglican/Roman Catholic Convergence...
...BIOGRAPHY PRESS, Rt...
...10524...
...ALAN WOOD, Dept...
...It is necessary to merely to name the demons, but it is meaning...
...Information: I see that in no other case has a re- Dr...
...Foreign 416...
...In the mean- Printed in the USA and published weekly, time-probable famine...
...20525...
...Daly's book Classified Unfortunately Commonweal was not to the ethereal world of "philosophical alone in unintentionally downgrading works of major importance," or to de- RATES: 50c a word, one time...
...Steinfels anyway...
...Printing...
...The starvation in the next 12 months could be the greatest calamity in the history of mankind if food, fuel, fertilizer and AMNESTY fertility aren't adjusted...
...Continue the Congress has the Constitutional authority...
...Steinfels to splendid drawings of Siegfried by Ar- dentists, hopelessly terminal illness, and label scholarship which takes seriously thur Rackham, an early, critical influ- making ends meet...
...Box 444, Saratoga, Calif...
...refusal to try of men who made a serious error," Mr...
...Someday we may all discover of a board to consider amnesty for draft-evaders on a case-by-case basis...
...my contentions...
...his plots are pe- women who are enlightened, uplifted, regulations...
...A PRACTICAL MAGAZINE for everyone interested in liturgy resources: songs, poems, art, Church assumes that only canonical or religion-a religion that promises to and ideas, plus informative articles...
...a religion that will not tolerate WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEEK GOD as a monk, praying and working in the warm fellowship of a point will suffice...
...According to a bill of which he is the author, a board would be set up to [REV.] JOHN WILLIAM WARD review the applications of young men who wished to earn immunity from prosecution by agreeing to do two years alternative service or two years Beyond Belief in the armed forces...
...Feb...
...I, Box 745, Aransas Pass, Texas 78336...
...The space traveler, the protagonist of Mary Daly's book, Beyond God the tors include letters and juvenilia illus- in cosmic struggle, was, like us, a com- Father: Toward a Philosophy of Womtrated by Lewis, studies of the Lewis muter...
...GRAYMOOR ECUMENICAL INSTITUTE, Garsubtle signs of power against which rison, N.Y...
...Certainly a willing suspension personal attack on the author...
...of the eldila might well begin with 1939 sermon, "Learning in War-Time," Dr...
...Hence a source of many of the book's probably the reliability of that judgTo the Editors: If Mary Daly's recent exaggerations and misstatements of ment Commonweal readers can only Beyond God the Father were just an- fact, and hence my outrage at the sug- gauge after they have read the book, other of the general books about wom- gestion that only a theologian should which I urge them to do...
...the national scene...
...14 a year...
...Commonweal: 95...
...that I came down on the side of honbook and of Mary Daly...
...None of these accusations is true...
...Volunteer your skills & experience in developing nations able...
...A former opponent of amnesty, Mr...
...Margaret O'Brien Steinfels' so- which should now be forgiven because of their youth...
...Lappe ILLUSTRATIONS: Front cover: Lincoln Gazette/LNS makes an irrefutable case that the world JAMES O'GARA: Editor JOHN DEEDY: Managing Editor RAYMOND A. SCHROTH: Assoclate Editor ANNE ROBERTSON: Editorial Assistan could support more people if goods COLIN L. WESTERBECK, JR.: Movies JOHN FANDEL: Poetry BRIAN WICKER: Great Britain ALAIN WOODROW: Paris were better divided...
...Daly England and Wales through which letters, sermons, and in the photographs as "enemy of the people...
...But the debate on amnesty goes a reading diet and I was suffering from on...
...summer programs, especially for low income chip The book contains generous servings dren, year-round program for adults...
...asks from the reader...
...Daly is not playing games with these drawings of an innocent facing does not...
...How does one CORRESPONDENCE ignorant assault on the sins and sinners read such scenes...
...JOYCE M. MARIEB theologians mucking about in worldly misses the mark of where we have been fields, Dr...
...Let us YOUR BOOK PRINTED from well-typed manuscript...
...45c, seven times...
...Free Sam...
...General Food for Thought Westmoreland has retired heavy with medals and is almost forgotten on Bethlehem, Pa...
...as Catholics wrestle with their theolog- US and Canada...
...Twelve words the book...
...what might be called a peer of the not modestly draw the veils of schol- Economical...
...should it be supported at all costs...
...2. Beyond God the Father is subti- subjects treated in its pages...
...Amnesty must not called "review" of Beyond God the be approached from vindictiveness but rather from the standpoint of a Father was no review at all...
