BOOKS:
Heideurv, John & Gersh, Gabriel
when they see their work as a "turn- ical Don Quixote by the meaning of So there are chautauquas about how ing point" in the study of slavery. It "quality" and the notion of...
...Dictators, 1922-1945, Anthony Rhodes dismisses the charges of callousness or pro-Nazi sympathies, and reserves his criticism for the involuted baroqueness 'V% Mw IM w*s to unbom you...
...way...
...of Philosophy, deeply racist and elitist ideology has Tufts University governments, Pius XII immured himinfected the roots of several sciences...
...For box numbers add 50c per insertion...
...Beset on all sides by the unsupported, which only shows how countervailing pressures of self-seeking Dept...
...ought to try to fix it-providing one is The author contributes a breadth of Your first issue is waiting...
...5.00 donation...
...All gone anti-Semitic (one of his early mistresses, 10022, 23 August 1974: 462 and certainly the most intelligent one, real core of criticism, however, is Kamin has shown...
...ates from thing to mechanic...
...or, when it comes Jews under the various Popes and fito that, writing one's own War and nally under Mussolini...
...equal partners on the long journey to- was aware of the extermination of Eu94501...
...self...
...Ranches yet the end result is to find oneself The author's thesis is that many EXCEPTIONAL 5-ACRE RANCH...
...In a manner is like a forerunner of a new kind of causts of concentration camps, contoo complicated to recapitulate here, technological intellectual: not just the fronted by many pious but anti-Semitic the father realizes that the son has graduate out of engineering school Christians, self-effacing in such combeen "carrying" him emotionally de- without the least interest in the hu- pany, but daring to say, "My plan, you spite the reverse situation of father manities...
...As Eric GUIDE state...
...There sketches a rather ambiguous chautauqua wonder the phenomenon has died out...
...ingness to reach out, help his boy, What is frightful about Pirsig is his JOHN HEIDENRY show him just a little love that will technological hatred for what he calls save both of them...
...a Commonweal: 463...
...I have consumption...
...author's best chapters, "Jewish Fas- erous and careful assessments of the Only with regard to premise (3) do cists," shows the extent to which many former only underscore Mr...
...His technological instructions, Reading it is like taking a reading of whether on computers or motorcycles, A unique single-source reference to 106° in the shade...
...Open Court, $9.95 The fate that overtook the Italian Jews Amnesty was remarkable because of their long AMNESTY BRACELET with war resister's name, silver plate...
...Martin E. Marty...
...This is because he has a pas- materials needed in adult (and high a rather monotonous motorcycle trip sion for wanting the reader to under- school) religious education prohe took with his eleven-year-old son stand technology and not run away grams...
...like trying to read Tolstoy, or make proper setting the fate of the Italian Mozart live again...
...Suzuki is trivial or complicated, as equivalent days of edifying lectures, concerts, and not likely to have foreseen...
...Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Hoffer correctly is quoted as saying Maintenance is like a thermometer in a jacket blurb, Pirsig is a born For Adult Religious Education protruding from the anus of America...
...It is a tellGuidelines, newly revised for Cincinnati Archdiocese...
...Pius XII denounced the racial policies less, they are demonstrably false or NORMAN DANIELS of the Nazis...
...travel across the lonely blacktop into philosophers from Phaedrus to Hegel cycle Maintenance the Great Plains we learn that the on the meaning of quality...
...but someone who has learned know...
...If there some set of valves, loving and hat- a rhetorical tour de force, that he has is a meeting place beyond the grave ing, but above all wanting it to work never been insane...
...The invidious and para- richly extended our knowledge of these RATES: SOc a word, one time...
...From the antediluvian model capable of han- counseling prisoners in jail-to teaching blind kids to swim...
...In view of the massive publicity vigorate the mystique of an aging fas- campaign the hereditarians have recism, to give a new cause and dynamic 000 000 000 ceived, however, and in view of their to a youth disillusioned with his revo- relentless activity as proponents of their lution...
