A Second Term Game Plan
Wanniski, Jude
THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR ~ VOL. 17, NO. 8 / AUGUST 1984 Jude Wanniski A SECOND TERM GAME PLAN There's no reason for Mr. Reagan to be vague about his plans. P r e s i d e n t Reagan's landslide...
...Much of the President's resources in his first term have gone to national defense and strategic diplomacy with our allies vis-a-vis the Soviet Union...
...It was the one idea that separated him from his Republican rivals for the presidential nomination...
...otherwise, he and his team will be occupied by crisis management...
...But it would give him neither the mandate he needs for specific reforms nor the Republican victories in the Senate and House that are essential for a dynamic second term...
...The greatest shortcoming of President Reagan's first term has been in the area of foreign economic policy...
...With the credit system rebuilt around a stable dollar, "gold-standard interest rates" would return, typically three to five percent...
...The same people who diverted Mr...
...The most important still at issue is the requirement that Mr...
...Mondale attempts to revive the old New Deal coalition by arguing that he would have "the rich" pay these bills through income-tax surcharges and that military outlays would be pared...
...As a further setback to Soviet strategic interests, China's economy began to President almost single-handedly has put the U.S...
...Professor Friedman believed the Federal Reserve, if it followed his money-supply theories, could manage the dollar's value by ignoring the price signals that the gold market provides...
...Similarly on foreign policies, Mr...
...A President cannot lead the free world if he cannot preside over a healthy domestic economy, and in the depths of the recession Mr...
...Reagan has understood and championed supply-side tax policies for the U.S...
...En~erprise zones will again be part of the Reagan campaign...
...on a path toward development of a space-based anti-missile defense, the so-called "Star Wars" program (which Walter Mondale derides as a "magic curtain...
...These are precisely the fears that Walter Mondale is fanning The greatest shortcoming of President Reagan's first term has been in the area of foreign economic policy...
...But at least we can say the Adminstration was oblivious to the fact that its support of monetarist policies at the Fed was the direct cause of this anguish in the world's poorest nations, especially in the dollar sphere in Latin America...
...At some point, then, whether in the platform or as an impromptu campaign decision, we can expect Mr...
...When it rises in price, it signals the onset of a general price rise...
...The White House is already moving toward endorsement of this provision, expecting the Democrats will do likewise...
...In this environment, the West Germans elected a government that backed the NATO decision to deploy Pershing missiles in Europe...
...When it falls, the general price level deflates...
...Third World nations that had acquired dollar debts in the last, inflationary years of the Carter Administration found the dollar value of their productive assets--the collateral for their loans-nose-diving with the dollar deflation...
...Yet such reform will have immediate, beneficial effects on the world economy...
...President Reagan is well aware that no great nation has ever left a goldbased money system for managed greenbacks, "fiat money," as he puts it, and remained a great nation...
...The U.S...
...This did not prevent Democrats from warning the voters that the commission might try to savage benefits...
...But what about his State Department and Treasury, who know full well the oppressive, counterproductive tax rates borne by the people of the Third World...
...The results have been dire...
...Reagan to refute the Mondale warnings by committing himself to the Kemp-Kasten flat-tax proposal or something like it...
...But as long as the deficit problem hangs over its head, the pressure on the Administration is to think not of fairness, simplicity, and the incentive effects of lower marginal rates, but of increasing tax revenues...
...Again, though, it will take more Republicans in Congress to overcome the vested interests of the Democrats...
...The bull market that began in August of 1982, with the Fed's ending of its two-year deflation, foreshadowed the economic boom that restored confidence at home and abroad in Mr...
...In 1982, the White House strategists believed they had defused the Social Security issue by arranging a bipartisan commission to report after the congressional elections...
...If the Republicans do not have a plausible counter to this pitch, Ron would likely still beat Fritz, but Democrats would likely take the Senate and hold their solid lead in the House...
...sional candidates to exploit voter worries that Eisenhower would pursue balance-the-budget austerity measures in his second term...
...This strategy is a perfectly good one for the President's re-election...
...The President's docility in this area has been the gravest blot in his first term...
...Reagan will have to find ways to let the Soviets get out of the corner they have been backed into and draw them into the expanding world economy...
...Because the tax cut was a purely domestic move, its expansionary effects were felt only indirectly by the rest of the world economy...
...He may soon after election send troops into Central America (his "December surprise," Democrats suggest...
...14 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR AUGUST 1984...
...Democrats seem to believe they cannot permit the President and the GOP to get credit for inner-city revitalization through freemarket forces rather than governmentspending solutions...
