Political Booknotes
Political Booknotes At The Hand of Man: Peril and Hope for Africa's Wildlife Raymond Bonner Knopf, $24 By Ann O'Hanlon Raymond Bonner moved to east Africa in 1988 to write for The New Yorker,...
...THOMAS PAINE Videocassette...
...Washington, DC 20009 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR foJ New York-based, 3,400 memberj activist-led writers union Strong Labor/Non-Profit expe rience...
...However, if his topic is "Peril and Hope for Africa's Wildlife," as the subtitle promises, Bonner falls short...
...You Can Help The Washington Monthly is seeking copies of our December 1991 publication for archive purposes...
...Even an internal report called WWF's approach egocentric and neocolonialist...
...The case in point is, of course, elephants and the argument for a total ban on ivory...
...Finally, the African people who cope with these dangers should be the people setting and implementing policy, both because it is their land and resource, and because their involvement is a fundamental precursor to caring for the survival of the species...
...Once it became politically or financially expedient for those who had hunted African wildlife to skip the hunt, they did so and asked the rest of the world to go along...
...Not one of the wildlife experts proposes a national or continent-wide strategy for keeping elephant populations in check while simultaneously respecting local cultures and allocating tourist dollars...
...Though Bonner is critical of a number of conservation organizations, he serves up a particularly thorough indictment of WWF...
...If Bonner had yielded to his obvious urge to write exclusively about elephants and the ivory trade, perhaps he would have addressed these issues...
...Political Booknotes At The Hand of Man: Peril and Hope for Africa's Wildlife Raymond Bonner Knopf, $24 By Ann O'Hanlon Raymond Bonner moved to east Africa in 1988 to write for The New Yorker, neatly in time to watch the 1989 global ban on ivory take effect...
...The organization provided the Zimbabwean Department of National Parks and Wildlife Management with a helicopter used to gun down poachers on sight, killing a total of at least 57 men...
...VHS $22.00 post paid...
...The neocolonialist charge gets at a number of uncomfortable truths...
...NW Washington, DC 20009 (202) 462-0128 May 1993/The Washington Monthly 61...
...Sorely missing from At The Hand of Man is an analysis of why none of the successful small-scale efforts to control elephant populations has been attempted or even proposed at the national level in Africa...
...Bonner claims the western approach to African wildlife management is racism and nothing else...
...The wisdom of allowing ivory sales is at least threefold...
...In fact, if racism disappeared tomorrow, Africa's wildlife woes would remain...
...First, elephant populations outgrow their habitat's support capacity and therefore must be kept from trampling the forest and farmland around them and dying of starvation...
...The report was largely covered up...
...SRR &| Associates (202) 544-6990...
...The tusks from these elephants, and from elephants who die natural deaths, should not go to waste...
...Ethnic Rights...
...Bonner himself was seduced into focusing on pachyderms, and he serves up some juicy reporting on the politics of elephants...
...And they were, perhaps, factors in the decision to implement the more simplistic ban on ivory than a more complex policy that, no doubt, would have been fairer to the Africans...
...Box 969, Ashland OR 97520 For a FREE Catalogue Call: 1-800-729-2665 The Monthly Mart Standard rate $1.25 per word (15 word minimum...
...Negotiable rates Contact Rogers...
...All ads must be prepaid...
...The ban on ivory, announced in 1989 at the initiation of WWF and AWF, was an abrupt reversal of both organizations' prior position of allowing the sale of some ivory...
...LITERARY AGENCY repre senting American Book Aware winning authors, seeks book-length fiction and nonfiction Send manuscripts with SASE td J. Solomon, First Books Inc., 2040, North Milwaukee Avenue Chicago, IL 60647...
...The secret list of members includes a disproportionate percentage of South Africans, all too happy in an era of social banishment to be welcomed into a socially elite society...
...The Africa section of the U. S. office of WWF hired its first black professional in 1991, and WWF-International has yet to hire a single black in its 30-year history...
...And, if it's possible to rate such overt racism, the African Wildlife Federation is worse due to its name and mission: In its 30 years, it has yet to have a single black on its board of trustees or in its Washington headquarters...