...SAFE RETURN, IS6 GABRIEL GERSH presence in Italy, their complete idenFifth Ave., NYC 10010...
...The twin obliged to witness countless acts of of not more than 250 or 300 words study and adoptive children study data atrocity which the war entailed...
...the height of his influence and fame One doubts whether Mussolini was Help for their protect can be sent to: Catholic Relief Services, 1011 First Avenue, New York, N.Y...
...quiry into Values"), not people...
...Pirsig has no inten- to concentrate on reading some simanachronistic term evokes an image of tion of providing for this ubiquitous ple instructions on, say, how to operate a bygone America in the days before machine what the great Taoist masters an electric can-opener, or fix a tire...
...REVIEWERS And conviction...
...or hit it full-square, and wound up in and grey skies in Montana, and many a mental ward...
...younger Pirsig too may be "mentally But if the reader is in some ways enROBERT M. PIRSIG disturbed...
...Premises (1), noble champions of the truth...
...10016...
...The new chautauqua is ropean Jewry, that the Vatican's proMusicians the motorcycle manual...
...Some things are who shouted "My plan, you know...
...Vacation Paradise...
...kitchen and shelter for homeless, destitute street children in the refugee-swollen Cambodian capital...
...RANCHOS, Box 2003CK, Alameda, Calif...
...42c, thirteen times...
...Twenty-two issues yearly for $16.95, by First Class Mail...
...STAMP SERVICES, SAM WAAGENAAR Box 84, Camillus, N.Y...
...He has drawn Classified Peace, or distributing one's goods to on many sources to good effect and has the peasants...
...writer...
...Waagenaar's book belongs to motorcycle...
...And hands...
...Lake Conches, New the complete egotist: everything is the Popes believed that the Jews were the Mexico...
...Rhodes' gen- background as the main determinant...
...As father and son more on insanity, the arguments of Zen and the Art of Motor...
...sympathy through their claims to be ian Jews...
...For years before Pirsig became dropping it off at the repair shop, and National Catholic Reporter a writer and editor of technical jour- learn to fix it...
...COMMONWEAL, 232 Madison Ave., New York, N.Y...
...If it were lingness of many Italians to take great (2) and (4) have long been widely Jews or Anglo-Saxons, and not Blacks, risks, many more Italian Jews would believed by behavioral geneticists, edu- who were being "proved" inferior, have perished...
...It's more than helpmation at the Pope's disposal...
...Write LITURGY OFFICE, 5440 Moel- field, if this is the future, then I'm glad ing indictment marshaled with an imler Ave., Cincinnati, Ohio 45212...
...cational theorists, and psychologists, would there be such favorable press Yet one must agree with the author's compensatory education programs of and sympathetic response for their objection to the slowness with which the 1960's notwithstanding...
...and so on...
...I n fact, American Red Cross tackles over 100 different kinds of "Helping People" jobs-in the city, the suburbs, wherever you are...
...24 Australian Xmas The Pope's Jews Italy has been the freest not only of stamps 1957 fhru 1972 plus Rwandaise Popes Pius XI, XII, John, Paul for 30o with approvals...
...Or he does so in a trans- metaphorized the repair of machines, the summer outdoors for two or three mutation of Zen which Dr...
...Pirsig describes his book as a What is between them, in a sense, the person who really is unable even series of chautauquas...
...After a stint at Benares for us whether the cumulative sick- Hindu University in India he wound nesses of our society are ebbing or up writing technical manuals...
...to repair a motorcycle, and others will, nevertheless, provoke considerable Somewhere he missed the windmill, again, almost lyrical, on blackbirds discussion...
...In a rather touching scene literature only to repudiate it, or sub- the spate of postwar literature that inon a beach, at journey's end, there is sume it to the qualities of the machine...
...the Romanticist, by which he means Mr...
...What is the rush...
...Neverthe- "rights" to promote their views...
...history at Columbia University, is the author of Harlem Renaissance...
...self behind walls of silence...
...Had it not been for the wil(4) IQ causes success...