...banking interests...
...When Third World countries found themselves unable to pay their dollar debts in the U.S.-induced deflation, the IMF bounced around from one capital to another with dollars to loan on the condition that these nationals tax their citizens more heavily, always in ways that led to capital flight...
...As soon as Mr...
...Reagan from monetary reform in the 1980 campaign would devote 1985 to fiscal action, believing the newly reelected President would have his best chance of slashing social spending and entitlement programs in the first year of his new term...
...Reagan is re-elected, goes the argument, he will seek to pay these bills by raising taxes on the poor and middle-class and by slashing social spending, leaving military outlays relatively untouched...
...And his rigid anti-Soviet posture will increase the danger of nuclear war and also expand the arms race...
...Voters like Ron...
...It follows the 1956 pattern that brought President Eisenhower an easy re-election victory over Adlai Stevenson, but which saw a wave of liberal Democrats elected to an increasingly Democratic Congress...
...The idea is to lower tax rates in those areas of the country like the South Bronx where unemployment is THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR AUGUST 1984 13 so high and opportunity so low that tax revenues are meager...
...In his second term as governor of California he moved far more boldly than he did in his first, feeling surer of himself, his scope, and his instincts...
...The President is not an incrementalist but a revolutionary, which is why he carefully listens to the counsel of his incrementalist advisers...
...It will not take much for the President to come to resemble Senators Baker and Percy, whose foreign-policy views are created for them by the Council on Foreign Relations and the Trilateral Commission, which is where Mr...
...It was the idea that most distinguished him from President Carter...
...The Administration is planning on a simplification-of the tax code, some form of "flat tax" that preserves the major tax deductions that affect most households: interest on home mortgages, state and local taxes, charitable deductions...
...Reagan based on the success of his first term and to trust that he would perform similarly in his second...
...In his second term, he will confront the delicate problem of dealing with a bitter, demoralized Kremlin, ideologically and economically bankrupt yet dangerously armed...
...This permitted Democratic congresJude Wanniski is president o f Polyconomics, Inc...
...Political necessity and his own inclinations will take him in that direction...
...It's a must...
...The Administration has not denied such charges because those people in the Administration who advocate a fiscal solution to the deficit problem have promoted this idea as a live option...
...In the 1980 campaign, Mr...
...We'd expect to see this in the Republican Platform that will be adopted at the August national convention in Dallas, and in the campaigns of the President and the congressional candidates...
...There are a few important prerequisites...
...Because he was not an establishment figure, Ronald Reagan should have pressed for new policies...
...Mondale's only real chance of defeating the President comes through his attempt to persuade the voters that a second Reagan term will be fundamentally different from the first...
...We will not hear anything about this in the fall campaign, however...
...The achievements of his second term in fostering an era of peace and prosperity will also complete the transformation of the Republican party into the party of economic growth and secure its dominance into the twenty-first century...
...It was designed to increase the efficiency of the economy, which, as a side effect, would expand the tax base, reduce tax evasion, and expand revenues in a growing economy...
...A unilateral U.S...
...Because the dollar is the invoice currency for 70 percent of world trade, international monetary reform must begin in the U.S...
...This growth-oriented reform would dissolve the worldwide debt crisis...
...At the outset of the Reagan Administration there had been great hopes that it would push the IMF to induce growthoriented tax and currency policies in exchange for their loans, so the loans could be paid back out of growth...
...The Administratiotl has no excuses, though, for blindly supporting the austerity policies of the International Monetary Fund...
...And when enacted and in place, the Reagan tax cut was the distinguishing feature of the expanding U.S...
...P r e s i d e n t Reagan's landslide reelection this November will be followed by a second term that will secure his place in history as one of the greatest of Presidents...
...American farmers, savaged by two Fed deflations since 1980, would be able to refinance their staggering debt load, enabling farm subsidies to decline by at least $10 billion...
...Many of his key political advisers are urging a campaign strategy that would have him be relatively vague about his plans...
...The plan would double the personal exemption for each taxpayer, spouse, and dependent ta $2,000 and increase the standard deduction, thereby removing 1.4 million of the lower income taxpayers from the tax rolls...
...At the same time, deferral of monetary reform would invite a wave of Third World debt repudiations in 1985--the only alternative to social strife--leading President Reagan into a perpetual state of crisis management that would poison his second term...
...Reagan will of course be pushed further and further into making substantive concessions...
...Reagan's foreign policy was said to be in disarray...
