Scents and Senselessness
Fumento, Michael
And SENSELESSNESS ine cafeteria workers from the Dirksen Senate Office Building cafeteria in Washington, D.C. were rushed to the hospital last August. "Everyone was getting sick headaches,...
...and they just gave off a strong odor...
...No one should be wearing perfume to the theater," the influential California activist Julia Kendall told author James Bovard...
...Could fragrant fabric softeners or detergents emitting neurotoxic chemicals cause the neurological breakdown...
...gloats activist Karen Robinson of Halifax...
...He says: "Typically, they're well off enough that they can afford to drop out if they're allergic to their entire environment...
...Dyslexia is a neurological dysfunction...
...Albert Donnay, executive director of MCS Referral and Resources, which provides so-called expert testimony in court cases and sends patients to clinical ecologists, recently took a baseball bat to a hornet's nest when he opined that MCS caused by breathing in carbon monoxide from coal gas lamps chronically afflicted Edgar Allan Poe and influenced his writing...
...Ronald Kramer, medical director at the Colorado Neurological Institute Epilepsy Center in Englewood, conducted a video electroencephalogram (EEG) to measure her brain wave patterns...
...But the defendants claim to have suffered from headaches, bronchitis, red and swollen eyes, vertigo, migraines, fatigue, sinus infections, and laryngitis...
...This last symptom was in a woman who spent all day on the phone answering customers' questions...
...art of ui434...
...There's even a connection to smoking in general, says Marilyn Pellerin...
...Miller is a clinical ecologist at the University of Texas Health Science Center and co-author of a book on chemical sensitivities...
...The Council on Scientific Affairs considered revisiting the topic last year, but found no compelling evidence to change its earlier conclusions...
...says Patrick Carroll, a general manager for Calvin Klein Cosmetics in Oakville, Ontario...
...She also suggests looking for biodegradable products at local health food stores, as if the ability of something to rapidly break down in a garbage dump somehow makes it healthier...
...People would say the odor was more intense if told it was industrial, and they reported more health symptoms, such as coughing, headache, chest tightness, and dizziness...
...Meanwhile, a 1,400-employee telephone service center has declared itself off-limits to fragrance...
...Basically, we want to destroy the fragrance industry...
...Enda 5Car,r2.„ a,c,z,e...
...Indeed, a Nexis computer database search of newspapers, magazines, and medical and science journals showed virtually no references to the foundation except for Kendall's...
...Because some Canadians claim that fragrances are giving them, well, the same symptoms as those claimed by the Dirksen building cafeteria workers...
...Many of the hospitals have gone [to a ban], so people think it's medically correct," Pellerin says...
...One commonly prescribed treatment for MCS is isolation from modern chemicals, which often translates into isolation, period...
...Because the bans are so broad (recall the one forbidding mouthwash), because there's no set definition of what a fragrance is, and because both the symptoms and the degree of accommodation needed are self-determined, the rules are inherently arbitrary...
...If you say there's no scientific data to back perfume prohibition, they say, `Aha, that's what the tobacco companies said!'" Indeed, it is...
...At least one high school outside Toronto has gone fragrance-free...
...But then it gets turned around, so that chemicals with no other purpose than to create odors, namely fragrances, become culprits in and of themselves...
...While it's not okay to deride those who believe they have MCS, it's perfectly proper to hoot and holler at the bizarre theories and sometimes harmful "treatments" of doctors who keep MCS patients on a perpetual psychological leash...
...Hence the term MCS (often also called not just "ecological illness," but "toxic encepholopy" or even "chemical AIDS...
...William Rea of the Environmental Health Center in Dallas...
...Stephen Barrett, a Pennsylvania psychiatrist who specializes in exposing quackery, says: "Clinical ecologists are a menace to society and should have their licenses revoked...
...Canadian authorities by and large have avoided taking a position...
...Iowa University Medical Center psychiatrist Dr...
...Their ribbon is blue and yellow...
...Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) is also a neurological dysfunction...
...Considering that the whole purpose of a fragrance is to cause smell, that's obviously a false assumption...
...But whereas eyes are very good at distinguishing between, say, an extended handgun or just an extended hand, the nose has a harder time with odors, which tend to be more ambiguous...
...So detractors of MCS are wrong when they say it has no solid definition...
