CORRESPONDENCE:
CORRESPOND- NEWS & VIEWS: 2 CORRESPONDENCE: 3 ...
...The in- I believe matters of social concern KENNEDY clusion of several critical selections must be sensitively interwoven with lends an open and inquiring tone to other human issues facing man today...
...It was based on published $250 Inclusive...
...but some institutions, in order to Where were its members when the deTIE FAT11ER qualify for desperately-needed state cisions were being made...
...10524...
...refer to and meditate upon...
...I, Box 745, Aransas Pass, Texas 78336...
...Will it work or won't it...
...Now this is in- done, especially since, as the editorial guage" to the writer...
...So the Feast of Mary, Mother of COMMONWEAL A Weekly Review of Public Affairs, Literature and the Arts...
...tolerant and understanding...
...As stated in these di27 2-week workshops .. . orders have simply had to redefine rectives, education, in various forms, topics range from Prayer their ministries to meet new needs...
...Yet you are munity living" is not a separate option Notre Dame, Ind...
...CORRESPONDNEWS & VIEWS: 2 CORRESPONDENCE: 3 EDITORIALS: 3 ENCE THE VATICAN AND ISRAEL: Henry ten Kortenaar 4 WASHINGTON REPORT: The Reality of the Budget: Sisyphus 5 'COMING OUT' FOR TOMMASO: Michael Novak 8 Pax Vobiscum PENTAGON SPIES AT THE WHITE HOUSE: Peter I. Ognibene 9 THE DECLINE AND FALL OF FRANK RIZZO: T. Laurence Berry 11 Niles, Ill...
...Listen closely at any "have really been failing attempts to Presidential press conference...
...the President's popularity is down-the polls show it and I hear it everyThe Feast of the Solemnity of Mary where-but ;let's be practical about it...
...Energy/Alternative tory and the convent...
...The ulti- discovery of God being granted to mate promise the book presages, then, many...
...WILLIAM 0. AYLWARD to several reasons why good people Prayer and Work PERSONS of independent means interested In creleave the religious life, and that there atiny commune for prayer and work in Nation's Capital, contact Box 38M, Commonweal...
...But there they left "a disheartened community the editorial implies a judgment of are many sound-and even pressing- holding the bag...
...Your edi- Michael Novak...
...if the knowledge that they once pos- ligious life and to a genuine response Economical...
...One year (8 issues), $8.00 ($9.00 foreign...
...He needs it...
...20525...
...We miss the boat, I think, when we do not celebrate in liturgy on that day .IDOUILEDAT Many of the testimonies speak of a new "sense" of God, a "savoring" of the human reality which is so signifiHis Presence, a "tasting" of His Good- cant: namely, the beginning of a new 17-Issue Trial, $3 Return coupon from back cover ness...
...This criticism seems Miss McCormack's decision-imputes a intellectual arguments for such a shift, designed to place Mother McCormack certain captiousness to it...
...In prejudice against the individual and for context, the original sense of the Two 4-week courses . . . the institution...
...He concludes that the readiCatholic Church...
...But, then, you brought it blight...
...clericalism...
...Besides, themselves nonsectarian, while retaining don't they have any faith...
...Commonweal: 23...
...Join the universal struggle mainder of the book is then divided for human dignity-through education, skilled into a number of topics characteristic trades, agriculture, engineering, business, urban of the movement such as "Baptism in planning, medicine & other fields of community the Holy Spirit" and "Speaking in CORRESPONDENCE development...
...She is described institutions, in the cases of colleges (Is this phrase just a variation of the as being, within her own field of higher and universities) to determine...
...Or read deal with deeper problems of faith8 March 1974: 22 in the church, in God, in the future constitute an insistent summons to of religious life...
...THE EDITORS 1974, GRAYMOOR ECUMENICAL INSTITUTE, Garrison, N.Y...
...I think it's overessay "Politics and the English Lan- ligious characters...
...your skills & experience in developing nations its emergence has aroused...
...In his The Holy Father Haughey's book demonstrates ness to find new ways is the first priorSpirit in Today's Church Erling Jorstad, some of the possibilities which such ity of the Church . . . the Church Professor of American Studies at St...