...If the presidential campaign unfolds along this line, Mr...
...This will almost certainly require Cabinet or at least subcabinet changes, people with the interest, knowledge, and energy to alter these profoundly important foreign economic policies...
...6 6 M,,ouncils of war breed timidity and defeatism," Douglas MacArthur was fond of saying, meaning that a committee of advisers tend to look for reasons not to do something that involves breaking with conventional wisdom...
...for democracy...
...Reagan's pollsters are finding the idea enormously popular with the electorate...
...Only monetary reform can solve the domestic deficit problem and the international debt crisis that besets the Third World and their industrialnation creditors...
...Any such step would of course have to be seen as an act of strength on the part of the U.S., which means a U.S...
...There are incrementalists everywhere around the President, urging him to move by inches if at all...
...The Democratic establishment and the Republican establishment are fully supportive, and policies thus do not change from one administration to the next...
...But the establishment quickly co-opted him in this area and it's not even certain he knows what hit him...
...There's no reason to think he will be anything but superb in his second...
...They would not only be able to refinance their dollar debts, now well over $600 billion, at much lower interest rates and longer maturities...
...By effecting a monetary reform that once again requires the Treasury and the Federal Reserve to stabilize the dollar value of gold at a price determined to be optimum--balancing the interests of debtors and creditors-President Reagan would lay the foundation for a worldwide noninflationary economic boom...
...In the same way, the President blundered early in Central America by endorsing the socialist reforms the Carter Administration had fostered in El Salvador: confiscatory landreforms, the nationalizing of banking and trade, and redistributionist tax policies...
...Only monetary reform can bring down dollar interest rates in a way that expands the U.S...
...national debt, approaching $1.7 trillion, would require $221 billion annually in debt service costs at current 13 percent interest rates...
...This is only partly due to the fact that the dollar has fluctuated wildly with a deflationary bent in the absence of a monetary standard...
...Mondale and the Democrats will assert, as they have been doing, that because the President will not be "accountable" in his second term, because he cannot go before the voters for a third term, he can indulge his hardline, militaristic propensities...
...The Soviets are alarmed at this shift in U.S...
...and world economy...
...Kemp-Kasten, which would lower the top marginal incometax rate to 25 percent and the top corporate rate to 30 percent, was not designed with the goal of higher revenues...
...If there is international monetary reform pursued in 1985 he will have time for such use of his resources...
...The Only monetary reform can solve the domestic deficit problem and the international debt crisis...
...If the President does not offer the voters a specific tax reform proposal during the campaign, he will be unable to refute the Mondale charges...
...This was the same formula that was forced on South Vietnam in the early Kennedy years, policies that destroyed the South Vietnamese economy and made a U.S...
...The President has been ardent in pressing for democratic institutions in the Third World, breaking with establishment policies that have long assumed poor countries are not ready blossom as it marched down the capitalist road, a development the President observed firsthand as he cemented relations with Peking...
...Former President Nixon.advocates a trade avenue...
...But it is precisely for this reason that the bill has not been enacted...
...Reagan can't simply hide behind a study...
...When Salvadorans in 1982 voted against the socialist plan by voting in the party that had opposed it, the Reagan State Department was persuaded to withhold U.S...
...The great inflation followed, with the quadrupling of the gold price in this "greenback" era preceding the quadrupling of the dollar price of oil in the fall of 1973...
...In the next four years, we can expect the rest of the world to emulate the 12 THE AMERICAN SPECTATOR AUGUST 1984 Reagan "supply-side" tax cuts, and the United States will feel the secondary effects of the global expansion of productivity and production that will follow...
...A recession in 1985 will result: Mr...
...The decision to break permanently the dollar's link to gold was made by President Nixon in 1973, with the heaviest shove coming from his Treasury Secretary George Shultz, on the advice of his friend Milton Friedman...
...For this reason, monetary reform must be initiated at the outset of the among the voters, which would deal the President a more Democratic Congress that would stymie spending cuts and bring renewed pressures for higher taxes...
...The only reform worth discussing is a gold-based reform, the kind the President came close to embracing in 1980...
...economy into deep recession...
...and President's second term, not put off until 1986 as some Administration of_ ficials have recommended to the President...
...The reduced cost of capital would shrink the costs of national defense by several times that amount...
...military solution impossible...
...economy...
...The Mondale pitch already being elaborated is this: Yes, there is an economic expansion that has made the President a popular figure, but it has been "bought" with massive deficit spending, $200 billion in federal deficits as far as the eye can see...
