THE TALKIES: Humanized Without Honor
Bowman, James
THE TALKIES JAMES B O W M A N Humanized Without Honor p What OLITICS ASIDE," wrote the New York Times critic, Stephen Holden, of HanyAbu-Assad's Paradise Now, "the movie is a superior...
...The movie ends just before the bus is blown up, and the consequences of the act of terrorism are tastefully omitted...
...In any properly organized society, this nomination would be a scandal, but the media have been too busy lately desperately trying to strike a spark of scandal in the wet tinder of Dick Cheney's hunting accident or the Bush administration's selling out our ports' security to a pack of A-rabs or its failure to stop Hurricane Katrina from devastating New Orleans to pay any attention to the movie industry's kudos for a cinematic apology for murderers...
...The reason for picking this particular morsel of humanity to celebrate is precisely so as to minimize the importance of an inhuman deed...
...DISTORTION IS NOT ACCIDENTAL...
...We watch the Germans, French, and Scots, most of whom we must suppose to be doomed to fall in the nearly four years of carnage still to come in World War I, climb out of their trenches for a few hours and treat their prospective killers as human beings...
...I felt obligated to see the movie," said Tal's father...
...I'm living at the end, and it's definitely not paradise...
...I just wanted that day back...
...James Bowman is a resident scholar at the Ethics and Public Policy Center and The American Spectator's movie critic...
...Ultimately, understanding why such an act was performed is irrelevant to the irreducible fact of its evil...
...This is politics reduced to the Lennonist "Give peace a chance" level, or Rodney King's "Can't we all just get along...
...Now here would be something for "nuance" to get its teeth into...
...Just once it would be nice to see a movie that knew so much about human beings as that, or that understood such a thing as honor even existed to be put into the scale along with humanity and compassion...
...The first question to be asked is not whether humanity is represented in the case of the suicide bombers but whether it is humanity that is the salient moral fact about them...
...Tout comprendre c'est tout pardoner, as the French understandingly put it...
...Politics aside...
...The human scale of the film is very interesting, even moving...
...The "understanding" that comes from putting an individual human life and psychology under the cinematic microscope is gained by wrenching that life out of its larger social and moral context...
...In this sense it doesn't matter if we pardon or condemn Phoebe or the suicide bombers in Paradise Now...
...Well, no we can't, as a matter of fact...
...It was wrong what I did to you and Eloise," she says, b u t - referring to 9Ill-"that day I was not a nobody...
...For by its means we can reduce a complex moral...
...I wasn't powerless, because everybody was powerless...
...Holden dehumanizes and renders insignificant their victims and so distorts the moral picture that any genuinely humane way of looking at them would require...
...He and the other families added an "extra page" to the screenplay, describing the human misery the bombing caused, in the form of a full-page ad in Variety...
...We get it, for heaven's sake...
...I particularly liked the comment of the father of Tal Kehrmann, a 17-year-old girl who died on a bus just like the one in the movie...
...Not that you'd know that from this film, or indeed almost any other of the last 30 years...
...Stanzler presumably cannot see this dreadful, politically-inspired moral imbalance, any more than the Academy voters who nominated Mr...
...Penn's crazy lady...
...But it doesn't show the end, it just fades to white...
...But isn't that kind of heavy-handed point-scoring itself just a little simple-minded...
...Just look at Joyeux Noel by Christian Carion, which offers a fictionalized version of the Christmas truce that took place on a part of the Western Front in France in 1914...
...Paradise Now is a good illustration of the hopelessness of the movie culture when it comes to dealing with serious political subjects...
...That Mr...
...Where's the nuance in that...
...But understanding can be overrated, particularly when the point of it is not just to pardon evil acts but to make us forget that they are evil...
...The subtext of such a film is therefore to excuse those deeds...
...All of human history shows us this...
...As a result, the film raises the question of whether or 58 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR APRIL 2006 JAMES BOWMAN not Islamic terrorism even exists apart from the fear of it, which has resulted in the shipping off to Guantfinamo of the innocent brother of Ashade (Abdellatif Kechiche...
...In other words, it humanizes the bombers only at the cost of dehumanizing Tal Kehrmann and others of their victims...