...The Halifax Chronicle-Herald prohibits its 35o employees from using perfume, aftershave, scented deodorant, shampoo, or even strong-smelling mouthwash on the job...
...Further, a diagnosis of MCS can keep a patient with a true, perhaps even life-threatening organic problem from seeing a proper doctor...
...Apparently the ventilation system was sucking in fumes from the powerful kitchen dishwasher...
...There's been no significant opposition to the fragrance fighters, Pellerin told me...
...Reminders pop up on computer screens when employees log on...
...I think people can be made more sensitive by thinking and talking about fragrances," says Dalton...
...It's no different from a business's vacation policy," the newspaper's personnel manager says...
...Since thee's a victim's group for absolutely everything in North America, not surprisingly there are a few for those who disdainfully refer to fragrances as "skunk juice...
...That just doesn't happen with a real seizure...
...The bad news is, the fragrance fighters have already gained a toehold in the U.S...
...According to allegedly clinical studies by MCS doctors, anywhere from 15 percent to a third of the general U.S...
...Note: the minister wasn't being asked to establish whether they exist...
...As New York psychologist Herbert Spiegel put it, "[The patients] just keep going back to their doctors week after week, taxing their insurance companies and enriching the physicians while continuing to live in misery...
...some don't...
...That's almost certainly true...
...A year earlier, no fewer than 170 students, teachers, and others sought emergency treatment at Warren County High School in McMinnville, Tennessee, after a teacher whiffed an odor that she said turned her stomach...
...There's no reliable way of simulating odor in absence of some chemical," says Dalton, because you always have to use one to mask another...
...And once they've snared you, they rarely let go...
...If you go from the 50's to the go's and look at smoking, guess what's going to happen with scents...
...Then how to explain that in Japan perfume is actually funneled through classrooms, and teachers are encouraged to wear it...
...But there have been studies showing people with reported sensitivity to a certain chemical didn't react to it when the odor was masked...
...I had a headache...
...Monell researchers have shown that people do react differently to a chemical's smell solely on the basis of a preconception of what the odor represented or whether it was from a natural or synthetic source...
...Some clinical ecologists have been sanctioned for such negligence...
...Violators are sent home to take a shower on unpaid time (presumably using unscented soap...
...If somebody becomes non-psychosomatically ill at the smell of something, "it's not really the odor, it's the chemical that's coincident with the odor," says Dalton...
...Witness ye the powers of man's most underrated sense, that of the nose...
...I mean, they can't be serious, right...
...Now she has even more to gloat about...
...This FREE special guide will give you everything you need to know about investing in gold...
...In February, a member of the Canadian parliament introduced legislation that would order the Minister of Health to "establish the existence of environmental illnesses...
...The woman wasn't exactly faking it...
...Virginia Salares, a chemist and researcher with Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, likens perfume to "invisible smoke...
...It seems the more word spreads that fragrances can make you feel ill, the more people say they do get ill from fragrances...
...And though Canada is hardly litigious compared to its southern neighbor, a Toronto resident filed suit against a neighbor for invading her air space with cooking smells...
...Federal courts do not consider environmental illness or MCS a scientifically valid diagnosis...
...As she underwent this "seizure," Staudenmayer's co-author, Dr...
...A sampling of 2,000 files revealed that a mere four out of 2,000 patients had tested negative for environmental sensitivity, apparently because they had been diagnosed with cancer...
...The city has struck "fear in the heart of the fragrance industry...
...Mass hysteria, according to an investigation MICHAEL FUMENTO is senior fellow at the Hudson Institute in Washington, D.C...
...The cause of this "poisoning...
...recently dry-cleaned clothing...
...Most of the city's public institutions, and a number of private businesses, now request or demand that workers be "scent-free...
...Why should we have brain damage because people are wearing toxic chemicals...
...If you're poor, you simply can't afford to have Multiple Chemical Sensitivity syndrome...
...Marilyn Pellerin, fragrance manager for Mills Brothers, an upscale Halifax apparel store, says perfume sales have fallen off by about a third compared with five years ago...
...The foundation, located north of San Francisco, is a supporter of MCS...
...Symptoms are often identical to chemical hypersensitivity...
...Washington University medical Professor H. James Wedner takes a rather jaundiced view...