...A ties, trustees, alumni of various insti- and nuns who changed their vocations, major change in her order, however"- tutions have agonized over the issue did so after single-handedly changing as you put it "was not for her...
...Does Commonweal have an says, such changes are commonplace The thumbnail sketch of the Society official position in this matter...
...We simply described a situa- small Catholic monastery of the English Benedicfine Congregation with an active and varied minisDoes the spirit breathe where it will, tion: that critical observers (not tory, i school...
...48c, three times...
...Jorstad selects brief ex- ton, D.C...
...One by now...
...Now this is an am- view the life of a religious community biguous and confusing section of the as a particular following of Jesus, as PASTORAL INSTITUTE editorial...
...is resentment against religious leaders Institute To the Editors: The reasons for mem- who transform their institutions and BIBLICAL INSTITUTE, Trinity College, Burlinqton, Vermont 05401...
...The renewal of time by the obCommonweal: 21 servance of the start of a new year is lady might take exception...
...sal Church by Pius XI on the fifteenth US and Canada...
...Are you questioning the per- a charism within the multiform life sonal faith of these people...
...MOREHOUSE-BARLOW opening chapters on the history of hundredth anniversary of my favorite Pentecostalism in America, on the new 14 East 41st Street mentor's death it may, perhaps, be per- New York 10017 Pentecostalism emergent in the 1960s missible to "come out": one of the and characterized by its flourishing within the mainline denominations, seven times seven dwarfs upon the and on some of the controversy which giant's shoulders in the succession of PEACE CORPS & VISTA NEED YOU...
...Or is "the complaint" Philadelphia, Pa...
...And who nnxp,y b Ly their religious identity through influ- exactly is it in...
...ecclesial organization...
...One obvious move is to try to dissociate the Republican party from (REV...
...JR.: Movies JOHN FANDEL: Poetry cent reform of the liturgical calendar BRIAN WICKER: Great Britain ALAIN WOODROW: Paris aimed at consolidation whenever pos- HENRY TEN KORTENAAR: Rome JOHN COONEY: Dublin EDWARD S. SKILLIN: Publisher JOHN BRUBAKER: Advertising Manager sible...
...It is with that this is nitpicking in light of the this foreboding in mind that many Republicans are racking their brains in main point and admirable purpose of an effort to find some medicine that will cure the party of the Watergate your editorial...
...People scribe a new GOP response to Watergate...
...JEROME C. ESPER, C.S.C...
...In no way, shape or form is Watergate ing for Peace" [Jan...
...remains our primary ministry: "At a to Politics It seems curiously inconsistent of you time when the integral development to berate Mother McCormack for do- of man is a task of special urgency, For brochure, write: ing just what the orders have done...
...14 a year...
...But to me it seems an indicteeyow'b 9 ma should keep their religious characters...
...In other words, as more and more Republican strategists see it, from the reality of the day and the Mr...
...the American people understand it, or our party will be paying for that I miss the old celebration of the Cir- `third-rate burglary' for decades to come...
...It is Elsewhere in the article he mentions editorials such that your next annisad, I think, that we seem to bypass "the complaint" against Miss McCor- versary edition can proudly include the more earthy dimensions of life like mack: "that she has changed things items from 1974...
...Qs the vague and evasive terminology are works accomplished by these people BEXCON PRESS familiar enough...
...fore commit ourselves to the renewal, v But why do you seem to rule out the at depth, of our life as community, RATES: 50c a word, one time...
...a helpful "handbook of the new pente(paperbound) $2.50 costalism," designed as a basic intro- 00000 0909 duction to the movement...
...Yet he never identifies the SUSAN R. GANNON of more abstract and ethical themes...
...Information: Tongues" (to name but the two most (Continued from page 3) Bruce Mazzie, ACTION, OCP Box P-5, Washing...
...45c, seven times...
...When they pulled out, the jaunty phrasing of this section of part by financial pressure...
...But "bold tries to up-date static institu- lications to lambaste priests and nuns your editorial of Feb...
...Were for the conservative faction are almost as explicit...
...Such a tactic is all very fine, and at this point Peace...