...If to develop a Secretariat of State beyond you like people, we have more than a few things you could be doing...
...Free brochure...
...Easy Terms...
...In his naturally have a better chance of used for estimating heritability are book, The Vatican in the Age of the worthless, as Princeton Professor Leon being published...
...confronted by his young self...
...That is to rides his colleagues in this profession THE say, a work that is the opposite of the who neither understand what they are platitudinizing or moral-cancer-diag- writing about-the machine, technology RESOURCE nosticating the heads of church and -nor know how to write...
...What makes in this book it is this: the next time CHURCH HISTORY -THEOLOGY the narrative almost compelling read- your radio stops working, or your auto- DOCTRINE - DEATH & DYING ing, however, is that the journey is mobile breaks down, try to fix it your- ABORTION - PREJUDICE also a going back into another time self...
...The critical tone of his re45c, seven times...
...according to plan, you see," says the old whole or part, his technological credo The trouble is, the son will be "all self, resplendent in his dinner suit, to or not...
...Waage- Jensen, Shockley and Eysenck stand Italian Jews supported Mussolini...
...Of course, Mr...
...One of the sions of his position...
...But we also need hearts...
...Cost: $2...
...The Good GABRIEL GERSH recently edited and NeWibm translated a collection of Gabriele D'Annunzio's essays...
...Pirsig says the future of America POVERTY - SEX - PRISONS and space somewhere in Montana is the machine and it will keep break= ECUMENISM - THE JEWS where the author was a person he calls ing down until we take the Zen ap- WORLD RELIGION - ATHEISM, Etc...
...from their home in St...
...Patently he has been treating right" now because he has the "right which the young self, perky, ill-dressed his son as a machine...
...Waagenaar, like many others, tions about the latter...
...Louis...
...Commonweal: 461 termine whether the author recants, in the two for the first time in years...
...naar's severe criticism of papal hestita- out on their very own limb...
...Pirsig comes to the realiza- and not too sure of his vowel sounds, tionship of a mechanic with a trouble- tion, in what can only be described as replies, "My plan, you know...
...CORRESPONDENCE views, it becomes impossible to achieve One of the drawbacks in this admir- public exposure of their racist and able book is the author's failure to (Continued from page 443) elitist views without clearly answering emphasize the many deeds of individual the persons as well as the ideas...
...NATHAN IRVIN HUGGINS, professor of Call your local chapter...
...Letters race-biased achievement test...
...are likely accurate, logical, in a way On one level Pirsig tries to recount poetic...
...If there is one valuable lesson Pacific coast of California...
...When the radio falls apart one which little has been written in English...
...When Pirsig came are identical, which is nonsense...
...It "quality" and the notion of reality...
...The motorcycle and the rider are murderers of Christ, that the Vatican Good long form investment...
...Timesaving, "inside" summary of religious and so- urgent...
...4, 221 W. Madison St., Chicago, IL 60606...
...If cation" of America...
...offer: You may cancel on receipt of invoice...
...Implicit in the book is a doccontrary, a repellent and dispiriting nology and is in that sense a "thingifi- trinaire Zen idea that self and thing work by a not very likable man...
...To misappro- tests were feeble, that no Jews were CHURCH MUSICIANS...
...We Box 281, Kansas City, Mo...
...He inflated by his memories of the holoheartlessness, as it were...
...to his own rehabilitation into a "sane recreation...
...all the speakers on the chautauqua cir- out of the sanatorium he abandoned At the end of the narrative Pirsig cuit were like the author, it is no the teaching of rhetoric as futile...
...dling the quantity and quality of infor- Remember: Red Cross is more than blood drives...
...64141 nals, he was a teacher of philosophical have a month, he tells his son, to get rhetoric, obsessed like some pedagog- to California...
...Phaedrus," after the ancient Greek proach, look upon the busted radio, teacher of rhetoric denounced by in a sense, as ourselves, forbear $9.95 a+ bookstores end Plato...