...they just convinced themselves something had happened that hadn't...
...I think Daubert so crushed this thing that if it is an MCS case, they're changing the terminology," says Bonnie Semilof, a Washington, D.C...
...Victims have their own activist group, the Carbonless Copy Paper Injury and Information Network...
...About 8o percent of Halifax's 146 schools now have some form of scent-free policy...
...Doctors who treat MCS patients also go by several names, but "clinical ecologist" and "environmental physician" seem most common...
...Rea claims to have seen over 20,000 patients, and it strains credibility that out of all the hypochondriacs and persons with psychosomatic illness that are out there, none manage to find their way to Rea's clinic...
...Upon exposure to various fragrances she would show behavioral signs of seizure activity, including muscle jerking, becoming disoriented, non-responsive, and giving classic signs of what she believed a seizure would look like...
...Louis Post-Dispatch quoted what it identified as an allergist but was clearly a clinical ecologist offering such pearls of wisdom as: "Don't breathe in what you cannot eat...
...Odor perception is almost always going to be the first cue that there's a chemical in the environment...
...Although the problem was soon fixed, some workers contend they are sick to this day...
...With no Second Amendment to the Constitution to rely on and no hope of getting Charlton Heston to rally to their cause, skunk juice wearers may be in for a tough fight if the Body Odor Liberation Front breaks out of its Canadian and Californian cordons...
...There was no reason for these people to lie...
...Unfortunately, Daubert doesn't extend to the most important court: that of public opinion...
...Could any of these neurological dysfunctions be caused by exposure to neurotoxic chemicals...
...Our [Nova Scotia] business has certainly stagnated and probably declined," he said...
...5Cati2a/x, The Halifax holy war started in 1991 when hundreds of staff members at the Camp Hill Medical Center reported illness from what was widely regarded as polluted indoor air...
...Either you abide by it or you don't work there...
...One worker suffered head and neck injuries when she collapsed, and the eight others reported nausea...
...2aAne gzom OZADA),a...
...The St...
...For years people have hypothesized that," says Staudenmayer...
...They were...
...The only support offered for this claim is a quote from a nurse at a Nova Scotia MCS clinic...
...Concerns Of Volatility...Uncertainty...
...So much for the benefits of onion and garlic...
...Most of the time somebody responds to a chemical, they're responding to an odor," says Pam Dalton, a cognitive psychologist with the Monell Chemical Senses Center in Philadelphia, which is chiefly handed by the National Institutes of Health and by some private companies as well...
...Can something carried in the odor itself be debilitating...
...some are synthetic...
...The American Medical Association, the American Medical Council on Scientific Affairs, the American College of Physicians, the American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, and the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology have all rejected MCS as a legitimate organic disease, with the last two reaffirming theirposition just last year...
...A 1998 draft report on MCS from a U.S...
...Surprisingly, MCS claims have not become a plaintiff's paradise...
...attorney who used to fight numerous MCS cases...
...But there's nothing in the medical literature to back it up...
...In the mid-198o's, Canadian investigators looked through the files of the most prominent (and notorious) clinical ecologist, Dr...
...It isn't like finding liver disease," explains Betty McEntire, executive director of the American SIDS Institute...
...Some of the chemicals are natural...
...What happens in a maritime region is that people tend to be kind and sympathetic, and you do everything in your power to accommodate someone else," says Pellerin...
...While she was showing overt signs of 'seizure,' her EEG was perfectly normal," Standenmayer says...
...But her reaction was a "learned sensitivity," The New Golden Rule: Diversification A Record High Stock Market...
...To be allergic to all of them is like being allergic to everything beginning with the letter F. This condition is not an allergy in any normally accepted sense of the word...
...A visit to a clinical ecologist means you have MCS...
...One receptionist at one of the local hospitals says that ink in newsprint is causing her allergic reactions and she's asking that newspapers be kept out of the lobby...
...how much more solid can you get...
...This shift makes all the more sense in that smell, like any of the other senses, can be a warning device...
...Grace Ziem, a prominent environmental physician in Emmitsburg, Maryland, says MCS may be the "largest unrecognized epidemic in the United States today...
...Some even claim that one whiff of a fragrance leads them to develop reactions to a huge variety of smells and other agents...
...Ten years ago I think I would not have had the same reaction to cigarette smoke that I do now...