...For me, these changes as instruments of God...
...Personally, I don't know tion essential to the future of our re- YOUR BOOK PRINTED from well-typed manuscript...
...Write FOLK MASS In short, your editorial smells of Religious of the Sacred Heart AND MODERN LITURGY, P.O...
...12 ance ["Working for Peace," Jan...
...ence rather than through power...
...Sacred Heart in 1970 "to offer five Theology Department What's more, your criticism of options for apostolic work (the poor, Catholic Committee Mother McCormack is given from a the Third World, community living, on Urban Ministry perspective which clearly reveals your internationalism and education...
...95070...
...Watergate entirely...
...1], a guest editorial by any your recent anniversary issue was a ture of prominent priests and nuns chance-say from Triumph, The Wanreminder of it) when Commonweal from the religious life (paragraph derer, or the Standard and Times of could be counted on for hard-headed, three) and the "others" who find the Philadelphia...
...Or are you of the Church, not limiting my vision FOR SOCIAL MINISTRY saying that all the reform programs to the single dimension of task-oriented they initiated were not to the point...
...He leaves the reader to P.S...
...Foreign $16...
...Needless to say, Miss McCormack (REV...
...prominent priests education, "an agent for change...
...and one can note with interest is the renewal of Trinitarian theology The Church now the affinity to the language of the and the Church to come .. . in the Catholic tradition...
...But the Surely such decisions are properly left of "critical experts...
...We are now in the process of Finally, you concede that "these learning how to implement this manmen and women, in their own ways, date of the 1970 Chapter: "We there- Classified may have been instruments of God...
...treatment given Miss McCormack war- to the individuals (or the individual According to these "critical experts" rants some comment...
...To be sure, such de- the character and style of their relishe has started a new career...
...VERSE: Sister Maura, S.S.N.D...
...One or two years...
...Included in his prescription (Continued on page 21) were the following: support by the party for reforms in campaign financing Commonweal: 3 initiates such an approach...
...while demands...
...10016 and which was extended to the Univer- MUrray Hill 3.2042...
...Com1112 Library meet her new needs...
...Nixon is a stone around any candidate's neck, and individual officeseason...
...15 To the Editors: Kindly spare us your 'THE FUTURE OF THE CATHOLIC PEACE MOVEMENT': An Exchange of Views 14 fashionably irreverent editorial ignor- THE SCREEN: Colin L. Westerbeck, Jr...
...in fact, as we said in the Director.Ecumenical Conference verse as the people themselves in their editorial, we defend these reformers "AGREED STATEMENT on Ministry and Ordination: Anplican/Roman Catholic Convergence...
...914-424.3671...
...We do not share that re- O'CONNOR, SUELZER, COLLINS, MINEAR...
...aNEWI A PRACTICAL MAGAZINE for everyone interested in liturgy resources: songs, poems, art, no longer has any use for them...
...My God, I of the particular position...
...vey of opinion on the matter...
...being insinuated through the mouths might muster for the subject...
...know that the GOP is in very big trouble indeed-a fact dramatically You may now consider yourselves illustrated by the election of a Democrat to fill Vice President Ford's Conno longer "hard-pressed to explain the gressional seat, the first time a Democrat has been elected in that district exact meaning of the Solemnity of since 1910...
...THE ANTI-FEMINIST BACKLASH: Jean Bethke Elshtain 16 BOOKS: Ronald Christ, Joseph A. Page, Robert P. Imbelli 20 Even Commonweal's memory should JAMES O'GARA: Editor JOHN DEEDY: Managing Editor be long enough to recall that the re- RAYMOND A. SCHROTH: Associate Editor ANNE ROBERTSON: Editorial Assistant COLIN L. WESTERBECK...
...Not on New...
...Copyright Q 1974 Commonweal Publishing Co., Inc...
...11 refers to a deci- June 24-July 19 second, a kind of Monday-morning sion taken by the Religious of the quarterbacking...
...In the context of list- word "options" in our chapter direc- Church and Its Mission ing the changes some colleges are tives conveys the meaning of mandate American Society in '70s forced to make, you make this analo- and commitment rather than that of plus . . . gous case for religious orders: "And alternatives...