...CertainlyAshade and the other Muslims in the film are very far from being terrorists...
...THE TALKIES JAMES B O W M A N Humanized Without Honor p What OLITICS ASIDE," wrote the New York Times critic, Stephen Holden, of HanyAbu-Assad's Paradise Now, "the movie is a superior thriller whose shrewdly inserted plot twists and emotional wrinkles are calculated to put your heart in your throat and keep it there...
...Hence the movie-makers and their apologists, like Mr...
...It is onlythe hope that they might be persuaded by her to commit terrorist acts that animates Phoebe, Mrs...
...She tries to explain to Ashade why she falsely denounced him and his brother's wife to the police when he failed to turn terrorist at her bidding...
...The soldiers of World War I died in their millions not because theywere too stupid to know any better, or too timorous to rise up against their masters, but because they believed in something-I would call it honor-that was more important than their individual humanity...
...It is the point...
...What about humanizing some of them...
...Given the explosive political climate in the Middle East," Mr...
...The movie itself divides the world into good people and bad people, only instead of drawing the boundary between them along national lines, it treats the leaders who believe in the war as the bad and everybody else as the good...
...The point is that the humanizing process so admired by Mr...
...Holden, are being disingenuous when they say the movie justifies itself by humanizing its subjects...
...Once again, the effort to humanize the act of a moral monster by means of psychological explanations produces a ludicrous sense of disproportion-as if the petty jealousies and feelings that loom so large in poor Phoebe's delusional world could ever be weighed equally in any plausible moral scale with the loss of over 3,000 lives...
...The filmmakers and their apologists who cite "nuance" and moral complexity as their justification and insist that their critics are guilty of 'Memonization" are often themselves guilty of such thinking...
...APRIL 2006 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR 59...
...It was mildly heartening to see that the families of three Israelis killed by a Palestinian suicide bomber just three years ago on Oscar night protested to the Motion Picture Academy about the nomination of this vile, terrorist-glorifying movie as Best Foreign Film, but their protests were hardly noticed...
...Holden went on, "humanizing suicide bombers in a movie risks offending some viewers in the same way that humanizing Hitler does...
...Humanity is everywhere around us...
...Likewise, he begins the film with vignettes of German, French, and British schoolboys reeling off, parrot-like, patriotic slogans in which each demonizes his country's enemies...
...The humanizing isn't the end but the means to the end, and the end is to excuse...
...The Manichean logic that treats one's own side as "the children of God" (as the bishop puts it) and the enemy as the children of darkness is wrong and simple-minded and what must have kept these men killing each other so assiduously for so long...
...The bombers' humanity is all we see, and it grows so large that it crowds out the monstrousness of their deeds...
...It's a good way to show us the political point of the film's ending where it does...
...It is frankly unbelievable to suppose that it was onlywicked generals and bishops and politicians that kept the war going...
...The same lopsided disproportion between the moral elephant in the middle of the room and their focus on the odd bit of humanity trying to get our attention in a corner is even more striking in Sorry, Haters, by Jeff Stanzler...
...is there besides politics for this "superior thriller" to thrill us with...
...matter to something much simpler and more manageable...
...But of course M. Carion cannot leave it at that...
...What bothers those of us who are bothered by Paradise Now is not that it humanizes suicide bombers but that the effort to humanize them creates a moral disproportion...
...Abu-Assad's film for an Oscar could see it, is partly a consequence of the political monoculture of the movie industry and partly of the illusion of knowledge created by therapeutic analysis...
...To saythat it is, which is what such movies in effect do say, is to trivialize mass murder...
...There, Islamic terrorism is a mere backdrop to the story of a crazy woman (Robin Wright Penn) driven barking mad by a combination of loneliness, self-hatred, and obsessive jealousy of her friend and boss (Sandra Oh...
...He must stick his political oar in by hyping the bloodthirstiness and unnuanced thinking of the superior officers and even a bishop-what on earth is he doing in the trenches?-who put a stop to the truce...
...Demons make more convenient villains than complicated people with their complicated motives" This is a typical liberal misunderstanding...
...The movies make us forget this, not as a by-product of their power to humanize but as their very reason for being made...
Vol. 39 • April 2006 • No. 3