...Some companies have valid scientific data supporting their health claims...
...Many of the chemicals found in smoke and second-hand smoke are the same chemicals that are found in perfume products," Karen Robinson says...
...In short," she says, "there's not a lot of evidence that fragrances at concentrations being experienced are having an adverse affect" But all MCS silliness aside, could it at least be that some people are simply more sensitive to odors than others are...
...Because there's less in the air and more on the airwaves in the form of discussions and warnings, she has become much more aware of the odor and likely to react to it...
...A block away...
...Kendall's source is something called the "Candida Research and Information Foundation, Perfume Survey, Winter 1989-go...
...The good news is that, for the moment at least, it seems confined to Northern California...
...he warns...
...1/4 29...
...Perfume is a pollutant generated by the occupant that the occupant can do something about...
...So what's the connection between fragrances and MCS...
...If you're going to San Francisco, be sure to wear only fake flowers in your hair...
...scented laundry detergents...
...Yes, those "personal rights" can be such pesky things...
...Fragranced furniture is all the rage in Britain...
...A school of 2,000 sounds like a lot, but what if you heard that fragrance fright has already swept an entire province in Canada and become institutionalized...
...But, says Dalton, "there's a tendency to assume that if we can smell it, it must be in a potent concentration...
...Authorities shut down the school of 2,000 students for more than two weeks, and nearly $100,000 was spent on emergency care alone...
...At the very least maybe they should start printing up bumper stickers reading, "If Giorgio is outlawed, only outlaws will wear Giorgio" and "You'll get my Chanel No...
...Don't...
...5 when you pry it from my cold, dead, but pleasant-smelling fingers...
...Herman Staudenmayer, a Denver psychologist who has had over 500 alleged MCS cases referred to him, published a paper last August focusing on a woman who was awarded workers' compensation after complaining of sensitivity to fragrances...
...So the only thing all fragrances have in common is that they're fragrant...
...scented deodorant, lotion, lipstick...
...We would tell one person that an odor was a fragrance, and another it's a strong indusThe American Spectator April 2000 trial chemical," Dalton told me...
...DrLe$: 5twedc5ovence, Anybody can be allergic to a given ingredient or collection of ingredients in fragrances...
...Adopted by voters in 1986, that law requires companies to give a "clear and reasonable" warning before knowingly exposing anyone to carcinogens or other hazardous chemicals on a stateThe American Spectator • April 2000 published list...
...So it becomes something of a circular argument...
...Meanwhile, the San Francisco Chapter of the Sierra Club has urged action to discourage the use of fragrance products in all public places...
...chewing gum...
...population suffers symptoms ranging from annoying to fatal...
...She had been led to believe she should react to fragrances and that this should be her reaction...
...What they found was a bag of onions...
...I think it tends to be a very sympathetic population, so that if you and I were to share an office and you felt my fragrance was bothering you, I wouldn't wear it...
...Everyone was getting sick headaches, stomachaches, vomiting, diarrhea," said a cafeteria cashier...
...San Francisco's Ecology House, an institution for alleged MCS sufferers, posts rules forbidding, among other things, • perfume, cologne or after-shave...
...The survey has no medical validity...
...27 FREE GOLD GUIDE Staudenmayer explains...
...When you find nothing, then that's what SIDS is, a death thatremains unexplained...
...Order Lear's New Millennium Gold Investment Guide FREE and learn how your investments can be protected and grow in the world's oldest form of wealth...GOLD...
...Still, Halifax's Robinson told the Toronto Globe and Mail, "The main point we've been making is that it's a health issue, not a matter of likes and dislikes...
...And these are just normal people, not ones claiming to have MCS," Dalton says...
...Further, some of these reactions apparently never actually occurred...
...On Prince Edward Island, off the country's east coast, a joint union-employer recommendation recently was made to ban perfumes and aftershaves from government offices...
...I don't think in the beginning people realized quite how invasive this might become...
...Don't be caught uninformed...
...tomorrow the world...
...A truly strong odor can be overpowering, of course...
...Given the prevailing view at local universities, at least one of which has launched a campaign discouraging the use of scented products, "they think it's intellectually correct," she says...
...The Yet nowhere is it worse than ocean-fresh Halifax, Nova Scotia...