...WRIGHT, MURPHY, bers of religious congregations chang- then leave...
...June 9-14...
...Times from former Governor of Texas John B. Connally: "I know from Mass...
...For the charisa seemingly "theoretical" context will matic movement seems to represent a GOD'S MOVING SPIRIT the most pressing of practical prob- recovery of the affective and experilems find illumination: the purpose of ential spirituality associated with names Ralph Morton freedom, the meaning of love, the like Augustine, Bernard, and Ruysrealization of personhood, the quality broeck...
...the future of the church, or only in reports, interviews with lay people, Vocations some preconceived notions of what con- other religious and Miss McCormack WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEEK GOD as a monk, praying ~ and working in the warm fellowship of a stitutes legitimate reform...
...service...
...April 1-3, life situations...
...Year's This guide to better self-understandWhat strikes the interested reader Day, however, in the manner suggested ing Is "a book to re-read, consult, by your editorial...
...Morton examines today's open society and its movement both within and without the evidence of a similar concern...
...WILLIAM D. STEELE imagine armies of students, faculty, deserves an apology...
...The re- overseas and U.S...
...Perhaps the challenge facing Ralph Morton-famous for his coof relations which constitute authentic the movement (and the hope which authorship of God's Frozen People and community...
...SISTER LORETTE PIPER nd ideas, plus informative articles...
...25] and the liturgy what the Republican party is all about, and we'd better make damn sure of New Year's Day...
...cumcision...
...Though the would go home depressed if I went to passages chosen are brief, they give, Mass and heard the type of homily you EUGENE Ce for the most part, a representative sur- recommend...
...Single copies 50c centenary of that Council) has beencommendably-joined to the celebration of the Octave Day of Christmas REPUBLICAN PROSPECTS where the prayers (Collect, Postcommunion) centered precisely on this A few Republicans still whistle on their way to the cemetery, but most Marian prerogative...
...University of Notre Dame It's just plain arrogant to pretend to do The editorial "Mother McCormack's the first, and fatuous to engage in the Complaint" [Feb...
...Let me be the first to admit for a debacle in 1974 and also in the Presidential race in 1976...
...complainants...
...keep the level of discourse in your widespread expressions of ritual...
...Some from the charismatic or pentecostal of the writers in Jorstad's book give In GOD'S MOVING SPIRIT, Dr...
...Surely cisions have often been shaped in good gious orders...
...Louis, Missouri 63141...
...As things stand now, many party leaders fear the GOP is headed Mary...
...Volunteer seven hundred years...
...up first...
...Facul- editorial "we...
...isation/Distinguished Lecturers/Group Work/Visits...
...simply an inept rhetorical device like To the Editors: Is your editorial, Pleasantville, N.Y...
...Gannon "TOWARD AN ALTERNATIVE SOCIETY...
...I welcomed the option of cele- seekers would be wise to put as much distance as possible between them brating a day of prayer for World and the star of Watergate...
...the social gospel...
...It would be a pompously announces: "we think re- Cormack done to Commonweal to kindness to pass on a copy of Orwell's ligious colleges should keep their re- merit such criticism...
...probably the only tack that has a chance at success, but it still remains a As a local pastor I would never in- gamble...
...The thinking " (paragraph four...
...ment of the disheartened community...
...the nameless "critical observers" who "Mother McCormack's Complaint" To the Editors: There was a time (and detect certain patterns in the depar- [Feb...
...is the experiential and ecumenical na- An Image Book, $1.75 ture of contemporary Pentecostalism...
...Twelve words possibility that they still may be such convinced that this is the one condi- m.nimum...
...circumcision and a new year in favor too much...
...Write ecFather Luke Rigby, Boxr 27311, Commonweal, or only where you tell it...
...alumnae, parents, all shaking their M cCormack's Complaint heads sadly...
...For box numbers add SOc per insertion...
...Only in such mystical tradition...
...Pilot...
...Gloucester, Mass...
...Expenses paidmedical, travel, vacation, living...
...Various party leaders have taken to following this tack, most recently and explicitly Senator Charles H. Percy of Illinois, himself Humble, Texas a Presidential hopeful...
