THE BORDERLINE SPECTATOR:The Immigration Trap

...ters in 29 states, 9,000 registered volunteers, and an e-mail list of 1.3 million...

...Richard Shaftan, who runs the PAC, argues that even the threat of a Hillary Clinton presidency may not be enough to dissuade disgruntled conservatives from bolting the Republican Party...

...The Minuteman Civil Defense Corps, not to be confused with Gilchrist’s Minuteman Project, has 61 chapEven the threat of a Hillary Clinton presidency may not be enough to dissuade disgruntled conservatives Announcing The American Spectator’s Young Journalism Training Program Promoting Excellence in Journalism by Training the Next Generation of Writers & Journalists from bolting the Republican Party...

...Hayworth and Randy Graf ran as hardliners on illegal immigration and lost...

...McCain will likely emphasize the hoops that illegal immigrants would have to go through to obtain citizenship under his reform plan...

...The list of possible Constitution Party nominees includes former Republican presidential hopeful Alan Keyes, Minuteman Project founder Jim Gilchrist, and Jerome Corsi, who co-authored a book on immigration with Gilchrist and also co-authored Unfit for Command: Swift Boat Veterans Speak Out Against John Kerry...

...42 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR F E B R U A R Y 2 0 0 7...

...Even Sam Brownback, who is presenting himself as the only true conservative in the field, came out in favor of a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants, drawing the ire of those who view such a policy as rewarding criminal behavior...

...He argues that Hayworth lost because of his links to convicted lobbyist Jack Abramoff and Graf fared poorly because he didn’t receive help from the Republican establishment, which supported his more moderate opponent in the primary...

...by Philip Klein HEN HILLARY CLINTON’S HUSBAND was elected president in 1992 with just 43 percent of the popular vote, many analysts believed that he owed his victory to the nutty Texas billionaire H. Ross Perot, who did well among middle-class and wealthy white voters who typically voted Republican...

...In addition to tougher border enforcement, Tancredo advocates imposing penalties on employers who hire illegal immigrants, which, he argues, would cause a natural exodus of immigrants back to their own country because they could no longer find work in America...

...The split within the conservative movement was reinforced by the starkly different interpretations that were offered for how the immigration issue played out in the recent midterm elections...

...Tom Tancredo, who has become the most prominent spokesman for tougher measures to stop illegal immigration, told TAS he was “seriously considering” seeking the nomination...

...Even in those races in which immigration was prominent, the results were not encouraging for proponents of tougher measures against illegal immigrants...

...Nclear that deep fissures remain on the immiO gration issue, which could mean big trouble MATTER WHICH NARRATIVE IS ACCURATE, it’s for Republicans in the next presidential election...

...That’s a completely biased spin,” he says, and offers a competing analysis...

...The American people aren’t being suckered into going with one party or another anymore and I think this will be a key litmus test and a real indication, this next presidential election, of just how willing voters are to go away from both parties,” Simcox said...

...But Chuck Muth, who deals with the immigration issue as president of the grassroots organization Citizen Outreach, thinks that if any legislation is passed, the immigration issue will become less important because voters will determine that the issue is being dealt with, as has been the case with past legislation...

...Clymer said that the party expects to be on the ballot in 46 to 50 states in 2008...

...One side argues that the elections proved that the immigration issue, which had been trumpeted by some as the potential savior of the Republican Party, was a dud...

...The Republicans always have their bogeyman, and this time it will be a bogeywoman,” said James Clymer, the chairman of the Constitution Party, which hopes to woo conservative defectors from the Republican Party, especially on the immigration issue...

...And we might still be looking at a Republican-controlled Senate today were it not for Stan Jones, the Libertarian candidate in Montana who may have siphoned off enough votes from incumbent Republican Conrad Burns to elect the Democratic challenger, Jon Tester...

...He also notes that when Arizona voters were able to vote specifically on the immigration issue, they overwhelmingly approved three anti-illegal immigration ballot measures, and another one to establish English as the state’s official language...

...No issue remains more divisive to Republicans than immigration...

...In a column published after the election, Linda Chavez wrote, “Now that the people have spoken, maybe the Congress will finally listen and pass comprehensive immigration reform...

...He argued that his policies as mayor were based on the fact that he took over a city that already had an estimated 400,000 illegal immigrants and emphasized that many of the same tactics he employed to cut crime in New York could be applied to improving border security (such as increasing law enforcement personnel and making better use of technology...

...901 Arlington, VA 22209 To learn how you can qualify to participate, write: Young Journalism Program, c/o The American Spectator The Young Journalism Training Program provides practical, hands-on journalism training for journalists by journalists...

...1611 North Kent St., Ste...

...President Bush, in press conferences and interviews, has repeatedly said that he hopes to work with the new Democratic Congress to do precisely that...

...If you have someone like McCain, the chances of a viable third party candidacy would be a very real thing, because to a lot of conservatives it would make no difference if it was McCain or Hillary Clinton, only McCain would be more dangerous because he’d be a Republican pushing all of this nutty stuff...

...Instead, he predicts an “erosion” of some of the measures that were passed last year...

...In 2000, Ralph Nader captured less than 3 percent of the popular vote nationally, but his 97,000 votes in Florida were more than enough to cost Al Gore the election...