...The self is not always so im- The focus of the book's attention is cial news . . . a rich source of ideas for portant-sometimes it is the least im- the Italian Jewish community about sermons, programs, classes...
...and the son gradu- where those of similar tastes foregather, right...
...This deliberately is the motorcycle...
...Paul to the from it...
...not too busy doing something better view to the subject by putting in its Write CONTEXT, Dept...
...cution, but even of a Jewish problem...
...was nothing about the quality of ideas in which the reader is unable to dePerhaps it is true that some books one could get one's hands good and are like thermometers which generalize dirty with...
...of the Pontiffs speeches, or his failure C-""• -`^) Next time you say, "I haven't a thing to do;' think...
...No risk portant...
...In an age of acute (3) is also false, as Professor Richard believes that Mussolini's conversion to nationalism and dangerous dictatorship, Lewontin has clearly argued...
...What revolts the reader is lightened, he certainly feels little moral Morrow, $7.95 the father's almost pathological unwill- elevation...
...In large part this is, to the The motorcycle is a portable tech- person...
...Yet the irony Religious Stamps is that of all the European countries, COLLECT RELIGIOUS STAMPS...
...3) Black/ White IQ have been awarded much undeserved Christian heroism in rescuing the Italdifferences are also highly heritable...
...radio and television, or for that matter have done for archery or the art of Pirsig has for all practical purposes motorcycles, when people assembled in serving tea...
...However, Mussolini also called for more than a prudent and press, are in error every step of the turned racist because he tried to rein- vacillating Pontiff...
...But the ing the thousands of victims of disasters...
...when they see their work as a "turn- ical Don Quixote by the meaning of So there are chautauquas about how ing point" in the study of slavery...
...Religious, the most brutal forms of Jewish perseXmas, Vatican City stamps...
...000000000 We need money, it's true, so we can go on offering all our free services...
...Twelve words minimum...
...pressive array of facts...
...And ian Jews and the Popes...
...monthly in advance about "values" (the subtitle is "An In- complex relationship between the Italfor more than t::ree times...
...carrying the son on the back of the a great deal about philosophy and Mr...
...one can imagine the shade of Hitler, Pirsig does get an insight into his Pirsig has considerable integrity...
...Mfila0lrlCill JOHN HEIDENRY is a free-lance writer Red (kOiL and critic living in St...
...It is the rela- attitudes...
...13031...
...Only $995 per acre...
...cal audience, by Dr...
...48c, three times...
...dicts the Christian world-particularly a real communication of love between Perhaps the most "romanticism" is the Catholic Church-for either its into treat a motorcycle as the self and difference to the plight of the Jews or time as something that can be divided its readiness to join the chorus of those CONTEXT-six-page newsletter for an ecumeni- into equal Zen parts...
...technology is that it is concerned only searches gives a fuller picture of the Classified payable with order...
...They highly heritable...
...DisilluThere is no reason to believe the IQ sioned of his aspiration to become the Commonweal welcomes letters on test is anything more than a class- and peacemaker of the world, he was subjects treated in its pages...
...Join us...
...So these anti-Semitism was due to his alliance the leadership of the Church surely revolutionaries, for all the heralding with Hitler...
...He deflowing on the fever chart...
...Employment and Salary priate the words of Katherine Mans- given refuge in the Vatican...
...And Economists Margherita Sarfatti, was Jewish), and, whether the Pope was lacking in judg- Samuel Bowles, Herbert Gintis and as the author tells us, he once told Emil ment in relying so much on the diplo- others have demolished the claim that Ludwig that Italians regard racial dis- matic rather than the prophetic dimen- IQ causes success (they point to class crimination with contempt...
...wards eternity...
...doxical thing about Pirsig's vision of sources...
...tification with the national life, their Phnom Penh Max Beerbohm has depicted, in a fewness in number and their loyal and THE MISSIONARY Brothers of Charity plan a well-known cartoon, Arnold Bennett at distinguished service to the country...
Vol. 100 • August 1974 • No. 19