...One cannot but rejoice in the year...
...theology of the Trinity issues today sustained theological reflection...
...1, "Mother Mc- tions have really been failing attempts who decide to change their lifestyle, Cormack's Complaint" is certainly not to deal with deeper problems of faith...
...One expects these pubsober, and responsible editorials...
...To help ensure that dissociation does have flict on my congregation the type of a real chance at succeeding, Senator Percy in his remarks went on to presermon your editorial suggests...
...At your bookstore or Jorstad himself supplies three brief Michael Novak (Cont...
...herself...
...freedom of openness and experiment...
...which commemorated the vindication Printed in the USA and published weekly, except biweekly Christmas-New Year's and June to mid-September, at Ephesus of the title of Theotokos by Commonweal Publishing Co., 232 Madison Ave., New York...
...He's not going to be on the ballot seems very contrived and very distant again...
...distinctive...
...teresting...
...It sees legitimacy only Oxford within the narrow confines of the rec- REPLY: We regret that Ms...
...Senator Barry Goldwater's we afraid that junior might ask what acid comments have been well publicized, but consider also this quote in "circumcision" means on the way home the N.Y...
...but I thought Commonweal was more in the great tradition...
...we reaffirm our educational mission Coordinator She has redefined her ministries to as our service in the Church...
...Were they financial aid, have had to declare that uncritical and passive...
...God, formerly observed on Oct...
...Oxford Summer Schools, July 5-19, 1974...
...Information: 9 Morton Avenue, Kidlingfon, Oxford, England...
...evidenced in it is confused and the In his final paragraph, your writer In any case, what has Mother Mcwriting is incompetent...
...There was something very Senator Percy represents the liberal wing of the party, but spokesmen earthy and Jewish about it all...
...But even if it is warranted, of the Sacred Heart is recognizable might as well say in an equally sweep- is there any reason why the criticism enough-though it is presented with all ing generalization: "we think members can't be offered directly, instead of the snide, false sprightliness Time of religious orders would remain such...
...able whether your hopes are really in editorial...
...its appearance within and not at the God's Lively People-believes that the A potent force pressing for renewed margin of the traditional churches conflict between tradition and experiment in the Church is inevitable-and reflection upon the Holy Spirit and the elicits) is to submit the experience to essential...
...Printing instruments...
...But please, Commonso deeply grounded in human nature torial-writer, like Atticus, is willing to weal, remember your past, and try to that it is one of the oldest and most hint the worst, while saying nothing...
...Write: ing their vocations surely are as di- sentment...
...11 Second class postage paid of New York...
...so of secularization...
...this is often problems of the human species in a followed by a selection from a critic twenty minute homily...
...cerpts from writers associated with do not come to Mass, especially on Pentecostalism who present and explain New Year's Day, to be told all the Now in Paperback the theme in question...
...The You go on to say, quoting some lack of focus, the loose connectives, more critical experts, that all the atro 6cS<s~M $8...
...Aylward have misread our Technology / Education / Communities / Decentral...
...The Pain of the whole discussion, well suited to a There is a place and a time to preach Being Human vital and still developing movement...
...Yet nothing arguments blithely ignored by your and the other prominent priests and has been actually said to which the writer, who deals with a delicate and nuns just mentioned in the unflattering complex matter in the following sen- light of irresponsible and heartless betence: "We think religious colleges havior...
...Said Senator Percy to his fellow-Republicans: "We To the Editors: Here are a few random must not put ourselves in the position of even seeming to condone or gloss thoughts on your editorial on "Work- over the misdeeds of Watergate...
...42c, thirteen times...
...necessarily ourselves) have pointed St...
...It is question- and Mr...
...46556 querulous with her, while offering a but the sine qua non of evangelical palliating rationale for the institutions...
...BIOGRAPHY PRESS, Rt...
...sibly were God's instruments will sus- to the summons of the Church and Liturgy tain them in the realization that God the world...
...reflection offers for the clarification must be willing to enter into a new Olaf's College, Minnesota, has edited and heightening of experience...
...Box 444, Saratoga, Calif...
Vol. 100 • March 1974 • No. 1