...The exact opposite has been followed, with State and Treasury bureaucrats enthusiastically supporting the IMF "medicine" of higher taxes and currency devaluations...
...Reagan's leadership...
...All this does mean that Mr...
...This low interest-rate strategy would thus be the key to GOP congressional victories that would make tax reform possible...
...Mondale will continue to warn voters that the Treasury tax study that is due to report in December, after the election, will propose to lower marginal rates for the rich and increase taxes on the poor and middle class, through some form of national sales tax...
...The Soviets are viewed as being hopelessly intractable, but it was not long ago that the Chinese were viewed as being even more hopeless...
...The practices of the IMF are those shaped by the Council on Foreign Relations and Trilateral Commission, policies designed by U.S...
...But here too the establishment outflanked him in El Salvador...
...There are sufficient numbers of senior Reagan aides who are aware of this specter to support his inclination to monetary reform this time around...
...farmers, have been crushed by the dollar deflations of recent years...
...The CIA subsequently used taxpayer funds to finance the socialist party...
...And they will become a feature of the second term...
...Reagan went to the South Bronx and committed himself to the idea of Enterprise Zones...
...economy in continued expansion...
...From this standpoint, it's not realistic even to think of what the President's second term will bring unless we can assume he and the party will put forward the general game plan...
...By the summer of 1982 he was headed toward failure as the Federal Reserve deflation pushed the U.S...
...Gold, universally recognized as the most monetary of all commodities, is the surest guide to incipient inflations and deflations...
...The increased risk of either forces higher interest rates, which is what we have observed when gold's price signals have been ignored...
...In the last dozen years of fiat dollars, the Federal Reserve has taken the U.S...
...But the President will not be able to avoid offering a complete, growth-oriented tax strategy a la Kemp-Kasten without remaining on the defensive...
...Mondale finds out what he thinks...
...And we can project many of the details by assessing what we know of the inclinations of the President and his party as we have seen them shaped in the first Administration...
...In a second term, things can only get better...
...world economy on a roller coaster ride of inflations and deflationary recessions...
...The outlines of the second Reagan term can already be seen or surmised...
...The second Reagan Administration would be contentious, indeterminate, moving sideways rather than forward...
...The key to it all, though, is the monetary reform that must be the distinguishing feature of the second administration...
...decision to grant the SOviets most-favored-nation trade status will probably be considered...
...strategic policy away from Mutually Assured Destruction toward Mutually Assured Defense...
...Reagan actually seek a mandate for his vision of a second term...
...The appeal to families, especially young families, of low-interest home mortgages is also self-evident...
...Instead of growling at the Kremlin, he coos...
...banks...
...The IMF, after all, is dominated by the United States, both the government and American multinational banks...
...support of that government...
...In the absence of a coherent foreignpolicy agenda for his second term, the President finds himself forced to respond to these kinds of attacks by simply altering his rhetoric...
...With a few major exceptions, he has been masterful in his first term in leading the Reagan Revolution...
...This year, Walter Mondale and the Democrats face the same kind of problem...
...The distinguishing characteristic of Ronald Reagan's run for the Presidency in 1980 was his pledge of a 30-percent across-the-board cut in marginal income-tax rates...
...at 5 percent, debt service plummets to $85 billion...
...Eisenhower had no agenda for his second term and ran an "I-Like-Ike, He-Got-Us-Out-of-Korea" campaign...
...The President also has to focus his attention here instead of simply accepting counsel...
...The policy would be of great benefit to the Democratic constituents of these inner cities...
...Such reform would bring profound relief to the dozens of Third World nations which, like U.S...
...The voters would be asked to re-elect Mr...
...At the same time, the Soviet Union sank into deeper economic depression as leadership changed hands through death again and again...
...Voters did like Ike, but they insured against his austerity inclinations by giving him a solidly Democratic Congress...
...The IMF has acted not as a doctor to sick economies, but as a collection agent for U.S...
...At least this is what couldbe, and the probabilities are good that it will be...
...The campaign appeal of a balanced budget through lower interest rates and economic growth rather than tax hikes and spending cuts is obvious...
...They would tend to lose constituents to the Republican party as minorities developed vested interests in market solutions...
...This would force uncertain voters to elect more Democrats to insure that a consumption tax will not be able to get through Congress...
...When the arguments are not persuasive, he feels confident in advancing the revolution...
...They would be able to sell their commodities to an expanding world market at stable, not falling, prices...
...And Mr...
Vol. 17 • August 1984 • No. 8