...We saw activism in that issue drop in our direct mail” In the next year, the leading Republican presidential candidates will do their best to placate the conservative base on the immigration issue...

...F E B R U A R Y 2 0 0 7 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR 4 1 T H E B O R D E R L I N E S P E C T A T O R It’s difficult to quantify the potential appeal of a third party movement fueled by the immigration issue, because polling results on immigration depend on the way the question is asked and how people define “amnesty” or “tough border security...

...PRESIDENT BUSH FOLLOWS THROUGH on his vows to work with the Democratic Congress on bipartisan legislation, it could trigger one of two reactions...

...Ron Paul would also be welcomed into the party, but neither of them is expected to leave the Republican Party...

...A Tarrance Group poll conducted days before the midterm elections found that by a margin of 48 percent to 46 percent, Americans agreed with the statement: “Any program in which one who is currently an illegal immigrant could earn the right to citizenship is amnesty...

...But with Hunter and Tancredo long shots to win the nomination, chances are anti-illegal immigration activists will be left without a candidate in either major party...

...I don’t think there will be a wholesale rush to the left on this, and by that I mean a massive amnesty or guest worker program that will be put through with one big bill,” Tancredo said...

...10 of the 18 candidates it supported won...

...Program emphasis includes news writing, investigative journalism, writing and editing for the e-news media, and developing effective writing skills...

...On the one hand, it could highlight the fact that the two-party system has failed those who support tougher measures against illegal immigration...

...A lot of people were worked up [last] year, but when Congress passed the legislation that authorized building the wall on the border, we saw the intensity of that issue drop tremendously even though there wasn’t money, even though it wasn’t built...

...Philip Klein is a reporter for The American Spectator...

...Simcox disputes the conventional wisdom that interpreted the election results to mean that Americans rejected a get-tough approach to illegal immigration...

...We’ll do everything we can to ensure that McCain doesn’t get to the White House...

...Despite blanket news coverage of immigration protests last spring, by the time the fall came around, the issue wasn’t on the radar in most congressional races...

...T H E B O R D E R L I N E S P E C T A T O R The Immigration Trap The issue that could send Hillary to the White House...

...Thus, her best hope may be to follow in the footsteps of her husband and divide and conquer...

...But if none of these gestures is enough to satisfy anti-illegal immigration hardliners, Hillary Clinton may be able to return to the White House—even if most people don’t like her...

...Duncan Hunter, who is a hardliner on illegal immigration, has said he intends to run, and Rep...

...The potential impact of the immigration issue will depend largely on what happens legislatively this year...

...For instance, the new Congress probably won’t adequately fund the construction of a 700-mile border fence that was authorized in a law signed by President Bush weeks before the elections...

...In Arizona, both J.D...

...In 2008, the Republican nominee could be especially vulnerable in potential swing states where the immigration issue is prominent such as Nevada, Colorado, New Mexico, and Arizona (if the nominee isn’t McCain, since it’s his home state...

...In a speech in New Hampshire a few days before the midterm elections, Giuliani gave a preview of how he may handle criticisms that he was lax on immigration as mayor...

...Candidates accepted into the program will have regular hands-on supervision, training, and editing, and will be published in TAS and Spectator.org...

...The question is whether they will stay home, or even 40 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR F E B R U A R Y 2 0 0 7 P H I L I P K L E I N defect to a third party in large enough numbers to swing the election, especially if that means risking another Clinton presidency...

...The same poll found that going into the elections, 11 percent of Americans identified illegal immigration as their most important issue...

...The biggest challenge Hillary faces in winning the presidency in her own right is that much of the public wouldn’t consider voting for her, making it difficult to attract more than 50 percent of the vote...

...Romney, meanwhile, in one of his last acts as governor, authorized state troopers to detain illegal immigrants—a move that drew kudos from Pat Buchanan...

...Tancredo and Rep...

...Not so fast, says Chris Simcox, president of Minuteman Civil Defense Corps, the grassroots group that gained notoriety for organizing volunteers to help patrol the border...

...It divides economic conservatives and populists, Beltway policymakers and grassroots activists, as well as urban conservatives and those living along the border...

...Of the three top contenders for the Republican nomination (John McCain, Rudy Giuliani, and Mitt Romney), none is considered acceptable to anti-illegal immigration hawks...

...Are you an aspiring writer or journalist looking to take the next step in building a life-long career as a professional journalist...

...It takes the issue off the table for a lot of people,” Muth said...

...Incidentally, that’s a position along the lines of the McCain-Kennedy bill that angered many grassroots conservatives...

...WEVER, A THIRD PARTY CANDIDATE would not have to garner Perot’s 19 percent to make a difference in the outcome of the election...

...If they passed amnesty, that will be the catalyst for millions more people going away from both parties and going with a third party movement,” Simcox said...

...But when given further details, 68 percent of Americans thought “A program in which an illegal immigrant could earn citizenship over many years by paying a fine, working, paying taxes, living crime free and learning English isn’t amnesty and is a reasonable way to deal with 12 million illegal immigrants here now...

...In addition, the group started a political action committee last year that raised nearly $1,000,000...

...In particular, he viewed a McCain candidacy as the most likely to cause anti-illegal immigration voters to abandon the Republican Party, because of McCain’s co-sponsorship, with Ted Kennedy, of a comprehensive immigration reform package...