...26 April 2000 • The American Spectator Other aspects such as lack of regulation, labeling laws, and "personal rights further corn-plicate the issue," writes Bridges...
...It's what also makes the comparison rather ludicrous...
...I call it the Halifax Hysteria Hotbed...
...reported in the January 13, 2000 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine...
...Yet the reporter from the Toronto Globe and Mail who quoted Robinson interjected that "that point is controversial, but an increasing number of health care authorities are willing to concede it...
...health bodies apply the adjective to the syndrome itself...
...Indeed, it doesn't even cover state courts...
...Call today and receive your FREE New Millennium Gold Investment Guide and learn why the "smart money" is buying gold NOW...
...And SENSELESSNESS ine cafeteria workers from the Dirksen Senate Office Building cafeteria in Washington, D.C...
...with so many chemicals in each, there's bound to be some overlap...
...The conclusion I draw in an upcoming medical journal report," he told me, "is that almost all studies have found an excess of mental illness in these individuals...
...Labor unions have taken up their cause, demanding cleaner air in area hospitals...
...We have scent-free...
...It's quite a leap to say that any company that tries to defend itself scientifically is therefore inherently wrong...
...Halifax, Nova Scotia, has been able to do what the FDA, the European Commission, and other regulatory agencies have been unable to do," declares fragrance foe Betty Bridges, who heads the Virginia-based Fragranced Products Information Network...
...After all, she willingly submitted to the EEG...
...fabric softener or dryer sheets (even those labeled unscented or fragrance-free...
...She draws on some innate source of knowledge to declare, "The two are quite similar in contribution to indoor air pollution as well as social and political aspects...
...uxrLeAvta "It's not just perfumes," Pellerin adds...
...He notes that, as with most mystery syndromes, "middle-class white women are most likely to complain of it...
...If you have an infant, you're probably already rushing to toss out these products...
...hair spray, mousse, scented shampoo, or hair conditioner...
...Chewing gum...
...Avoid things that have distinct odors," she concludes...
...Certainly it has in the local fragrance industry...
...They're way a head of us," says Claudia Miller about Halifax's fragrance fanaticism...
...He compares smelling other people's fragrances to the dire claims some have made about inhaling others' cigarette smoke...
...It's simple...
...The reviewers said that Rea used "no appropriate controls and the patients were assumed to have environmental hypersensitivity mainly by being referred to the unit...
...Betty Bridges's Fragranced Products Information Network, quoting verbatim from a newsletter put out by the late Julia Kendall of Marin County, just north of San Francisco, claims: Symptoms provoked by fragrances include: watery or dry eyes, double vision, sneezing, nasal congestion, sinusitis, tinnitus, ear pain, dizziness, vertigo, coughing, bronchitis, difficulty breathing, difficulty swallowing, asthma, anaphylaxis, headaches, migraine, seizures, fatigue, confusion, disorientation, incoherence, short-term memory loss, inability to concentrate, nausea, lethargy, anxiety, irritability, depression, mood swings, restlessness, rashes, hives, eczema, flushing, muscle and joint pain, muscle weakness, irregular heartbeat, hypertension, swollen lymph glands and more...
...Are we to believe he's the Jack Kevorkian of East Asia...
...In South Korea, a man has invented a self-perfuming business suit...
...Why all the fuss...
...Critics quickly noted that Poe was both an opium addict and an alcoholic, had suffered tremendous personal tragedy, and that in any case everyone in cities back then inhaled carbon monoxide from gas28 April 2000 The American Spectator lit lamps without sitting down to write The Raven and The Fall of the House of Usher...
...Activist Bridges admits, "While the dangers of second-hand smoke have been widely studied and publicized, both the scientific community and the press have largely ignored the dangers of exposures to fragrances...
...This does not foster mental health...
...Grace Ziem admitted to me that she's diagnosed MCS in practically every patient she's ever seen...
...shoe polish...
...There's been a move among medical and scientific bodies in the U.S...
...The haz-mat [hazardous material] unit went down, and all the readings were negative," a police officer said...
...By great coincidence, Donnay also directs something called Carbon Monoxide Referral & Resources...
...Really...
...I think it's just lost its appeal," she says, no pun intended...
...Today's best gold buys, future trends and the best way to protect and grow your family's savings and retirement...