...Enchanted by the continent's peoples and wildlife, Bonner explored the interplay of the two as they relate to wildlife conservation...
...Frequency discounts available...
...P.O...
...Such may not be a reporter's responsibility, but his omission both of alternative strategies and of obstacles pro60 The Washington Monthly/May 1993 The Monthly Mart hibiting such strategies is frustrating...
...Send to: Jennifer Schindeler The Washington Monthly 1611 Connecticut Ave...
...Second, putting a value on the elephants—outside of the western aesthetic value that many Africans don't have the luxury to share—is the best way to ensure that those peoples work for the survival of the species...
...AUDIO bOOKS 475 Unabridged Recordings Easy Rentals by Mail * I go through a book a week using time otherwise wasted in taxis, shaving or walking" —George F. Will Blaowtone Audio Books P.O...
...What are the hurdles that might obstruct such plans...
...Box 31| Pelham, NY 10803...
...Instead, he paints a picture that is compelling but incomplete...
...GIFTS PERSONAL CROSSWORDS for birthdays, anniversaries, art) occasion...
...Both WWF and AWF paid exaggerated attention to the case of the elephant (elephants have never been doomed to extinction...
...No foreign government that pushed for the ban on ivory ever compensated local populations for their loss of income from ivory sales, nor included any Africans in policy making, an attitude Bonner refers to as "eco-colonialist...
...For unattached music lovers Nationwide...
...There were in-house arguments at WWF over the project, but it later denied knowing how the helicopter was being used...
...No Free Trade...
...AMERICANISTS...
...Topics critical to wildlife management yet barely touched upon in the book—crippling population growth, political corruption, and unstable governments throughout the continent —are as African as elephants and daunting obstacles in the execution of complex policy...
...Illuminating 40-minute 1992 cable television presentation| about America's foremost democratic founder...
...Ann 0 'Hanlon is a returned Peace Corps volunteer and an intern at The Washington Monthly...
...in fact, several countries had to stabilize their elephant populations well before the 1989 ban) once they discovered this was a fool-proof recipe for fundrais-ing...
...Independent Publications POB 102, Ridgefield, NJ 07657...
...The United States and other western nations have helped create a demand for ivory—thus contributing directly to elephant poaching and the ivory trade—and supported many a politically corrupt African government that was tied to the ivory trade...
...AUDIO/VIDEO CASSETTES EDITORIAL SERVICES Editing, research, writing, ancj proofreading...
...A lifelong conservationist working in Namibia described the average poacher as "an average, normal guy, a poor farmer who is trying to feed his family...
...Nor does Bonner, despite his criticism of the ivory ban...
...American Party, P. O. Box 14011, North Palm Beach, FL 33408...
...Sample: CCC—W 1/ Emerson Way, Sudbury, MA 01776...
...WWF's "1001 Club," a fundraising gimmick conceived by South African tobacco businessman and WWF boardmember Anton Rupert, is made up of 1,000 individuals who have given $10,000 to the WWF, the 1001st being Prince Bernhard of the Netherlands, a former WWF president...
...PERSONALS CLASSICAL MUSIC LOVERS' EXCHANGE...
...Other contributors include businessmen with suspect connections, including organized crime, environmentally destructive development, and corrupt African politics...
...Display rate $50.00 per inch...
...Highest prices paid...
...NWU 873 Broadway] #203 New York, NY 10003...
...EMPLOYMENT ORGANIZATIONS SERVICES MISCELLANEOUS AUTOGRAPHS, banners, political pins, leathers, baseball cards, sports memorabilia wanted...
...Africans were not included in such decisions...
...Stan Block, 128 Cynthia Road, Newton, MA 02159...
...He discovered that American wildlife organizations such as the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) and the African Wildlife Federation (AWF) pay scant attention to local peoples while establishing wildlife policy and distort facts when it is conducive to fundrais-ing...
...1-800-233-CLMS...
...If you have the issue and are willing to part with it, please send it to our publisher, Mary Beiro, at: The Washington Monthly 16U Connecticut Ave N.W...
Vol. 25 • May 1993 • No. 5