...If Perelandra al- the oppression inflicted by religious inence on Lewis, are reproduced...
...What was it some Vermont 05401...
...But who HENRY TEN KORTENAAR: Rome JOHN COONEY: Dublin needed to be convinced...
...Steinfels...
...Christian tives those features of Western religions In a seminal Pentecost sermon, men of culture know this but get which serve to dehumanize women...
...by Commonweal Publishing Co...
...One year (8 issues), $8.00 ($9.00 foreign...
...to narrowly confine Dr...
...Steinfels sees Lewis, in the Ransom trilogy, and Wil- lief than most...
...He excels at fantastically and encouraged by Dr...
...try, including the conduct of a college prepara...
...ton, D.C...
...ARLENE SWIDLER criticism, if Drs...
...Indeed, the only war criminal the papers talk about any To the Editors: The right mood, suffi- more is Lt...
...How does one read of the past," by calling her book "a the end of The Last Battle, when Nar- (Continued from page 75) symptom of madness," and by implying nia becomes the new heaven and new to see what the book is about and a that Dr...
...42c, thirteen times...
...Lewis always stressed that it oppression as Ms...
...They provoked indigestion be- for middle America, Senator Robert Taft Jr...
...cumbent upon Ms...
...Froehlke has now changed his has dealt women a low blow in the mind...
...Of the half dozen reviews I fine it merely as "a creative theological minimum...
...covered by the book, although Daly's As a fond student and practitioner book may well be the most complicated of polemic myself, I reject any effort of the lot...
...95070...
...The edi- lege...
...232 Madison Ave., New York, N.Y...
...Calley, and that only because a civilian judge found restriction cient time, and a touch of intellectual to a military apartment too confining for a man who had, after all, only starvation all converged to give me an been found guilty of massacring 22 Vietnamese women and children in cold opportunity to digest the last few issues blood...
...Send contributions for diggin...
...At evil of war, to be repetitious...
...His recommendation: (Continued on page 94) amnesty that is made conditional on draft resisters' duty for three months Commonweal: 75 on the pain or anxiety of another, and was not writing novels...
...Daly's book...
...of Commonweal...
...CORRESPONDNEWS & VIEWS: 74 CORRESPONDENCE: 75 EDITORIALS: 75 ENCE BISHOPS IN BONDAGE: Peter Hebblethwaite 76 FROM WATERGATE TO WHERE?: Peter Steinfels 78 LIBERATING PORTUGUESE AFRICA: Joseph P. Carney 79 RETREAT FROM BOOMTOWN: Peter Freiberg 83 Feeding the Hungry THE SCREEN: Colin L. Westerbeck, Jr...
...Daly's book...
...R. J. Reilly's chapter in Romantic Re- beautiful as to be painful...
...The Catholic in addition, she is talking about a new NEW...
...914-424-3671...
...Both discouragement with more wit and be- Whether or not Ms...
...As far as we can tell, not many still want to try Richard M. Nixon as RICHARD L. STROUT a war criminal for such acts as the Christmas terror-bombing of the VietThe Christian Science Monitor namese civilian population...
...naturally have a better chance of acre camp site near Richmond, Virginia, to develop being published...
...He has little Ms...
...Write FOLK MASS theological specialists can function on be as authoritarian and narrow-minded AND MODERN LITURGY, P.O...
...Kilby and Gilbert include what at Of the many splendid photographs in first seems to be a bathetic detail: a Waltham, Mass...
...Second class postage paid at New York, N.Y...
...They aren't EDWARD S. SKILLIN: Publisher JOHN BRUBAKER: Advertising Manager justly divided...
...The whole cast of characters out of the Pentagon Papers is going about its business scot-free and full of public honor...
...Steinfels claims to have read the fundamentalist hostility to science, sympathy for most of his characters, Beyond God the Father but her piece whereby Ransom talks about interplan- who either come up to his standards shows no sign of it...
...10016 look with sympathy and compassion MUrray Hill 3-2042...
...Steinfels' 'credentialism' is part of the patriarchal reviews are consistently interesting and mentality...
...It was a just and generous nation dealing mercifully with a relatively small number blind (and deliberate...
...Write Sister Marianna...
...She exits best, C. S. Lewis: Images of His and imaginative experience, on the amines and analyzes from historical, World gives us note after note towards other hand, is personal and unique, and philosophical and theological perspecfuture study of its subject...
...Froehlke said...
...and where we ought to be going...
...June 9-14...
Vol. 100 • March 1974 • No. 4