...Wilke's "source" is a number of documents in which she combines 2 plus 2 and arrives at 526...
...Ooh-la-la...
...I felt very lightheaded, nauseated," said one...
...But some 3,000 different chemicals have been identified in fragrances, which makes for an almost infinite number of possible combinations...
...That's already a foregone conclusion...
...At first I thought it was a tempest in a teapot...
...The Japanese feel it makes their senses cleaner...
...And finally, what of those French...
...and elsewhere toward replacing "MCS" with the term ideopathic (literally, "of unknown origin") environmental intolerance, which allows for the possibility that chemicals have nothing to do with it...
...Thus one specifically excluded the possibility of MCS under the Supreme Court's 1993 William Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals decision as "unsupported by sound scientific reasoning or methodology...
...Anti-fragrance policies also appear to be the norm at most of the city's workplaces...
...Call Now 1-800-965-0580 GUARANTEED LOWEST PRICES LEAR FINANCIAL • 429 SANTA MONICA BLVD • SANTA MONICA, CA Call Now And Receive A FREE Silver Coin...
...The suit, naming 12 manufacturers as defendants, asserts that at least three chemicals on the list are used in carbonless paper...
...government interagency workgroup also found the disorder lacked an accepted case definition, that limitations abound in published studies on MCS, and that no widely accepted protocols have proved effective in addressing symptoms of MCS...
...6.) caio In Ottawa, public buses ask riders to be seated only without scents, while the Queensway-Carleton Hospital has embarked on a "No Scents Is Good Sense" campaign...
...But only a small portion of the odors to which we are exposed come from food...
...Thus, natural gas can kill you but the odor added to it to warn of its presence is harmless...
...When we monitor some of these people, they would report coughing or sneezing, but it certainly wasn't audible," says Dalton...
...So odors become a whipping boy, so to speak, for chemicals...
...Warning signs are posted in toilets reminding you not to use toiletries...
...restaurants and scent-free offices everywhere here...
...Anti-Fragrance Movement has its nose out of joint—and sweetsmelling Canada is leading the way...
...Her agenda...
...SIDS isn't a neurological dysfunction...
...To her it's an "unrecognized" illness, but major U.S...
...Another olfactory activist, Barb Wilke from the San Francisco area, informs us via the Web that: Multiple Sclerosis, Parkinson's, Lupus, and Alzheimer's are all neurological disorders...
...Fragrance products worn by people a block away adversely affect the chemically sensitive," claims Mann County's Barb Wilke...
...American mills produce three-quarters of a million tons of it each year, and we've all likely been exposed...
...As to what ails them, you name it and they suffer from it...
...We don't laugh at them, but our feeling is this is not a true clinical entity...
...5C10A,O, tfLe Oto,u...
...She complained of seizures," Staudenmayer told me...
...Some don't see that as a problem...
...Donald Black has studied MCS for many years...
...Government buildings, schools, and other public buildings have also moved to cleanse their air of odors, posting voluntary no-fragrance notices...
...Wow...
...But then [the fragrance foes] just pushed and pushed and pushed...
...The syndrome is most commonly known as "multiple chemical sensitivity" (MC S) or "environmental illness" (EI...
...The obvious implication is: "Today Halifax...
...any scented personal care or cosmetic product...
...The cause of the odor may never be known, but the cause of the outbreak...
...What if you heard that there were efforts to essentially turn the entire United States into a Dirksen building cafeteria or Warren County High School, that powerful environmental groups are involved, and that something already generally accepted by the media called "Multiple Chemical Sensitivity" has already paved the way...
...In September, a class action lawsuit filed in California contended that carbonless copy paper violated the state's Proposition 65...
...The odors "are unwanted intruders...
...If someone believes that man-made or perhaps just man-bottled chemicals are harmful (as apparently most everyone in Halifax now believes) then smelling anything not immediately recognizable as a natural odor can be alarming, even frightening...
...gatt,ain),e Greame Gilday, a hea and safety officer with the York Region (Toronto's province) District School Board, travels from school to school with a troupe of Aurora High drama students, who perform under a banner declaring "No Scents Make Sense...
...I threw up...
...It has a Website (www.carbonless.org), but so far, no ribbon...
Vol. 33 • April 2000 • No. 3
